Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH thinks best friend is a freeloader because of facebook

514 replies

Notanotherhousepost · 29/09/2023 10:30

Firstly I want to say, money is not the issue. We are more than comfortable. We have also always had joint finances - everything goes into a joint pot.

So, BF - lets call her Jane, works for the NHS as a band 4 - used to be a band 6 but when her job ended the best she could get was a 4. She's late 50s and works in admin.

Her outgoings are greater than her incomings even before food - her mother helps her out each month.

Most of her friends, including me, are a lot better off. I live the opposite end of the country from her. If she comes to visit I pay her train tickets and cover the cost of anything we do including food and drink. She literally can'f afford it.

Other friends will take her to gigs etc

DH has a massive issue with her because (1) he doesn't believe you should get help from people to the extent she does and (2) she never posts on facebook the way he thinks she should.

She'llpost about going to XYZ gig or going out for the day but does not say "thank you to notanotherhousepost for buying me the ticket"

Or"thank you to my other mate for getting me the ticket to XYZ"

Frankly I couldn't care less and she always sends a thank you note. But apparently she should be making it clear she can only do these things because people pay for her.

I just don't get it - I don't understand even vaguely where he's coming from.

OP posts:
Deepf60 · 29/09/2023 13:54

I think you realise how fortunate you are (albeit you work hard for it) you are a lovely friend to Jane and I'm sure she knows it. I really don't think she should be humiliated by having to thank everybody that helps on Facebook. Hopefully her fortunes will change one day. Good on you and her other friends for being there for her.

Riverlee · 29/09/2023 13:54

Reading between the lines, I think dh thinks friend is sponging of people.

Out of curiosity, does she suggest going to see Take That ( 9ir whoever) and then automatically expects her friends to pay for the ticket, meals out etc, or is it a case that you (and other friends) invite her.

If she demands/asks/suggests etc tickets, etc because ‘she can’t afford it’, then she is a cf and I see where your dh is coming from.

If it’s a case of you inviting friend up for the weekend, and the invite is at your instigation, then that’s different.

The fact that your husband implies she freeloads frequently suggests she’s in cf territory also.

I agree she doesn’t need to publically thank her friends on Facebook, but I kinda get what what your husband means.

viques · 29/09/2023 13:53

I assume you and your DH have worked out from your finances that you both have an equal amount of personal spending money each to spend as you want. If not I suggest you do this, then if you want to spend your personal money on treating your friend you can, and if he wants to spend his on buying star war figures ( other options exist) then that would be his choice.

Nanaof1 · 29/09/2023 13:51

Rattymcratty · 29/09/2023 10:45

I have a friend who is NHS band 3 (very important role from the 80s but because she didn’t need a formal qualification for that role back then that’s the best she’s offered).

she left her abusive ex and now rents a small flat. She barely makes ends meet. I’ll quite often treat her to lunch/dinner/take out.

she’s not a freeloader as she’ll never ask me to pay but I know she doesn’t have any disposable income. I don’t see her as a charity case. She’s my friend and I know if the roles were reversed she’d do exactly the same. I’d be mortified if she thought she ought to shame herself into a public gratitude.

To me, it sounds like the OP's NVDH wants the woman to humiliate herself on FB, so he can have the satisfaction of feeling "better than her".

Not a very attractive trait in a man.

dothehokeycokey · 29/09/2023 13:49

The bloody social
Media situation is so fake and bloody annoying

I'm kind of with dh on this and not in the way I think Jane should publicly thank all of her friends for the charity but it can be quite annoying and grating.

Similar situation but me not dh that has been financially helping someone close a fair bit since the beginning of the year as they plead poverty and to then see the friggin social media posts of the other non essential things they've managed to finance while everyone comments on how much they deserve said treats because they should etc grates me abit especially when there's no acknowledgment other than a thanks text which to me is rude in itself.

The problem youl find is Jane is living a great lifestyle off of the back of everyone else and not trying to live within her means.

I'd want to know why Jane pays £1300 a month rent for a start. Does Jane have children?

It depends on what Jane classes as priorities in life.

To me it doesn't add up because if Jane has less than £400 a month after rent and before bills and food surely she should be seeking help with the basics not going on jollys

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 29/09/2023 13:49

I can see why he thinks she’s a bit of a freeloader TBF. But I don’t get why he expects her to publicly announce who pays for what on Facebook. That really isn’t anyone else’s business.

I treated a friend to a trip away and a couple of meals out recently because she’s been struggling (she was caring full time for her mother, who has recently died - meaning she had no carer’s allowance anymore either). I know how much she appreciated it, but I didn’t need anyone else to know. Why would I, unless I’d done it to play Lady Bountiful?

Sunshinenrain · 29/09/2023 13:46

Spacemoon · 29/09/2023 13:36

I can see this from both perspectives.

I'd be annoyed if my DH (we also have joint money) was continually paying for days out etc for his friend. Helping a friend out of a dire situation is of course fine, but it is completely different to continually buying them tickets for gigs, buying them dinner etc. As a treat once or twice, yes, but when this becomes a habit, it's more than just being generous and kind. It's allowing your friend to live a lifestyle she cannot afford, at yours (and DHs) expense. Regardless of if you have enough money to do so, I'd be seriously questioning why this friend was happy to accept all these things. I know when I've been in tough times financially, I would have died at embarrassment to even consider excepting free tickets, free travel or free meals etc from a friend. It's a little odd that she seems so comfortable doing so to be honest. She seems like a bit of a freeloader who is taking advantage of yours and your other friends kind nature.

That being said, your DHs comments about FB are very strange and uncalled for - I don't think anyone should have to publicly declare if someone has bought something for them. So long as they are thanking you in private, that's the main thing.

I'd be interested to know how long this has been going on and if your friend is showing any signs of helping herself get out of the situation? I.e getting a second job, moving to a cheaper location etc. It's a shit situation for anyone to be in (I've been there), but often people who are being subsidised by others, won't even consider finding a solution, because, well, why would they? If her mum is helping her out with bills and her friends are treating her to lovely days out, she's never going to help herself.

I completely agree.

I think it’s fine to accept things as one offs but her mum gives her money every month and then her friends pay for everything for her when they meet.

Sometimes you have to live within your means and that means not always going to the gigs and events with friends if it means them having to pay.

If her mum dies then she is going to seriously struggle and she needs to sort out her finances asap.

As the PP said could she look into moving to a cheaper area or join the council list and get affordable rent?

squirrlebutkin · 29/09/2023 13:42

Your husband is horrible. She says thank you to the people who sub her when they go out. Presumably these people do this as they like her and her company and want her to accompany them. They do not want her to disappear from their lives as she can't afford to socialise with them. She only needs to thank them.

She does not need to abase herself publicly to everyone else.

JemimaTiggywinkles · 29/09/2023 13:40

What he wants is to humiliate her. That makes him a knob. Unfortunately there are plenty of people who think those in poverty should be shamed. I wouldn't want to be married to a person like that though.

KeepTheTempo · 29/09/2023 13:39

DH is horrible especially given you're not short of cash and you're earning double him anyway.

Your friend can't afford her rent, though, it's not a stable place for her to be.

Ramalangadingdong · 29/09/2023 13:38

Notanotherhousepost · 29/09/2023 10:50

That wouldnt work.... he hardly spends anything. Which is fine because I'm the main earner (double his take home).

After all out bills (we are mortage free) we ahve £5K per month to spend on food, fuel, holidays and shite and giggles. No kids.

Have you room for another friend in your life?

Just kidding. It is so lovely that you help her like that. And I also love the fact that she shows off a bit on Facebook. I bet in real life she is always telling others about being treated by her lovely friend. I know I would.

oksothisisusnow · 29/09/2023 13:38

TBH I think your husband is a miserly arse, it seems he wouldn't be happy for your friend to survive unless your friend posts
" Thanks to my mum, I can eat this basic cheese and tomato sandwich"
"Thanks to Linda for taking me out for coffee today, I wouldn't have been able to have coffee today otherwise as I don't have milk in"

Its funny he hold that view when you are the higher earner in your household, so you are propping him up financially in some ways unless he carefully portions out his % of things in relation to his contribution to the household.

I cab appreciate if he doesn't want the household money to help her, but it is horrible for him to seemingly resent her having any help.

Fwiw- I'd also tell her to check whether she's entitled to Uc top up, even if it's just toward her rent. If not, she may be able to get a discretionary housing allowance from the local council.

GinAndJuice99 · 29/09/2023 13:37

Your husband sounds immature and downright weird to be honest. If people are paying for her to do stuff it must be because they want to and enjoy her company. What the hell has it got to do with him? And thinking she should publicly thank people is deeply strange. He needs to get himself a hobby or something.

Guess he must be jealous of her for some reason.

Spacemoon · 29/09/2023 13:36

I can see this from both perspectives.

I'd be annoyed if my DH (we also have joint money) was continually paying for days out etc for his friend. Helping a friend out of a dire situation is of course fine, but it is completely different to continually buying them tickets for gigs, buying them dinner etc. As a treat once or twice, yes, but when this becomes a habit, it's more than just being generous and kind. It's allowing your friend to live a lifestyle she cannot afford, at yours (and DHs) expense. Regardless of if you have enough money to do so, I'd be seriously questioning why this friend was happy to accept all these things. I know when I've been in tough times financially, I would have died at embarrassment to even consider excepting free tickets, free travel or free meals etc from a friend. It's a little odd that she seems so comfortable doing so to be honest. She seems like a bit of a freeloader who is taking advantage of yours and your other friends kind nature.

That being said, your DHs comments about FB are very strange and uncalled for - I don't think anyone should have to publicly declare if someone has bought something for them. So long as they are thanking you in private, that's the main thing.

I'd be interested to know how long this has been going on and if your friend is showing any signs of helping herself get out of the situation? I.e getting a second job, moving to a cheaper location etc. It's a shit situation for anyone to be in (I've been there), but often people who are being subsidised by others, won't even consider finding a solution, because, well, why would they? If her mum is helping her out with bills and her friends are treating her to lovely days out, she's never going to help herself.

Bored1000 · 29/09/2023 13:35

If she is a good friend and thanks you personally I wouldn’t mind paying for occasionally as long as she Dosen’t expect it and isn’t asking for it.
Her rent is huge ( presume she is living on her own) compared to her income but what other choice does she have, at her age living in a house share would be horrendous and she is unlikely to ever be able to buy on that wage, you are lucky that you are in a much more fortunate position than her.

Do you think she appreciates how generous you/ her other friends are being?

Fundays12 · 29/09/2023 13:31

I wouldn't want my friend to post on Facebook I gave them X or Y unless they wanted to. I think if she is genuinely struggling and you are happy to help her enjoy her life your a great friend. I really don't understand the culture of everything needs shared on Facebook. Can someone things like financial situations etc not stay private? Your a great friend.

Maray1967 · 29/09/2023 13:30

Rattymcratty · 29/09/2023 10:45

I have a friend who is NHS band 3 (very important role from the 80s but because she didn’t need a formal qualification for that role back then that’s the best she’s offered).

she left her abusive ex and now rents a small flat. She barely makes ends meet. I’ll quite often treat her to lunch/dinner/take out.

she’s not a freeloader as she’ll never ask me to pay but I know she doesn’t have any disposable income. I don’t see her as a charity case. She’s my friend and I know if the roles were reversed she’d do exactly the same. I’d be mortified if she thought she ought to shame herself into a public gratitude.

Well said.

OP, your H wants her to publicly acknowledge how indebted she is to friends. Quite frankly, that’s disgusting.

My DH knows that I pay way more for drinks than my junior less well paid colleagues - he does the same. What you’re doing is similar to that. There is no need to make an issue of it.

pastaandpesto · 29/09/2023 13:26

ShinyPebble32 · 29/09/2023 13:10

Forget the social media thing, and your DH’s opinion - no adult human being, let alone someone in their 50’s, should have outgoings greater than their income! Jane needs to sit down and take a long hard look at her life - what are her plans to get out of this situation, if any - other than relying on her 70/80 year old mother and friends to pay for her lifestyle?
You are enabling her to live an unsustainable lifestyle, surely you realise this isn’t doing her any favours long term… this has got to be one of the most ridiculous things I’ve read on here recently.

Quite right. OP, you're giving this woman ideas above her station. It's far better for poor people not to get a taste for the nice things that non-poor people enjoy.

It would be a much kinder act to stop these activities immediately so she can learn to accept her dull and dreary life, which is, after all, entirely of her own making so she really only has herself to blame.

Blinkityblonk · 29/09/2023 13:26

Plus it says in the OP that the friend had a better paid job and then lost it, and this is what she's been able to get since then, not easy in mid-fifties to either move (if parent is settled) or get new higher paid job.

I'd love to know if the people criticising are in their mid-fifties, trying to get new jobs/work longer hours and cope with CoL increases whilst looking after parents. On their own, not depending on their husbands. I know what I think...(given most people on here seem to be quiet quitting!)

Morewineplease10 · 29/09/2023 13:25

Fucking hell!! Why on earth should she need to publicise her appreciation on FB?! How bizarre!

If you're happy to treat her and she's appreciative to you it's absolutely no one else's business.

SouthLondonMum22 · 29/09/2023 13:24

Shadowonasun · 29/09/2023 13:14

That's why I was always against any 'joint pots', but that's just me and my relationships. I'm an adult person earning my own money and after all the essentials/bills are paid, savings, etc covered, I will spend my leftover money however I please, without any input from my partner, thanks. I refuse to discuss my personal spending/ask for permission (??) from my partner, he's not my father or my owner. My partner is entitled to do the same, obvs.

Other than that, I'm with you, OP. You have more than enough money to treat your friend and you're happy to do so. Your friend always thanks you. I don't see a problem at all, it's your business, not your husband's.

Thanking friends over the facebook would be deeply embarrassing for both her and you, and humiliating for her. That's a mean and nasty suggestion from your husband.

I agree. It's a reason why DH and I have separate money, it means we have little say on what each of us spend day to day because we earned that money so it is ours and ours alone to spend.

sHREDDIES19 · 29/09/2023 13:24

The real issue is that Jane works a job that I am assuming is vital. It's unfortunate she doesn't earn more but the reality is we need people to fill all NHS bands for it to function. Jane doesn't need to take a hard look at her lifestyle and income v outgoings, we all need to be paid enough to actually live a life. And as a friend you are helping her to do what the government can't or won't. God there are some horrendously callous people out there.

gamerchick · 29/09/2023 13:24

Notanotherhousepost · 29/09/2023 11:04

His is mine and mine is his - its always been ours - a bit old fashioned but we are happy with that. Before he retired we were equal

As it should be

But personally, maybe pointing out that he wouldn't have the lifestyle he has if it wasn't for you might make him knock off the comments and see your point of view.

In my friendship group we treat each other if we're in a better position financially. The whole gang being there is more important.

Blinkityblonk · 29/09/2023 13:23

If the OP suggested free things, then she would still have to pay the train fare, which is over £100 I guess.

The friend is probably staying local to her mum and her mum undoubtedly is subsiding her in exchange for her being around, supporting her and so on, so it's a transaction, not a gift. My mum still gets me things, I don't rely on her income but she loves to buy us shopping, and give us things, and I do the same for my children, it's like a cascade down the generations!

willWillSmithsmith · 29/09/2023 13:23

MariePaperRoses · 29/09/2023 10:56

Team husband.

Your so called friend is actively pursuing a life she cannot afford and is happy to keep on take take taking from her chums who indulge her.

She should be doing everything in her power to resolve her situation rather than her sponging off other as being an acceptable way of life.

Do you think she should have publicly thanked people on FB rather than just privately?