Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be raging that my dd is being so utterly failed?

87 replies

SocialistSally · 29/09/2023 10:17

My dd is autistic, she was diagnosed age 6 (which is very rare with girls). She’s now 11 and been out of school since April, burned out from masking and the pressure of school.

Before that she was working well above expected levels. We are at the draft EHCP stage and have names provisions, but everything is full. Every autism unit, every specialist provision (state and independent) that could meet her needs and still provide the education she deserves.

I’m so angry for her. We’ve only got this far because she is out of education. She shouldn’t have had to wait for her to be in crisis. I’ve been fighting for her since she started school and I’m exhausted. I’ve been ill with the stress of it (in hospital).

She has been utterly failed by the system and she’s only 11 and deserves so much more. And I no longer know what to do to help her.

OP posts:
YellowRosesWithRedTips · 30/09/2023 13:27

Again, that is not a suitable, full-time education and parents can challenge such unlawful practices. They don’t have to accept unlawful practices.

Lovesocksie · 30/09/2023 13:26

YellowRosesWithRedTips · 29/09/2023 18:11

@caringcarer a tutor for a few hours a week does not fulfil the LA’s duty to ensure DD receives a suitable full-time education.

Again, where I live we provide a child with only 5 hours of home/ online tuition per week ( English, Maths and Science)
In the unit they get a maximum of 15 hours.

The problem is what the so called rules are and what really happening out there.

YellowRosesWithRedTips · 30/09/2023 13:25

It is not misleading. It matters because if it was only consecutive, some DC wouldn’t be eligible. Whereas, cumulatively, they are. It doesn’t have to take months on end/years. Parents can enforce provision and challenge unlawful policies, via JR if necessary - sometimes the mere threat of JR is enough, other times a pre-action letter is required, very few get further than that.

Lovesocksie · 30/09/2023 13:19

@YellowRosesWithRedTips
The 15 days whether consecutive or not is misleading as in reality it takes months even years sadly for something to be done.

Ah I didn’t know it was unlawful, I’m just the teacher, but I can assure you our criteria is consultant’s letter for the vast majority of accepted referrals. It sadly means that many children slip through the net.

YellowRosesWithRedTips · 30/09/2023 13:16

The days don’t have to be consecutive, or even already missed. Provision should be provided once it becomes clear 15 days will be missed (consecutive or cumulative).

Where I live you have to be at consultant level and they refer you

This is unlawful. LAs cannot have such a blanket policy.

Lovesocksie · 30/09/2023 13:09

@SocialistSally
I’m not sure where you live but it is the law that local authorities provide education for students out of school for medical reasons for 15 consecutive days. In reality I see students who have been out of school for months, sometimes years and it’s a disgrace.
This could be virtual learning, home tuition, a unit or school specifically for this reason.
I home tutor and work in a unit. We have many autistic children who cannot cope in mainstream, awaiting EHCPs. We even have some with EHCPs although we’re not supposed to because there are no places for them anywhere else. They often thrive with is, it changes their lives and those of their families when it works well.
Where I live you have to be at consultant level and they refer you, other areas may be different. Many parents are in the dark as schools don’t advertise this as they have to pay. Other schools are extremely supportive.

FatandRoundBouncingontheGround · 30/09/2023 12:51

Unless there has been a policy change, the LA cannot just add classes to existing special schools, or build new schools. They are forbidden from doing so. Only free schools and academies can expand or build new.

This became such a huge issue in our area that the special schools formed a MAT and left LA control, with their blessing, just in order to be able to expand to meet need. This has caused a heap of other problems, but at least the possibility of expansion is there.

I don't expect you to be sympathetic, and nor should you, but you would not believe the complete bind local authorities are in, with huge funding cuts (up to 69 percent), inability to expand provision, and yet all the responsibility to meet need whilst the government, who put them in this position, shakes their head sadly and says LAs are failing parents.

Pigeonqueen · 30/09/2023 12:44

This isn’t directly what you’re asking I know but I take it you’ve applied for dla for her? Make sure you’re getting everything you’re entitled to - depending on your income level you may be entitled to carers allowance (or may be able to drop hours / income to apply for this which may make things easier for you at the moment) and there is a disabled element of universal credit which you can claim if your child has dla which has a higher threshold than the usual income bracket so even if you don’t normally quality for UC due to income you might if your child gets dla - just worth a consideration.

PattyDukeAstin · 30/09/2023 12:39

OP - I am not questioning your parenting or how you choose to describe your daughter. I am guessing you decided to take her out of school rather than school saying that they are unable to meet her needs? Concentrate on the draft EHCP - follow that through and get her some appropriate support. I have always found Directors of Education and MP's really dont care so direct your energies on things you can influence If she was diagnosed at 6 yrs I am not sure why it has taken so long - I guess she seemed to be coping - you say she is a high achiever. I hope things work out.

YellowRosesWithRedTips · 30/09/2023 12:29

Have you threaten judicial review and then sent a pre-action letter? LAs often ignore parents until they pursue enforcement action.

SocialistSally · 30/09/2023 10:07

PattyDukeAstin · 29/09/2023 22:12

OP - she 'stays out of your way until lunchtime' - that's the child you describe as 'disabled' - it clearly isn't great.

No it’s a totally shit situation. I don’t describe her as disabled, she is disabled as defined by the Equality Act. She’s autistic and the anxiety and sensory overload means she can’t attend school, I’d say that is disabled.

An 11 year old doesn’t need constant interaction, she plays games, reads, does art all by herself. It’s an awful situation that she shouldn’t be in. It I can’t quit my job, as then we lose our house. What do you suggest?

I have been fighting for months, issuing complaints, writing to my MP, filling in endless paperwork.

@caringcarer you don’t need an EHCP to be entitled to an education. Anxiety and EBSA is a medical condition, just like being in a car accident. Also she does have a draft EHCP. Your dismissal of ‘well there is a school place’ is ableism. Imagine a wheelchair loser not able to go to school through lack of ramps and lifts. It’s th same.

OP posts:
PattyDukeAstin · 29/09/2023 22:12

OP - she 'stays out of your way until lunchtime' - that's the child you describe as 'disabled' - it clearly isn't great.

YellowRosesWithRedTips · 29/09/2023 22:04

caringcarer · 29/09/2023 21:55

But this child doesn't have an EHCP. It's not like there isn't a space in school for her, there is, she just doesn't go and without EHCP no alternative provision will be made.

OP’s DD doesn’t need an EHCP for provision under s19 of the Education Act 1996. It is incorrect to say ”without EHCP no alternative provision will be made.” The LA has a statutory duty to ensure those unable to attend school receive a suitable, full-time education. The school place is not a suitable, full-time education if she cannot attend due to her MH/SEN. This should have begun once it became clear OP’s DD would miss 15 days. The days don’t need to have already been missed or consecutive. Full time is more than a few hours a week.

X posted with @lifeturnsonadime.

lifeturnsonadime · 29/09/2023 21:59

caringcarer · 29/09/2023 21:55

But this child doesn't have an EHCP. It's not like there isn't a space in school for her, there is, she just doesn't go and without EHCP no alternative provision will be made.

You don't need an EHCP for AP to trigger.

AP must be made after 15 days of absence (whether consecutive or not) under s. 19 of the Education Act 1996.

In practice most people put in the application for the EHCP at the same time as requesting the AP. The AP comes first.

caringcarer · 29/09/2023 21:55

YellowRosesWithRedTips · 29/09/2023 18:52

Actually, that isn’t lawful. It may be what is often provided, but that doesn’t make it lawful. Parents can enforce provision. The LGO is clear that is not a suitable, full time, education even when 1:1.

But this child doesn't have an EHCP. It's not like there isn't a space in school for her, there is, she just doesn't go and without EHCP no alternative provision will be made.

Spanglemum02 · 29/09/2023 18:58

Definitely ask your LA for EOTAS provision for her.

YellowRosesWithRedTips · 29/09/2023 18:52

And EOTAS via an EHCP can certainly provide far more.

YellowRosesWithRedTips · 29/09/2023 18:52

caringcarer · 29/09/2023 18:49

Actually that is what generally happens when kids miss school for example because they have been in a serious car accident and are recovering at home. 5 or 6 hours a week is what they get and can be off school for months. 1-1 tutoring is more intensive than whole class teaching so more can be covered in less time.

Actually, that isn’t lawful. It may be what is often provided, but that doesn’t make it lawful. Parents can enforce provision. The LGO is clear that is not a suitable, full time, education even when 1:1.

SocialistSally · 29/09/2023 18:50

caringcarer · 29/09/2023 17:48

@SocialistSally have you asked them to send a tutor around to teach her a few hours a week? If you are at work.full time who is looking after her?

I work from home. Luckily my employer is understanding. She’s 11 so she stays out of my way until lunch time anyway.

OP posts:
caringcarer · 29/09/2023 18:49

YellowRosesWithRedTips · 29/09/2023 18:11

@caringcarer a tutor for a few hours a week does not fulfil the LA’s duty to ensure DD receives a suitable full-time education.

Actually that is what generally happens when kids miss school for example because they have been in a serious car accident and are recovering at home. 5 or 6 hours a week is what they get and can be off school for months. 1-1 tutoring is more intensive than whole class teaching so more can be covered in less time.

YellowRosesWithRedTips · 29/09/2023 18:11

@caringcarer a tutor for a few hours a week does not fulfil the LA’s duty to ensure DD receives a suitable full-time education.

caringcarer · 29/09/2023 17:48

@SocialistSally have you asked them to send a tutor around to teach her a few hours a week? If you are at work.full time who is looking after her?