Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH thinks best friend is a freeloader because of facebook

514 replies

Notanotherhousepost · 29/09/2023 10:30

Firstly I want to say, money is not the issue. We are more than comfortable. We have also always had joint finances - everything goes into a joint pot.

So, BF - lets call her Jane, works for the NHS as a band 4 - used to be a band 6 but when her job ended the best she could get was a 4. She's late 50s and works in admin.

Her outgoings are greater than her incomings even before food - her mother helps her out each month.

Most of her friends, including me, are a lot better off. I live the opposite end of the country from her. If she comes to visit I pay her train tickets and cover the cost of anything we do including food and drink. She literally can'f afford it.

Other friends will take her to gigs etc

DH has a massive issue with her because (1) he doesn't believe you should get help from people to the extent she does and (2) she never posts on facebook the way he thinks she should.

She'llpost about going to XYZ gig or going out for the day but does not say "thank you to notanotherhousepost for buying me the ticket"

Or"thank you to my other mate for getting me the ticket to XYZ"

Frankly I couldn't care less and she always sends a thank you note. But apparently she should be making it clear she can only do these things because people pay for her.

I just don't get it - I don't understand even vaguely where he's coming from.

OP posts:
lottiegarbanzo · 30/09/2023 09:18

Your DH sounds mean - and more importantly, has an enjoyment of humiliating other people publicly. That is not a nice characteristic.

He wants to 'put her in her place' publicly. Maybe wearing a sign around her neck and ringing a bell while announcing her gratitude would please him? Bit of scraping, grovelling and doffing of cap?

He's a bully, basically.

SurprisedWithAHorse · 30/09/2023 09:16

Do you know, I actually feel sorry for all these posters who have never just wanted to do something nice for another person without trying to work out how the person could move house to pay for it themselves or whatever.

Some people want to do nice things with people they care about and don't mind covering it if that's the only way it can happen. You don't have to be one of those people if you don't want to.

SilentHedges · 30/09/2023 09:13

SurprisedWithAHorse · 30/09/2023 08:59

She can't go to gigs and restaurants otherwise because she is paying too much for housing. Her friends aren't physically paying her rent, but they are subsiding her chosen lifestyle (ie the obvious thing being her rent is unnecessarily high).

The pretzels you are twisting this into to justify your anger at a woman who isn't taking a penny from you or anyone who doesn't wish to give it are laughable.

She covers her housing, so all your guff about that is irrelevant. She just can't do much fun stuff outside of essentials. Her friends who like her want to do stuff with her and can afford to treat her, so they do. If they stopped, she'd carry on living in her house and just not go to gigs etc with them.

She's not "relying" on them. They don't pay her rent. They pay for her fun stuff. They want to.

You sound like those men who refuse to pay CMS because the mother goes to the gym or something and they can't grasp that that's not what they're paying for.

Edited

Thank you for second guessing my emotions, while chucking in the personal insults and personality assumptions, while ironically showing you're somewhat more emotionally involved in this than I am.

To remind you, the AIBU question in the OPs original post is her husband thinks the friend is freeloading. Which clearly she is, for all the reasons I've explained to you. Solved by all the solutions I've given to you.

As you suggest, if of course she wishes to continue to do this and her friends wish to continue subsiding this ad finitum, they're at liberty to do so, but ultimately, over the next 40 years or so, if she doesn't seek these solutions, there will be a bad outcome.

Some people play chess and some don't.

Mothership4two · 30/09/2023 09:11

NewName122 · 30/09/2023 09:05

Jane sounds like a scrounger.

Except scroungers ask for or insinuate they want things and tend to give nothing in return which quite clearly is not happening according to the OP.

she never suggests doing anything, I invite her. She would never dream of inviting herself. several time a year I stay at hers for the wekend and she cooks etc and makes me more than welcome

NewName122 · 30/09/2023 09:07

Jane needs to claim universal credit to see if she can get any help with her housing costs.

SurprisedWithAHorse · 30/09/2023 09:05

It isn't even about thanks, that's what's so nasty. She gives her thanks. The husband wants her to make a public statement to the world that she is enjoying things that were covered by others. Could anything be crasser?

Let's be honest, if I shared all the things my husband's salary and not mine have covered, and stated "Thanks for spending all this money, husband, I didn't pay for it!", I'd look like an absolute twat on so many levels. Who cares? Who needs to know? And why?

NewName122 · 30/09/2023 09:05

Jane sounds like a scrounger.

C8H10N4O2 · 30/09/2023 09:03

Ringdoodledumpling · 29/09/2023 22:52

@C8H10N4O2 if it’s the OPs disposable fun spend it nothing to do with him and if she chooses to spend her money on her friend that fine.

If it’s from joint accounts it’s his money too. So yes, he can feel annoyed cos social media is just about image. She can do what she does without posting. Yet she does. For image.

OP can do what she likes with her own money (and it is described as her money). She also spends money doing things for her DH.

So you view friendship as a financial transaction whereby the one who hands over money for a trainfare is the donor and the person bringing friendship and fun on that train provides nothing? I think you have a skewed view of relationships, very depressingly so.

Why on earth shouldn't she post as normal if that is what she and her friends normally do. Again - absolutely nothing to do with DH, she isn't even one of his friends. He isn't required to snoop through her FB posts.

Perhaps you think the OP should ditch any friends without equal income and instead take up the proverbial MN hobby and spend the money on lycra and an overpriced bike. Then go on solitary cycling routes and not see anyone. Would that get DH approval do you think?

Fuck that - she spends a small amount of her money (in annual terms) on maintain a friendship of value to her since before she knew DH. She has known this woman in good times as well remember.

Everyone saying she should ditch a friends who can't keep up with her financially is undervaluing friendship and telling us a lot about how they value people.

wednamenov · 30/09/2023 09:03

@grex Jesus Christ. 🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️ I suppose you think she's probably eating to much avocado on toast too <sarcasm>

Sjh15 · 30/09/2023 09:01

If you have 5k disposable income a month (wow, can only dream of that) and she can’t even afford her bills then I think to expect her to put a thank you on Facebook will probably make her feel like scum of the earth, saying thank you to you should be enough, the world + Facebook don’t need to know that you’re to thank and it’s quite entitled to expect a public thank you.

SurprisedWithAHorse · 30/09/2023 08:59

SilentHedges · 30/09/2023 08:51

Yes, we agree, she IS relying on friends. She can't go to gigs and restaurants otherwise because she is paying too much for housing. Her friends aren't physically paying her rent, but they are subsiding her chosen lifestyle (ie the obvious thing being her rent is unnecessarily high).

Solutions: Friend gets better paid job, and pays less for housing and therefore can support herself without relying on others.

It's fantastically simple maths that "most" people understand in order to get by in life.

She can't go to gigs and restaurants otherwise because she is paying too much for housing. Her friends aren't physically paying her rent, but they are subsiding her chosen lifestyle (ie the obvious thing being her rent is unnecessarily high).

The pretzels you are twisting this into to justify your anger at a woman who isn't taking a penny from you or anyone who doesn't wish to give it are laughable.

She covers her housing, so all your guff about that is irrelevant. She just can't do much fun stuff outside of essentials. Her friends who like her want to do stuff with her and can afford to treat her, so they do. If they stopped, she'd carry on living in her house and just not go to gigs etc with them.

She's not "relying" on them. They don't pay her rent. They pay for her fun stuff. They want to.

You sound like those men who refuse to pay CMS because the mother goes to the gym or something and they can't grasp that that's not what they're paying for.

GRex · 30/09/2023 08:58

Notanotherhousepost · 29/09/2023 20:23

The only reason I know the details is she has asked me.to help.review her budget to see.if there is anything she's missed.

She's missed that her rent is much too high. Unfortunately if she has a low income then she can't afford that much on a nice flat to rent. In many parts of London she can get a studio for £800-900, which would revolutionise her budget. Anything below £1200 would also allow universal credit contributions. She could also go for bank shifts to top up salary, apply for roles with travel etc.

I don't think she needs to thank people on Facebook, but I also don't think you and your friends are actually helping her by making her into a charity case, it must be so humiliating for her and that will breed resentment and friendship issues over time.

wednamenov · 30/09/2023 08:58

Notanotherhousepost · 29/09/2023 10:30

Firstly I want to say, money is not the issue. We are more than comfortable. We have also always had joint finances - everything goes into a joint pot.

So, BF - lets call her Jane, works for the NHS as a band 4 - used to be a band 6 but when her job ended the best she could get was a 4. She's late 50s and works in admin.

Her outgoings are greater than her incomings even before food - her mother helps her out each month.

Most of her friends, including me, are a lot better off. I live the opposite end of the country from her. If she comes to visit I pay her train tickets and cover the cost of anything we do including food and drink. She literally can'f afford it.

Other friends will take her to gigs etc

DH has a massive issue with her because (1) he doesn't believe you should get help from people to the extent she does and (2) she never posts on facebook the way he thinks she should.

She'llpost about going to XYZ gig or going out for the day but does not say "thank you to notanotherhousepost for buying me the ticket"

Or"thank you to my other mate for getting me the ticket to XYZ"

Frankly I couldn't care less and she always sends a thank you note. But apparently she should be making it clear she can only do these things because people pay for her.

I just don't get it - I don't understand even vaguely where he's coming from.

God this makes me angry.

Why does he want her to do this? So you publicly look like great benefactors, or so she is publicly exposed to the world? That's repulsive .

I never to lie to my DH, but on something like this I'd tell him she'd paid her own way (even if I paid), and I certainly wouldn't discuss any details of her private struggles with him. I can't see myself in this situation though because your husbands attitude gives me the Ick so I'd probably be in the relationships forum asking for advice on leaving him.

Does she have to have her dignity stripped off her as well as everything else? So your DH feels validated ... how ...? That the world order of rich and poor is publicly recognised? That the poor recognise the superiority of the rich and grovel appropriately. Honestly, totally revolting values and such a breathtakingly unattractive quality.

I know so many people in your friend's situation and my heart breaks for them and I worry so much about how bad things have got in this country that professional qualified people working full time jobs can't make ends meet. My DH and I are a heart-beat away from being in this situation - extremely well-educated (seven degrees between us), middle class, working etc. Your husband is embarrassingly clueless about whats actually going on in the country.

It absolutely terrifies me that people with empathy bypasses and a streak of ignorant self-righteous self-centred selfishness like your DH might vote in the Tories more self-centred selfish bastards with empathy bypasses to wreak more damage on the country and destroy more lives.

Your friend isn't a free-loader, she's a victim. And your husband is victim blaming.

SoundTheSirens · 30/09/2023 08:55

The question people should be asking here is not “why doesn’t she move somewhere cheaper?” but “why the fuck have rents been allowed to get so out of kilter with salaries that a full-time NHS worker can barely afford to rent in the South East, where these jobs are needed just as much as they are further north?”

SurprisedWithAHorse · 30/09/2023 08:53

If her close friends all live the other end of the country where her salary would go much further, why doesn’t she move?

Because her job is where she is and it sounds like that was hard enough to get, she likely has important people like family and other friends there, and moving is a huge stress and massive expense.

I don't know where you live but it's likely you could find somewhere cheaper in the UK. So why don't you move?

SilentHedges · 30/09/2023 08:51

SurprisedWithAHorse · 30/09/2023 08:41

This woman is relying on friends

She's not relying on them for her housing costs. And it doesn't sound as if she has any expectations for what they do pay for.

What are these "solutions"? The only problem is that she can't go to gigs and restaurants with people who want to go with her. So they choose to treat her, as they can afford to and they want to. Is that not a solution?

Yes, we agree, she IS relying on friends. She can't go to gigs and restaurants otherwise because she is paying too much for housing. Her friends aren't physically paying her rent, but they are subsiding her chosen lifestyle (ie the obvious thing being her rent is unnecessarily high).

Solutions: Friend gets better paid job, and pays less for housing and therefore can support herself without relying on others.

It's fantastically simple maths that "most" people understand in order to get by in life.

Kwasi · 30/09/2023 08:48

No objection to helping out friends and don’t think gratitude needs to be public, but..

If her close friends all live the other end of the country where her salary would go much further, why doesn’t she move? Personally, I couldn’t stand to live in an area where I didn’t even have enough left over after paying rent that I had to use my mother’s pension money just to eat. That’s no way to live.

Totaly · 30/09/2023 08:44

*Team husband

Defiantly not!

I bet your DH benefits more than £300 a year from your wages -

Actually if you work it out he puts in 1/3 but spends 1/2

17% benefit for being married to you. If you earn £50K and he earns £25 that’s £12,500 extra £6250 is his free of charge!

Does he post on FB how grateful he is?

Andnowtowhatcomesnext · 30/09/2023 08:42

Why shouldn’t she post her fun times on Facebook? If she was funded by some family trust fund or rent from a house left to her, she wouldn’t be earning the money but wouldn’t be judged. Someone born into a massively wealthy family, who doesn’t need to earn money, has done nothing to ‘change their life circumstances’ or earn that money.

I also think saying that a 50 year old woman whose salary doesn’t cover the basics should ‘just change her circumstances’ is just naive. How should she do that? What needs to change is making sure that people can afford to live.

Why is her rent so high? Because we have allowed a small percentage of people to hoard assets. The more they buy, the more they earn, the more they can buy and so on. Capital Gains Tax is tiny compared to the massive amounts of wealth that the top 2% make (doing absolutely nothing to earn it I might add). why is her salary comparatively low?

I work as a HC professional in the NHS and I can tell you very clearly that the Band 3 admin posts are not only an essential part of the service, they ensure that those of us with specific clinical skills can use our time efficiently and effectively doing ‘only what only we can do’. So why should the OPs friend change her life? She should be able to afford to live as someone in an essential
service role.

The anger at the OPs friend is misplaced IMHO and should be aimed at a system that has consistently underfunded public services, promoted social inequality and failed to tax wealth so that life becomes more affordable for all.

liveforsummer · 30/09/2023 08:42

Notanotherhousepost · 29/09/2023 10:50

That wouldnt work.... he hardly spends anything. Which is fine because I'm the main earner (double his take home).

After all out bills (we are mortage free) we ahve £5K per month to spend on food, fuel, holidays and shite and giggles. No kids.

Does he thank you publicly on Facebook for being the major contributor to your finances. He is BU

SurprisedWithAHorse · 30/09/2023 08:41

SilentHedges · 30/09/2023 08:38

Incorrect, I didn't HAVE to flatshare. I could have rented an expensive flat for myself. I flatshared because because it enabled me to save money, be independent and have enough money that I could go about my life without being "subbed" by other people.

If I had family support helping me out, so I didn't have to flatshare, then no I wouldn't have done it. Because then presumably I'd have family money paying for me and then I wouldn't have to rely on friends either.

This woman is relying on friends, ergo she needs to rethink her housing costs, or get a better paid job. Mumsnet really hates solutions.

This woman is relying on friends

She's not relying on them for her housing costs. And it doesn't sound as if she has any expectations for what they do pay for.

What are these "solutions"? The only problem is that she can't go to gigs and restaurants with people who want to go with her. So they choose to treat her, as they can afford to and they want to. Is that not a solution?

SilentHedges · 30/09/2023 08:38

SurprisedWithAHorse · 30/09/2023 08:28

You did it because you had to.

If you had a mother in a position to help you out so you didn't have to, would you have done it?

Maybe you would. Personally I'm not particularly proud about help from parents so if accepting some money from my mother kept me out of house sharing in my 40s after I lost my job and couldn't fully recover my career, then I'd do it and not feel bad at all (assuming she could afford it without detriment to her lifestyle, of course).

I wouldn't feel any need to live a way I didn't want to when I didn't have to, just to prove a point. My husband earns more than I do so while I contribute, I already live a very subsidised life.

Edited

Incorrect, I didn't HAVE to flatshare. I could have rented an expensive flat for myself. I flatshared because because it enabled me to save money, be independent and have enough money that I could go about my life without being "subbed" by other people.

If I had family support helping me out, so I didn't have to flatshare, then no I wouldn't have done it. Because then presumably I'd have family money paying for me and then I wouldn't have to rely on friends either.

This woman is relying on friends, ergo she needs to rethink her housing costs, or get a better paid job. Mumsnet really hates solutions.

Batalax · 30/09/2023 08:34

I’m with you op, however I don’t like Facebook bragging, and I really wouldn’t like Facebook bragging that isn’t even being funded by herself, so for me, I think it’s how the Facebook posts are worded. If it’s factual or obvious bragging.

Nina1013 · 30/09/2023 08:33

Your husband sounds awful.
We are in a better financial position than many of our family and friends.
We regularly pay for things, including weekends away and the odd holiday, because we enjoy their company and know they couldn’t afford it otherwise. It’s our decision, they don’t ask us to.
Our one rule is, we offer, it gets booked/paid and then it’s never mentioned again. I don’t want repeated thanks, it just reminds everyone that there’s a ‘power imbalance’ in the relationship and I hate that. It’s ’the Holiday’ or ‘the weekend away’ not ‘the holiday that X and Y paid for’ etc. I would die if this was mentioned on Facebook - our financial situation is our own business and so is the other party’s.
If we didn’t pay for things, they’d still enjoy our company. They did long before we were able to do this and if we lost it all tomorrow they wouldn’t disappear into the distance.

SilentHedges · 30/09/2023 08:30

SpidersAreShitheads · 30/09/2023 07:58

Different people have different priorities though. Some folks are very happy in a shared house, for others, that would be complete misery.

I've lived in a shared house before. I'm in my 40s now and I couldn't do it again.

From the OP's description, her friend hosts her, cooks dinner etc - that's really difficult in a shared house.

The friend sounds pretty frugal - it's not her fault that her friends want to treat her. And OP doesn't say much about the friend's mother - maybe she's comfortable financially and is happy to top up her daughter's income.

Moving into a shared house feels like a drastic solution that wouldn't necessarily improve her quality of life.

Absolutely people have different priorities, and I would have loved a place of my own, and like you I would never have shared if I didn't have to. I had some terrible but equally really enjoyable experiences. BUT I certainly wouldnt expect friends to pick up the tab linked to my life choices, so I down graded my living expectations and paid my own way.

This friend wants it both ways, to live in unnecessary housing she cant afford, but then to take hospitality, paid gifts etc from friends to "compliment" her lifestyle. I'm all for helping people in need, but not someone who could a) save on living expenses and /or b) seek a better paid job.

Swipe left for the next trending thread