Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH and I can’t agree on whether we should move house

87 replies

sunlightinthetrees · 29/09/2023 15:48

We live in a nice house in a nice village. Objectively it’s a good place to live.

However, both our DC go to primary school in the nearby town 10-15 mins away. All of their friends live near the school and most of their activities are in the town too.

I’m SO fed up of driving to and from the town. On a “normal” day it’s twice but some days it can be three or even four return journeys.

Generally the traffic is ok but every now and again it’s not, yesterday there was a bad accident and I ended up being really really late for an important meeting at the school and it was really embarrassing and frustrating. I’ve been saying for ages that I’d prefer to live in the town but this was the last straw for me.

I’ve said I want to move house but DH doesn’t get it. He just doesn’t think it’s enough of an inconvenience to warrant the hassle and cost of moving. I think it is. We would only be able to afford a smaller house in the other town (but still big enough for our needs), again I think it’s worth it and he doesn’t.

It may be relevant that he grew up in a rural location and is used to being driven everywhere but I did not. It’s starting to become an issue and I don’t know how we resolve it.

AIBU to want to move closer or is he right that it’s not worth the hassle?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
sunlightinthetrees · 02/10/2023 08:18

OliveWah · 01/10/2023 21:17

We moved from a very rural (7 minute drive to nearest tiny village shop) 3 bed semi with a huge garden on the coast to a 3 bed flat 10 mins walk from the city centre. Our DC were late primary age and school run was 25 min drive each way before we moved, and a 20 minute walk after. We are so glad we moved when we did, they are now teens and have busy social lives, which I don't have to micromanage by ensuring lifts are on hand at all hours. There is so much for them to do in our smallish city, compared to our previously rural not-even-a-hamlet, and DH and I are happy to compromise on the peace and quiet of the countryside for teens who aren't complaining they're bored constantly!

It is really tricky if you and DH aren't on the same page though, but perhaps he'll start to come around to the idea as your DC get older and he sees how much they will rely on the 2 of you for lifts to enable their social lives.

Glad the move worked out so well for you, I would definitely have wanted to move as well in your situation. Good point about teenagers as well.

I think in a way it would help my case if we had to drive to a shop, so it’s actually a shame we aren’t more isolated 😂

We do have a shop, library and post office all within walking distance, if we were older and didn’t have kids it would be perfect to be honest but it feels like the wrong place to be living with young kids.

OP posts:
PinkRoses1245 · 01/10/2023 22:11

I am totally with you. I cannot think of anything worse than having to drive every day. We have chosen a smaller house to be in the centre of a good size town, and rarely drive. Worth it so much. It will be so much better for your children to have more independence as they grow up, and they’ll get this living in a town.

Pacificisolated · 01/10/2023 22:08

It’s not just about what you and your DH want. It’s so much nicer for teens to be able to independently get themselves around to socialise, work part time etc. It feels particularly crap when your friends all live in a different area to you and you’re always the one who needs extra notice to meet up so you can arrange a lift. You miss out on a lot.

43ontherocksporfavor · 01/10/2023 21:43

It’s our dream to live by the coast, do you think you’d go back? Which coast ?

OliveWah · 01/10/2023 21:38

@43ontherocksporfavor DH and I both grew up in cities, and had only moved to the coast when we had DC, so it wasn't too much of a shock for us!

43ontherocksporfavor · 01/10/2023 21:30

That was a brave move @OliveWah . We live in suburban area of large town and lust after village life but I know I’d go mad if I had to get in a car to get basic things.

OliveWah · 01/10/2023 21:17

We moved from a very rural (7 minute drive to nearest tiny village shop) 3 bed semi with a huge garden on the coast to a 3 bed flat 10 mins walk from the city centre. Our DC were late primary age and school run was 25 min drive each way before we moved, and a 20 minute walk after. We are so glad we moved when we did, they are now teens and have busy social lives, which I don't have to micromanage by ensuring lifts are on hand at all hours. There is so much for them to do in our smallish city, compared to our previously rural not-even-a-hamlet, and DH and I are happy to compromise on the peace and quiet of the countryside for teens who aren't complaining they're bored constantly!

It is really tricky if you and DH aren't on the same page though, but perhaps he'll start to come around to the idea as your DC get older and he sees how much they will rely on the 2 of you for lifts to enable their social lives.

sunlightinthetrees · 01/10/2023 21:11

Blondeshavemorefun · 01/10/2023 19:51

Still a good size house

Driving every day for years isn't fun and very time consuming o

I agree! And I personally think that the inconvenience of driving isn’t outweighed by the house (which in all honesty is bigger than we need for four people, although it is lovely).

OP posts:
ahtred · 01/10/2023 19:56

(It was an upsize too though- we wanted the kids to have more space)

ahtred · 01/10/2023 19:55

We moved from a lovely village with the primary school to a town in preparation for the teenage years, and to have more available to us on our doorstep so to speak. No regrets, we found a lovely area of a town that has almost a village feel but with the town within walking distance, if you're finding it annoying now it'll only get worse as they get older.

Blondeshavemorefun · 01/10/2023 19:51

Still a good size house

Driving every day for years isn't fun and very time consuming o

sunlightinthetrees · 01/10/2023 19:49

Blondeshavemorefun · 30/09/2023 23:45

Go and look at houses in other town and see what you think

If secondary school is also a car journey away the you will be doing the drive for years

School runs if bus is late

Driving them miles for friends /meet ups

Yes location is important

But so is socialising and travelling

What size house are you in now

And what will you get for same money

We’re in a five bed detached right now and we’d get a large four bed semi or smaller four bed detached/large three bed detached for the same money.

I do realise I really shouldn’t be complaining and this is very much a first world problem!

OP posts:
Blondeshavemorefun · 30/09/2023 23:47

We live near our school

It's so nice dd6 can walk home with friends from school and see then at weekends

A big plus

Blondeshavemorefun · 30/09/2023 23:45

Go and look at houses in other town and see what you think

If secondary school is also a car journey away the you will be doing the drive for years

School runs if bus is late

Driving them miles for friends /meet ups

Yes location is important

But so is socialising and travelling

What size house are you in now

And what will you get for same money

Broodywuz · 30/09/2023 23:17

I agree with your DH OP, I would definitely be happy with more driving for the bigger house and rural/quieter location. I also grew up in a very rural location where we were driven everywhere (although did get a school bus) so I think this probably is a lot to do with it

justaanothermum · 30/09/2023 23:09

sunlightinthetrees · 29/09/2023 15:48

We live in a nice house in a nice village. Objectively it’s a good place to live.

However, both our DC go to primary school in the nearby town 10-15 mins away. All of their friends live near the school and most of their activities are in the town too.

I’m SO fed up of driving to and from the town. On a “normal” day it’s twice but some days it can be three or even four return journeys.

Generally the traffic is ok but every now and again it’s not, yesterday there was a bad accident and I ended up being really really late for an important meeting at the school and it was really embarrassing and frustrating. I’ve been saying for ages that I’d prefer to live in the town but this was the last straw for me.

I’ve said I want to move house but DH doesn’t get it. He just doesn’t think it’s enough of an inconvenience to warrant the hassle and cost of moving. I think it is. We would only be able to afford a smaller house in the other town (but still big enough for our needs), again I think it’s worth it and he doesn’t.

It may be relevant that he grew up in a rural location and is used to being driven everywhere but I did not. It’s starting to become an issue and I don’t know how we resolve it.

AIBU to want to move closer or is he right that it’s not worth the hassle?

I think your husband is right. I would be driving my children to school and back as long as I have a nice house AND in a village to go back to. That's luxury not many can afford.

StillWantingADog · 30/09/2023 09:57

ps I also totally get the “wanting to be properly part of the community” thing rather than being a 15 minute drive
away. Another reason why we chose not to move away.

VestaTilley · 30/09/2023 09:56

Where will they go to secondary school? If it’s in the town then move. That should be a bigger factor.

StillWantingADog · 30/09/2023 09:50

I grew up in a similar environment, 15 minutes drive from town, my parents taxied me everywhere, all the time. I was an OC which probably helped and my dm was a teacher so was generally around when I was, so overall it was feasible.

it didn’t bother me at the time but now as a parent I couldn’t bear to do all the ferrying so Yanbu. We live in the suburbs of a city where quite a lot is very close, walking distance in fact, or a very short drive. We considered moving some miles away to a more rural location which would have turned us into permanent taxis but ultimately decided to stay put, until the kids leave home.

it’s not just about not wanting to be a slave to the car though - we really want our kids to be able to wander round town independently and go and see their friends and just not be reliant on us all the time.
it’s also obviously much better for your health and the environment to rely on your feet/bike than a car.

I don’t think you’re being unreasonable at all but I can see the appeal of a more rural location too (I’d love it except for the car reliance) so I don’t think your dh is necessarily unreasonable either, as long as he’s definitely doing his fair share of the taxying.

Not sure how easily you can resolve this but I’d be making the point about the lack of kids’ ability to be independent as they get older. And increasing petrol prices
and general traffic congestion. And how using your feet is so much healthier!

Pushpull · 30/09/2023 09:33

I think that the lifts are symbolic for you (and a very obvious daily frustration) of not quite getting why you're not physically located in the community that you're building a life in - you mentioned the communities and activities.

I agree with others that in some ways this will get 'worse' during teen years as they will want to socialise with their friends (who sound like they will be in town mainly) and you'll need to be on standby for lifts.

It's more complicated to address I suppose because DH can hear (even if not intended) implicit criticism of his childhood. Which isn't what you're saying. It's not only whether this is affecting the children, it's impacting you and the huge life change hasn't worked out how you thought. If try and reframe it like this and toen as a compromise position between London and rural living?

It might help to think through the logistics and finances.of the move or asking if you could do that together to see what is actually possible. For example in town you might be reducing costs in other ways - like can you just run one car.

Good luck

Diddleflop · 30/09/2023 09:33

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

sunlightinthetrees · 30/09/2023 09:26

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

They went all over the place TBH. Local school, schools at the town on the other side of the village, private schools.

Actually I do think there may be one child at the same school as my DC but they live over the other side of the village and I don’t know them well. But prob still worth exploring.

OP posts:
Diddleflop · 30/09/2023 09:15

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Diddleflop · 30/09/2023 09:14

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

sunlightinthetrees · 30/09/2023 09:10

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

No they didn’t. But the more I reflect on it the more I don’t think it’s just about the inconvenience of school runs to be honest, it’s a bigger thing about feeling separate from the community and town where we spend most of our time. Hope that makes sense!

OP posts: