Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sycamore Gap - tree has been felled!

707 replies

NepheliLoux · 28/09/2023 10:51

Looks like someone has deliberately felled the famous tree in Sycamore Gap. I can’t believe anyone would do such a thing. I don’t normally get emotional but this has really upset me. It’s absolutely irreplaceable.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
28
Ghostytoasty · 29/09/2023 23:07

BIossomtoes · 29/09/2023 23:05

If 16 yo are fully developed mentally then why do we not let them vote, gamble, drive, enlist for active duty, or drink alcohol?

Because as a society we infantalise them. A hundred years ago a 16 year old would have been earning their own living for two years. The age of criminal responsibility is ten.

(Just over) 100 years ago women weren’t allowed to vote, but thankfully we learn, we develop and society moves on.

Missingpresumedhidden · 29/09/2023 23:06

If 16 yo are fully developed mentally then why do we not let them vote, gamble, drive, enlist for active duty, or drink alcohol?
But the age quoted was 25 for brain development to be completed and we allow all those things at 18.

Ghostytoasty · 29/09/2023 23:05

quiteoldad · 29/09/2023 22:55

This is a time of sadness, a time of grief, a time for lamentation and in such times, we mourn. We mourn this tragic loss. Our hearts go out to not only those Northumbrians who may once have sat bathed and blessed by the dappled light, beneath the boughs of this magnificent tree, but to everybody in this timbered isle who is touched by this tragedy. Our thoughts and prayers are for those devastated by this senseless felling. Just as we were united in grief for The Princess of Diana, we come together again, melded in sorrow for The Tree of Sycamore Gap. I now appreciate that puerile, arboreal puns were insensitive and my attempts to cedar funny side were inappropriate.

You’re being a total ash-hole.
Is that punny enough for you?

Leave people alone, they’re allowed to be distressed about such a subject and not appreciate having the piss taken.

BIossomtoes · 29/09/2023 23:05

If 16 yo are fully developed mentally then why do we not let them vote, gamble, drive, enlist for active duty, or drink alcohol?

Because as a society we infantalise them. A hundred years ago a 16 year old would have been earning their own living for two years. The age of criminal responsibility is ten.

Frequency · 29/09/2023 22:57

If 16 yo are fully developed mentally then why do we not let them vote, gamble, drive, enlist for active duty, or drink alcohol?

No one is arguing that the child should not be punished but the punishment needs to be appropriate for the crime and his age. He didn't rape or murder anyone and comparing the severity of illegally felling a much-loved tree to murdering an actual child is disgusting.

quiteoldad · 29/09/2023 22:55

SlipSlidinAway · 28/09/2023 23:28

Totally agree. Why anyone thinks it's appropriate to make stupid puns about this is beyond me.

This is a time of sadness, a time of grief, a time for lamentation and in such times, we mourn. We mourn this tragic loss. Our hearts go out to not only those Northumbrians who may once have sat bathed and blessed by the dappled light, beneath the boughs of this magnificent tree, but to everybody in this timbered isle who is touched by this tragedy. Our thoughts and prayers are for those devastated by this senseless felling. Just as we were united in grief for The Princess of Diana, we come together again, melded in sorrow for The Tree of Sycamore Gap. I now appreciate that puerile, arboreal puns were insensitive and my attempts to cedar funny side were inappropriate.

Gingerbee · 29/09/2023 22:47

I too was upset. I loved the tree on the wall.

BIossomtoes · 29/09/2023 22:46

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 29/09/2023 22:33

This brain not being fully developed until 25 really pisses me off. I had two kids by the time I was 25.

What's that got to do with anything? Giving birth is no guarantee of mental maturity. Girls can give birth at 14 or younger.

I didn’t just give birth to them, did I? I looked after them, fed them, kept them clean and safe. So I’d say it had plenty to do with everything. Christ, the fuss we see here sometimes about having a newborn from women in their 30s, you’d think it was climbing Everest.

Ghostytoasty · 29/09/2023 22:44

Missingpresumedhidden · 29/09/2023 22:30

Presumably she used her brain to feed them, clothe them, keep a roof over their heads and generally keep them alive and well.

Having not completed 100% of brain development can be used to explain a 19 year old not bothering with a pension plan but not grasping that criminal damage is against the law not so much.

That’s good because that’s not what I said, is it? I said the punishment shouldn’t be too harsh taking everything into consideration - it should fit the crime.

Someone said they wanted to chop him up. Some else compared it to rape and murder. I read somewhere else that he should be jailed for life. My point was, as I have said a hundred times, is that we need perspective of the situation and that the vigilante justice and bloodlust calls are ridiculous. IF this 16 year old even did it, we don’t have any of the facts, yet alone all of them. The point I was also making is that we shouldn’t let this situation be used by the government and media as a scapegoat over some other similar behaviours they have acted out in recent years. People are twisting my words to fit their own rhetoric and now it has somewhat detailed the thread.

PenhillDarkMonarch · 29/09/2023 22:43

Disgusting comparison 😳

Yup. Really distasteful.

Sometimes I think people get so wrapped up in arguing they lose sight of what they are really saying.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 29/09/2023 22:33

This brain not being fully developed until 25 really pisses me off. I had two kids by the time I was 25.

What's that got to do with anything? Giving birth is no guarantee of mental maturity. Girls can give birth at 14 or younger.

Missingpresumedhidden · 29/09/2023 22:30

smallshinybutton · 29/09/2023 22:16

You didn't have kids with your brain so that's irrelevant

Presumably she used her brain to feed them, clothe them, keep a roof over their heads and generally keep them alive and well.

Having not completed 100% of brain development can be used to explain a 19 year old not bothering with a pension plan but not grasping that criminal damage is against the law not so much.

smallshinybutton · 29/09/2023 22:16

BIossomtoes · 29/09/2023 20:54

This brain not being fully developed until 25 really pisses me off. I had two kids by the time I was 25.

You didn't have kids with your brain so that's irrelevant

Olindia · 29/09/2023 22:12

I’m very sad/ mad but comparing it to rape and murder of a human is beyond weird. As is calling for vigilante justice or hanging. And it is a fact that the brain isn’t developed until 25, obviously the age for criminal culpability in this country is 10 and people can judge this how they like but it doesn’t change that fact.

Royaly82 · 29/09/2023 22:06

DeeCee77 · 29/09/2023 19:33

Thank Christ you had no say on the judgement to this 16 year old then:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murderof_Alesha_MacPhail

If indeed it is another 16 year old cretin who did this, the twisted scrote took a chainsaw to a beloved landmark, on a site covered with messages to deceased loved ones, a place filled with memories hence the genuine devastation, and carried out such an act that took alot of planning given the remote location and the tools needed to execute it.

I think the outrage is because of two things: 1. the act of destroying something that meant so much to people, 2. that an individual could be this spiteful.

I struggled to wrap my head around his when the news broke because of its depravity. He took out something because it was cherished. He's a wicked bastard and please God he gets his justice.

Edited

Disgusting comparison 😳

User19537876 · 29/09/2023 22:00

I don't think we know who felled the tree, 2 people have been arrested so far.

TheHateIsNotGood · 29/09/2023 21:51

Oh well, seems it was a teenager, probably doing it for a 'bet'. Sad but true.

At least the 'kid's got talent' - he did do a good 'felling' after all - not condoning his actions, but I'll 'bet' not many on here have properly felled a tree lately.

RIP Sycamore Gap Tree.

MissMillyFluff · 29/09/2023 21:46

If some peoples argument is that a 16 year olds brain isn't fully developed, I'm sure the 60 odd year old man who's been arrested has a fully developed brain 🙄

Ghostytoasty · 29/09/2023 21:46

Missingpresumedhidden · 29/09/2023 21:39

My 12 year child has one grandparent who left school at 14, one who left at 15 and two who left at 16 (one of whom moved out of home into a shared house at that age and had to cook, budget etc as well as working full time). The brain may not be fully developed at 16 but it should be developed enough to have a basic grasp of right and wrong and even to act like semi useful member of society rather than indulging toddler level desires then shrugging off the consequences.

Which is precisely what I have said repeatedly. If people actually read what I have written rather than obsessing about one particular statement, maybe they would understand that.

Ghostytoasty · 29/09/2023 21:44

HotChocolateAlbum · 29/09/2023 21:40

@Ghostytoasty thankfully this is just a discussion forum not a jury so people can say what they please within talk guidelines. Most people manage to get to 25 without being destructive arseholes and your repeated 'it's a scientific fact' makes you seem tone deaf. People are deeply upset about the tree, stop lecturing them, it's not helpful or kind. Why do you chose to have empathy for this young man but not with those who mourn the tree or are shocked by the calculating and aggressive nature of this man? Do you think that people being angry about this on MN, within the talk guidelines, will impact a fair trial? If any posts risk a fair trial MN would delete them. If this 16 year old engaged in risky destructive behaviour, his parents should have kept a closer eye on him.

Have you read any of my posts on this thread? At all? People are focusing on the fact I said the brain isn’t developed.

What I’m saying is that the punishment should fit the crime. That’s what I’ve said over and over. In my earlier posts I expressed how awful this was. Caring for trees like this is my job. I value such nature above most things in life. And of course I expect such a reaction. But do I think people should be saying some of the things I’ve read online about someone who is technically stiff a child? So I think it’s right to compare his crime to rape and murder? Or course fucking not. This tree like many others meant a hell of a lot to me. So trying to call me whatever it is you’re trying to call me is ridiculous, but as it is a public forum as you point out, I can also say publicly that I think some of the sentences people are dreaming up for a 16 year are obscene.

The reason why I have repeated the statement about brain development is because Everyone else is obsessing over it and ignoring everything I have said repeatedly.

This forum is batshit sometimes.

Cadburysucks · 29/09/2023 21:41

I hope the bastards who did this are found and sentenced to a very long time in prison.

HotChocolateAlbum · 29/09/2023 21:40

@Ghostytoasty thankfully this is just a discussion forum not a jury so people can say what they please within talk guidelines. Most people manage to get to 25 without being destructive arseholes and your repeated 'it's a scientific fact' makes you seem tone deaf. People are deeply upset about the tree, stop lecturing them, it's not helpful or kind. Why do you chose to have empathy for this young man but not with those who mourn the tree or are shocked by the calculating and aggressive nature of this man? Do you think that people being angry about this on MN, within the talk guidelines, will impact a fair trial? If any posts risk a fair trial MN would delete them. If this 16 year old engaged in risky destructive behaviour, his parents should have kept a closer eye on him.

Missingpresumedhidden · 29/09/2023 21:39

My 12 year child has one grandparent who left school at 14, one who left at 15 and two who left at 16 (one of whom moved out of home into a shared house at that age and had to cook, budget etc as well as working full time). The brain may not be fully developed at 16 but it should be developed enough to have a basic grasp of right and wrong and even to act like semi useful member of society rather than indulging toddler level desires then shrugging off the consequences.

DeeCee77 · 29/09/2023 21:30

Solonge · 29/09/2023 21:01

How anyone can say it’s just a tree is beyond me! Shows a lack of understanding of the environment and absolutely no soul at all.

Apologists (and thankfully there are very few regarding this) will minimise things when it comes to criminal acts.

And yes, it wasn't just a tree (as I said previously, that it was a tree is besides the point), it was a beloved thing, and that thing was destroyed because it was beloved.

An individual(s) thought, "that thing is beloved, so I will destroy it".

We know they thought this because the thing they destroyed was famous as a beloved thing, you couldn't not know this. It wasn't just some random act where an object was plucked out by chance. They purposely, with great planning, in a remote location needing travel and tools, targeted a specific object, knowing the damage they would inflict. It was premeditated, thought out.

To destroy something because it is cherished, is the act of a sick, twisted, spiteful bastard.

Ghostytoasty · 29/09/2023 21:20

BIossomtoes · 29/09/2023 20:54

This brain not being fully developed until 25 really pisses me off. I had two kids by the time I was 25.

It’s a scientifically accurate statement. It isn’t excusing behaviour, it isn’t saying ‘this person shouldn’t be prosecuted for what they have done’ but I am using it to add perspective for the people online who are demanding the harshest punishments for this crime. All I have said is that people need some perspective and the punishment should fit the crime. But another poster is trying to start a fight so is twisting my words. At no point have I said that negative behaviour should be excused due to being under 25, but it is important to remember that their age is important to consider as will be the facts and reasoning. And the fact that there has, as I have repeatedly said, been no information put forward as to what has happened. So demanding the blood of a 16 year old is crazy when we don’t know the facts. That a 60 year has now been arrested backs that up.

Swipe left for the next trending thread