Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dealing with needy colleague

91 replies

Thepeopleversuswork · 29/09/2023 13:20

Wonder if anyone has any advice: I'm at my wits' end with this. Sorry, long.

I have a colleague who is constant need of support, advice, feedback, hand-holding and its driving me absolutely nuts.

She's not junior, mid-level role, mid 30s and has been with the firm well over a year so it's more than teething problems. She calls or Teams messages me five or six times a day to discuss REALLY trivial things about the job which she should either know herself by now or know which channels to go through. Or unilaterally puts meetings in my diary with her without checking first.

I'm senior but not leadership, three levels above her and she doesn't report into me I think she just finds me sympathetic. But she has a lot of support already in place and it's really not my job to deal with it.She's got two senior mentors (from the top management) and a line manager already, (none of them me).

She's technically good at her job but struggles with "soft" skills: boundaries/inappropriate behaviour/wasting time and generally bad at reading a room. Has had various flare-ups with people over her manner. Very bad at taking any criticism or feedback, which tends to trigger tears, accusations of victimisation and requests for more support from management/training etc. Numerous people have tried to coach her through various aspects of this (not being too much of a drain on management time, asking questions appropriately, not hogging conversation etc) and she takes all of it incredibly personally and it triggers tears etc. All of this has been raised at performance reviews. She's been told to stop bothering people (including me) with tiresome questions and demands for more mentoring etc.

I was giving her the benefit of the doubt -- and I'm generally a big fan of giving people time and of mentoring and support and helping them adapt culturally. But it's got to the point where dealing with her requests is a massive drain on both my time and emotional resources.

I've started screening calls and I will say "can you just email me and I'll come back when I have time?" etc, but she still hasn't got the message - every professional interaction I have with her leads to a request for a "debrief" or "feedback" and a meeting being booked in my diary. It's as if any engagement at all is seen as a green light to ask for more. I'm now at the point where I'm considering asking her not to contact me at all without a specific business need, or asking HR to do this, but I know this is going to trigger another furious meltdown. Should I do this or should I ask my managers/HR to do it?

OP posts:
Thepeopleversuswork · 01/10/2023 12:46

PortalooSunset · 01/10/2023 10:20

If you know she's been told about this but is still doing it, not just to you but others as well, why on earth is she not on some form of performance management?!

She is. Her probation was extended twice. She's now technically completed probation because it was felt she'd dealt with these issues but she seems to have slipped into old habits and she is now on a performance review (none of which I have any input into).

She's theoretically eligible for promotion at the end of the year and has told everyone she is going to be promoted and told her line manager she will find another job if not promoted. But SLT are giving serious thought to actually terminating her contract. She seems not to be able to learn from mistakes at all.

OP posts:
Thepeopleversuswork · 01/10/2023 12:42

TigerBull · 01/10/2023 00:42

PS I re-read and notice the mentors are senior management. Is there no one at, or closer to, the employee's hierarchical level who can be a mentor?

Just from experience that "blokes in suits" terrify me, which in turn is likely why the employee comes to you. Whenever people from head office come to visit, I literally only speak if I'm invited in to the conversation, or to offer a tea/coffee/etc, otherwise my tongue is likely to get me into trouble!

The issue with having a mentor closer to her level is that she's fallen out with almost all of the people at her level.

As for the "blokes in suits" thing: all of the senior leadership team at this company are women. As are all of her mentors.

I don't think she's terrified of anyone. She's extremely forthright and confident in work situations. She just reacts really really badly to being told what to do or criticised.

OP posts:
EmpressaurusOfCats · 01/10/2023 12:33

At my place when someone’s being taught to do something, they’ll be encouraged to take notes, or given a manual if someone’s written one. Is that a far too simplistic answer?

ChlorrOfTheMask · 01/10/2023 12:30

TigerBull · 01/10/2023 00:42

PS I re-read and notice the mentors are senior management. Is there no one at, or closer to, the employee's hierarchical level who can be a mentor?

Just from experience that "blokes in suits" terrify me, which in turn is likely why the employee comes to you. Whenever people from head office come to visit, I literally only speak if I'm invited in to the conversation, or to offer a tea/coffee/etc, otherwise my tongue is likely to get me into trouble!

Exactly this, she's probably turning to those around her because it's scary to continually annoy managers. She might be frightened she'll be sacked

ChlorrOfTheMask · 01/10/2023 12:26

TigerBull · 01/10/2023 00:10

Came here to say thank you for this reply @ChlorrOfTheMask 😊 I relate to both OP and the employee as I am both.

I wonder if, as part of the performance review process, an assessment on learning styles has been completed? For example I am a very visual learner, show me step by step while allowing me to take notes (eg click this button, then a dialog box appears, then click this), being patient when I ask can you show me again. Or a step by step guide with screenshots. In these situations I absolutely thrive, and at most may ask "can you check that I've done this correctly please?". I openly ask for baby steps.

OP my suggestion is to suggest this to your line manager. The making of the resources (if they don't already exist!) will take time, but it is for the two mentors and the line manager to plan and execute/delegate. If there is a particular task the employee comes to you about repeatedly, you could offer to prepare that guide and then reply with "have you checked your guide? This is covered in (section 4/page 7/etc)"

I also acknowledge how being empathetic can lead OP to sometimes feeling drained. I 'latch' on to other people, as others 'latch' on to me. Going to your manager with this solution hopefully provides both yourself and the employee a way to reset boundaries, but also still respond tactfully to future requests.

I think what you've said about learning styles and guides is important <3

PortalooSunset · 01/10/2023 10:20

If you know she's been told about this but is still doing it, not just to you but others as well, why on earth is she not on some form of performance management?!

BadSkiingMum · 01/10/2023 09:00

Make a detailed record of her incursions into your time for a defined period, preferably a month. This will help when she complains about you, as she inevitably will.

However, I think you also need to ask yourself why this has gone on for so long. What about her has made this difficult for you to stop?

XelaM · 01/10/2023 08:47

OP - I soooooo sympathise because I have the exact same problem with a colleague who Teams messages and calls me ALL DAY LONG and if I don't reply immediately she emails/texts me. Everything takes me 10 times longer to do because I'm constantly busy replying to her inane questions

Hibiscrubbed · 01/10/2023 08:37

If you feel it’s ‘risky’ for you, you need a very frank dialogue with her actual line managers about the situation, and repeatedly.

Dustybarn · 01/10/2023 08:31

Some great suggestions from pp here. I’d not accept any meeting requests from her and answer all calls with “sorry, can’t talk. Crazy deadline. Can you email me and copy x so if I can’t get to it maybe x can”. You need an email trail for HR. If she doesn’t copy x then forward to x copying your colleague. When she realizes that management are seeing all her requests she will likely stop.

theduchessofspork · 01/10/2023 00:50

And revive her access to your diary or just send a bcc round Robin email (which will only be sent to her) informing everyone that any meetings put in your diary without checking will be deleted. And then delete them.

theduchessofspork · 01/10/2023 00:48

Speak to her manager and HR and let them deal with it.

It’s a disciplinary issue and it’s simply not your problem.

Just be less helpful to her. Go back every couple of days referring her to other people (don’t answer every query she’s sent you in 2 days, just one or two). You are feeding it by giving her attention so you have to cut off the oxygen supply.

TigerBull · 01/10/2023 00:42

PS I re-read and notice the mentors are senior management. Is there no one at, or closer to, the employee's hierarchical level who can be a mentor?

Just from experience that "blokes in suits" terrify me, which in turn is likely why the employee comes to you. Whenever people from head office come to visit, I literally only speak if I'm invited in to the conversation, or to offer a tea/coffee/etc, otherwise my tongue is likely to get me into trouble!

JFDIYOLO · 01/10/2023 00:26

You have your own job, objectives, targets to deliver.

Minutely supporting her probably doesn't figure in those essentials.

Her line manager is responsible for her performance management.

Make it clear to your own LM that delivering to your own targets is your number 1 priority and that to this end
you'll hand all this over to her LM with a written statement why this is essential.

Tell her from now on all requests for metoring/coaching/feedback etc must go direct to her LM as you must focus on your own workload and time management.

If you have that feature, lock off your meetings calendar for now - yes that will mean nobody can book a meeting and they will all have to email you to ask when is convenient.

TigerBull · 01/10/2023 00:10

Came here to say thank you for this reply @ChlorrOfTheMask 😊 I relate to both OP and the employee as I am both.

I wonder if, as part of the performance review process, an assessment on learning styles has been completed? For example I am a very visual learner, show me step by step while allowing me to take notes (eg click this button, then a dialog box appears, then click this), being patient when I ask can you show me again. Or a step by step guide with screenshots. In these situations I absolutely thrive, and at most may ask "can you check that I've done this correctly please?". I openly ask for baby steps.

OP my suggestion is to suggest this to your line manager. The making of the resources (if they don't already exist!) will take time, but it is for the two mentors and the line manager to plan and execute/delegate. If there is a particular task the employee comes to you about repeatedly, you could offer to prepare that guide and then reply with "have you checked your guide? This is covered in (section 4/page 7/etc)"

I also acknowledge how being empathetic can lead OP to sometimes feeling drained. I 'latch' on to other people, as others 'latch' on to me. Going to your manager with this solution hopefully provides both yourself and the employee a way to reset boundaries, but also still respond tactfully to future requests.

ReadingSoManyThreads · 01/10/2023 00:00

I had this with a colleague. Sadly, she was just not cut out for the job. She went to every person in the workplace other than her Line Manager for help on how to do the job, and I'm talking random people with no experience of our department. Anyway, eventually, all of us got sick of it and started directing her to her Line Manager, she never ever went to her, turns out she didn't like her Line Manager (who was lovely). Anyway, she failed her probation and was let go for being shite. She cried. The rest of us sighed with relief. As heartless as it sounds, it was for the best, she couldn't cope with the job and was massively struggling.

You need to address this with her Line Manager and get tough, become a brick wall.

ChlorrOfTheMask · 30/09/2023 23:54

pandarific · 30/09/2023 23:14

I think yes as @ChlorrOfTheMask says, this colleague is highly highly likely to be ND. The behaviour is inappropriate and does need to stop, but just keep it very very professional, calm, polite, and refer back to her manager every time. You’re not tattling, they are aware and are the person tasked with supporting her.

Yeah, I think it's likely OP's colleague is autistic or ADHD too, although we can't obviously assume. I'd add that as well as being professional and polite while signposting to appropriate support, boundaries will need to be explicitly, gently, patiently explained and a warm tone rather than a cold one makes a huge difference. A cold tone could cause confusion and suffering to the colleague for days afterwards. Remembered that it's not her fault she is the way she is.

ChlorrOfTheMask · 30/09/2023 23:46

Bored1000 · 30/09/2023 23:30

@ChlorrOfTheMask
Thanks for your response, and giving some perspective, sounds like you had a very bad experience.
Some workplace environments can be very difficult to navigate, I’d say there isn’t anyone on here who hasn’t had a bad work experience at some point, but not all are like that, hope you are better supported in the next job you go onto.

Thanks. The thing is, it wasn't a particularly bad experience; this was a typical experience. I felt a sense of pride in myself for working, liked all my colleagues and although I could tell I irritated most of them, most of them were friendly to me when they weren't feeling harassed. I had a kind and supportive line manager. The anxiety, confusion and needs I've described are just what social environments/work environments tend to be like for neurodivergent people. The OP's colleague might not be experiencing the same as I did, but I think it's likely she might be.

Bored1000 · 30/09/2023 23:30

@ChlorrOfTheMask
Thanks for your response, and giving some perspective, sounds like you had a very bad experience.
Some workplace environments can be very difficult to navigate, I’d say there isn’t anyone on here who hasn’t had a bad work experience at some point, but not all are like that, hope you are better supported in the next job you go onto.

Moveoverdarlin · 30/09/2023 23:24

Start rejecting her meetings and having your own dramas, fire off emails like

  • ‘up against it, shits hit the fan, spk later’
  • ‘Hi, it’ll have to wait, issues at home, don’t ask!’
  • ‘Catch up Friday when I’ve got more time, I’m worried about project X and under loads of pressure. *’This morning has been a nightmare, can you ask Manager to sort this time?’
pandarific · 30/09/2023 23:14

I think yes as @ChlorrOfTheMask says, this colleague is highly highly likely to be ND. The behaviour is inappropriate and does need to stop, but just keep it very very professional, calm, polite, and refer back to her manager every time. You’re not tattling, they are aware and are the person tasked with supporting her.

ChlorrOfTheMask · 30/09/2023 23:11

Bored1000 · 30/09/2023 23:02

@ChlorrOfTheMask
I get your point, it’s a difficult one to answer
Have you found yourself in that position and if you have how would you suggest that it is handled in the workplace from your perspective.

If when I'm able to work again I find someone's needing lots of help from me at work, I'll understand having been there myself, so I'll try to help as much as I can. If they needed more help than I was able to give, I'd explain that to them gently and clearly, as well as talking to someone in a position of authority about how this person obviously needs more support. It sounds like part of the problem here is the colleague is just being told to stop bothering her colleagues and go to the managers with any queries, but obviously doesn't feel she can do so. Maybe because she's not being adequately supported by the management, because everyone just sees her as a pain in the arse seeking extra support they assume she doesn't actually need.

Bored1000 · 30/09/2023 23:02

@ChlorrOfTheMask
I get your point, it’s a difficult one to answer
Have you found yourself in that position and if you have how would you suggest that it is handled in the workplace from your perspective.

ChlorrOfTheMask · 30/09/2023 22:52

also want to add as someone has said the colleague should "grow up or get out as she isn't coping" that there's huge pressure for everyone to be in paid work and shame piled on those of us who aren't working and are surviving on benefits, but when we do go to work, if we're not as confident or competent as everyone else, this comments section is how people respond. Can you all try to imagine how it feels to not be able to cope in a workplace like everyone else, so if you do work your colleagues feel like this ^ about you, but then if you don't work, everyone's judging you and assuming you're a lazy scrounger?