Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

. . . to be cheesed off at vet prices?

115 replies

RedPandaFluff · 28/09/2023 21:03

I had a premolar extracted last week in preparation for having braces fitted. Total cost of the x-ray and extraction was £145.

Had our cat at the vet today and she needs a tooth removed. They've quoted £950 for the x-ray and tooth extraction.

AIBU to feel a bit ripped-off? The vet said we can phone around but we're unlikely to find a vet who will do it for less than £800! Is this really a reasonable cost? Absolutely prepared to listen and learn why it's so expensive, but it just seems excessive!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Yants · 30/09/2023 11:13

WiddlinDiddlin · 28/09/2023 22:21

Everything costs a fortune - independent vets are making very little money.

The big corporate chains are - charging £350 for you walking through the door, without the huge overheads in most cases as they hire their premises from independents which is far cheaper than buying and maintaining your own...

But again it isn't the vets making the big bucks, its the fat-cats at the top of the chain, as ever.

Avoid the corporates, use your independent vets - if not, you will lose them completely!

Many small, local (once) independent vets have already been bought out and taken over by big corporate entities, but they do it in a stealthy way by retaining the old name and branding etc so most customers don't realise its under new corporate ownership.

Yants · 30/09/2023 11:03

Financial regulation of the veterinary industry is now desperately needed, the sheer profiteering and blatant price gouging is utterly obscene and entirely without justification.

It's not just the profiteering either, the level of customer service they provide is a disgrace with practices now obviously ran on a skeleton staff with long waits for appointments, even emergency appointments, that's if they even grant you an appointment at all!

Ultimately the industry will just kill the golden goose (no pun intended) and price itself out of existence as there will be a huge reduction in levels of pet ownership eventually.

Namddf · 30/09/2023 09:45

kitsuneghost · 29/09/2023 09:44

I have no sympathy
People shouldn't own animals

It’s a provocative post, and I disagree as I know how much joy pets can bring people, but I do agree this is a wider issue.

Owning pets has become a national obsession, certainly in the UK, and as a nation we are far too sentimental about them. It’s almost become an entitlement.

The pet industry has exploded, and I’m pretty sure the exploding vets bills aren’t a coincidence. People are so obsessed with their pets and are being told they need this, that and the other when in reality a lot of these services are just not needed. An industry where consumers are so passionate is a corporate gift - you can almost charge what you like.

To tell people they shouldn’t have got a pet if they can’t afford it isn’t fair though - it’s the rapid and extortionate increase in costs that people are struggling with. No one could have predicted that. Having said that, one of the reasons I don’t have a dog is because I know I couldn’t afford the vets bills.

I also think we over treat our pets. I know many dog owners who rush their dog to the vets if they accidentally eat a bit of a chocolate, for example, get charged a fortune and it’s just not needed. Ditto keeping elderly animals alive for as long as possible - when often bring PTS is a far more humane and less selfish option.

I adore my pets and they bring us a lot of joy, but we do need to keep things in perspective.

WiddlinDiddlin · 29/09/2023 17:30

hattie43 · 29/09/2023 06:57

@WiddlinDiddlin

Who rattled your cage .
I'm guessing you're American where this may be more common to take off skin , like BOAS surgery is also not common here although mine had this . I have enough money thankyou to do whatever is needed for my dogs but I won't put them through cosmetic procedures just incase something happens .

You guessed wrong - as British as tea and chip butties.

I work with dogs all day long, I count multiple vets and vet nurses as friends and deal frequently with people buying brachy breeds without realising the costs and the maintanance required and the potential surgeries necessary for those dogs to live relatively comfortably.

Kangaroobrain · 29/09/2023 11:15

Regarding insurance, most policies don't cover dental treatment. And even if they do (and you're likely to be paying much more for it) according to Money Supermarket they won't cover:

Routine teeth cleaning
Cosmetic dental treatment
Treatment for pre-existing conditions, general tooth decay or anything else that the insurance provider believes you could have prevented by taking better care of your dog’s teeth.

So they could easily wriggle out of paying up.

Edited to add: no idea what it would be for cats, but can't imagine trying to clean a cat's teeth!

WhatACluster · 29/09/2023 10:13

We used to use an amazing small vets practice and they were absolutely amazing!

However in the past couple of years they built an annex and something else and now their prices have doubled…used to be £30 for the consultation now it’s £58 for one!

I’ve actually now gone to a chain as it’s cheaper which is a shame as I’m all for supporting local businesses

When my old dog was poorly as soon as they found out he was insured the bill went from 2.5k to around 5k…I’m not entirely sure he needed all the extra treatment…a dog inhaler was £105 ffs you could buy them on Amazon for £20!

jlpth · 29/09/2023 09:57

I'd say you're being ripped off. My vet would charge less than half that.

Obviously the difference between your procedure and the cat's procedure is the general anaesthetic needed for the cat, but £900 is still a major rip off.

Badgerandfox227 · 29/09/2023 09:54

Dental treatment fees for cats and dogs is really expensive, whether it’s right or not is another thing. Do you have insurance?

Reminder for everyone here with a cat or a dog, check you have decent insurance to cover these things. Look at the policy wording for what is not covered, most look like they have decent cover but it’s carved out in the small print so this is super important - you get what you pay for with expensive pet insurance - if it’s cheap, it’s cheap for a reason!

We lost my dog after an infection a few years ago, the bill then was £3k so I’d expect it now to be £5k. That was only 3 days worth of treatment to try and save his life.

Agree with other PP that we have the NHS so don’t realise how much treatment can cost for our pets.

Thatbloodyhedge · 29/09/2023 09:45

kitsuneghost · 29/09/2023 09:44

I have no sympathy
People shouldn't own animals

🥱

kitsuneghost · 29/09/2023 09:44

I have no sympathy
People shouldn't own animals

Thatbloodyhedge · 29/09/2023 09:43

hattie43 · 29/09/2023 09:35

@Thatbloodyhedge

It annoys me when bulldogs are singled out for vilification, no-one ever complains about dachshunds have long back's constantly failing or basset's with legs too short to carry huge weight , or what about German shepherd / labs propensity to hip dysplasia etc etc it's always bulldogs . Men bloody snore but no-one suggests not breeding them lol

Totally agree
Folk who spout crap know nothing.

hattie43 · 29/09/2023 09:35

Sorry that was more of a rant than I intended .

hattie43 · 29/09/2023 09:35

@Thatbloodyhedge

It annoys me when bulldogs are singled out for vilification, no-one ever complains about dachshunds have long back's constantly failing or basset's with legs too short to carry huge weight , or what about German shepherd / labs propensity to hip dysplasia etc etc it's always bulldogs . Men bloody snore but no-one suggests not breeding them lol

Thisismynewusername1 · 29/09/2023 09:32

My dog has just had dental surgery following an attack by another dog.

here’s what my vet said about costs.

£800 is generally their “top” quote. As they often don’t know what is in the animal’s mouth until it’s anaesthetised and they can get a proper look. £800 is their ballpark for tooth extraction allowing for a couple of suprises, needing more teeth out than expected (this is usual, if one needs doing it’s likely others will). If it turns out to be one tooth very simple it will be nearer £500- but it’s pretty rare not to find more issues apparently.

secondly dental surgery is much more expensive than stuff like routine spays- they called it “dirty surgery”. Due to the mouth’s environment the infection risk is very high and there’s a much higher risk of complications.

There’s no harm in getting a few more quotes though.

RedPony1 · 29/09/2023 09:24

Small animal vets cost are wild and so much more than a large animal! A dog trip to the vets for vaccs cost more than a vet coming to my stables to vaccinate my horses.

RVN · 29/09/2023 09:22

IntheJingelyJangelyJungle · 28/09/2023 21:32

Human anaesthesia doubles your cost as you are paying for a specialist anaesthetic consultant, at baseline circa £200/ hr.

As best I’m aware your cat won’t have a specialist consultant purely for his anaesthetic (surgeon bungs in some propofol or whatever they use for cats), vet nurse monitors and bobs your uncle.

So attributing the additional cost to the GA, as compared to a GA cost for human, isn’t really comparable.

GA drugs are cheap as chips as generic. Private consultation rate of £300/hr is fair (as costs to provide service are large). But £950 for a 20 min standard procedure (and a few hours tucked up in a cage with a nurse in proximity) is crazy!

Im with you OP. Vet costs are incredible. Yes the vets are as highly trained as human counterparts they add a lot of inflated drugs costs, venflon costs, triple charge the hardware. I’ve paid £500 for a specialist private canine ophthalmologist and didn’t grudge it.

My last itemised vet bill charged £25 for a cannula. They cost a pound or two. They will argue ‘there is skill in siting it’, and yes, there is- but I’m also invoiced for the vets skills and expertise per 10 min and I would expect the skill and time in during the cannula to be included in that time, not surcharged on top as well.

Current vet charges are, in my opinion, putting people in a position to defer or not have treatment. I know 2 people recently to have had pets PTS because the inflated costs of standard treatments are just too too much.

Rant done.

Ok, I normally can't be bothered to challenge comments online, I spend enough time explaining costs on a daily basis, however just to explain.

RVN's (registered veterinary nurse) are experienced qualified professionals who are indeed 'specialists' in what they do. Most now enter the profession through the 4 year degree route and many go on to further study in specialist disciplines such as anaesthesia which is a further 2 years study.
Monitoring a patient during surgery isn't really a case of ' Bob's your uncle'. It requires considered concentration, often for several hours, training in specialist monitoring equipment, understanding of abnormal patterns and how to correct them. Certain parts of surgery are more painful than others, anaesthetic depth has to be adjusted throughout. Maintaining homeostasis/thermoregulation etc. Patients have to be monitored from premedicant stage through to recovery which can add an hour on to monitoring time. Post surgery we will regularly pain score our patients and check all their parameters, then take any appropriate action.
I could go on but you get the picture. We are certainly not paid £200 per hour though, not even £200 per day!

As for anaesthetic drug costs. We are not allowed to use cheap generic drugs if there is a species specific licensed alternative, these are often 10 X the cost. Plus there is a huge amount of wastage.

£900 for a single extraction is excessive though. Full mouth x-rays bump up the bill but really are necessary in cats. I would say average is around £500 unless multiple extractions.

Thatbloodyhedge · 29/09/2023 09:07

hattie43 · 29/09/2023 08:43

@feelingalittlehorse

I'm not engaging in discussions about bulldogs it's well known they're vilified on here . The OP was talking about the costs of vets bills and I answered as did others . My bulldog has not had anymore health issues than my others. You are just using an excuse to spout your views about bulldogs which definitely isn't what the OP asked .
I'm not listening .

Quite right 👏

wetotter · 29/09/2023 08:58

Goodornot · 28/09/2023 23:58

I wasn't comparing prices. People keep telling OP she would have been charged more if she'd needed a general anesthetic. Not strictly true as she'd need to be in hospital for a GA and then hospital dentistry is free.

I'm surprised people are surprised by vet fees. Pets are expensive.

Edited

But then you wouldn't be comparing like with like - because I was comparing prices, and the whole opening post is about price comparison.

The total bill for my dog (just checked the itemised receipt) was nearly all the costs of the GA and other ancillary charges such as post-op prescription pain killers and (optional) bloods.

If it was simply the X-ray and the actual extractions, then £142 - just cheaper than OP's human price.

The question in OP was why the price difference - the answer is the GA

So if OP wants to compare properly, then she either needs to know what she would have been billed privately for the procedure to be done under GA (eg in a private hospital, which has all the kit and the staff trained for this - just like vets do, but are overheads dentists don't have)

Or she needs to look at the itemised bill and compare only the specific parts of the animal procedures

hattie43 · 29/09/2023 08:43

@feelingalittlehorse

I'm not engaging in discussions about bulldogs it's well known they're vilified on here . The OP was talking about the costs of vets bills and I answered as did others . My bulldog has not had anymore health issues than my others. You are just using an excuse to spout your views about bulldogs which definitely isn't what the OP asked .
I'm not listening .

Chesneyhawkes1 · 29/09/2023 08:13

@Glendaruel totally agree. I've kept my dogs at a vet miles from where I live because of this.

They were my vets when I had horses and they do farm animals too. By far the cheapest vets in the area.

One 5 mins from my house wanted almost double when I asked for a quote.

feelingalittlehorse · 29/09/2023 08:06

hattie43 · 28/09/2023 23:50

Whatever the justifications given by vets the huge fees are mind blowing . I have spent circa £10k at the vets since May . This isn't for major surgery or disease this is for routine things across 3 dogs , in the old days if you took a poorly dog to the vet checks were done and pills given but now as soon as you step through the door every ailment described needs an X-ray to see what's wrong at £900
in my practise , it's all changing , one of my dogs was recommended to have cosmetic surgery to take skin off his nose rolls rather than me clean them with wipes , since when has surgery been recommended for something that's general maintenance. If they were becoming infected I could perhaps understand it but it just seems like another way of parting a customer from their money .

So someone bred a dog who’s skin is so folded and deformed that they are at risk of constant infections, and also one that needs surgical help to breathe (that’s what your later mentioned BOAS surgery is, isn’t it?), and you have knowingly bought that poor dog?
In all my years of dog ownership I have never had to have a “cosmetic” procedure to help them function normally. Not sure your vet is the villain here.
Also, completely irrelevant to the OP, as her cat actually has a medical problem requiring the removal- that’s bad luck, nothing to do with bad human choices.

Iheartmysmart · 29/09/2023 07:30

My vet used to be a little independent practice with just the owner and one other vet running it. He then retired and the practice was bought out. The prices have now gone up hugely. An appointment is £60 just for the consultation where it used to be £35, a prescription has gone from £10 to £26.

Every time I take my elderly spaniel in the vet wants to try different medication, all involving expensive pre-treatment blood tests. If it wasn’t for the fact that the poor old dog probably won’t be here for much longer I’d definitely move to another practice.

Motnight · 29/09/2023 07:18

Motnight · 29/09/2023 07:17

Last year we paid £400 for our cat to have 2 teeth removed under GA and his follow up care and medicine.

That included x-rays etc. Based in London

Motnight · 29/09/2023 07:17

Last year we paid £400 for our cat to have 2 teeth removed under GA and his follow up care and medicine.