Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask if you have an inner life?

234 replies

crochetmonkey74 · 28/09/2023 11:46

Really interesting conversation at work this morning - I was saying that I often walk around a bit oblivious whilst in town/ walking somewhere etc as I am thinking of all of my inner life things- things like bits of films I've seen, ideas for stories, lots of 'imagine if' scenarios. Other colleagues were split half and half between being the same and not having a clue what we were talking about - so for fun: have you got an inner life and what is it?

OP posts:
Alltheyearround · 28/09/2023 21:58

Yes. Snippets of books or things on TV (Woman in the Wall). Sometimes I narrate my own life, as if I'm writing a long letter to someone.

Alternative lives I could have lived. Revenge fantasies for people who have crossed me and great come back lines after nasty incidents at work. I'm generally non-confrontational so they remain just thoughts.

Scenes from my past, thinking about friends, wondering what the future might hold. Hoping for seaside and greyhounds on that front.

Thinking about what house I might buy (fantasy) and how I'd make it nice. Or even what eye shadow.

Plotting to outwit the LA who constantly try to remove/deny provision for child with multiple SEN is a popular route - I have to remind myself not to tread that path too often lest it wear a hole in my brain.

Noticing things people pass by - red berries on tree, puddle reflections. Little glimmers. Also writing a book in my head set around Partition era India.

I'm always surprised other people's minds are not like this. Some people have very little inner resources to go at and need a lot of stimulus coming from the outside so they don't get bored. I'm never bored but I am a worrier so maybe that's a downside to a vivid inner life?

Xtraincome · 28/09/2023 21:56

Massive daydreamer here! My current favourites are:

  • picturing another dog in the family
  • fantasy life as a film maker. But I refuse to attend award ceremonies as I have my children and my farm to look after!
  • interactions with random people I see and what I might say if I wanted to say something.
  • how much better I'd make that house look as I walk past their windows and stare in like a weirdo.
  • where my dream bookshop and writers workshop courses would be, as I search commercial.properties nearby
  • dinosaurs and stuff
Tumbleweed101 · 28/09/2023 21:51

I have written novels and at times the characters were all busy doing stuff in my head.

More recently I’ve lost that creative flow and tend to think about the more mundane and realistic stuff going on. I’m putting that down to a busy job and family but I’d love to have my creative novel building mind back.

I can’t imagine not having that constant chatter going on in my head though. I always assumed everyone had it.

WingingItSince1973 · 28/09/2023 21:49

When I was a child I would look forward to times when I could just be in my head. Be a different person with a different family. It was my coping mechanism to abuse at the time but it's something that's lasted into my adulthood. My thoughts are always there along with an inner monologue. I love to rebuild and redesign houses to the point of being in someone's house and getting a bit lost in my thoughts of how I would do things if was my home. I'm constantly fascinated by people and places and always looking things up so I have the right image in my head. I love thinking of who came before me if I'm in a certain area of history. Just standing in an old doorway and thinking of the person a hundred or so years ago. What they were wearing etc. writing it down I sound quite mad but I love my inner life. My husband doesn't understand but he swears he never dreams and despite being a builder and designer he doesn't see things in his head like I do. I don't get that at all. 😂

Fink · 28/09/2023 21:45

Fink · 28/09/2023 21:42

Yes, it's on a spectrum. That's why I say complete aphantasia, because if I just say aphantasia then some people confuse it with a less severe form. I'm at one end of the spectrum. People at the other end have hyperphantasia. Roughly 3% of the population are thought to be at either extreme, most people are at some point in between. When I did tests for it they calculated it as a centile, like child growth charts, so people who don't have either extreme will still have varying degrees of a mind's eye, internal monologue etc. I would imagine that relatively few people fall exactly on the 50th centile.

If you do an online test for aphantasia, they will usually ask you to imagine something and then note on a scale how clearly you can 'see' it in your head. It's certainly not that everyone can see it completely clearly except people will aphantasia who can't see it at all; people fall on different points on the scale. And for people who don't have aphantasia there might be differences in how well they can picture different people or things.

Shallana · 28/09/2023 21:45

I have a few longstanding fantasy lives, usually influenced by whatever I am reading/watching or things happening in my real life. In my favourite one, I'm an apprentice to a mysterious and handsome wizard and we live in a tower and go on adventures 🤣

I can't imagine not having these daydreams, I feel like I'd be bored out of my head often without them, especially when I go for long runs or dog walks by myself.

Fink · 28/09/2023 21:42

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 28/09/2023 20:06

See my post above. I have complete aphantasia, it's not the same as not having imaginative thoughts, it's just that there is nothing internal that acts like sense data (sight, sound, feeling, smell). We still think! Whether or not people daydream or think about things that are not concretely present is a separate issue.

I've often wondered if this is on a spectrum, rather than being an 'either you've got it or you haven't' thing. I am not a very visual person. I can conjure up images in my mind's eye, but not very clearly or in much detail, and it doesn't really happen automatically. I'm all about words. Everything in my head happens via language. I have even dreamed in the written word occasionally (kind of with subtitles). I guess that is visual in a way, but it's not pictures. I also have rubbish spatial awareness, which may be linked!

Yes, it's on a spectrum. That's why I say complete aphantasia, because if I just say aphantasia then some people confuse it with a less severe form. I'm at one end of the spectrum. People at the other end have hyperphantasia. Roughly 3% of the population are thought to be at either extreme, most people are at some point in between. When I did tests for it they calculated it as a centile, like child growth charts, so people who don't have either extreme will still have varying degrees of a mind's eye, internal monologue etc. I would imagine that relatively few people fall exactly on the 50th centile.

Bananaman123 · 28/09/2023 21:21

Overthinker so constantly replaying conversations, scenarios in my head. To relax and try to sleep, shut my brain up I go to my ideal life, don’t need to work, live in country, long dog walks etc.

I have always wondered about people who don’t overthink, not able to picture anything, would like to experience a quiet mind sometimes

stonkytonk11 · 28/09/2023 21:06

Yes! I love to relive things and 'tell' them like a story as if I'm saying it out loud. I think of an event and then re tell it in my head. Weird but fun 🤣 I have a lot of what ifs. Also...does anyone have this...I will get a flashback of a place (usually really random, insignificant) and feel like I'm right there. Usually a place from childhood and it's just a flash and I'm there and then back but it's the same few places that I go back to...?

MotherOfCatBoy · 28/09/2023 20:56

I do a lot of this, always have. Only child, emotionally distant parents, introverted until I discovered a bit more autonomy as a teenager and kind of adapted into extraversion for work situations. I read all the time.
It is rich and fulfilling. I do a lot of thinking about past and future (I am mid life), also a story I’m working on and experimenting with writing, a detailed plan for starting a new business and life in a few year’s time, and various things I’ve been reading and listening to. They all blend and link to each other and my brain goes off on tangents. I do wonder whether I have some ADHD traits as I am so easily distracted and constantly have so many subjects on the go in my head.

@Freetodowhatiwant I know exactly what you mean about it being empowering. I also had a strong imagination when I was younger about how I wanted my life to be and I have been lucky enough to achieve most of it, and still think that way about the future. “What you imagine, you create”

@NooNooHead1981 I used to work in a Claims department for car accidents and once had a file where a man had a head injury and one of his outcomes was that he could no longer dream whilst asleep. I remember both feeling profoundly sorry for him and wondering how the hell you value that for compensation, as some people may not see it as having any value, but I think it’s extremely psychologically important.

Lastly, anyone read Woolf and thought that the stream of consciousness is exactly like real life? Mrs Dalloway, To the Lighthouse?

whiteonreds · 28/09/2023 20:40

@bonzaitree are you confused by the 23/7 part? Or the whole thing? 23/7 is a scenario where the submissive still has control over what they eat, when they pee etc. So not a true power exchange, not 24/7. Obviously it's entirely consensual.

My dominant is a real person, I've no idea who he is but I see him regularly in passing and he looks like John Lennon.

I'm in a very happy outer life with a man who has shades of dominance but I do love my fantasy inner life

rubydoobydoo · 28/09/2023 20:19

I still say if it enriches your life it's not maladaptive - I resent this term!

When I was young, in my fantasy world, I was secretly an alien princess with magic powers trying to pass as normal amongst humans and only using my powers when really needed.

Now I'm older, my fantasy world is more realistic but still somewhere exciting to escape to!

If I'm particularly stressed or tired I just can't do it no matter how hard I try, and if I'm ill or depressed my fantasy world gets a lot darker than normal but still an escape.

If I get bored I have different versions I can visit - there's a dystopian future version, and more of a near-future version where all the characters are much older!

I did consider turning one of the versions into a book, but there's so many intricacies and spin-offs it would be impossible to narrow it down into just one story! I also think I'd feel a bit exposed if it was out in the open in that way, like having someone read my diary or something. So it's staying in my head!

Mummadeze · 28/09/2023 20:15

I spend a lot of time marvelling at how beautiful things are that I have seen before, but that suddenly stand out to me and look different. I am constantly having ideas for businesses, stories, artistic creations. I plot out conversations I would have in various scenarios. I also role play giving people money in my head after a lottery win. Glad I am not weird.

Snowinjulyy · 28/09/2023 20:06

I spend more time in my inner life than in my outer life.
My son is the same way.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 28/09/2023 20:06

See my post above. I have complete aphantasia, it's not the same as not having imaginative thoughts, it's just that there is nothing internal that acts like sense data (sight, sound, feeling, smell). We still think! Whether or not people daydream or think about things that are not concretely present is a separate issue.

I've often wondered if this is on a spectrum, rather than being an 'either you've got it or you haven't' thing. I am not a very visual person. I can conjure up images in my mind's eye, but not very clearly or in much detail, and it doesn't really happen automatically. I'm all about words. Everything in my head happens via language. I have even dreamed in the written word occasionally (kind of with subtitles). I guess that is visual in a way, but it's not pictures. I also have rubbish spatial awareness, which may be linked!

givemeasunnyday · 28/09/2023 20:05

KimberleyClark · 28/09/2023 12:16

Part of mine is a fantasy life with a TV show character I have long had a crush on! Also memories generally. I am retired, sometimes think about working but in a nostalgic and certainly not regretful way!

OMG - are we twins??? I could have written this.

CinnamonJellyBeans · 28/09/2023 20:01

Hont1986 · 28/09/2023 12:45

I think you are romanticising the simple concept of having thoughts.

Yes. They're called thoughts.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 28/09/2023 19:59

Oh yes, I pretty much live in my head. But it's thinking rather than daydreaming or living other lives. My inner voice is ever-present, but it is not very imaginative or creative!

Doingtheboxerbeat · 28/09/2023 19:58

Maladaptive day dreaming is how I discovered MN and I am grateful everyday for having a name for this lifelong, amazing condition which I honestly thought was unique to me 😄.

Mountaineer0009 · 28/09/2023 19:56

time travel and outa space thinking

crochetmonkey74 · 28/09/2023 19:56

feralunderclass · 28/09/2023 19:27

I think this is maladaptive daydreaming. I googled it recently as I do this a lot and the NHS website said its a very serious condition 😅

Nah not maladaptive in my case, doesn't encroach. Its just an enjoyable pastime. It's not fixated on one thing either

OP posts:
spookehtooth · 28/09/2023 19:55

I misunderstood, no audible inner monologue here just lots of regular boring silent thinking. Sounds like it would be a nuisance, so I'm quite glad. What if I started thinking about some shite song lyrics???? You can keep that special power thanks :-D

I can put on some music if I need to hear something.

JaneyGee · 28/09/2023 19:52

There is a difference between a rich inner life and escapist fantasy.

For example, I often fantasize about the life that might have been, and imagine being happy and fulfilled when I was young instead of a broken neurotic mess. Escapist fantasies/yearning for a life that never was/yearning for things that can never happen, etc (and playing them out in your head) is probably unhealthy.

But that's not the same as having a rich inner life. For example, today I was daydreaming about Van Gogh, imagining him arriving in Provence for the first time and being bowled over by the colour and light. I was also thinking about Tolkien and C. S. Lewis and how they used to get drunk together and talk for hours about poetry and myth and the Icelandic sagas, etc. I could almost see them in a smoky Oxford pub. Those daydreams have been sparked by books I'm reading. Now that kind of daydreaming is probably healthy. That's having a rich inner life.

itsmyp4rty · 28/09/2023 19:51

Yes, lots. Sometimes I just sing the days of the week over and over in my head sometimes I imagine what would happen if I took off all my clothes and danced naked down the street (not that I ever would!). I have aphantasia though so there's no pictures with it (or they're only very fleeting), just words.

Poppysmom22 · 28/09/2023 19:46

I honestly didn't know that some people don't do this and I didn't know that it had a name and everything until recently I thought everyone did it but just hid it better

Swipe left for the next trending thread