Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be raging that my dd is being so utterly failed?

87 replies

SocialistSally · 29/09/2023 10:17

My dd is autistic, she was diagnosed age 6 (which is very rare with girls). She’s now 11 and been out of school since April, burned out from masking and the pressure of school.

Before that she was working well above expected levels. We are at the draft EHCP stage and have names provisions, but everything is full. Every autism unit, every specialist provision (state and independent) that could meet her needs and still provide the education she deserves.

I’m so angry for her. We’ve only got this far because she is out of education. She shouldn’t have had to wait for her to be in crisis. I’ve been fighting for her since she started school and I’m exhausted. I’ve been ill with the stress of it (in hospital).

She has been utterly failed by the system and she’s only 11 and deserves so much more. And I no longer know what to do to help her.

OP posts:
SocialistSally · 30/09/2023 14:16

She has a draft EHCP. We have named three provisions. But I also know that every special school in the LA and many in the neighbouring one are full.

@Soontobe60 saying she has been fine in primary shows a complete misunderstanding of autism and masking. She was burned out. Social communication and relationships get harder as you get older. Much trickier to understand if you struggle with social cues. Work becomes more pressured. You start doing comprehension in language, which she finds impossible. So many reasons why many autistic children are fine until they aren’t.

OP posts:
Babyboomtastic · 30/09/2023 14:16

edited to state that my post crossed with several of the OPs, making my post mostly redundant

I appreciate that it may be related to the transition to secondary school (I don't know if she's y6 or 7) but if your daughter was diagnosed at 6 and was working well above expected levels, she presumably was ok in school for a while, and the burnout was a more recent thing? Because if she'd but been and to go in for more than the occasional hour throughout, and you aren't able to homeschool, she wouldn't have been able to achieve those levels.

How are things with the school? Are they willing to work with your to determine what changed and if there is anything that can be done about it? If she's year 6, then I guess the biggest priority is getting her a suitable school for September. If she's year 7, and you withdrew her in April, then does that mean she doesn't have a place at secondary school?

lifeturnsonadime · 30/09/2023 14:14

YellowRosesWithRedTips · 30/09/2023 14:10

I’m more than aware how difficult it is. I have DC with EHCPs, including one with EOTAS. I have supported thousands of parents to enforce provision. Even though it is difficult it is important to give parents information about the law and how to enforce provision rather than accept unlawfulness otherwise they don’t know what should be provided and how to get it. That’s not blaming parents for the situation, but sadly DC whose parents know the system and advocate get better support. It shouldn’t be like that, but isn’t going to change any time soon.

I didn’t mention it being as simple as finding a small private school?

I know you know and I know you are just trying to make others aware Flowers

I just think it is important to point out that even in the knowledge that it is possible some people choose not to pursue because they can't because they don't have the energy or can't give up work etc.

The point about small private schools wasn't because you've mentioned it, it was directed really at those on this thread and others who seem to think that parents are pushing for better educations than mainstream can provide, which is categorically not the case. No one would willingly choose to put themselves through the rigmarole of trying to fight for appropriate education. The emotional and financial cost of having a child who can't be in school is massive.

SocialistSally · 30/09/2023 14:13

AnySoln · 30/09/2023 14:10

What is the issue if she is put in school in a separate room /out of class? What happens?

Or is it during breaks and lunch etc.
As at secondary there is at dd school homework club or quiet space or library etc.

Definitely more flexibility for asd students is needed. Ds has to attend music lessons despite sound being an issue.

Are you focusing on secondary provision?

All the secondaries near us are huge, 2000 pupils. It is the noise, the smells, the amount of people in the corridors. The constant transitions from class to class (translations are very difficult for autistic people). It is the pressure of assessments.

She needs low stimulus classroom, fewer pupils in class (her hearing is so sensitive she can hear everyone in classroom and can’t concentrate on work), fewer teachers. She needs a sensory room to help her manage and staff that are fully trained and understand autism, especially in girls.

The senco at the mainstream secondary she has a place at is excellent and very accommodating, but has also agreed that they can’t meet her needs.

OP posts:
SocialistSally · 30/09/2023 14:11

bakebeans · 30/09/2023 14:07

Just a thought but is homeschooling a possibility? My friend pulled her autistic son out of school and he thrived. Lots of homeschooling Facebook groups and support. No exams to sit. They can still go to college or university.

No, because she doesn’t want that and I work full time.

OP posts:
AnySoln · 30/09/2023 14:10

What is the issue if she is put in school in a separate room /out of class? What happens?

Or is it during breaks and lunch etc.
As at secondary there is at dd school homework club or quiet space or library etc.

Definitely more flexibility for asd students is needed. Ds has to attend music lessons despite sound being an issue.

Are you focusing on secondary provision?

YellowRosesWithRedTips · 30/09/2023 14:10

lifeturnsonadime · 30/09/2023 14:00

It isn't good enough but councils do get away with so much because parents are either unaware or don't have the energy to fight it. I fought for YEARS and made 2 JR pre-action letters and 2 Ombudsman claims BEFORE the LA conceded that they had to make full time AP. The local offer is consistently seemingly nationwide 5 hours per week and many just don't question it.

Our local PRU and home and hospital provisions have months of waiting lists.

The truth is that it costs LA less money to break the law than it does to comply and as the threat of legal action isn't punitive they have no incentive to comply.

I had multiple discussions with the conservative MP of the time who was sympathetic (she was sacked by Johnson over Brexit eventually) about how backward thinking this is. It is common sense that putting money in education saves money in the long run as educated kids are less likely to be on benefits long term. But the system is screwed.

Ultimately my kids got EOTAS packages including education and therapy and even then it has been nigh on impossible to find even private therapists without a waiting list a mile long.

I had to give up my successful career to get my children's education right, if it as as simple as finding a small independent private school that would be suitable it would have cost our family less than my salary loss. Eventually my second child now has proper full time provision and my eldest has successfully reintegrated into mainstream for 6th form.

The information is out there about what children are entitled to, it doesn't mean that, in the majority they are getting it sadly.

I’m more than aware how difficult it is. I have DC with EHCPs, including one with EOTAS. I have supported thousands of parents to enforce provision. Even though it is difficult it is important to give parents information about the law and how to enforce provision rather than accept unlawfulness otherwise they don’t know what should be provided and how to get it. That’s not blaming parents for the situation, but sadly DC whose parents know the system and advocate get better support. It shouldn’t be like that, but isn’t going to change any time soon.

I didn’t mention it being as simple as finding a small private school?

SocialistSally · 30/09/2023 14:10

I HAVEN’T removed her from school. She is unable to attend due to illness/disability. It’s this sort of comment that particularly grates as if I’ve made a choice for her to be at home.

She is technically in year 7, we applied to EhCP in May. Previous to that she was presenting as ‘fine’ and therefore no assessment for EHCP was granted. It is very common for autistic girls to mask for so long that they burnout. She had a tricky year 5 and then the pressure of year 6 was too m much.

I work from home so I look after her. I know many parents of similar children who have had to give to work, often then relying on UC and carers allowance.

OP posts:
YellowRosesWithRedTips · 30/09/2023 14:08

Soontobe60 · 30/09/2023 14:01

I should imagine that as the OP has removed her DD from school, the LA will go down the line that she DOES have a school she can reasonably attend. IPSEA states that:
“The Courts have confirmed that the LA has a duty to provide education for all children of compulsory school age who don’t have a school they can reasonably attend”
Who makes the decision as to what ‘can reasonably attend’ means is the grey area. The fact that the DD has managed to stay in school for most of her primary years and does not yet have an EHCP suggests that the LA will argue that she CAN reasonably attend a mainstream school.

If DD can’t attend because of her MH/SEN she can’t reasonably attend. Ultimately, it is the court who decides.

bakebeans · 30/09/2023 14:07

Just a thought but is homeschooling a possibility? My friend pulled her autistic son out of school and he thrived. Lots of homeschooling Facebook groups and support. No exams to sit. They can still go to college or university.

lifeturnsonadime · 30/09/2023 14:04

Soontobe60 · 30/09/2023 14:01

I should imagine that as the OP has removed her DD from school, the LA will go down the line that she DOES have a school she can reasonably attend. IPSEA states that:
“The Courts have confirmed that the LA has a duty to provide education for all children of compulsory school age who don’t have a school they can reasonably attend”
Who makes the decision as to what ‘can reasonably attend’ means is the grey area. The fact that the DD has managed to stay in school for most of her primary years and does not yet have an EHCP suggests that the LA will argue that she CAN reasonably attend a mainstream school.

They might argue that but unless the child has been deregistered it is possible that the school cannot meet needs BEFORE the EHCP is applied for, the application process takes months.

It is inconceivable that a child should be legally denied an education because the EHCP process is so long winded.

My kids were both OK in primary school till about year 5. Then they were not. School could not meet their needs and they couldn't go without severe damage to their health. This is not about parents not wanting their kids to be in school. No one would wish this on their child or themselves.

lifeturnsonadime · 30/09/2023 14:02

Soontobe60 · 30/09/2023 13:50

In my LA a child will have no chance of special school or AP if they dont already have an EHCP. Sadly, there are just not enough places for the demand.
When did you first apply for one? Have you considered her going to school part time? We have some children that do this in my school and it’s very successful.

They can get AP without an EHCP, It is nonsense that this is impossible.

I have had 2 who have had it whilst in the process of applying for one.

Spendonsend · 30/09/2023 14:01

Its not good enough op and I feally feel for you.
I always find it upsetting how people try and explain this situation away by sort of blaming parents for not nativating the process competently enough. The process itself is shit.

Soontobe60 · 30/09/2023 14:01

YellowRosesWithRedTips · 29/09/2023 22:04

OP’s DD doesn’t need an EHCP for provision under s19 of the Education Act 1996. It is incorrect to say ”without EHCP no alternative provision will be made.” The LA has a statutory duty to ensure those unable to attend school receive a suitable, full-time education. The school place is not a suitable, full-time education if she cannot attend due to her MH/SEN. This should have begun once it became clear OP’s DD would miss 15 days. The days don’t need to have already been missed or consecutive. Full time is more than a few hours a week.

X posted with @lifeturnsonadime.

Edited

I should imagine that as the OP has removed her DD from school, the LA will go down the line that she DOES have a school she can reasonably attend. IPSEA states that:
“The Courts have confirmed that the LA has a duty to provide education for all children of compulsory school age who don’t have a school they can reasonably attend”
Who makes the decision as to what ‘can reasonably attend’ means is the grey area. The fact that the DD has managed to stay in school for most of her primary years and does not yet have an EHCP suggests that the LA will argue that she CAN reasonably attend a mainstream school.

lifeturnsonadime · 30/09/2023 14:00

YellowRosesWithRedTips · 30/09/2023 13:31

No, it isn’t good enough. Parents shouldn’t have to enforce provision. It shouldn’t be that DC whose parents know the system and can advocate for them get better support. But parents don’t have to accept unlawful policies. They can challenge them.

It isn't good enough but councils do get away with so much because parents are either unaware or don't have the energy to fight it. I fought for YEARS and made 2 JR pre-action letters and 2 Ombudsman claims BEFORE the LA conceded that they had to make full time AP. The local offer is consistently seemingly nationwide 5 hours per week and many just don't question it.

Our local PRU and home and hospital provisions have months of waiting lists.

The truth is that it costs LA less money to break the law than it does to comply and as the threat of legal action isn't punitive they have no incentive to comply.

I had multiple discussions with the conservative MP of the time who was sympathetic (she was sacked by Johnson over Brexit eventually) about how backward thinking this is. It is common sense that putting money in education saves money in the long run as educated kids are less likely to be on benefits long term. But the system is screwed.

Ultimately my kids got EOTAS packages including education and therapy and even then it has been nigh on impossible to find even private therapists without a waiting list a mile long.

I had to give up my successful career to get my children's education right, if it as as simple as finding a small independent private school that would be suitable it would have cost our family less than my salary loss. Eventually my second child now has proper full time provision and my eldest has successfully reintegrated into mainstream for 6th form.

The information is out there about what children are entitled to, it doesn't mean that, in the majority they are getting it sadly.

Soontobe60 · 30/09/2023 13:52

SocialistSally · 29/09/2023 12:46

@caringcarer i expect them to at least provide alternative education while she’s out of school. They also need to find and build more provisions. What am I supposed to do, just give up that she will have an education because she is disabled?

I can’t home educate, partly because that isn’t what my dd wants and also because I work full time. I’m a lone parent and need my salary to pay my mortgage, that houses my dc.

So who is looking after your DD at the moment?

Soontobe60 · 30/09/2023 13:50

In my LA a child will have no chance of special school or AP if they dont already have an EHCP. Sadly, there are just not enough places for the demand.
When did you first apply for one? Have you considered her going to school part time? We have some children that do this in my school and it’s very successful.

CarrotJanice · 30/09/2023 13:46

@Ponche I was signed off with stress

Ponche · 30/09/2023 13:41

OP I’m so sorry, this is so awful for you and your DD. School is my biggest worry and my DD has only just turned 3 and is no where close to being diagnosed yet. How would you be expected to cope if your job wasn’t working from home?!

Lovesocksie · 30/09/2023 13:40

@SocialistSally
I really feel for you, I see many children and parents at the very end of a long hard battle, just to get to us! It’s disgraceful.

At the very least google ‘supporting children with medical needs/conditions’ followed by your LA area for guidance on what is available where you live and then push for it.

Even if as another poster said, it’s nowhere near enough as far as the law says, any tuition or placement would help your child, and may even be the making of her.

Good luck x

Hankunamatata · 30/09/2023 13:36

Ypu could also look as last resort boring schools especially those for girls with asd. Lea hate going out of area so if your on a border make sure you look at schools in other areas as your lea will not suggest them

Hankunamatata · 30/09/2023 13:34

What have the lea suggested as a school placement? Are you looking a specific placement?

If she is the last year of primary you will find it tough especially now all places have been filled over the summer and there isn't usually much movement in the last year of primary. You can ring around mainstream schools direct, drop dd statment on and ask directly of they can meet her needs

YellowRosesWithRedTips · 30/09/2023 13:31

No, it isn’t good enough. Parents shouldn’t have to enforce provision. It shouldn’t be that DC whose parents know the system and can advocate for them get better support. But parents don’t have to accept unlawful policies. They can challenge them.

SocialistSally · 30/09/2023 13:30

PattyDukeAstin · 30/09/2023 12:39

OP - I am not questioning your parenting or how you choose to describe your daughter. I am guessing you decided to take her out of school rather than school saying that they are unable to meet her needs? Concentrate on the draft EHCP - follow that through and get her some appropriate support. I have always found Directors of Education and MP's really dont care so direct your energies on things you can influence If she was diagnosed at 6 yrs I am not sure why it has taken so long - I guess she seemed to be coping - you say she is a high achiever. I hope things work out.

I didn’t take her out of school, she was unable to attend. She tried every single day, but she couldn’t. Occasionally she would manage an hour. But never in the main classroom.

OP posts:
Lovesocksie · 30/09/2023 13:28

@YellowRosesWithRedTips
you are clearly very knowledgable, more so than me and what you say is very helpful.
But my reality is what I’ve described, worked in medical education for most of my 30 year career and sadly we offer more now than ever. It’s not good enough is it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread