Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think you can't behave however you want because of MH issues?

206 replies

insertanswerhere · 29/09/2023 11:21

DH is struggling atm with MH issues. He's usually such a lovely, lively person but at the moment our life stresses are causing him to be irritable, moody...basically hard to be around. He'll get mad at me about anything, raise his voice at me and the kids, make the home environment not a nice place to be. I know it's because he's feeling like he can't cope at the minute so I'm not saying anything and trying to take on as much as I can myself so that he doesn't have to. But does he have the right to be unkind to everyone because he's struggling? Do I just have to put up with it so that I'm being supportive? How can I say, without making things worse, that he can't go on behaving in this way? (He's currently getting help for his issues but it's early days).

OP posts:
Teder · 01/10/2023 16:30

Atmytethersend · 01/10/2023 16:06

Would you ask the same of someone who had cancer?

Of course most people would! I would shield my children as much as practically possible and indeed, I do. I have a serious illness and I do treatments with needles and IVs. It’s not something they need to witness. It’s not age appropriate. They know “mummy is poorly”.
If a person is irritable and another parent is around, then the husband needs to find a way to remove himself from any triggers. If he’s not coping, he goes to his room and shuts the door or goes for a walk or does whatever is helpful for his own health.

“Leaving” doesn’t mean moving out, it means separating the children from witnessing an unwell parent.

CharlotteRumpling · 01/10/2023 16:15

Do people with cancer generally yell and huff at their 3-year-olds? Or create an atmosphere of walking on eggshells? I have had a family member with cancer- whom I nursed btw- and that was not my experience. Women are not therapy centres.

HoneyBadgerMom · 01/10/2023 16:15

Jumpingthruhoops · 01/10/2023 15:39

Ahh, if only it was that easy. As the other poster said, you only have to look at the situation on the streets of the US to see how 'easy' it is to access mental health services. Not.

Similarly, mental health support in the UK - and I mean REAL MH support, not just chucking someone a few pills! - is distinctly lacking. Unless you can afford to go private (which I did).

So, respectfully, I think you need to do a bit more research into what mental health support is actually available before suggesting people are weak for not accessing it. You can't access something that doesn't exist!

It is very easy to access mental health services in the States. But when you access those services, they will not allow you to use drugs while in treatment. They will expect you to get clean, they will expect you to obey the law and they will expect you to TRY to put yourself together. This silly lie that we don't have access to medical and mental health care in the US is transparent propaganda. If someone wants help, there are many, MANY ways to get it.

People CHOOSE to remain on the streets because they prefer to do drugs, commit crimes and live lives with no responsibilities. THAT is the majority of those living on the streets in the US. Those with devastating mental health issues are not getting help because of nonsense like "it's impossible to get mental health help in the mean ol' United States" so lets just leave them out there until they end up killing themselves, either deliberately or accidentally. Heaven forbid we actually help people who desperately need it, better to just let them fester in the streets rather than hurt their feelings by making them stop using drugs and committing crimes. Fake compassion and virtue signaling is not helpful to anyone. Ever.

Things could be different in the UK, I know NHS is a terrible mess, which is why most in the US do NOT want government healthcare. That's a whole different discussion, though.

Atmytethersend · 01/10/2023 16:06

CharlotteRumpling · 29/09/2023 13:13

I'd ask him to leave if possible, and sort himself out. He can come back when he feels able to be civil.

Would you ask the same of someone who had cancer?

itsmyp4rty · 01/10/2023 16:01

I think if you can't reduce or remove the stresses that are affecting him then he needs to move out while he gets help. This is not a healthy environment for your children if he is constantly angry and shouting.

What are the stresses that he is struggling to cope with?

SiouxsieSiouxStiletto · 01/10/2023 15:55

'Services' aren't readily available. I think the current wait time for talking therapies on the NHS is about three years!

And medication is NOT for everyone, due to the catalogue of side effects - mental and physical - associated with them. These are not drugs I'd suggest people take lightly.

I know. It can take years to be seen and medication can have side affects. I hear what you're saying.

That doesn't give him a free pass to be a bastard to his family though and a swine to live with.

I think the OP just needs to look at if he's willing to seek help and change or if this is how he's going to be.

Froodwithatowel · 01/10/2023 15:51

My ex suffered horribly with a diagnosed MH need and all the meds, and was a truly lovely person in their good patches, but the relentless depression and needing to argue me down that absolutely everything was awful and horrible and wrong, and the rages where she'd throw things and kick out panes of glass? Or scream and swear at me? I grew up with a parent with violent tantrums and I found myself shaking and frozen like I used to when my parent lost it, and becoming increasingly depressed myself.

I cared a great deal about my ex. I tried for a long time to support and help them, but I could not expect them to be any different: they didn't have the resources, and they felt terrible so much of the time. But I couldn't live with feeling like that and being treated like that 24/7, and I had a right to a relationship that was happy and fulfilling rather than frightening and abusive. They didn't mean it to be like that for me, but in reality it was. There comes a point where you accept that they don't mean it, they can't help it, and that does not compel you to stay in a relationship that is making you unhappy.

Jumpingthruhoops · 01/10/2023 15:43

SiouxsieSiouxStiletto · 01/10/2023 15:16

I agree with others, it entirely depends on what he's doing to recover.

If he's not actively doing things to help himself to recover like engaging with services and taking medication then he's simply being horrid to you and Dd and it could most probably will go on for years.

You have to decide if you and DD want to live like that.

'Services' aren't readily available. I think the current wait time for talking therapies on the NHS is about three years!

And medication is NOT for everyone, due to the catalogue of side effects - mental and physical - associated with them. These are not drugs I'd suggest people take lightly.

Jumpingthruhoops · 01/10/2023 15:39

HoneyBadgerMom · 01/10/2023 14:36

Nonsense, that's clearly not what I said. Having a mental illness and doing nothing about it, and expecting the people around you to bear the brunt of your issues, is weakness. Having ZERO self control and following your impulses like a child is weakness.

Making excuses and refusing to take responsibility for your actions is also weakness.

Ahh, if only it was that easy. As the other poster said, you only have to look at the situation on the streets of the US to see how 'easy' it is to access mental health services. Not.

Similarly, mental health support in the UK - and I mean REAL MH support, not just chucking someone a few pills! - is distinctly lacking. Unless you can afford to go private (which I did).

So, respectfully, I think you need to do a bit more research into what mental health support is actually available before suggesting people are weak for not accessing it. You can't access something that doesn't exist!

SiouxsieSiouxStiletto · 01/10/2023 15:16

I agree with others, it entirely depends on what he's doing to recover.

If he's not actively doing things to help himself to recover like engaging with services and taking medication then he's simply being horrid to you and Dd and it could most probably will go on for years.

You have to decide if you and DD want to live like that.

SlippySarah · 01/10/2023 14:59

Jumpingthruhoops · 01/10/2023 12:55

You're confusing those using MH as an 'excuse' with those suffering from genuine mental health issues. Surely you know that? Or are you saying you think all mental illnesses are an excuse for bad behaviour?

Honestly, the ignorance on this thread is breathtaking.

Edited

No I'm not. Having a mental health problem doesn't excuse poor behaviour. I didn't say anything about it being genuine or not. We all have a responsibility to manage our behaviour, whatever the reason for it.

HoneyBadgerMom · 01/10/2023 14:47

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 01/10/2023 05:09

Mental ill health is not "weakness".

Thankfully the civilised world has moved beyond institutionalising people who display undesirable behaviours, but the irony here is the US has an epidemic of totally untreated catastrophic mental ill-health, partly because of the lack of institutional care.

What your attitude leads to is exactly what you see on the streets of major US cities. Entire blocks full of down and outs, most of them with complex, untreated mental health issues, living rough, at the mercy of all sorts of vice, and with little to no hope of ever seeing their lives turned around.

Do your 'life is tough, deal with it' routine all you want. The very fact you can 'tough it out' shows that no matter what you say, your mental health issues clearly are not sufficient to make you dysfunctional, so perhaps you could lay the fuck off with the sanctimony over those less fortunate, and ditch the ridiculous tough guy act because all it does is show that you genuinely haven't got the first idea about what serious mental illness is.

🙄Ridiculous.

You're making excuses for people, and THAT is weakness.

What I clearly said is that someone who cannot control themselves, who acts on every impulse and is unable to be safely around children needs to not be around children. Seriously, if you're throwing a tantrum and attacking people because of a mental illness, you don't think the right thing to do is get help?

"I have a condition, I can't be expected to behave like an adult, and everyone around me has to indulge me and coddle me" isn't going to help anyone with mental illness.

I've clearly triggered the snowflakes. I'm not surprised, typically those like you don't like to be told you need to be responsible for your behavior. It says a lot about you that you would happily allow someone to terrorize and traumatize children because you don't want to "stigmatize" them. It's all about virtue signaling and fake compassion, with exactly zero concern for the damage done to children. Those children can just suck it up, right? Never mind that typically those struggling with mental illness are in that struggle because of childhood trauma. 🙄 We certainly wouldn't want to expect an adult to make an adult choice, that's not "civilized" in your view.

All across the US, in every major city, we see people strung out on drugs, living in their own filth, and no one is doing anything to help them. Because heaven forbid we actually help them by bringing them to a hospital where they will be weaned off the drugs and given psychiatric care and helped to get their lives back under control. No, fake virtue signalers like you want to leave them to their struggle because we wouldn't want them to have to exercise some self control. What you're advocating for isn't compassion.

HoneyBadgerMom · 01/10/2023 14:36

Jumpingthruhoops · 01/10/2023 12:49

So, in your view, having a mental illness is a weakness?

'I have ZERO patience for weakness'

I have ZERO patience for ignorance.

Blimey, this thread really is the gift that keeps on giving... 🤯

Nonsense, that's clearly not what I said. Having a mental illness and doing nothing about it, and expecting the people around you to bear the brunt of your issues, is weakness. Having ZERO self control and following your impulses like a child is weakness.

Making excuses and refusing to take responsibility for your actions is also weakness.

Jumpingthruhoops · 01/10/2023 13:33

CharlotteRumpling · 01/10/2023 13:12

You are not really going to get people to agree with you @Jumpingthruhoops by making personal attacks. Plenty of people on this thread don't. Including those with experience of MH issues.

Anyway the OP hasn't returned, so maybe she is just going to put up with it. Her choice. We all decide what we can put up with.

I'm not trying to get people to agree with me - I already know I'm right.🤷🏼‍♀️

Hardly a personal attack, though. You openly admitted you don't care what people think of you!

Yes, I guess we should leave things to OP now. Hopefully they can work through their issues together.

Jumpingthruhoops · 01/10/2023 13:27

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 01/10/2023 13:14

@Jumpingthruhoops so you don't think a child's need to be and feel safe should be prioritised? they don't matter more... but, in that moment, the adult is the one who's poorly. Obviously. So because the adult is 'poorly' their behaviour should be accepted?

To a degree, yes. As I've already said, if they're actually violent, then that's another matter entirely. That's not the case here.

But, yes, in a healthy relationship, in times of crisis, people work through things together. Not just abandon them. But you do you.

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 01/10/2023 13:14

@Jumpingthruhoops so you don't think a child's need to be and feel safe should be prioritised? they don't matter more... but, in that moment, the adult is the one who's poorly. Obviously. So because the adult is 'poorly' their behaviour should be accepted?

CharlotteRumpling · 01/10/2023 13:12

You are not really going to get people to agree with you @Jumpingthruhoops by making personal attacks. Plenty of people on this thread don't. Including those with experience of MH issues.

Anyway the OP hasn't returned, so maybe she is just going to put up with it. Her choice. We all decide what we can put up with.

Jumpingthruhoops · 01/10/2023 13:07

CharlotteRumpling · 01/10/2023 10:53

Luckily I am not Christian and didn't take any marriage vows. Asking someone to leave for a bit is fine in my book.

Now why doesn't that surprise me?

Jumpingthruhoops · 01/10/2023 13:04

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 01/10/2023 05:09

Mental ill health is not "weakness".

Thankfully the civilised world has moved beyond institutionalising people who display undesirable behaviours, but the irony here is the US has an epidemic of totally untreated catastrophic mental ill-health, partly because of the lack of institutional care.

What your attitude leads to is exactly what you see on the streets of major US cities. Entire blocks full of down and outs, most of them with complex, untreated mental health issues, living rough, at the mercy of all sorts of vice, and with little to no hope of ever seeing their lives turned around.

Do your 'life is tough, deal with it' routine all you want. The very fact you can 'tough it out' shows that no matter what you say, your mental health issues clearly are not sufficient to make you dysfunctional, so perhaps you could lay the fuck off with the sanctimony over those less fortunate, and ditch the ridiculous tough guy act because all it does is show that you genuinely haven't got the first idea about what serious mental illness is.

1000% this! With bells on.

You've probably seen my very short response to this poster. I frankly couldn't come up with any more words.

But you have articulated my thoughts beautifully here.

Jumpingthruhoops · 01/10/2023 12:55

SlippySarah · 01/10/2023 08:52

Adults need to take responsibility for their behaviour, no matter what might be behind it. I can have sympathy for someone with a MH condition and want to be supportive, but I don't have to live with someone who behaves unpleasantly no matter why that might be.

MN is full of posts from people who use anxiety or depression as excuses for things they do and the general feeling is "oh that's OK then", it's not ok to be a dick just because you've got an illness.

You're confusing those using MH as an 'excuse' with those suffering from genuine mental health issues. Surely you know that? Or are you saying you think all mental illnesses are an excuse for bad behaviour?

Honestly, the ignorance on this thread is breathtaking.

Jumpingthruhoops · 01/10/2023 12:52

Teder · 01/10/2023 08:40

I wouldn’t allow my children to be scared by a parent in their own home.

I have a physical illness and shield my children from some of the overt parts of it.

That's because you are of sound mind in order to be able to do that.

Are you really not understanding what's being said here?

Jumpingthruhoops · 01/10/2023 12:49

HoneyBadgerMom · 01/10/2023 03:03

I have not read all the responses.

I am someone who has struggles with mental health issues. I am also SUPER independent, stubborn and have VERY high standards for myself. I insist on being tough and independent because nothing scares me like dependence.

All that said, I think today people use "mental health" and "neurodivergence" as excuses to act like children. It's overused and an excuse to not have any discipline or self control. "It's a condition, I can't control it."

If someone's mental health has deteriorated to the point where they cannot control themselves, they need to be in an institution. I realize people will think that's mean. I'm American, Texan, and have had a really hard life, so I have ZERO patience for weakness. It is mean, they are correct. Life is mean. Nature is mean. Reality is mean.

Occasional outbursts happen. It's not a sign of bad mental health to have a bad day. But if it's a common occurrence for someone to have a fit when they don't get their way, they're not "neurodivergent." They're a brat.

When adults have mental health issues, they get help and get it under control. They don't subject the people in their lives, and certainly not CHILDREN, to their rages. When you care about your family, you protect them, you don't use them as whipping posts for your frustrations.

You have a responsibility to protect your children. Exposing them to someone who is mentally unstable to the point where they cannot control themselves is not protecting them.

So, in your view, having a mental illness is a weakness?

'I have ZERO patience for weakness'

I have ZERO patience for ignorance.

Blimey, this thread really is the gift that keeps on giving... 🤯

Jumpingthruhoops · 01/10/2023 12:36

Atethehalloweenchocs · 30/09/2023 15:54

Stop being provoked. It is shitty to be on the receiving end of this but it is not personal. When you are able to turn your emotions off and just see it as part of illness, then you can approach this without triggering further outbursts.

I have worked in MH for 20+ years and fundamentally disagree with this. Yes, there are people who cannot control themselves such as people with psychosis or bipolar. But other than that, people can control themselves from being unkind and cruel and it makes me so cross to hear people giving carte blanche to people because of MH issues. Plenty of the people I have worked with have struggled for years without being arseholes to the people they live with.

You may have 20+ years of working in mental ill health but I fundamentally disagree with this.
With all your experience, you'll know first hand that one size doesn't fit all.
As an aside, I haven't found the mental health 'professionals' I've dealt with all that supportive. The first hospital I went to discharged me... that's the night I nearly died.
So forgive me for taking what 'mental health professionals' say with a pinch of salt.

CharlotteRumpling · 01/10/2023 10:53

Luckily I am not Christian and didn't take any marriage vows. Asking someone to leave for a bit is fine in my book.

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 01/10/2023 10:31

Jumpingthruhoops · 01/10/2023 00:53

They don't matter more... but, in that moment, the adult is the one who's poorly. Obviously.

Honestly, I cannot believe some of these responses.

Anyone that supports this stance is literally saying out loud: 'My husband's suffering really badly with depression, but his mood swings are scaring the kids, so I had to chuck him out!'

Whatever happened to 'In sickness and in health', eh?

I don't think the 'forsaking all others' is intended to mean to make children live in an unsafe environment? In sickness and in health also doesn't mean having to accept all
behaviours it could also mean making extreme steps like leaving or asking them to leave while they seek professional help.