Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not understand how any can afford to live?

168 replies

ploddingalong2023 · 27/09/2023 22:47

Firstly I get that everyone is in a different situation and we are fortunate to have a house.
however, I can’t help to feel that it’s really hard to understand how people can actually afford to live?

My partner and I earn around £3600 per month combined. Our mortgage is £1200 (which I appreciate isn’t bad and a lot less than a lot of renters)

Our outgoings are reasonable, mortgage, council tax, paying for 1 car, some credit card payments etc. literally nothing luxury! But in total our outgoings of just bills, without food, petrol etc. is £3200.

We don’t have things like Sky TV or fancy cars etc.

We are tight with our weekly shops, all own brand stuff, no big brands, maybe 1 takeaway a month.

Our weekends are mostly trips to the park, walks etc. we might get a coffee on a walk but nothing exciting. Our evening weekends treat as a couple are getting a bag of popcorn and a bag of sweets for a film evening, so again nothing “out there.”

We do have the odd social event, maybe one a month or a family birthday we need to budget for.

We don’t really go on holiday. We have a small 5 day break coming up, which is cheap as we have family accommodation so mainly flights and spending money.

We do have £700-£800 per month on childcare per month which really is the breaker for us but that is what it is.

but even with all of this, we tend to be in a minus every month, relying on credit cards for little things or the final shop of the month before payday.

I just don’t understand how even with us not living luxury, and a decent (I think decent?!) income are still relying on credit cards?!

I don’t know what I am expecting from this post, maybe just someone to say they are I the same situation and make me feel better 😂

OP posts:
ginandtonicwithlimes · 28/09/2023 06:44

This is why some of us can't afford to work full time so work around our partners and claim UC instead. Childcare is absolutely ridiculous.

OP you might be entitled to something. Probably very small but enough for a food shop.

Augustus40 · 28/09/2023 06:40

Ds is 18 and works full time. He pays £300 towards the food and bills every four weeks. No mortgage or rent plus I sold my car in April as I work from home.

Touch wood I feel more comfortable these days. It helps not having a car to be honest. I don't smoke or drink and rarely have takeaways as not keen on them.

Aprilx · 28/09/2023 06:36

I never really understand these “how does anybody manage” threads. By all means ask if you want advice on budgeting or increasing your earning potential. But why phrase it as “how does anybody manage”. Other people manage because they earn more, manage their outgoings better or a combination of both.

ginandtonicwithlimes · 28/09/2023 06:30

That is to @ZeldaWillTellYourFortune

ginandtonicwithlimes · 28/09/2023 06:29

Hope you haven't been on holiday or ever used a car or had any children then...

Pebstk · 28/09/2023 06:10

I have to be honest I don’t think £3600 after tax is a lot in this day and age. I earn c£4200 after tax and my husband has income of £2400 so about £6600 per month and no childcare costs but lots of teenage children and son at Uni - I find it tight enough.

frivlot · 28/09/2023 06:05

Your mortgage payments should equal about 20%. Yours are 33% of your income. I'm afraid you're over stretched on your mortgage by a considerable amount

I'd love to have mortgage payments 20% of my income but didn't become an adult until the 00s... luckily my mortgage is still cheaper then renting

margotrose · 28/09/2023 06:00

Unfortunately having children is a very expensive life choice.

autienotnaughty · 28/09/2023 05:37

Can you reduce your insurances ? Our home insurance was £27pm before a large claim and life insurance £35. When do your phone contracts run out ? Sim only would be around £10 pm. We have Netflix £8pm but our freebie/broadband is £25 per month. So all of above is £115 for us but £220 for you. Will you own your car when the loan is up? That will help you massively.

Justifiedcheese · 28/09/2023 05:23

Adreno · 27/09/2023 22:58

I have some shocking news for you, OP:

Some people earn more money than you do.

And many who earn less spend less.

Coffeaddict · 28/09/2023 05:09

pompomdaisy · 28/09/2023 02:50

Your mortgage payments should equal about 20%. Yours are 33% of your income. I'm afraid you're over stretched on your mortgage by a considerable amount.

I hate this argument so much. The alternative to a mortgages is rent. Where I live the averge rent has gone up by about 50% in the last 3 years. There is no where to rent in my town for less then 1200 ( other then house shares). These are the houses in the dodgy areas of town. In the nicer areas there more like 1600 and that is alot cheaper then cities like Bristol, Bath, Oxford and don't even get me started on london
It would be great if we all had affordable housing but that is not available for the vast majority of the population so unless you have family support your paying exterminate rents or mortgages.

PurBal · 28/09/2023 03:26

OP our income is almost identical and sounds like we have a similar lifestyle. Nothing extravagant, just muddling through. But that’s life and I don’t feel discontent. Our outgoings are about £1700 excluding childcare. Childcare is the killer (£700ish part time, we will have two in next year and no free hours so we’re actually “planning” to go into debt for a couple of months until the hours kick in in April). We (DH) really shopped around for the best deals. Groceries are about £70pw for 4, including a toddler and 2 in nappies. Holidays are usually long weekends either camping or visiting family.

pompomdaisy · 28/09/2023 02:50

Your mortgage payments should equal about 20%. Yours are 33% of your income. I'm afraid you're over stretched on your mortgage by a considerable amount.

MintJulia · 28/09/2023 02:29

The childcare years are expensive. That's normal. You take a deep breath and scrape by. But your other bills are still very high.

Mortgage & childcare aside, I run a 4 bed detached house in the Home Counties and 2 adults & a car for £1,000 a month incl food and all bills.

Looking at your list, car insurance is high, and phones. And your car costs. Are you on a pcp? Better to by a 2yo car outright and keep it for 10 years. I bought a 2yo Volvo for £16k. Spread over 10 years that works out at £120 a month.

Tohaveandtohold · 28/09/2023 02:27

Op, it’s the childcare cost. Basically your mortgage and childcare is already 63% of your income so you have the remaining 37% to pay your other bills and live on. Obviously if anything can be done about the car payments then it’ll be doable but at least, the childcare will obviously reduce soon and you just have to not have luxury at all till then.
DH and I also pay that much in childcare when our children were younger as all our family live abroad and there’s almost a 6 year age difference between DD1 and DD2 for this reason but the high fee wont last forever, after school clubs is now less than £200 a month so that’s a big drop.

spottywren · 28/09/2023 02:16

@ploddingalong2023 try going on entitledto website and calculating UC again using your full childcare costs (not the 20% off tax free childcare amounts)

coxesorangepippin · 28/09/2023 02:12

Imagine if the UK had subsided daycare...

chappoi · 28/09/2023 02:02

That's ridiculous amount for childcare. This is why people I know stopped working and somehow got a few days at nursery free for their toddlers but only because they stopped working. If the mothers worked then they got charged more than they'd ever earn

Shadypaws23 · 28/09/2023 01:36

I have nothing left after paying my bills really
Did have a bit of a rant about it this week that working FT 40hrs should be able to afford a meal out or something
My two luxuries are a gym membership at £39 and now TV. This month I had £18 left so had a takeaway from the chip shop
No DC, live alone

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 28/09/2023 01:33

ploddingalong2023 · 27/09/2023 22:47

Firstly I get that everyone is in a different situation and we are fortunate to have a house.
however, I can’t help to feel that it’s really hard to understand how people can actually afford to live?

My partner and I earn around £3600 per month combined. Our mortgage is £1200 (which I appreciate isn’t bad and a lot less than a lot of renters)

Our outgoings are reasonable, mortgage, council tax, paying for 1 car, some credit card payments etc. literally nothing luxury! But in total our outgoings of just bills, without food, petrol etc. is £3200.

We don’t have things like Sky TV or fancy cars etc.

We are tight with our weekly shops, all own brand stuff, no big brands, maybe 1 takeaway a month.

Our weekends are mostly trips to the park, walks etc. we might get a coffee on a walk but nothing exciting. Our evening weekends treat as a couple are getting a bag of popcorn and a bag of sweets for a film evening, so again nothing “out there.”

We do have the odd social event, maybe one a month or a family birthday we need to budget for.

We don’t really go on holiday. We have a small 5 day break coming up, which is cheap as we have family accommodation so mainly flights and spending money.

We do have £700-£800 per month on childcare per month which really is the breaker for us but that is what it is.

but even with all of this, we tend to be in a minus every month, relying on credit cards for little things or the final shop of the month before payday.

I just don’t understand how even with us not living luxury, and a decent (I think decent?!) income are still relying on credit cards?!

I don’t know what I am expecting from this post, maybe just someone to say they are I the same situation and make me feel better 😂

This IS life.

Until the last 30 years or so, most people lived far more modestly. Flying on holiday was a fantasy. As were several other items in your budget.

Your kids are your luxury, as they should be on a burning planet losing valuable species every day and teeming with 8 billion humans.

What on earth do discontented people expect?

AuntieBadge · 28/09/2023 01:32

Your insurances are really high, do you live in a shitty or do you just let it auto renew. I haggle every year with car insurers. I have been with the same company for years. I do a comparison every year and then cal, them and say I like you I dint want to change but x can do it for Y they usually can’t go quite so cheap but it some obscure insurance firm I have never heard of and don’t trust them but they don’t know that. So they give a discount. Just like I ring up my internet provider and threaten to swap and I would.

We can run our house on just over 1k per month that’s actual bills though not including if the car has an issue and we have no mortgage or childcare anymore. Your bills are really high.

clopper · 28/09/2023 01:28

I can remember when my youngest child started school, I honestly felt rich beyond my wildest dreams!

many of my younger colleagues at work seem to be using family for childcare for at least part of the week, so I guess that’s how some are better off.

Hankunamatata · 28/09/2023 01:09

Childcare a killer
Your car costs are on higher side. I think we pay £600 in insurance for the year.
Same with life and house insurance. Our life policy is £20 a month and house insurance for the year is £500 and that's with top end policy with all bells and whistles

Ihateslugs · 28/09/2023 00:47

Do you look around for cheaper insurance, tv, phone etc rates every year or just renew automatically. My virgin package was going to be £90 a month but I negotiated it down to £45 a month. My car insurance, for me and my daughter on one car is just over £200 a year and my house/ contents insurance is £250 a year for a 3 bed detached bungalow. I never renew without looking for a better deal. I think you could reduce your monthly outgoings quite a lot but it does take time and effort.

But yes, childcare costs are a big chunk, I don’t need that any more thankfully.

Winter2020 · 28/09/2023 00:27

Is the 190 "car" a hpi/lease agreement or a loan where you will own the car when you are finished?

If the 190 is an ongoing thing I.e. when it is finished you start again with another the same or more that is £22,800 over a decade.

My car cost £2500. I have had it 8 years and it would not have cost me £200 each year in MOT, tyres and maintenance (most year it just passes it's MOT). (It's a little Kia Picanto) but for ease of calculation call it 10 years ownership and £200 a year maintenance that adds up to £4500 over 10 years. A saving of £18,300 versus continued payment of £190 a month over 10 years. If we repeat this pattern purchasing a new (second hand) car every 10 years the difference over a lifetime of driving is staggering - could be 100k!

But not everyone is going to manage with a Kia picanto of course. My husband bought a nice Touran for £4500 recently. It might not be expected to last another 10 years so let's imagine it lasts 7 years and costs £400 a year in MOT and maintenance. That would make the cost over 7 years £7,300. £190 each month for 7 years is £15,960 so less than half the cost. Again this could halve your car costs over a life time and save you tens of thousands.

We didn't have the £4500 upfront. We bought it on a credit card which we quickly transferred to a 0% balance transfer offer.