Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH thinks best friend is a freeloader because of facebook

514 replies

Notanotherhousepost · 29/09/2023 10:30

Firstly I want to say, money is not the issue. We are more than comfortable. We have also always had joint finances - everything goes into a joint pot.

So, BF - lets call her Jane, works for the NHS as a band 4 - used to be a band 6 but when her job ended the best she could get was a 4. She's late 50s and works in admin.

Her outgoings are greater than her incomings even before food - her mother helps her out each month.

Most of her friends, including me, are a lot better off. I live the opposite end of the country from her. If she comes to visit I pay her train tickets and cover the cost of anything we do including food and drink. She literally can'f afford it.

Other friends will take her to gigs etc

DH has a massive issue with her because (1) he doesn't believe you should get help from people to the extent she does and (2) she never posts on facebook the way he thinks she should.

She'llpost about going to XYZ gig or going out for the day but does not say "thank you to notanotherhousepost for buying me the ticket"

Or"thank you to my other mate for getting me the ticket to XYZ"

Frankly I couldn't care less and she always sends a thank you note. But apparently she should be making it clear she can only do these things because people pay for her.

I just don't get it - I don't understand even vaguely where he's coming from.

OP posts:
SurprisedWithAHorse · 30/09/2023 10:20

Kwasi · 30/09/2023 10:14

That’s what I said. No one else seems to have picked up on the face Jane’s elderly mother is giving her money for food shopping every month. Honestly, when you need your mother’s pension to feed yourself, it’s time to reassess your life.

Or it's time to reassess the cost of living against salaries.

At any rate, if OP stopped buying gig tickets and meals out for Jane, Jane's mother would still be helping her because OP's money isn't going towards Jane's rent.

There are so many pretzels and accusations and deflections and made-up bollocks on this thread, but it's all looking very much to me like the age-old "poor people should never be allowed to have fun" mentality that PPs have shared links about.

SurprisedWithAHorse · 30/09/2023 10:16

SilentHedges · 30/09/2023 09:32

I do honestly wish you'd stop transposing emotions that you seem to "know" I'm feeling. It's quite cringey and embarrassing. Do try not to be personal towards people in a discussion, it's really not helpful.

It's also really not about me, it's about how most fully functioning adults, with the privilege of freedom and choice operate and get through life.

You're right it's not about you, which is why it's hard to see why you're so offended by it.

A person who was unable to completely recover her career after job loss has friends who would rather pay for her tickets than go without her as she can't afford it. That's all it is. If you can't understand why some people would do that, you don't have to do it yourself.

Since you like to talk about solutions so much, perhaps you can address the real problem here: that a person in an essential NHS service role can't afford a decent, modest life. But that doesn't seem to be what offends you.

Bellyblueboy · 30/09/2023 10:15

So it’s not enough that she says thank you - she has to declare to everyone that the rockets were a gift?

explore why this annoys your husband: he doesn’t want the gift givers thanks - they have been. He wants everyone to know this lady can’t afford the tickets. He wants her to be humble and small.

does he think she is showing off - trying to be better than she is?

of her Facebook page annoys him why is he looking?

Kwasi · 30/09/2023 10:14

That’s what I said. No one else seems to have picked up on the face Jane’s elderly mother is giving her money for food shopping every month. Honestly, when you need your mother’s pension to feed yourself, it’s time to reassess your life.

FUPAgirl · 30/09/2023 10:13

OP please stop telling your judgemental DH your friends business. Why are you even telling him who paid for her ticket etc? Stop talking about her private business, both to your DH and on social media!

SurprisedWithAHorse · 30/09/2023 10:12

Sureaseggs44 · 30/09/2023 09:44

You missed the bit out about her mother bailing her out on essentials presumably because she can not meet her rent and bills .

something has to give somewhere .

That's nobody's business but hers and her mother's. The poster was angry because she claims OP subsidises the friend's rent. She doesn't.

Louiseb85 · 30/09/2023 10:12

I live in the southeast and my rent is much lower than that for 3 bedrooms. The south east is a large area with some deprived towns like Hastings, so to say the rent in that area is high is a generalisation. And my comment was based on the original post, not ant other additional information that was added after. Unfortunately I don't have time to read 17 pages of comments

FUPAgirl · 30/09/2023 10:12

JollyJunee · 30/09/2023 09:40

Haven’t read the whole thread, apologies if this has been mentioned already.
Im amazed a Band 6 nurse could only get an admin Band 4 job. I’m Band 6 NHS and could have my pick of so many jobs. I know it’s not ‘the point’ of the thread, but it’s very hard luck if that’s all available work wise.
I think you’re a lovely friend OP, I’d do the same for a pal. Can’t believe your DH needs/wants public confirmation of his benevolence. 🙄

But she isn't a nurse, she works in admin. Clearly it was a temp contract at B6 and she hasn't been able to secure another B6 position. In my trust, there are very few B6 admin positions . I am surprised you have your pick of them in your trust. Most admin in my trust are B2 or 3.

Pinkglobelamp · 30/09/2023 10:07

wednamenov · 30/09/2023 08:58

God this makes me angry.

Why does he want her to do this? So you publicly look like great benefactors, or so she is publicly exposed to the world? That's repulsive .

I never to lie to my DH, but on something like this I'd tell him she'd paid her own way (even if I paid), and I certainly wouldn't discuss any details of her private struggles with him. I can't see myself in this situation though because your husbands attitude gives me the Ick so I'd probably be in the relationships forum asking for advice on leaving him.

Does she have to have her dignity stripped off her as well as everything else? So your DH feels validated ... how ...? That the world order of rich and poor is publicly recognised? That the poor recognise the superiority of the rich and grovel appropriately. Honestly, totally revolting values and such a breathtakingly unattractive quality.

I know so many people in your friend's situation and my heart breaks for them and I worry so much about how bad things have got in this country that professional qualified people working full time jobs can't make ends meet. My DH and I are a heart-beat away from being in this situation - extremely well-educated (seven degrees between us), middle class, working etc. Your husband is embarrassingly clueless about whats actually going on in the country.

It absolutely terrifies me that people with empathy bypasses and a streak of ignorant self-righteous self-centred selfishness like your DH might vote in the Tories more self-centred selfish bastards with empathy bypasses to wreak more damage on the country and destroy more lives.

Your friend isn't a free-loader, she's a victim. And your husband is victim blaming.

Yes, I agree.

Pinkglobelamp · 30/09/2023 10:05

Louiseb85 · 30/09/2023 09:48

Your husband is wrong. If she is thanking you privately there is no need to make a big deal on social media. However it is concerning that a lady her age is sponging off other people to this extent. What will she do when her mother is no longer around? Her rent seems quite high. Is she living within her means? Maybe she needs to downsize her house. She is taking the P to be honest

Her rent is normal for the southeast, she's struggling with depression after bereavement so working at all is probably incredibly difficult, she's doing a job that's doing good for society...surely housing costs, the lack of social welfare support for people going through traumatic experiences and low pay in essential jobs are the issues and should be blamed, rather than pretending someone who sounds as if she's showing extraordinary levels of strength, determination and hard work is "taking the piss"?!

Seaside3 · 30/09/2023 09:59

Jane should become financially more savvy. However, what you choose to do with your money, and how Jane chooses to thank you, is none if your husbands business.

Expecting her to Publicly declare her thanks on socials is crass.

Perhaps Jane is embarrassed, or doesn't want to make her other friends feel obliged/inadequate. Maybe she feels a thank you note is sufficient.

Just out of interest, does your hubby publicly thank you every yine you go.out, as you're the main bread earner?

CinnamonJellyBeans · 30/09/2023 09:56

There's something very wrong with your husband that he feels the need to make her do that, shame herself publicly because she is "less than" the other members of your friendship group.

I find it concerning that he's also policing your friendships. What is his motivation behind this?

I would take a fresh look at this man and his core values as a human and a husband.

Louiseb85 · 30/09/2023 09:48

Your husband is wrong. If she is thanking you privately there is no need to make a big deal on social media. However it is concerning that a lady her age is sponging off other people to this extent. What will she do when her mother is no longer around? Her rent seems quite high. Is she living within her means? Maybe she needs to downsize her house. She is taking the P to be honest

jessycake · 30/09/2023 09:47

In the south east rents have massivly outstripped incomes , yet if everyone gave up their low paid jobs / got better paid jobs / moved to somewhere cheaper we would have a severe shortage of services . I feel sorry for her .

Sureaseggs44 · 30/09/2023 09:46

DinnaeFashYersel · 30/09/2023 09:26

Your DH's views on how she posts on Facebook are bizarre

Agree , if she sends thank you notes that’s lovely and adequate . But agree with him about her living beyond her means . .

Sureaseggs44 · 30/09/2023 09:44

SurprisedWithAHorse · 30/09/2023 08:59

She can't go to gigs and restaurants otherwise because she is paying too much for housing. Her friends aren't physically paying her rent, but they are subsiding her chosen lifestyle (ie the obvious thing being her rent is unnecessarily high).

The pretzels you are twisting this into to justify your anger at a woman who isn't taking a penny from you or anyone who doesn't wish to give it are laughable.

She covers her housing, so all your guff about that is irrelevant. She just can't do much fun stuff outside of essentials. Her friends who like her want to do stuff with her and can afford to treat her, so they do. If they stopped, she'd carry on living in her house and just not go to gigs etc with them.

She's not "relying" on them. They don't pay her rent. They pay for her fun stuff. They want to.

You sound like those men who refuse to pay CMS because the mother goes to the gym or something and they can't grasp that that's not what they're paying for.

Edited

You missed the bit out about her mother bailing her out on essentials presumably because she can not meet her rent and bills .

something has to give somewhere .

JollyJunee · 30/09/2023 09:40

Haven’t read the whole thread, apologies if this has been mentioned already.
Im amazed a Band 6 nurse could only get an admin Band 4 job. I’m Band 6 NHS and could have my pick of so many jobs. I know it’s not ‘the point’ of the thread, but it’s very hard luck if that’s all available work wise.
I think you’re a lovely friend OP, I’d do the same for a pal. Can’t believe your DH needs/wants public confirmation of his benevolence. 🙄

lottiegarbanzo · 30/09/2023 09:34

I would ask your husband why he needs to put other people down, or to see them being put down (putting themselves down even!) in order to feel good about himself. Why is he 'not enough' as he is, as you know him to be?

The obvious implication is that he has low self-esteem and derives his idea of self-worth from a very fragile and subjective idea of public status.

That is not a healthy way to be - for him, or for the people around him.

SilentHedges · 30/09/2023 09:32

SurprisedWithAHorse · 30/09/2023 09:23

It's not just OP's situation that you like to make all about you, is it?

She is clearly not freeloading because as OP says, she does not expect the gifts, she does not request them, she does not need them to survive. They are offered to her by people who want to give them and she accepts with thanks. It's a pity you can't understand the difference.

If you are so sure that she's heading for some terrible punishment for the great crime of not being like you, then it's hard to see why you're so pissed off. Her comeuppance for accepting the gifts is coming, so what's the problem?

The "solutions" you offer are for what you consider the problem to be: someone being treated to things they couldn't afford otherwise. To me, OP and others, that's not a problem. The problem is that OP wants to do nice things with her friend but friend can't afford them after covering her housing and bills. OP can, so she covers it.

Maybe that will change in future, maybe it won't. In the meantime, there's nothing wrong with the situation as it is unless you have an issue with people who are able to treat the people they care about choosing to do so.

I do honestly wish you'd stop transposing emotions that you seem to "know" I'm feeling. It's quite cringey and embarrassing. Do try not to be personal towards people in a discussion, it's really not helpful.

It's also really not about me, it's about how most fully functioning adults, with the privilege of freedom and choice operate and get through life.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 30/09/2023 09:28

SurprisedWithAHorse · 30/09/2023 09:16

Do you know, I actually feel sorry for all these posters who have never just wanted to do something nice for another person without trying to work out how the person could move house to pay for it themselves or whatever.

Some people want to do nice things with people they care about and don't mind covering it if that's the only way it can happen. You don't have to be one of those people if you don't want to.

Haven't read the entire thread but it's clear from what I have read that this friendship to OP means enough that she's happy to sub Jane and can afford to. The DH OTOH has been pretty much summed up by lottiegarbanzo's comment. He likes, it appears, the power to humiliate lesser, less well off people that money gives him and thinks they should acknowledge that power imbalance all the time. I do wonder what his attitude would be if Jane were a male friend of the OP, as well.

*Your DH sounds mean - and more importantly, has an enjoyment of humiliating other people publicly. That is not a nice characteristic.

He wants to 'put her in her place' publicly. Maybe wearing a sign around her neck and ringing a bell while announcing her gratitude would please him? Bit of scraping, grovelling and doffing of cap?

He's a bully, basically*

DinnaeFashYersel · 30/09/2023 09:26

Your DH's views on how she posts on Facebook are bizarre

SurprisedWithAHorse · 30/09/2023 09:23

SilentHedges · 30/09/2023 09:13

Thank you for second guessing my emotions, while chucking in the personal insults and personality assumptions, while ironically showing you're somewhat more emotionally involved in this than I am.

To remind you, the AIBU question in the OPs original post is her husband thinks the friend is freeloading. Which clearly she is, for all the reasons I've explained to you. Solved by all the solutions I've given to you.

As you suggest, if of course she wishes to continue to do this and her friends wish to continue subsiding this ad finitum, they're at liberty to do so, but ultimately, over the next 40 years or so, if she doesn't seek these solutions, there will be a bad outcome.

Some people play chess and some don't.

It's not just OP's situation that you like to make all about you, is it?

She is clearly not freeloading because as OP says, she does not expect the gifts, she does not request them, she does not need them to survive. They are offered to her by people who want to give them and she accepts with thanks. It's a pity you can't understand the difference.

If you are so sure that she's heading for some terrible punishment for the great crime of not being like you, then it's hard to see why you're so pissed off. Her comeuppance for accepting the gifts is coming, so what's the problem?

The "solutions" you offer are for what you consider the problem to be: someone being treated to things they couldn't afford otherwise. To me, OP and others, that's not a problem. The problem is that OP wants to do nice things with her friend but friend can't afford them after covering her housing and bills. OP can, so she covers it.

Maybe that will change in future, maybe it won't. In the meantime, there's nothing wrong with the situation as it is unless you have an issue with people who are able to treat the people they care about choosing to do so.

WetWetBottomOnTheNightBus · 30/09/2023 09:22

I'm not sure how it's your husbands business tbh.
Who would expect their friend to grovel on social media?
If said friend is thanking you in a way you find appropriate then tell him to butt out....
Is it something to do with you being the higher earner? Does he thank you on Facebook? Are you expecting him to increase his earning potential?
It sounds mean and a bit distasteful imo.

Kindling1970 · 30/09/2023 09:22

Nice to see lots of empathy for OP's friend here.

GRex · 30/09/2023 09:19

wednamenov · 30/09/2023 09:03

@grex Jesus Christ. 🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️ I suppose you think she's probably eating to much avocado on toast too <sarcasm>

What a strange reply. The rent is a problem, and OP was explicitly asked to help with her budget, so buying her a few drinks on a night out instead of discussing it is frankly strange. She is over the rent limit for universal credit, because she's actually spending a lot on her rent.

Swipe left for the next trending thread