Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dealing with needy colleague

91 replies

Thepeopleversuswork · 29/09/2023 13:20

Wonder if anyone has any advice: I'm at my wits' end with this. Sorry, long.

I have a colleague who is constant need of support, advice, feedback, hand-holding and its driving me absolutely nuts.

She's not junior, mid-level role, mid 30s and has been with the firm well over a year so it's more than teething problems. She calls or Teams messages me five or six times a day to discuss REALLY trivial things about the job which she should either know herself by now or know which channels to go through. Or unilaterally puts meetings in my diary with her without checking first.

I'm senior but not leadership, three levels above her and she doesn't report into me I think she just finds me sympathetic. But she has a lot of support already in place and it's really not my job to deal with it.She's got two senior mentors (from the top management) and a line manager already, (none of them me).

She's technically good at her job but struggles with "soft" skills: boundaries/inappropriate behaviour/wasting time and generally bad at reading a room. Has had various flare-ups with people over her manner. Very bad at taking any criticism or feedback, which tends to trigger tears, accusations of victimisation and requests for more support from management/training etc. Numerous people have tried to coach her through various aspects of this (not being too much of a drain on management time, asking questions appropriately, not hogging conversation etc) and she takes all of it incredibly personally and it triggers tears etc. All of this has been raised at performance reviews. She's been told to stop bothering people (including me) with tiresome questions and demands for more mentoring etc.

I was giving her the benefit of the doubt -- and I'm generally a big fan of giving people time and of mentoring and support and helping them adapt culturally. But it's got to the point where dealing with her requests is a massive drain on both my time and emotional resources.

I've started screening calls and I will say "can you just email me and I'll come back when I have time?" etc, but she still hasn't got the message - every professional interaction I have with her leads to a request for a "debrief" or "feedback" and a meeting being booked in my diary. It's as if any engagement at all is seen as a green light to ask for more. I'm now at the point where I'm considering asking her not to contact me at all without a specific business need, or asking HR to do this, but I know this is going to trigger another furious meltdown. Should I do this or should I ask my managers/HR to do it?

OP posts:
ChlorrOfTheMask · 30/09/2023 22:36

If someone is needy, it's because they have needs that are not being met and that they're unable to meet themselves. I can relate to your colleague unfortunately. In my previous job, it took me a long time to learn what I was supposed to be doing, how I was supposed to be doing it and why I was doing each thing (how the different tasks were connected). I would always have to ask for more detail about how to carry out tasks and would have to keep asking the same questions each time I had to do a thing, because I'd have forgotten since last time I had to do it/was told. Gradually I got to the point where I knew what I was doing, but then when anything new was introduced or we were told to change the way we worked, I'd be lost again for a while. It felt awful, I was anxious all the time at work because I could tell people were irritated/impatient with me and I didn't want to annoy them, I wanted them to like me as much as I liked them, so I'd feel scared to ask, however I was also scared that if I didn't ask, I'd make mistakes and that would annoy folk more or cause people more work and I thought asking and making sure was the right thing to do rather than guessing. Your colleague might be terrified to continually ask the managers for guidance/reassurance. In my case I tried not to keep asking the same person so I'd ask another person next time and then a different person but looking back I'm sure some felt like you do. I was beyond grateful for the kind, patient colleagues and probably did ask them a bit more as I felt safer, I wasn't scared to. I felt that anxiety about annoying people/folk not liking me/making mistakes constantly and intensely throughout each shift. When I could tell people were irritated by me I felt intense rejection and I'd go home and worry about it for hours or days afterwards, which impaired my ability to function at home. On one particularly stressful day at work I tried to tell a colleague someone was on the phone for her and she snapped at me obviously thinking I was going to ask her something. I felt the tears coming and knew I wasn't going to be able to stop them and had to go into the printer room to sob. Another colleague found me in there and gave me a hug; I told her I was doing my best but felt everyone was annoyed with me all the time. Eventually I ended up having to take increasingly longer periods of sick leave as I wasn't coping at home and finally I was referred to the community psychiatric team. My CPN advised me to stop working. Since then I've been diagnosed autistic and ADHD assessment is ongoing. Needing detailed step by step instructions and lots of clarification is common among neurodivergent people and lots of us have developed rejection sensitive dysphoria as a result of experiencing so much criticism and rejection growing up, which can mean we need a lot of reassurance and validation. Many of us also struggle to regulate our emotions, or can't do so to the degree that is socially expected. That was probably a big part of why I struggled at work, but I was also isolated and controlled for nearly a decade beforehand by my ex and this was my first job after leaving him, so not only had I not worked for about 8 years, I'd been mostly shut away at home and had barely had any social interaction and zero independence, since my early 20s. Just because someone is in their 30s doesn't mean they necessarily have the same level of life experience and opportunity to develop skills you had/have at the same age. You don't know what others have been through/are going through and you don't know what additional needs they might have that could be undiagnosed. Being treated in the way most people on this thread are suggesting ("starve them of the attention they're seeking") has never helped me become more self sufficient or stop seeking help, it's caused me intense emotional pain and made me more anxious, which results in me feeling even more desperate for reassurance, in a vicious cycle, until I feel suicidal. You don't have a responsibility to help your colleague at your own expense, but when you set boundaries please do so clearly, kindly and patiently. Not everyone is able to understand hints, or cope with harsh, cold behaviour.

WhoWants2Know · 30/09/2023 21:36

I sometimes blame things on the policy/procedures that have been put in place to avoid hurting feelings. "Sorry, I've been reminded recently to avoid personal discussions at work, and I don't want to be pulled up on it."

Bored1000 · 30/09/2023 21:31

Don’t answer her calls, you are busy.

Don’t accept meeting invites, you are busy

Take ages to reply to texts / emails, you are busy

if she asks you why you don’t meet her / reply to e-mails, tell her in the kindest possible way that you are busy.

I think she is so needy she will go elsewhere for her support.

Still be friendly enough when speaking but start to distance yourself by degrees, no one has time for this, and it will negatively affect your work, she is not a new starter and needs to grow up or get out as she sounds like she can’t cope for whatever reasons

SillySausagez · 30/09/2023 20:51

Tell your manager you will cancel each meeting and ask her to email you. Then keep cancelling and emailing every time.

Mememe9898 · 30/09/2023 20:50

I would keep it strictly business. If she’s pushing your boundaries this needs to stop plus I wouldn’t be worried about telling things as it is.
If she’s already being taken through a performance management plan they are hardly going to think you are the problem as it’s already known to the business that she’s a problem.
Also the business need to know is that she is taking up so much of other peoples time too. To me it sounds like she needs to be managed out as not only can she not take any feedback but she’s disruptive to the existing team and taking up a lot of resources internally too.

Kwasi · 30/09/2023 20:47

You need to talk to your manager as it’s impacting your work. Your manager should take it up with her manager and HR.

Eskimal · 30/09/2023 20:35

I really sympathise with you. I am the manager of a person like that. It’s really difficult for everyone. They just don’t listen no matter how many different ways you approach the issue with them. They carry on just as they are despite all the conversations you try to have with them. As a manger, the thought of getting rid of someone like this feels cruel but ultimately if they can’t open their mind to the idea they have to work on things that are highlighted to them as a problem, they have to go as they are draining everyone’s energy.

Eskimal · 30/09/2023 20:31

CherryMaDeara · 29/09/2023 23:09

Also block out your diary so she can’t put meetings in.

That stops anyone putting meetings in, even people who genuinely need meetings with the OP!

InsertUsernameHere · 30/09/2023 20:09

The only thing I would add to all the advice you have been given, is to speak to your manager before you do it. That way if there are any complaints - your manager can say - I knew about that, I’ve agreed with thepeople keeping appropriate boundaries to ensure she gets her work done.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 29/09/2023 23:34

I'd decline her meeting requests and give what you consider a reasonable alternative. Eg put something in for half an hour in a weeks time to go through all her queries for the week

Thepeopleversuswork · 29/09/2023 23:15

ThirtyThrillionThreeTrees · 29/09/2023 18:06

I had this and in the end I just got ruthless because of the annoyance and time cost.

You need to adopt a zero tolerance. It's not your job and she really is taking advantage of your kindness to date.

Speak with her manager & tell her it's put of control and you won't be entertaining it any longer and put it in writing that you expect the manager to address it.

Responded to everything with "I don't have capacity to assist on this, please raise it with your manager", as she'll probably persist for a while.

I forwarded every single email, appointment she put in my diary, screenshot every text, call, IM etc. to her manager until it stopped.

I'm more than happy to help most people but I won't help people with no boundaries and/or people who aren't willing to help themselves.

You're totally right. I need to grey rock her at work.

OP posts:
CherryMaDeara · 29/09/2023 23:09

Also block out your diary so she can’t put meetings in.

HowDoesThisWorkPlease · 29/09/2023 22:59

ThirtyThrillionThreeTrees · 29/09/2023 18:06

I had this and in the end I just got ruthless because of the annoyance and time cost.

You need to adopt a zero tolerance. It's not your job and she really is taking advantage of your kindness to date.

Speak with her manager & tell her it's put of control and you won't be entertaining it any longer and put it in writing that you expect the manager to address it.

Responded to everything with "I don't have capacity to assist on this, please raise it with your manager", as she'll probably persist for a while.

I forwarded every single email, appointment she put in my diary, screenshot every text, call, IM etc. to her manager until it stopped.

I'm more than happy to help most people but I won't help people with no boundaries and/or people who aren't willing to help themselves.

This

ThirtyThrillionThreeTrees · 29/09/2023 18:06

I had this and in the end I just got ruthless because of the annoyance and time cost.

You need to adopt a zero tolerance. It's not your job and she really is taking advantage of your kindness to date.

Speak with her manager & tell her it's put of control and you won't be entertaining it any longer and put it in writing that you expect the manager to address it.

Responded to everything with "I don't have capacity to assist on this, please raise it with your manager", as she'll probably persist for a while.

I forwarded every single email, appointment she put in my diary, screenshot every text, call, IM etc. to her manager until it stopped.

I'm more than happy to help most people but I won't help people with no boundaries and/or people who aren't willing to help themselves.

Jibo · 29/09/2023 17:24

she has form for then going to more senior people and saying "X isn't supporting me properly on this account, can I have another manager who is more engaged?" so it's risky for me.

How is that risky if she doesn't report to you, though?

You can block and mute people on teams and I hope you have hidden your diary from her prying eyes.

She's already been asked to leave you alone and hasn't listened. That's harassment. I would suggest making a written complaint to HR ccing her line manager, with details of dates/times of unwanted contact. Ordinarily it's not ideal to come across as a troublemaker, snitch or whatever, but I think in this case you'll be doing them a favour. They must be desperate to get her out.

Tiredbehyondbelief · 29/09/2023 15:16

Definitely time to get tough

TrickOrRuddyTreat · 29/09/2023 15:09

I've had similar in previous jobs and in my current job I've had to manage someone just like her, it's exhausting on all fronts!

I agree with pps saying be less available to spontaneous calls and push her towards the mentors she already has.

I do understand your fear of her making you look unhelpful if you ignore her etc. I would suggest that if she calls (and you haven't asked her to) then drop the call and send a Teams message saying you're in the middle of something and can't talk. Ask her to put it in an email and you'll respond when you can. She will reply with either an email or another Teams message and either way it will be clear it isn't a specific work question so either way you should respond by saying 'that sounds like something X, Y and Z are best placed to help with so it's best you speak to one of them'. If she's emailed you then cc them in.

If she says anything to you about preferring to speak to you or comments that you aren't helping/supporting etc you can point out that she has mentors already allocated to her and you don't want to tread on anyone's toes, especially as you don't have time to be a mentor yourself. You can't be accused of not being helpful if you are clearly directing her towards help.

AlwaysFoldingWashing · 29/09/2023 15:03

I would start replying with every email with her mentors and line managers copied in so they can see the extent of the unwanted communications and can deal with her from now on. Will be awkward to start but will probably address the issue

Thepeopleversuswork · 29/09/2023 14:59

Thanks all, very helpful advice.

@ManateeFair this really resonated with me:

for some reason I just couldn't bring myself to speak to her manager somehow - it just felt like I was snitching!

I really intrinsically dislike working in a culture where people go running to managers to complain about other staff unless it's absolutely necessary. I far prefer dealing with people directly and one to one. I also dislike the idea that work interaction has to be strictly limited to business discussions, some of the joy of work is talking about non work stuff. But that only works if people don't abuse it.

But she's been told. I've asked her on three separate occasions to send non urgent questions to me via email so I can deal with them when I have time and not to suddenly bounce me into having to deal with her shit all the time and she doesn't learn or take any of it on.

Time to get tough.

OP posts:
WitcheryDivine · 29/09/2023 14:48

Usually I'd give someone as much support as possible at work but it's clear this woman is the next level, she has been told 100 times not to keep bothering people about non-work stuff but she cannot/will not listen.

So in your case I would:

  • decline the meetings, no need to explain why (if asked face to face, just say you have a packed week)
  • decline the calls, no need to explain why (as above)
  • if she messages, respond rarely and only if it's absolutely necessary
  • if responding in a message or in person, fake complete ignorance/be deliberately unhelpful - so if she says "X person is doing Y thing" instead of asking questions or taking it seriously/trying to solve it, have a generic answer like "oh dear" or even better "oh dear, I'm sure your manager is the person to speak to about that"
  • "I don't know" is a magical answer (even if you do, obviously must do etc) - so if she says "what do you think I should do to follow up with X project" you are allowed to just say "oh, I'm not sure"/"I don't know"/"hmm"

I think what she's basically looking for is ATTENTION and so you need to starve her of it by being really boring and uninterested.

WrongSwanson · 29/09/2023 14:44

I think definitely limit contact and also raise it with her manager.

There was someone like this at my work and untol people started flagging to her manager it wasn't tackled, but once it started being flagged her manager r realised pretty much all of this person's week was taken up with ringing different people and just being needy

BettyPhuckzer · 29/09/2023 14:43

I agree that you need to reject every single diarised meeting

I'd suggest that anything that she emails to you, you forward to her line manager cc-ing her in and asking for her LM to deal with it

If she phones, say you're too busy and ask her to email her LM. If she emails you instead, as above!

If she pops into your office to chat, ask her to speak to her line namager , reject any diary entries, forward any emails

That should sort it!

ManateeFair · 29/09/2023 14:39

It sounds like this is something that needs to be addressed by her manager (assuming her manager and your manager are not the same person).

When I was in a similar situation with someone at work, I knew the only person who could deal with it was really her manager, who needed to be aware of her behaviour, but for some reason I just couldn't bring myself to speak to her manager somehow - it just felt like I was snitching! But I had a conversation with my own manager about how to approach it, and my own manager said she would address it with the other manager because she could do that without saying who it was that had complained, and because they were on the same management rung so it was more of peer to peer conversation than me saying 'Hello senior manager, your team member is a pain in the arse and I feel like I'm being stalked by her, sort it out'

MammaTo · 29/09/2023 14:37

Omg I am so sympathetic to you because this drives me fucking insane! The constant reassurance and hand holding drives me mental.
I had a colleague like this and in the end I used to forward her messages to her team leader/mentor and say “Hi X has this question, is this something you can help with as I’m tied up with XYZ” or reply to them directly with something similar “can you ask your team leader as I’m tied up with such and such a task”.
In the end I think one of her managers needs to be firm with her and say part of your annual review was to ask us for support and you’re not doing that. It’s a really tough situation.

ShooLala · 29/09/2023 14:31

Dear oh dear. I feel your pain. I had one of these vampires at work but on a personal level. Could. Not. Leave. Me. Alone. Smashed through every boundary I tried to put in place so that she could bore me yet again about herself. Same subject gone over and over for years and years. Shocking neediness that drained the life out of me and anyone else she latched on to. Complete fun sponge that sucked any small pleasure out of going to work. Luckily I was able to resign and bin her off.

Swipe left for the next trending thread