Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect OH to put my job first ?

339 replies

greyA · 28/09/2023 19:49

Bit of back story, husband has been in his job 23 years, hasn’t really moved up that much and is still in junior management - has had opportunities to progress but has always said he doesn’t want them. He earns around 38k. I was a career changer and in 3 years have gone from earning 20k to 80k. I work in a fast paced industry ( tech ) and whilst I do wfh and have reasonable flexibility, I take my job very seriously and I absolutely love it. Currently we split things as equally as possible however I still pay around £500 more than OH each month ( I buy all food and pay a couple of extra bills ) ( I also do the bulk of the housework, shopping and cooking but that’s for another post ) I am currently expecting and previously we discussed OH taking some time off to look after baby so I could return to work after about 3 months and the plan was he’d be around and I’d do as much flexi working as I could ( possibly going down to a 4 day week or working some of my hours in the evenings) OH has now said he doesn’t want to do that and seems to think it’s perfectly feasible for me to wfh and take care of the baby. The fact is he doesn’t earn enough to cover all our bills but I do so AIBU expecting him to step up and either be home and care for the baby or earn more so I can stay home and do it myself ?

OP posts:
MargotBamborough · 29/09/2023 14:40

beanii · 29/09/2023 14:18

Your husband shouldn't have to stay at home to look after the baby.

£38k is more than enough to cover bills - cut your cloth to suit.

Or YOU stay at work and employ a nanny - £80k a year you should be easily able to do so.

Time to get in the real world OP.

Your husband earns a good wage - maybe appreciate that a bit more. Shouldn't matter if he wants to progress or work in a supermarket 🙄

What the hell did I just read?

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 29/09/2023 14:26

Grumpy101 · 28/09/2023 20:00

No. Put baby in nursery. Split cost proportionately.

If he's not doing his share of domestic work now, he'll take paternity leave as a jolly and will do even less. Especially if you are WFH, you'll end up doing EVERYTHING and will burn out.

And if you decide enough is enough and divorce, you'll end up having the child less than him and paying his lazy arse maintenance.

This.

Housework should be split equally though, as should childcare outside of working time/ nursery hours.

You probably need to be putting a bit more into joint funds with the income disparity.

Neither of you can make the other one be a SAHP though.

Working from home whilst caring for a baby is not an option though- most work places don’t allow if for good reason. Why does your OH think he can get away with just working and nothing else when he’s the lower earner?

beanii · 29/09/2023 14:18

Your husband shouldn't have to stay at home to look after the baby.

£38k is more than enough to cover bills - cut your cloth to suit.

Or YOU stay at work and employ a nanny - £80k a year you should be easily able to do so.

Time to get in the real world OP.

Your husband earns a good wage - maybe appreciate that a bit more. Shouldn't matter if he wants to progress or work in a supermarket 🙄

smartiesneberhadtheanswer · 29/09/2023 14:16

greyA · 28/09/2023 20:34

I don’t know - I’ve never had a baby before and never expected to be the higher income earner. I’d just like to have a year off like everybody else seems to but doesn’t seem possible. I hate the idea of putting my tiny baby in childcare and loved the thought of OH being at home with baby and me getting to spend time with them both between working. It seemed like the best of both worlds.

In fairness, this is what men have been enjoying for years. Why shouldn't you want that?

LogicVoid · 29/09/2023 14:05

He's a lazy uninvolved husband and 'father' and possibly a bit dim if he thinks you can WFH and look after a baby. He wants you earning and doing all the domestics unsupported. You'll be better off in so many ways without his weight. He'll drag you down.

Bellyrumble · 29/09/2023 13:49

We’re in this situation in terms of who earns more- except the numbers aren’t as high as yours (half each of your salaries and that’s us).

our DS is now 2. I took 6 months Mat leave, finished work the day before he was born. DH took months 6-9. Childcare kicked in then

DH was very up for it and knew I would have taken more if we could afford it but we couldnt, we needed my wage. However his mental health suffered a lot when he was off and he struggled with not working. If your DH is already voicing that he doesn’t want to do it then you can’t force him.

can’t you do a middle ground- you take 6 months and then both work full time after that. Baby in childcare (you may still be able to breastfeed as they start solids from 6m) and pay for a cleaner (wish we could do that!)

MarvellousMonsters · 29/09/2023 13:41

Ok, please don't plan on returning to work after 12 weeks, there's good reasons why civilised countries give 6-12 months paid maternity leave. You need time to rest, heal, get feeding established and just generally be with your baby. Plan on at least 6 months off.

Then consider part time nursery for baby, and reducing both your hours (if you both do 4 days a week your baby only needs nursery for 3 days a week, and you both get significant time caring for the baby.

You're bringing an entire human being into the world, they need more than just a full belly and a dry bottom, they need contact, communication, stimulation (not just a bouncy chair & a screen) interaction and so on. Babies rarely sleep when it's convenient, it's biologically normal for them to wake in the night for the first 2-3 years, and working full time is hard when you've had to re-settle a small person at 3am.

Resolve the domestic chore split. He needs to be doing 50%, and hiring a cleaner would be a good idea too.

spitefulandbadgrammar · 29/09/2023 13:35

MrsSlocombesCat · 29/09/2023 13:24

I’m amazed that anyone says they can’t live on 38,000 pa. My son and I live on around 20,000 quite comfortably.

How nice for you but different people have different mortgages and bills.

Your £20k would cover my nursery bill, council tax and most of my gas and electricity, though I’d get further in the red each month. Unfortunately I’d have nothing left for school wraparound, food, water, internet, toiletries, clothes, my car, buildings and contents insurance, TV licence, or my house. Even less if I wanted to contribute to a pension or have some rainy day savings or heaven forfend a Christmas present or two .

MargotBamborough · 29/09/2023 13:29

MrsSlocombesCat · 29/09/2023 13:24

I’m amazed that anyone says they can’t live on 38,000 pa. My son and I live on around 20,000 quite comfortably.

Well it depends largely on how much your housing costs, doesn't it?

If you're on 38k you're taking home less than 30k per year after tax.

If you have a 400K mortgage on a 4.5% interest rate then your annual repayments are going to be not far off that, and that's before you've paid for utilities, council tax, other bills, food, transport etc.

MrsSlocombesCat · 29/09/2023 13:24

greyA · 28/09/2023 20:08

Absolutely not adverse to childcare, but OH has 2 older kids from previous relationship and was very resentful towards his ex that he spent all his time at work and she effectively got 5 years off with the kids and he was always adamant he wanted to do it differently this time. I would absolutely love to be a sahm but unfortunately our outgoings just wouldn’t allow that- we aren’t frivolous, it’s just general living. It’s not that his job has to be second but if I loose my job we literally wouldn’t be able to survive. And when I say we share bills fairly equally I mean mortgage and utilities - all food, meals out, holidays, luxuries etc are paid by me.

I’m amazed that anyone says they can’t live on 38,000 pa. My son and I live on around 20,000 quite comfortably.

SouthLondonMum22 · 29/09/2023 13:20

MeridaBrave · 29/09/2023 13:17

You can’t work from home unless you have full time child care support. And at 3 months baby is likely too small for a nursery or childminder although you might make it work if working from home.

So either:
a) you employ someone full some in your home (that would be my first choice, ideally someone who’d clean when the baby was asleep). Reality is that this will cost more than your DH earns but they will do a better job of cleaning than him.
b) one of you takes time off - if you don’t get paid beyond the statutory maternity pay it will have to the one who earns the least.

Mine started nursery at 3 months. Areas will differ of course but I found plenty of nurseries in my area from 3 months.

MeridaBrave · 29/09/2023 13:17

You can’t work from home unless you have full time child care support. And at 3 months baby is likely too small for a nursery or childminder although you might make it work if working from home.

So either:
a) you employ someone full some in your home (that would be my first choice, ideally someone who’d clean when the baby was asleep). Reality is that this will cost more than your DH earns but they will do a better job of cleaning than him.
b) one of you takes time off - if you don’t get paid beyond the statutory maternity pay it will have to the one who earns the least.

SouthLondonMum22 · 29/09/2023 12:54

MargotBamborough · 29/09/2023 12:19

Well she says they can't afford to pay the bills on his salary alone. I assume the three months is based on how long she can stay off before she drops down to SMP and they can no longer afford to make ends meet.

I agree she should stop cooking and washing for him, but I think once you get to the point where you are making dinner just for yourself and not your partner because they are a lazy cocklodger, your relationship is over, isn't it? My husband and I sometimes just sort out our dinner separately by each eating different leftovers from the fridge, or sometimes I might just make myself some pasta because he's not hungry or he wants something else, but I can't imagine either of us just deciding to cook separately because we're so pissed off with the other person.

Oh, absolutely. Like I said before, I wouldn't be married to him.

AnnaTortoiseshell · 29/09/2023 12:19

I’ve read your updates and I think the first post was misleading - it’s not 50:50 and then you pay for luxuries. He is only paying £650 a month for everything, and still in his overdraft?! That’s a totally different situation.

I have a very supportive husband, totally shared finances, a partner in all ways. But when I had DC with him, I truly realised how alone you are as a mum to tiny baby. You are the only one having this baby, and you will have to figure out childcare and all of that. Of course your DH is technically equally responsible, but it doesn’t work like that in reality. Men can choose not to step up, and it looks like that’s his choice. Not a great surprise given his attitude towards his ex wife. So it’s on you, I’m sorry to say. What would you do if you were a single parent? That’s what you need to do.

MargotBamborough · 29/09/2023 12:19

SouthLondonMum22 · 29/09/2023 12:13

Can she not afford it? She was previously talking about going part time so I assumed going back at 3 months was a choice because I work in the same industry and went back FT at 3 months too because as OP says, it is fast paced but it was completely by choice.

OP can do the basics to keep things reasonably clean and safe of course but she certainly doesn't have to cook for him or wash his clothes.

Well she says they can't afford to pay the bills on his salary alone. I assume the three months is based on how long she can stay off before she drops down to SMP and they can no longer afford to make ends meet.

I agree she should stop cooking and washing for him, but I think once you get to the point where you are making dinner just for yourself and not your partner because they are a lazy cocklodger, your relationship is over, isn't it? My husband and I sometimes just sort out our dinner separately by each eating different leftovers from the fridge, or sometimes I might just make myself some pasta because he's not hungry or he wants something else, but I can't imagine either of us just deciding to cook separately because we're so pissed off with the other person.

SouthLondonMum22 · 29/09/2023 12:13

MargotBamborough · 29/09/2023 12:07

She can't decide to take a longer maternity leave if she literally can't afford it though, that's the point. And she can't really decide to stop doing everything around the house, because there will soon be a baby living there and it needs to be at least a reasonably clean, safe, habitable environment.

She can decide to get rid of him though, which I would be seriously contemplating in her position.

Can she not afford it? She was previously talking about going part time so I assumed going back at 3 months was a choice because I work in the same industry and went back FT at 3 months too because as OP says, it is fast paced but it was completely by choice.

OP can do the basics to keep things reasonably clean and safe of course but she certainly doesn't have to cook for him or wash his clothes.

MargotBamborough · 29/09/2023 12:07

SouthLondonMum22 · 29/09/2023 12:01

He should absolutely pull his weight around the house, OP shouldn't be working FT and doing everything around the house too.

OP can decide if she wishes to take a more average maternity leave as opposed to a shorter one
OP can decide to stop doing everything around the house, especially things that may benefit him
OP can decide if she should even stay married at all because I don't think I would in her position

But she can't make him stay at home with the baby.

She can't decide to take a longer maternity leave if she literally can't afford it though, that's the point. And she can't really decide to stop doing everything around the house, because there will soon be a baby living there and it needs to be at least a reasonably clean, safe, habitable environment.

She can decide to get rid of him though, which I would be seriously contemplating in her position.

SouthLondonMum22 · 29/09/2023 12:01

MargotBamborough · 29/09/2023 11:41

You're not wrong about it not being in the baby's interests to be looked after by someone who doesn't want to do that.

But do you think the OP's other half should be forced to do anything he doesn't want? Because it sounds like he doesn't want to do equal childcare, he doesn't want to pull his weight around the house, he doesn't want to get a better paid job, and he doesn't want to facilitate the OP's career.

So she doesn't get to decide that she doesn't want to do these things. She has to do all the things he doesn't want to do, because if she doesn't, no one will.

He should absolutely pull his weight around the house, OP shouldn't be working FT and doing everything around the house too.

OP can decide if she wishes to take a more average maternity leave as opposed to a shorter one
OP can decide to stop doing everything around the house, especially things that may benefit him
OP can decide if she should even stay married at all because I don't think I would in her position

But she can't make him stay at home with the baby.

MargotBamborough · 29/09/2023 11:41

SouthLondonMum22 · 29/09/2023 11:29

I don't think anyone should be forced to take a longer maternity/paternity leave than they want. Man or woman.

It certainly wouldn't be good for the baby to have someone at home with them who doesn't want to be there.

You're not wrong about it not being in the baby's interests to be looked after by someone who doesn't want to do that.

But do you think the OP's other half should be forced to do anything he doesn't want? Because it sounds like he doesn't want to do equal childcare, he doesn't want to pull his weight around the house, he doesn't want to get a better paid job, and he doesn't want to facilitate the OP's career.

So she doesn't get to decide that she doesn't want to do these things. She has to do all the things he doesn't want to do, because if she doesn't, no one will.

RiderofRohan · 29/09/2023 11:37

I can't believe people are suggesting the OP should contribute more financially (note she is already contributing 6k more a year as she stated) while she does the majority of the domestic work and is also pregnant. That's like reverse feminism.

SouthLondonMum22 · 29/09/2023 11:29

beAsensible1 · 29/09/2023 10:38

This.

in what world is it ok for your partner to refuse to take parental leave and send a 3 month old to childcare when you don’t need to.

OP you’re obviously not going to
leave this guy so you need to sit down with him and have serious talk about the division of Labour and if he really won’t contribute in any way to the household other than £650 pm, then you’ve got bigger problems.

I don't think anyone should be forced to take a longer maternity/paternity leave than they want. Man or woman.

It certainly wouldn't be good for the baby to have someone at home with them who doesn't want to be there.

maddening · 29/09/2023 11:23

Could you offset what dh would lose If he dropped his salary to a nanny who has the baby in the home with you while you are wfh so you have what dh would have provided but he is in work?

Hayley0203 · 29/09/2023 10:44

Very few of my friends who are high earners took a full year off, OP. Nor did I. I know you said you want that because "everyone else seems to," but it's not actually that common for women in senior positions, at least that I know. Just to reassure you a bit. By 9 months postpartum, everyone in my circle had gone back apart from one and she is a SAHM.

As others have said there's unfortunately zero chance of you successfully working from home with a baby. Maybe in the very early days when they nap all the time (and even then, the times when they're hungry and need changing will be totally out of your control, so if they start crying for milk or fill their nappy while you're in the middle of a meeting, you're stuck). Then from three/four-ish months onwards baby will want constant interaction and stimulation (plus all the feeding and changes)....

I'm surprised at how many people are arguing that just because your husband is a lower earner he shouldn't be the one staying at home if you guys decide against childcare. I'm assuming you have mortgage bills to pay and other outgoings that are based on having a much higher household income than his alone could provide while you're off.

Anyway, in terms of solutions, if you don't want baby in full time nursery in the first year, could you speak to your employer about the feasibility of 3 days a week, say, so baby is only in childcare for those 3 days and gets the other 4 days of the week (so still the majority!) with you. Would that work at all?

beAsensible1 · 29/09/2023 10:38

stealthbanana · 29/09/2023 09:31

Well if nothing else this thread is an excellent example of why the endless “it just made sense for me to stop work when the baby came because my OH earned more than me” responses on threads about why more women stop work when kids arrive are absolute bollocks - apparently it doesn’t make sense for the lower earner to stop work when they’re male! Instead the higher earning OP needs to stop earning and burn through her savings so that her OH can contribute less to both the domestic and the financial load.

OP YANBU. Your OH needs to pull his head out of his arse and get with the real world. He can earn more, or he can step up on child and domestic care. Either/or choice.

This.

in what world is it ok for your partner to refuse to take parental leave and send a 3 month old to childcare when you don’t need to.

OP you’re obviously not going to
leave this guy so you need to sit down with him and have serious talk about the division of Labour and if he really won’t contribute in any way to the household other than £650 pm, then you’ve got bigger problems.

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 29/09/2023 10:18

stealthbanana · 29/09/2023 09:31

Well if nothing else this thread is an excellent example of why the endless “it just made sense for me to stop work when the baby came because my OH earned more than me” responses on threads about why more women stop work when kids arrive are absolute bollocks - apparently it doesn’t make sense for the lower earner to stop work when they’re male! Instead the higher earning OP needs to stop earning and burn through her savings so that her OH can contribute less to both the domestic and the financial load.

OP YANBU. Your OH needs to pull his head out of his arse and get with the real world. He can earn more, or he can step up on child and domestic care. Either/or choice.

That's something Arlie Hochschild picked up on in her study. The reasons why higher earning women spent more time on domestic work and childcare than their lower earning husbands make interesting reading.

Anyway OP, leaving larger questions aside, I can't help wondering if your partner has just been telling you things you wanted to hear.

Swipe left for the next trending thread