Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect OH to put my job first ?

339 replies

greyA · 28/09/2023 19:49

Bit of back story, husband has been in his job 23 years, hasn’t really moved up that much and is still in junior management - has had opportunities to progress but has always said he doesn’t want them. He earns around 38k. I was a career changer and in 3 years have gone from earning 20k to 80k. I work in a fast paced industry ( tech ) and whilst I do wfh and have reasonable flexibility, I take my job very seriously and I absolutely love it. Currently we split things as equally as possible however I still pay around £500 more than OH each month ( I buy all food and pay a couple of extra bills ) ( I also do the bulk of the housework, shopping and cooking but that’s for another post ) I am currently expecting and previously we discussed OH taking some time off to look after baby so I could return to work after about 3 months and the plan was he’d be around and I’d do as much flexi working as I could ( possibly going down to a 4 day week or working some of my hours in the evenings) OH has now said he doesn’t want to do that and seems to think it’s perfectly feasible for me to wfh and take care of the baby. The fact is he doesn’t earn enough to cover all our bills but I do so AIBU expecting him to step up and either be home and care for the baby or earn more so I can stay home and do it myself ?

OP posts:
Aprilx · 29/09/2023 07:18

There are a few issues here. Your husband needs to pull his weight around the house. You also need to adjust your finances, you bring home not far off double what he brings home so evenly splitting other than the extra £500 is not fair and would certainly have been called abuse if it was the other way around.

And no, I don’t think he has to prioritise your job. You are both entitled to have a baby and work full time. So you need childcare.

MargotBamborough · 29/09/2023 07:06

GrumpyPanda · 28/09/2023 22:19

Dump the lazy fucker and get a nanny instead. Life will be so much more relaxed.

This. He's awful.

When you add up how much you're paying for everything, OP, you're clearly paying more than twice what he is which is disproportionate even with your higher earnings. If you're on £80k and he's on £38k then you should be paying, at most, twice what he is paying, given that if those are your gross salaries your actual take home pay won't be twice his.

And then it turns out that when you were earning £20k and he was the higher earner he wanted separate finances and everything split down the middle?

I bet he bloody did.

He wants to have his cake and eat it, doesn't he?

When he's the higher earner he wants you to financially contribute the same as him (and also do all the housework).

When you're the higher earner he wants to sit back and relax and be a kept man, whilst he also doesn't do childcare and doesn't do housework.

He is just going to be a millstone round your neck, OP.

You can't work and look after your baby so if he refuses to take parental leave then you will have no choice but to use paid childcare when you need to go back to work. But if he's already spending all his income because he can't manage his money effectively, guess who will be paying for the childcare?

That's right, you.

If you don't want this to be your life then your only real option is to leave the lazy fucker and claim child support. You might not be any better off financially but at least you'll be rid of this leech.

Schoolchoicesucks · 28/09/2023 22:45

YABU to insist your OH to take time off work to stay home with your DC. He would also BU to expect you to do so and is BU to expect that you can wfh and care for a baby.

If he's backing out of an agreed plan then he is also B slightly U, however clearly you need to be able to discuss and reach an agreement.

You're going to need childcare if you are going back to work at 3-4 months and he doesn't want to take parental leave. So start talking about whether that will be a nanny or nursery and whether he/you will reduce hours at all or whether this needs to be FT.

His comments about his ex and the 5 years off make him sound like a knob. If he is a knob then you could also start thinking about how the relationship is working for you and will work for you and your DC.

poorchurchmouse · 28/09/2023 22:43

How far on are you? Do you think you can cope as a single mother if you have to ? Because he really doesn’t sound like a keeper- he’s a misogynist who resented his ex for taking five years away from paid work to look after their children,and who already expects you to do most of the housework. There will be three times as much housework when the baby arrives and you won’t be able to do it all and will resent him for not pulling his weight.(Separately I also think you’re unreasonable about the finances, but that isn’t what you asked about.)

OspreyLambo · 28/09/2023 22:35

Dump him. You and baby will be better off.

FrangipaniBlue · 28/09/2023 22:34

If I've understood correctly:

OP earns £80k and pays £1800 towards household costs

Her DH earns £38k and pays £650

So actually, the OP is already paying more proportionate to earnings.....

DH is always in his overdraft, on £38k he will be taking home circa £2,300. If £650 goes on the household where exactly does the rest go?

OP currently does all household tasks.

DH expects her to continue this AND all childcare when baby arrives, while also still working?

Strikes me you'd be better off financially and emotionally without him.

hettie · 28/09/2023 22:30

So... He thinks his X wife took "5 years off" to look after the kids and is resentful of her and that you can look after a baby and when full time. He basically thinks that childcare and domestic duties are a piece of piss and 'time off' and therefore is either a clueless manchild who has never actually looked after a child/loaded a dishwasher or a misogynistic pig who things it's all little women's wife work and not to be valued. Either way you're in for a bumpy ride and I suggest you set some clear expectations pronto.

Therealjudgejudy · 28/09/2023 22:29

He sounds useless

Goldbar · 28/09/2023 22:27

GrumpyPanda · 28/09/2023 22:19

Dump the lazy fucker and get a nanny instead. Life will be so much more relaxed.

This. He's not a team player, he's lazy and he doesn't contribute much.

You're the one who carries the burden at home and you're the one who's driven in your career. What does he add to your lives, exactly?

I would love it all to go into a pot but he wasn’t keen until I started earning more than him and then I thought better of it.

He's a bit of a taker, isn't he? Not really a giver.

GrumpyPanda · 28/09/2023 22:19

Dump the lazy fucker and get a nanny instead. Life will be so much more relaxed.

mrsm43s · 28/09/2023 22:15

greyA · 28/09/2023 22:09

We may have to do this and I will look at working part time. He was always adamant he wanted to be hands on and would take extended leave. We agreed it made more sense as I earned more and could cover all of our outgoings plus it would mean I’d get to be with baby all day long- work is busy but I’m not chained to a desk all day so there would be plenty of opportunities for cuddles, lunch together etc. He’s now decided he doesn’t want to so I don’t really know what to do ☹️

Did you discuss how he would be financially compensated (including pension contributions) as the lower earner taking extended leave?

Because, I suspect that is the sticking point. Are you prepared to make up his salary/pension contributions?

Blondebutnotlegally · 28/09/2023 22:14

Grumpy101 · 28/09/2023 20:00

No. Put baby in nursery. Split cost proportionately.

If he's not doing his share of domestic work now, he'll take paternity leave as a jolly and will do even less. Especially if you are WFH, you'll end up doing EVERYTHING and will burn out.

And if you decide enough is enough and divorce, you'll end up having the child less than him and paying his lazy arse maintenance.

I'm not sure how you can "do even less" when looking after a baby full time. Nor can paternity or maternity leave ever be taken as a "jolly".

greyA · 28/09/2023 22:09

We may have to do this and I will look at working part time. He was always adamant he wanted to be hands on and would take extended leave. We agreed it made more sense as I earned more and could cover all of our outgoings plus it would mean I’d get to be with baby all day long- work is busy but I’m not chained to a desk all day so there would be plenty of opportunities for cuddles, lunch together etc. He’s now decided he doesn’t want to so I don’t really know what to do ☹️

OP posts:
greyA · 28/09/2023 22:06

I don’t expect him to contribute 50% exactly and he doesn’t. He covers half the mortgage and utilities ( approx £650) I put £1000 into our joint account to cover the other half and rest of the bills ( then there’s approx another £400 on various insurances, gym memberships etc that I also pay for) and all good shopping (£400) anything else for example - oven just blew up and I bought it. He’s happy for me to pay for meals out etc - but I frequently put extra in our joint account for such instances so he never has to thank me. I would love it all to go into a pot but he wasn’t keen until I started earning more than him and then I thought better of it. We always shared everything 50/50 when I earned 20k so feel like it’s only fair he pays his share now as it’s not like he earns a pittance. He’s also not great with money and no matter how much spare he has he’s always overdrawn at the end of the month ( we’ve tried me paying everything, 75%, 50/50 exactly etc )

OP posts:
PinkNailpolish · 28/09/2023 21:54

What is your work's maternity policy? You could go back to work when your baby is 6-12 months old and put her in nursery. You could also go part time for a couple of years. You'd still earn loads considering full time is £80k.

Cookiedough123 · 28/09/2023 21:51

@greyA this is so unrelated but please can I ask what you do? I currently kind of work in tech but it’s education related! Feel free if to PM if you’d prefer! Thank you

disappearingfish · 28/09/2023 21:45

You need a proper childcare plan. He doesn't want to be at home and you can't afford to.

Save like mad in the months leading up to the birth and be ruthless with your outgoings. If you've quadrupled your salary in 3 years you must have some financial flexibility??

What's your maternity pay like?

mrsm43s · 28/09/2023 21:40

JustAMinutePleass · 28/09/2023 21:31

Are you a contractor - is that why you need to go back after 3 mths? It’s certainly doable if you’re working from home but you will need childcare. Most nurseries will take babies from that age - find one that will take baby until 5pm. I still exclusively breastfed while DS was at nursery at that age (night feeding exclusively from 6pm-6am, then 200mls of expressed fed in intervals if needed).

Next tell your DH that if he isn’t going to step up for childcare or earn more then he MUST do 100% of the housework, all the nursery drops/pick ups, all the shopping - or the alternative is divorce and he’ll have to pay you CMS.

What? No! Why should one parent work full time, do all the housework and do all the nursery drop offs/pick ups, while the other gets to just work full time? Earning more doesn't mean you get a free pass on other aspects of family life (especially when you're keeping your higher earnings for yourself!)

Utterly ridiculous.

Not OK for the higher earner to abuse the lower earner is such a way.

If they both work full time then, regardless of earnings, they should have equal responsibility for chores and child related activities, and equal spending money. Anything else is abusive.

pastaandpesto · 28/09/2023 21:36

OH has 2 older kids from previous relationship and was very resentful towards his ex that he spent all his time at work and she effectively got 5 years off with the kids

Wowzers. What a shitty attitude. Staying at home to look after young children full time can be deeply rewarding but bears absolutely no resemblance to "time off". And the idea that you could WFH while caring for your baby is utterly laughable, especially as he has already done this twice.

I would arrange paid childcare and absolutely do not give yoir financial independence, because his attitude is quite troubling, in a way that may not be as obvious as a first time mother.

mrsm43s · 28/09/2023 21:31

SunRainStorm · 28/09/2023 21:07

So his plan is for you:

  • to be the primary breadwinner
  • do the bulk of housework, cooking, cleaning etc; and
  • provide 100% of the childcare while working at the same time.

What is he planning to contribute?

I'd put the baby in nursery so he can't claim he's the primary cared when you divorce him.

The flip side of this, though, is the OP seems to expect him to contribute 50% despite earning far less (except for luxuries she graciously treats him to) and hasn't mentioned how he'd be funded (as the lowest earner paying a larger proportion of his salary towards costs) in his period of shared parental leave.

It's really hard to see who is wrong and who is right here, but I can say clearly that if I was earning less than half of my partner and being expected to pay half of essential household costs, I'd be very, very reluctant to commit to taking on childcare that would mean a loss of my earnings, because it is clear that in that scenario that the higher earner saw their salary as theirs and not family money.

So all income in the pot, bills paid, joint savings topped up, joint (and child) spends accounted and paid for for, remainder split equally for equal spends each regardless of earnings. Once that is done, then it's reasonable to discuss who drops hours at work (with compensation for loss of pension) and what childcare is needed etc, safe in the knowledge that both parents will be financially secure.

On £38K a year, it's reasonably likely that it makes financial sense for OP to be the breadwinner and go to work full time, and him to be the care giver, maybe working part time to keep his skills up to date. And of course chores would fall mainly to the one who works outside of the home, since the SAHP is working 24/7 compared to the workers 8/5. But for sure, the SAHP needs equal access to money plus their pension topped up. And no-one on Mumsnet would be advising a woman who's higher earning partner expected her to contribute 50% to quit/pause their jobs to be a SAHM.

JustAMinutePleass · 28/09/2023 21:31

Are you a contractor - is that why you need to go back after 3 mths? It’s certainly doable if you’re working from home but you will need childcare. Most nurseries will take babies from that age - find one that will take baby until 5pm. I still exclusively breastfed while DS was at nursery at that age (night feeding exclusively from 6pm-6am, then 200mls of expressed fed in intervals if needed).

Next tell your DH that if he isn’t going to step up for childcare or earn more then he MUST do 100% of the housework, all the nursery drops/pick ups, all the shopping - or the alternative is divorce and he’ll have to pay you CMS.

gamerchick · 28/09/2023 21:23

greyA · 28/09/2023 20:34

I don’t know - I’ve never had a baby before and never expected to be the higher income earner. I’d just like to have a year off like everybody else seems to but doesn’t seem possible. I hate the idea of putting my tiny baby in childcare and loved the thought of OH being at home with baby and me getting to spend time with them both between working. It seemed like the best of both worlds.

Bless you. That doesn't work, it won't work. You'll be constantly interrupted and the arguing will happen. Your productivity will slip.

Tell him if he wants you to stay at home to look after a kid then he can take over the financials completely. Start a dry run his next pay day for the remainder of your pregnancy.

If he won't pull his weight around the house, why were you expecting this to happen? He's a lazy bugger by the sounds of it.

Dacadactyl · 28/09/2023 21:17

Good luck OP, you're gonna need it with this bloke 😬

PinkRoses1245 · 28/09/2023 21:10

YABU to say he should put your job first because you earn more. If you both want to work, get childcare. You can’t WFH whilst parenting a small baby. Household chores and childcare should be split in proportion to your working hours.

SunRainStorm · 28/09/2023 21:07

So his plan is for you:

  • to be the primary breadwinner
  • do the bulk of housework, cooking, cleaning etc; and
  • provide 100% of the childcare while working at the same time.

What is he planning to contribute?

I'd put the baby in nursery so he can't claim he's the primary cared when you divorce him.