Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be raging that my dd is being so utterly failed?

87 replies

SocialistSally · 29/09/2023 10:17

My dd is autistic, she was diagnosed age 6 (which is very rare with girls). She’s now 11 and been out of school since April, burned out from masking and the pressure of school.

Before that she was working well above expected levels. We are at the draft EHCP stage and have names provisions, but everything is full. Every autism unit, every specialist provision (state and independent) that could meet her needs and still provide the education she deserves.

I’m so angry for her. We’ve only got this far because she is out of education. She shouldn’t have had to wait for her to be in crisis. I’ve been fighting for her since she started school and I’m exhausted. I’ve been ill with the stress of it (in hospital).

She has been utterly failed by the system and she’s only 11 and deserves so much more. And I no longer know what to do to help her.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
PutYourBackIntoit · 01/10/2023 18:18

Sorry @SocialistSally I didn't mean to suggest your dd had PDA, just that you're in same boat with working and needing to pay for your home.

SocialistSally · 01/10/2023 17:27

I think my dad would be overwhelmed by trying to teach herself. She doesn't have diagnosis fo PDA, but she is demand avoidant. Home schooling was an absolute disaster during lockdown. She hated it, I hated it, we nearly killed each other! And this wasn't trying to do school work, this was me trying to be led by her doing stuff like making paper mache volcano etc.

I've tried to do bits of home ed, in the last few months, but she wants my full and undivided attention while doing it. I can't just set her up and get on with work.

OP posts:
PutYourBackIntoit · 01/10/2023 12:04

The Chris Packham documentary should be mandatory viewing imo!

I've had a look and sadly there don't seem to be any international schools in Yorkshire, which is surprising.

@BlackcatsAndPumpkins it doesn't sound like de-registering would work for OP as home schooling wouldnt suit her childs needs.
People kept recommending this to me, but I work full time, and my dd has traits of PDA. She would have learnt nothing from me, and I wouldn't have been able to afford the mortgage. OP is in the same position.

BlueBlubbaWhale · 01/10/2023 11:36

Being full isn't a legal reason to refuse a place you must appeal.

My dd has thrived in a unit op.

BlackcatsAndPumpkins · 01/10/2023 10:39

It's an absolute disgrace, schools discriminate against pupils with these issues and only add to the problems.
My advice would be to draw a line under school, it's not the right environment for your daughter, my son had self taught himself since she 13, he is more than capable, all of the information is free online and of a much better standard.
Once my son was deregistered from school, things really improved.

SocialistSally · 01/10/2023 10:33

It does help to hear success stories. I don’t think the whole school/unit is full, but full for her year. So that is worth exploring.

I don’t think she would board anywhere, she has quite significant separation anxiety from me, which is probably linked to the trauma from school.

She watched the Chris Packham documentary with me and she’s love to go to the Girls autistic school on Sussex (or Surrey?), but sadly we are in Yorkshire.

Tomorrow is another week and another round of me ringing and emailing people!

OP posts:
PutYourBackIntoit · 01/10/2023 01:06

OP, I was where you are 18 months ago.

I know it probably means little to hear it, but take solace that your dd is bright. She will pick up academically, and she will be feeling safe and loved with you right now.

Do you know if the schools you've named on the draft ehcp are full entirely, or just for her age? The school my dd attends have a couple of kids in classes outside of their age group, if academically appropriate.
Don't overlook IB schools. They have been able to accommodate my dd where others wouldn't let her come to visit.

Also, just in case it's helpful, we got our preferred school named in the final ehcp by paying for a solicitors letter to send to the judge. At that point I had no more fight left in me. I had been battling with the system since she was 5, and my dd was completely broken by 11. It was the best £500 I've spent.

UsingChangeofName · 30/09/2023 20:24

I can see it's very frustrating but if every single state and independent unit is full what do you propose they do?

How about society not treating the most vulnerable people so shabbily ?
How about we find politicians who are prepared to have a long hard look at where money from taxes is spent ?
How about Governments fund local authorities with enough money to provide enough appropriate places for children that just can't cope in mainstream schools ?

The OP's dd isn't some one off situation. There are hundreds upon hundreds of dc in my LA alone who do not have an appropriate school place provided for them. It isn't something that has come out of the blue this month or this year or even this decade. It is known about and brushed under the carpet rather than any sort of workable solution being offered up.

IhearyouClemFandango · 30/09/2023 19:57

I know two little girls in the same boat. The transition to high school is a known trigger for many autistic girls, who through dint of being female mask successfully for longer than many boys but that can't last forever

Pandora55 · 30/09/2023 19:06

YellowRosesWithRedTips · 30/09/2023 18:24

@Pandora55 if DD wanted to do GCSE Art and can engage with online provision have a look at OCAD (Online College of Art and Design). Among other courses they offer online IGCSE Art. Technology Triumphs also offer some online creative courses. They can be funded via the EHCP.

Thanks for this x

AnySoln · 30/09/2023 18:57

The local secondary with hub didnt sound very flexible to me.
Kids needed ehcp and diagnosis to get in. Then there were no uniform adjustments. The kids were in a tutor group with some sen kids. But while main lessons like maths and eng were in the hub some other classes were not so they had to move round school. They were only in the hub till about y9. And only 10 students over all the year groups.
I was surprised abour their lack of understanding of sen students.

My dd has gone to a bigger school but the buildings are apart so less corridor stress. (Though shes now stressed about seagulls pooping on kids)
The uniform has no tie etc.

Our main issue is the music lessons.

YellowRosesWithRedTips · 30/09/2023 18:24

@Pandora55 if DD wanted to do GCSE Art and can engage with online provision have a look at OCAD (Online College of Art and Design). Among other courses they offer online IGCSE Art. Technology Triumphs also offer some online creative courses. They can be funded via the EHCP.

YellowRosesWithRedTips · 30/09/2023 18:22

Posts saying they would home educate often appear on threads like these. But, people wouldn’t do that if it meant their DC didn’t get the support they need. It isn’t just about academic work, it is about therapeutic and other provision.

SocialistSally · 30/09/2023 18:21

I don’t have a DH, so I am the only wage earner.

The three provisions we have asked for on her EHCP are all autism specialist units attached to mainstream schools. They are specifically for children who are able, but cannot manage the social and communication aspects of mainstream. They can actually access some mainstream, as they feel able to.

A generic special school wild be totally unsuitable for her.

OP posts:
caringcarer · 30/09/2023 18:13

SocialistSally · 30/09/2023 17:57

So you’d give up work and lose your house because you couldn’t pay the mortgage?

We do some stuff, we have conversations about things. Most recently it was about the suffragettes and also the match girls strike (she watched Ebola Holmes).

My DH earns enough to cover the mortgage and bills. I was a teacher and I offered to give up my job to home school my Foster Son but LA wanted him to attend a Special School. Interestingly he was held back in the Special School only being allowed to sit 3 GCSE's and no 1-1 support and no competitive Sports, only when he left and went to a mainstream college last year did he flourish. Last year he got 5 more GCSE's in a year. Now he is at the same mainstream college where he has a 1-1 TA in every theory lesson doing BTEC LEVEL 3 Sports Extended Diploma. Throughout his time at the Special School where they did nothing at all through Covid I got him a private tutor at home 3 evenings a week. The thing is he loves learning but his special school offered very few opportunities lunch time was 1.25 hours long, break was 1/2 an hour both morning and afternoon and registration was 1/2 hour every day both morning and afternoon. Very little time was spent learning.

caringcarer · 30/09/2023 18:02

SocialistSally · 30/09/2023 14:16

She has a draft EHCP. We have named three provisions. But I also know that every special school in the LA and many in the neighbouring one are full.

@Soontobe60 saying she has been fine in primary shows a complete misunderstanding of autism and masking. She was burned out. Social communication and relationships get harder as you get older. Much trickier to understand if you struggle with social cues. Work becomes more pressured. You start doing comprehension in language, which she finds impossible. So many reasons why many autistic children are fine until they aren’t.

I suggested they may offer her a special school further afield. Would you be ok with her being a boarder or not? If she goes to a special school, like my Foster Son did, they usually do less academic work and only a few GCSE's. Usually Some kind of Maths either Functional Skills or GCSE but it depends on all of the children's needs but if just 1 or 2 are capable of GCSE but the rest are not it's unlikely they will teach the GCSE. My Foster Son excelled at Sport but most DC didn't so they only offered BTEC level 1 Sport. Some type of English either Functional Skills or GCSE, often Art GCSE and some sort of Science again either Functional Skills or GCSE but often not double award.

SocialistSally · 30/09/2023 17:57

caringcarer · 30/09/2023 17:48

If it was my child I'd be doing this.

So you’d give up work and lose your house because you couldn’t pay the mortgage?

We do some stuff, we have conversations about things. Most recently it was about the suffragettes and also the match girls strike (she watched Ebola Holmes).

OP posts:
caringcarer · 30/09/2023 17:48

bakebeans · 30/09/2023 14:07

Just a thought but is homeschooling a possibility? My friend pulled her autistic son out of school and he thrived. Lots of homeschooling Facebook groups and support. No exams to sit. They can still go to college or university.

If it was my child I'd be doing this.

caringcarer · 30/09/2023 17:46

@SocialistSally if there was a school without ramps and a wheelchair user wanted to attend it would be a simple fix by getting ramps put in so it's not the same at all. If your DD feels anxious so won't attend her school there is nothing LA can physically do to change her school to make her able to attend is there? They could give her some worksheets though until something better is sorted so instead of just playing and drawing she could be getting on with more productive work so she doesn't fall behind her peers. Could she go on to one of those Maths sites people used during Covid. My Maths has some free activities.

Pandora55 · 30/09/2023 15:00

Hi op. I wish I could give some advice or words if wisdom but my dd was in exactly the same boat and is still being let down.

My dd was diagnosed aged 8. Burnt out age 11. Only ever managed one day in mainstream. Tried to take her life aged 12. Was out of education for nearly three years. We finally got her a place in alternative provision which is a lovely school and she's very happy there. But, although she's extremely bright the school doesn't concentrate on exam results. So she's just started her GCSE years. She's an amazing artist yet there no art teacher and no art GCSEs. She's taking five GCSEs , English, English lit, math, combined science and R.E. She's not even remotely reaching her potential. And it seems it's the same at all our regions ASD provision schools. It's a shame.

While she was out of education we had tutors through EOTS but she really wanted to be around other children. So I'm grateful that she did get a school place and that it's really helped her anxiety, but it's just a shame that she's just coasting through this stage in her education when she's capable of so much more.

Best of luck op

OfcourseitsaNC · 30/09/2023 14:46

I have quite a significant position working with SEN children.

The system is broken. My heart aches for children like yours OP, and others, which are not getting an education.

I don't know why the sea change, but there are so many more children with significant needs than there were 10 years ago. The amount of pre verbal 5 year olds has risen exponentially.

Our SEN service is beyond crisis point. All special schools in our area are taking over PAN and then tribunals are making them take more.

And, as always, it's the ones with money and education who are successful in getting their children places. If you're poor/don't understand the system then you haven't got a hope, and your child is being failed.

I could write so much more, but it's depressing.

jeaux90 · 30/09/2023 14:35

OP I have an ADHD and ASD DD14. I am also a lone parent so homeschool was not an option.

For secondary school I found an independent/private school with really good SEND provision. Class sizes of 12 small school etc. her masking and burn out at year 5/6 were overwhelming her. She is flourishing now.

I don't know your finances so for argument sake I'll assume you can't afford it. However....

I had a call this week with a SEND education consultant called Lorna Woolley. I was consulting with her on post GCSE provision but She specialises exactly on these cases. So please do get in contact if you want but my point is this, she said you need a lot of evidence on the EHCP that basically points towards the schools you are targeting.

And yes I'm afraid that may well be out of the area but I make that work with flexi boarding/week boarding. This has actually been great for my DD.

You probably know most of what I have written, but you may well have to widen your search criteria and get the evidence that supports your choices, and your choices will need to confirm they can accommodate your DD.

It's so bloody complicated. I was lucky I could chuck money at the problem but when you don't it may well be worth investing in working with a specialist consultant like Lorna for example.

lifeturnsonadime · 30/09/2023 14:25

YellowRosesWithRedTips · 30/09/2023 14:18

@lifeturnsonadime ah, sorry I misunderstood your post. The whole system is broken, and only going to get worse.

It is going to get worse because ultimately no one cares about these kids.

Inclusion was really about saving money. They need more specialist provisions not less.

I feel deeply sorry for teachers in mainstream schools who are (largely speaking) trying to do their best.

And it breaks my heart to see posts like those from @SocialistSally, when you've been in this position yourself you know that this child cannot be in school and that there is no choice and you also know what a hard road needs to be walked to resolve this in the child's best interests.

People who haven't been in this position largely just don't get it or think it is weak parenting. They haven't got a clue.

Senmumofmany · 30/09/2023 14:22

All of my dc have autism. One by one as soon as they get to secondary age they can’t cope and we have had to home educate . It’s happened to others we know too-it’s definitely a trigger point for burnout 😞

YellowRosesWithRedTips · 30/09/2023 14:18

@lifeturnsonadime ah, sorry I misunderstood your post. The whole system is broken, and only going to get worse.