Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH thinks best friend is a freeloader because of facebook

514 replies

Notanotherhousepost · 29/09/2023 10:30

Firstly I want to say, money is not the issue. We are more than comfortable. We have also always had joint finances - everything goes into a joint pot.

So, BF - lets call her Jane, works for the NHS as a band 4 - used to be a band 6 but when her job ended the best she could get was a 4. She's late 50s and works in admin.

Her outgoings are greater than her incomings even before food - her mother helps her out each month.

Most of her friends, including me, are a lot better off. I live the opposite end of the country from her. If she comes to visit I pay her train tickets and cover the cost of anything we do including food and drink. She literally can'f afford it.

Other friends will take her to gigs etc

DH has a massive issue with her because (1) he doesn't believe you should get help from people to the extent she does and (2) she never posts on facebook the way he thinks she should.

She'llpost about going to XYZ gig or going out for the day but does not say "thank you to notanotherhousepost for buying me the ticket"

Or"thank you to my other mate for getting me the ticket to XYZ"

Frankly I couldn't care less and she always sends a thank you note. But apparently she should be making it clear she can only do these things because people pay for her.

I just don't get it - I don't understand even vaguely where he's coming from.

OP posts:
SurprisedWithAHorse · 01/10/2023 12:24

MistressoftheDarkSide · 01/10/2023 11:10

With regard to sodding housing costs - I am in a South coast university town. I live in a relatively large but quirky and dilapidated property. My son and DIL live with me. We were lucky enough to get this property through my late DP having connections, when we encountered a crisis due to our previous rental becoming insecure due to a legal dispute between the leaseholder and the freeholder. We were very lucky, about 4 years ago. It was in my DPs employer’s (also a long time friend) interests to keep his most lucrative employee securely housed.

Fast forward to now. The rent is 1200. The bills are around 600. My DS and DIL contribute 600 a month and I am solely responsible for the rent. Since my business started to tank we have looked into down sizing. As a single person a bedsit would still cost me 800 in the current market, and a small 2 bed would be 1200. Plus bills.

My DIL was working full time but has developed a chronic long term health condition so is off sick and desperate to figure out how to survive. My DS works in an industry that was paying well till the writers strike had the knock on effect of decimating said industry. He’s currently doing landscaping work.

Every fucking thing has gone tits up for us in a short space of time.

The point I’m trying to make is that just moving is not simple. OPs friend is currently securely housed. She’s working, on hand for her mother who is at liberty to help her daughter if she is able to and chooses to. No-one else’s business.

If she moves it may cost her thousands which she plainly doesn’t have. A month - or more deposit plus a months rent up front. Potential commute costs. Moving costs.

No doubt she “should” just sell any possessions, lose all sense of security and comfort because her “pride” at being in penury should keep her warm, right? A good dose of suffering will teach her, right? Turn her into a responsible economic unit ? Or might she feel life isn’t worth living and spend the rest of her life grinding away to appease the capitalist monster?

Think of all those myths about dragons where towns and villages are held hostage, feeding the beast with everything they produce including sacrificing people, until a hero turns up to save them by slaying the dragon…. It strikes me as a relevant metaphor for modern life, but there is no hero to slay the dragon. Instead it’s a race to the bottom and a smug attitude that because a few can do well, so should everyone else, regardless of economic factors etc.

Maybe as more people find their illusory security chipped away we might realise that we’re heading for really dark times, because at some point the bread and circus routine won’t be sustainable.

Just move house, just get a better job, just solve all your mental anguish by going for a walk, just bend the world to your will, just suck up your suffering because it’s good for the soul - not that we believe in that sort of nonsense of course.

The only things I have that give me meaning or hope are my kitten, which some here will no doubt consider an unnecessary expense (but that’s ok - I have no appetite so my food budget is about 2.00 a day) and my DS because somehow I want him to have a better life.

If the OPs friend is being kept sane and functional by the odd treat from a lovely friend, why the hell does the DH want to take that away from her and humiliate her to boot?

I am sorry that ignorant, glib and flippant comments on here about "why doesn't Jane just move" seem to have upset you, as they would me if I were in that situation. I'm sure Jane isn't actually an idiot and that it has occurred to her but there are reasons she is where she is.

I'm almost glad, though, because you've explained so well why just move isn't the magic, easy solution so many people think it is. I wonder if they'd like all their NHS service providers to just move somewhere else.

And of course, the "poor people don't deserve to have fun" mindset that naturally everyone will deny.

MistressoftheDarkSide · 01/10/2023 11:46

@Pinkglobelamp

Thank you ♥️

Pinkglobelamp · 01/10/2023 11:26

What I don't understand is that surely OP's friend, by doing an essential job at a very low wage and paying most of that wage to a property owner, is subsidising all of us (plus the property owner) at great sacrifice to herself.

So why isn't OP's husband thanking her on Facebook every time he is able to do something enjoyable due to his good health?

Pinkglobelamp · 01/10/2023 11:21

MistressoftheDarkSide · 01/10/2023 11:10

With regard to sodding housing costs - I am in a South coast university town. I live in a relatively large but quirky and dilapidated property. My son and DIL live with me. We were lucky enough to get this property through my late DP having connections, when we encountered a crisis due to our previous rental becoming insecure due to a legal dispute between the leaseholder and the freeholder. We were very lucky, about 4 years ago. It was in my DPs employer’s (also a long time friend) interests to keep his most lucrative employee securely housed.

Fast forward to now. The rent is 1200. The bills are around 600. My DS and DIL contribute 600 a month and I am solely responsible for the rent. Since my business started to tank we have looked into down sizing. As a single person a bedsit would still cost me 800 in the current market, and a small 2 bed would be 1200. Plus bills.

My DIL was working full time but has developed a chronic long term health condition so is off sick and desperate to figure out how to survive. My DS works in an industry that was paying well till the writers strike had the knock on effect of decimating said industry. He’s currently doing landscaping work.

Every fucking thing has gone tits up for us in a short space of time.

The point I’m trying to make is that just moving is not simple. OPs friend is currently securely housed. She’s working, on hand for her mother who is at liberty to help her daughter if she is able to and chooses to. No-one else’s business.

If she moves it may cost her thousands which she plainly doesn’t have. A month - or more deposit plus a months rent up front. Potential commute costs. Moving costs.

No doubt she “should” just sell any possessions, lose all sense of security and comfort because her “pride” at being in penury should keep her warm, right? A good dose of suffering will teach her, right? Turn her into a responsible economic unit ? Or might she feel life isn’t worth living and spend the rest of her life grinding away to appease the capitalist monster?

Think of all those myths about dragons where towns and villages are held hostage, feeding the beast with everything they produce including sacrificing people, until a hero turns up to save them by slaying the dragon…. It strikes me as a relevant metaphor for modern life, but there is no hero to slay the dragon. Instead it’s a race to the bottom and a smug attitude that because a few can do well, so should everyone else, regardless of economic factors etc.

Maybe as more people find their illusory security chipped away we might realise that we’re heading for really dark times, because at some point the bread and circus routine won’t be sustainable.

Just move house, just get a better job, just solve all your mental anguish by going for a walk, just bend the world to your will, just suck up your suffering because it’s good for the soul - not that we believe in that sort of nonsense of course.

The only things I have that give me meaning or hope are my kitten, which some here will no doubt consider an unnecessary expense (but that’s ok - I have no appetite so my food budget is about 2.00 a day) and my DS because somehow I want him to have a better life.

If the OPs friend is being kept sane and functional by the odd treat from a lovely friend, why the hell does the DH want to take that away from her and humiliate her to boot?

This is the best comment I have ever read on Mumsnet and I think it ought be pinned as a reminder as there are so many comments generally from people who seem not to get how capitalism works and why people struggling in poverty are at its core.

MistressoftheDarkSide · 01/10/2023 11:10

With regard to sodding housing costs - I am in a South coast university town. I live in a relatively large but quirky and dilapidated property. My son and DIL live with me. We were lucky enough to get this property through my late DP having connections, when we encountered a crisis due to our previous rental becoming insecure due to a legal dispute between the leaseholder and the freeholder. We were very lucky, about 4 years ago. It was in my DPs employer’s (also a long time friend) interests to keep his most lucrative employee securely housed.

Fast forward to now. The rent is 1200. The bills are around 600. My DS and DIL contribute 600 a month and I am solely responsible for the rent. Since my business started to tank we have looked into down sizing. As a single person a bedsit would still cost me 800 in the current market, and a small 2 bed would be 1200. Plus bills.

My DIL was working full time but has developed a chronic long term health condition so is off sick and desperate to figure out how to survive. My DS works in an industry that was paying well till the writers strike had the knock on effect of decimating said industry. He’s currently doing landscaping work.

Every fucking thing has gone tits up for us in a short space of time.

The point I’m trying to make is that just moving is not simple. OPs friend is currently securely housed. She’s working, on hand for her mother who is at liberty to help her daughter if she is able to and chooses to. No-one else’s business.

If she moves it may cost her thousands which she plainly doesn’t have. A month - or more deposit plus a months rent up front. Potential commute costs. Moving costs.

No doubt she “should” just sell any possessions, lose all sense of security and comfort because her “pride” at being in penury should keep her warm, right? A good dose of suffering will teach her, right? Turn her into a responsible economic unit ? Or might she feel life isn’t worth living and spend the rest of her life grinding away to appease the capitalist monster?

Think of all those myths about dragons where towns and villages are held hostage, feeding the beast with everything they produce including sacrificing people, until a hero turns up to save them by slaying the dragon…. It strikes me as a relevant metaphor for modern life, but there is no hero to slay the dragon. Instead it’s a race to the bottom and a smug attitude that because a few can do well, so should everyone else, regardless of economic factors etc.

Maybe as more people find their illusory security chipped away we might realise that we’re heading for really dark times, because at some point the bread and circus routine won’t be sustainable.

Just move house, just get a better job, just solve all your mental anguish by going for a walk, just bend the world to your will, just suck up your suffering because it’s good for the soul - not that we believe in that sort of nonsense of course.

The only things I have that give me meaning or hope are my kitten, which some here will no doubt consider an unnecessary expense (but that’s ok - I have no appetite so my food budget is about 2.00 a day) and my DS because somehow I want him to have a better life.

If the OPs friend is being kept sane and functional by the odd treat from a lovely friend, why the hell does the DH want to take that away from her and humiliate her to boot?

Lollypop701 · 01/10/2023 11:10

@PikachuChickenRice
If op was spending money they couldn’t afford as a family then her dh would be completely right to mention it but she isn’t so he can’t … so instead he is being mean. If my dh suggested my friend must publicly humiliate herself because if money I chose to spend , that I earnt and can afford I would look at him completely differently .. and yes it would be a sticky wicket from me. Not because of the money but because of how he wants to treat another person.

if op expected dh to publicly thank her every time they went on holiday that would be abusive … he is contributing to their family and also finances. Ops friend has her to stay over, cooks and look after her, is a good friend and is therefore contributing in a way op is happy with … so pays for treats occasionally and imo what dh is suggesting would be abusive to ops friend

GRex · 01/10/2023 10:28

@SurprisedWithAHorse - obviously the OP's husband is being weird and unpleasant. I don't think I've seen people supporting his "humble thyself on Facebook" nonsense, though there's always one so let's assume some small minority do. OP separately however has said her DF asked her for actual budgeting advice, and that's why some of us have commented. OP lives elsewhere and she might think £1300 is the cheapest property in SE/ London, perhaps you think that too, but it isn't by any means cheap. I wouldn't personally comment about the mum, for all we know mum can afford it just fine. I do know that living with low disposable income is highly stressful though and best avoided if possible.

SurprisedWithAHorse · 01/10/2023 10:15

GRex · 01/10/2023 10:03

Why do you think it's such an impossible suggestion that a woman in a flat she can't afford should move? She is paying significantly more than she needs to even in London, and this is budgeting 101; reduce the biggest cost first. Man + van moving costs will be less than she would save in one month moving to a £800-900 flat. She can't currently get universal credit for low income, because her rent is above the limit for a single person, so she's locking herself out of support just for rental. Most of us have some level of budget to live within our means, why is she different than everyone else?

Why do you think it's such an impossible suggestion that a woman in a flat she can't afford should move?

I don't think it's necessarily impossible, but it's clear that a lot of posters simply have an issue with the fact her mother helps her out, as if that's anyone else's business and anything at all with the fact that OP is happy to treat her to gigs etc.

It's also obvious that the people saying "just move" haven't even considered the costs of moving, the upheaval, the fact that she may need to be where she is for her job or possibly to support her mother... and they've no bloody idea whether moving would reduce her costs anyway because they don't know enough about her, her salary or her area.

And anyway, it isn't relevant. OP isn't asking about whether Jane should move because MNers don't approve of whatever arrangement she has with her mother. OP isn't paying for Jane's housing. She's asking whether her husband, whom she subsidises, is right that Jane shouldn't talk about her life on Facebook unless she publicly abases herself by making sure everyone knows who paid for it. To which the answer is: of course he's not, the prick.

The thread is full of pretzels, sneering and pure bollocks. And despite posters pretending that they want everyone to stop supporting Jane because they're so concerned about her or her mother, it's very clear that it's actually all coming from the "poor people should never have fun or choices" school of thought.

Straggletag · 01/10/2023 10:03

OhmygodDont · 29/09/2023 11:04

Hmm I mean she doesn’t need to thank you publicly as long as she thanks you personally but she’s showing off this lifestyle that’s funded completely by others when she’s basically not even able to live on her own wages and that’s off in itself.

She needs to seriously look at moving/changing jobs. Her mum won’t be here forever to support her and even as friends it’s going to get tiring at some point always paying for everything.

Ah yes ‘just get a better job,’ I mean it’s not like we need NHS staff is it?
I hear there was a time when families could buy a house comfortably- on one wage…and not even a brain surgeon wage, imagine that!

Society needs even low paid jobs to function- the problem isn’t with the people doing those jobs, the problem is the profiteering in the rental market and the employers paying shitty wages. And let’s not forget the bizarre money laundering thing of paying shitty wages, charging shitty rent and leaving the tax payer footing the bill for housing benefit.

Or do you believe that people on low wages shouldn’t have a decent life?

GRex · 01/10/2023 10:03

SurprisedWithAHorse · 01/10/2023 08:45

She relies on her mum's pension/savings every month though.

That's between her and her mum. Nobody else's business.

She might as well move...Or move...Or move...

Yes yes. And take in ironing. It's a mystery why there are any poor people around when you could always just move....

Edited

Why do you think it's such an impossible suggestion that a woman in a flat she can't afford should move? She is paying significantly more than she needs to even in London, and this is budgeting 101; reduce the biggest cost first. Man + van moving costs will be less than she would save in one month moving to a £800-900 flat. She can't currently get universal credit for low income, because her rent is above the limit for a single person, so she's locking herself out of support just for rental. Most of us have some level of budget to live within our means, why is she different than everyone else?

SurprisedWithAHorse · 01/10/2023 10:01

PinkNailpolish · 01/10/2023 09:51

She's not on a poor salary though. She just lives in an expensive area. And who mentioned anything about ironing? You are strange.

You don't know anything about her or how far her salary goes in her area, but never mind. The point is, her mother's support is between the two of them and it's nobody else's business. I'd bet that a lot of people complaining that her mother helps her out had some parental support for housing at some point (I know my parents helped me with my first deposit). But even if not, it's irrelevant. Nothing to do with OP or anyone else.

I assume you must be very new to MN if you're not familiar with the "just move house and take in some ironing" attitude that is apparently the solution to poverty. Just to warn you, you'll find "penis beaker" even stranger.

PinkNailpolish · 01/10/2023 09:51

SurprisedWithAHorse · 01/10/2023 08:45

She relies on her mum's pension/savings every month though.

That's between her and her mum. Nobody else's business.

She might as well move...Or move...Or move...

Yes yes. And take in ironing. It's a mystery why there are any poor people around when you could always just move....

Edited

She's not on a poor salary though. She just lives in an expensive area. And who mentioned anything about ironing? You are strange.

ingenvillvetavardukoptdintroja · 01/10/2023 09:25

Maybe mum is financially comfortable but needs her daughter nearby to help out? My friend and her mum are in this situation, her mum does help her out financially but she does her mums shopping, helps with housework and keeps her company when she's feeling anxious. Money isn't the only thing people offer to each other. Sounds like the friends company and hospitality bring a lot of joy to op's life.
She might be entitled to a small UC top up, definitely worth checking.

SurprisedWithAHorse · 01/10/2023 08:45

PinkNailpolish · 01/10/2023 08:40

She relies on her mum's pension/savings every month though. She might as well move in with her mum and help her around the house seeing as she takes her money every month. Or move to a cheaper studio flat in the SE. Or move to a more affordable area. There are plenty of other options other than taking advantage of your mum and friends' generosity just because you want to live in an expensive area.

She relies on her mum's pension/savings every month though.

That's between her and her mum. Nobody else's business.

She might as well move...Or move...Or move...

Yes yes. And take in ironing. It's a mystery why there are any poor people around when you could always just move....

PinkNailpolish · 01/10/2023 08:40

SurprisedWithAHorse · 30/09/2023 08:59

She can't go to gigs and restaurants otherwise because she is paying too much for housing. Her friends aren't physically paying her rent, but they are subsiding her chosen lifestyle (ie the obvious thing being her rent is unnecessarily high).

The pretzels you are twisting this into to justify your anger at a woman who isn't taking a penny from you or anyone who doesn't wish to give it are laughable.

She covers her housing, so all your guff about that is irrelevant. She just can't do much fun stuff outside of essentials. Her friends who like her want to do stuff with her and can afford to treat her, so they do. If they stopped, she'd carry on living in her house and just not go to gigs etc with them.

She's not "relying" on them. They don't pay her rent. They pay for her fun stuff. They want to.

You sound like those men who refuse to pay CMS because the mother goes to the gym or something and they can't grasp that that's not what they're paying for.

Edited

She relies on her mum's pension/savings every month though. She might as well move in with her mum and help her around the house seeing as she takes her money every month. Or move to a cheaper studio flat in the SE. Or move to a more affordable area. There are plenty of other options other than taking advantage of your mum and friends' generosity just because you want to live in an expensive area.

Alwaysdieting · 01/10/2023 08:26

Hey #SurprisedWithaHorse. yourbeing a bit harsh to #Roxy69. your taking all this a bit personal.

SurprisedWithAHorse · 01/10/2023 07:31

Roxy69 · 01/10/2023 00:52

There's something deeply unpleasant about him wanting someone to confess publicly that they can't afford to live their life. However, if I was the recipient of these gifts of money, tickets, gigs etc I'm afraid I have too much pride to accept them and would certainly make some effort to increase my income or find cheaper housing, move etc. It's not really helping her going forward and she's a bit old to be on this level of help sadly.

However, if I was the recipient of these gifts of money, tickets, gigs etc I'm afraid I have too much pride to accept them and would certainly make some effort to increase my income or find cheaper housing

It's not about you or your tedious variations of "just move" or "take in ironing". You would choose to refuse your friends' invitations and the opportunity to do nice things with them. That's your decision but it's not a superior one.

It's not really helping her going forward

As if you're thinking about "helping" her!

How is it not helping her? It's enabling her to do things with friends that she couldn't otherwise do. That's the help it's meant to be giving.

and she's a bit old to be on this level of help sadly.

At what age are we no longer allowed to do nice things for friends if we want to?

Aussiemade · 01/10/2023 06:16

Let her keep her pride. She obviously doesn’t have much more. If she thanks you personally that’s enough
helping out is what free are for. She working full time

Notsandwiches · 01/10/2023 04:30

Perhaps your DH should make sure his facebook posts are clear that his lifestyle is funded to a great extent by you OP since you earn the most...wouldn't want people thinking he's making an equal financial contribution...

YerArseInParsley · 01/10/2023 04:18

Why are people suggesting dh thanks his wife for earning double what he does, paying for bills etc? They are a partnership that have pooled their money throughout their marriage, very different to the friend situation and has no relevance to this post at all. The husband has retired and that's maybe why his income is now a lot lower.

Your husbands suggestion isn't very nice at all, I don't think it's a case of him wanting to humiliate her but I think he probably sees that she's taking the piss and he's fed up with it.
Is it the occasional treat from friends or does it happen quite often? Imo your post suggests it's regular treats. I think it's nice helping out a friend but I think it's a bit much if it's happening all the time, it will become expected and when the friends do decide they don't want to keep paying for Jane it makes it much harder to get out of that arrangement.

I'm interested to know if it's jane suggesting the fun stuff or are all the friends inviting her and paying? Me personally, I could not keep letting my friends fund my social life but then there are 2 kinds of people in the world, givers and takers.

I think it would be a benefit to your friend if someone actually sat her down and helped her work out her finances otherwise what yous all going to do, pay for your friend forever?

Blueink · 01/10/2023 03:50

tattygrl · 29/09/2023 11:00

Your husband's comments make me feel a bit uncomfortable, in that he's judging how she posts on facebook and he thinks she needs to make it publicly known that she can't pay for herself and should extend public gratitude every time. It's just a bit icky and superior of him. She thanks you, that's what matters. If you don't feel sponged off and taken for granted, that's the end of it as far as I can see. It sounds like she is just someone struggling with COL crisis. I'm sure she absolutely hates being helped financially by her mum. Doesn't mean she shouldn't be able to do nice things if her friends are able and willing to help her do so. Sounds like your DH thinks she's being poor in the wrong way.

Agree with this.

As you have said, you have a huge disparity in income from your friend, having very high disposable income, while she is barely able to cover food.

She seems very appreciative, personally sending thank you card etc. I would prefer this to some kind of public announcement on FB which is unnecessary and would be jarring and embarrassing for both of you.

Your DH seems very resentful, possibly this is more about him being a lower earner than you?

Suggest he stop looking at her FB and focusses on his own issues, he’s being very petty.

OhcantthInkofaname · 01/10/2023 02:39

At least she didn't pawn your shoes!

Roxy69 · 01/10/2023 00:52

There's something deeply unpleasant about him wanting someone to confess publicly that they can't afford to live their life. However, if I was the recipient of these gifts of money, tickets, gigs etc I'm afraid I have too much pride to accept them and would certainly make some effort to increase my income or find cheaper housing, move etc. It's not really helping her going forward and she's a bit old to be on this level of help sadly.

randomfemthinker · 30/09/2023 23:17

You pay for her travel to go across the UK to see you over bridging the long distance best friend gap and enjoy going places? Easier than having to travel maybe to her place and mostly staying in over it? You are best friends and want to see one another. And this works over simply being together, whatever you do over it. I don't really "get" your partner's point of view over it. I'm sure she's happy just spending time together and it would be FAR more awkward to run a public display of thank you over what you both do when she is visiting. Or would he rather she just not post? What exactly does he even want over it? And is he tagging you every time over it too when you pay for him? Good friends are rare and special. And not everyone can obtain higher paid jobs over life for all sorts of reasons. Someone has to do the less paid jobs like myself and your bestie, otherwise life would fall apart and society gets to dictate value of jobs over pay that is unfair. Also, rental costs keep going up over landlord greed!

SunnyLiving · 30/09/2023 22:21

Your husband sounds like a real delight 🙄. Can’t believe some of the people on here harping on that she’s an adult and shouldn’t get “charity” from friends. DH & I are both extremely lucky to have large disposable income, if we want to do extravagant things with friends we will always pay as know our friends aren’t in the same financial position as us. Our options are to either do things alone or pay for our friends. Personally I’d much rather spend my money having a great time with friends than sit at home miserably counting the couple of hundred quid I’ve saved in concert tickets or flights for another person who simply couldn’t afford to come if I didn’t offer to pay. No one has ever asked me to pay for anything or even suggested things and then waited for me to offer. Which is exactly what is sounds like with your friend OP, you are offering and she will always thank you. What an awful thing to expect this poor woman to publicly shame herself on social media so that your husband feels better about her posts. Bizarre. Surely he can just click to not see her posts if it bothers him that much?