Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not understand how any can afford to live?

168 replies

ploddingalong2023 · 27/09/2023 22:47

Firstly I get that everyone is in a different situation and we are fortunate to have a house.
however, I can’t help to feel that it’s really hard to understand how people can actually afford to live?

My partner and I earn around £3600 per month combined. Our mortgage is £1200 (which I appreciate isn’t bad and a lot less than a lot of renters)

Our outgoings are reasonable, mortgage, council tax, paying for 1 car, some credit card payments etc. literally nothing luxury! But in total our outgoings of just bills, without food, petrol etc. is £3200.

We don’t have things like Sky TV or fancy cars etc.

We are tight with our weekly shops, all own brand stuff, no big brands, maybe 1 takeaway a month.

Our weekends are mostly trips to the park, walks etc. we might get a coffee on a walk but nothing exciting. Our evening weekends treat as a couple are getting a bag of popcorn and a bag of sweets for a film evening, so again nothing “out there.”

We do have the odd social event, maybe one a month or a family birthday we need to budget for.

We don’t really go on holiday. We have a small 5 day break coming up, which is cheap as we have family accommodation so mainly flights and spending money.

We do have £700-£800 per month on childcare per month which really is the breaker for us but that is what it is.

but even with all of this, we tend to be in a minus every month, relying on credit cards for little things or the final shop of the month before payday.

I just don’t understand how even with us not living luxury, and a decent (I think decent?!) income are still relying on credit cards?!

I don’t know what I am expecting from this post, maybe just someone to say they are I the same situation and make me feel better 😂

OP posts:
ASCCM · 28/09/2023 07:49

XenoBitch · 27/09/2023 22:50

How on earth are your bills £3200 a month? Are you melting gold to heat your home?

This amount is easily done, ours is more like 4600 but our mortgage is much higher than OP.

OP I am not sure anyone has much left over these days, we are all just riding it out the best we can

Hufflepods · 28/09/2023 07:48

100% agree shouldn’t be going on holiday. But also don’t think it’s unreasonable to want to go on a cheap 5 days trip after working all year with no breaks. Much cheaper than a weekend in the UK too.

This is your issue though. You feel like you deserve holidays, meals out, coffees etc but the reality is that it is unreasonable if you can’t afford it. And you can’t afford it if you need to put groceries in credit by the end of the month!
You don’t have a massive income but you have relatively high outgoings. After your mortgage and childcare you still have £16-1700 per month for bills, food and spending. Honestly if you’re going into debt at the end of the month in that scenario it’s because you’re living outside if your means, not that you don’t have enough cash to get by.

WetsuitRevolutionary · 28/09/2023 07:44

Is there any chance one of you could take a second job in the evenings or weekends. Yes it would be absolutely shit but short term pain for long term gain and would help get the credit cards paid off.
Rather than trying to cut back on everything life might be easier if your income is increased. My parents and grandparents both had to do this.
Coming up to Christmas there will be temp jobs in retail and hospitality.

ChesterDrawz · 28/09/2023 07:41

Pebstk · 28/09/2023 06:10

I have to be honest I don’t think £3600 after tax is a lot in this day and age. I earn c£4200 after tax and my husband has income of £2400 so about £6600 per month and no childcare costs but lots of teenage children and son at Uni - I find it tight enough.

£6,600 per month net is the equivalent of a £137,000 salary.

And you're finding it "tight enough"?

Really?

pompomdaisy · 28/09/2023 07:33

@Didimum you do realise they are all talking about gross salary and not net right?

FlyingSoap · 28/09/2023 07:33

YANBU, some people on here don’t understand what it’s like

Plenty of cars cost over £1000. You have one claim, fault or not, and policy rockets up. If you’ve not renewed yours yet you’ll probably notice it’s more expensive next year anyway. We pay £150 a month for two cars. It’s how it is, inflation and all

£1200 for a mortgage isn’t necessarily a big house or an expensive area, interest rates are stupid RN

OP you have my full sympathy I hope you get your free hours soon but until then check if you’re entitled to UC x

Goldencup · 28/09/2023 07:31

We had roughly your income in 2009, but just one earner, no childcare, 2 kids, one car, it was tight and we did sometimes end up using credit cards.

I think that is tight for a family to live on, especially if split over 2 incomes, so still needing childcare.

ploddingalong2023 · 28/09/2023 07:30

agree with everyone on the phone comment. I was on a £10 sim only deal. My phone broke, partner tried to do a nice thing and get me a new one. Definitely shouldn’t have, I’d be happy with an older 2nd hand one but we are in it now so no getting out.

our life insurance is higher as I have a direct family history of illness. Shopped around, was the cheapest.

by evenings out, our only evenings out in the last 4 months have been our best friends weddings - couldn’t miss them 😂
1 other time have opted to have a couple of friends over for dinner instead to keep costs down.

100% agree shouldn’t be going on holiday. But also don’t think it’s unreasonable to want to go on a cheap 5 days trip after working all year with no breaks. Much cheaper than a weekend in the UK too.

We have two cars so that definitely doesn’t help. We are discussing getting rid of one and sharing. Not having at least 1 car isn’t an option as I work in the office and it’s in the middle of nowhere.

but 1 car is paid off, 1 is on a small loan not brand new or pcp etc.

just to clarify we aren’t running around in range rovers at £400 a month and wondering where our money is! 😂

I know we need to be tighter with the odd coffee etc. my point of this thread was more to see if everyone is living the same or if it’s just us.

find it mental we can’t afford to get a coffee on a walk when we both work our butts off! I know life is life and definitely a 1st world problem yes.

OP posts:
Ugzbugz · 28/09/2023 07:28

How much is your water bill exactly?

What car costs over a 1000 pounds a year to insure? That is insane.

Life and house insurance seems steep to.

HashBrownandBeans · 28/09/2023 07:22

Over the last 6 weeks we have really really started to struggle with the rising food costs. We can’t go on like this much longer. We are now reduced to buying everything processed and frozen as it’s cheaper and it’s still crippling us. We both earn the same as you I think? We don’t own our home, drive an old banger, have no house insurance etc, no sky tv. I think we will just be living on beans on toast soon. We’ve had to quit everything healthy and fun in our lives, no more fitness activities. I’m working 50 hour weeks for this?

pompomdaisy · 28/09/2023 07:12

@Didimum by experts do you mean mortgage sellers? In which case 'well they are going to say that aren't they?'

Suckingalemon · 28/09/2023 07:12

It's the time of life with childcare costs. We were just as tight when our kids were young.

When they were both at school money was easier, partly because I could earn more, partly because I paid less to nurseries and childminders.

It's wearing having to count every last penny though, never being able to have an indulgent treat combined with young kids being exhausting. It is a first world problem but I hear ya.

Purplerain0505 · 28/09/2023 07:11

Definitely the childcare. It made a massive difference to us when we no longer had to pay it. It’s so bloody expensive.

A lot of people also have lower mortgage/rent payments. We earn a bit more than you and our rent is half your mortgage, so partner that with no childcare payments and that makes our disposable much higher for things like food, days out, holidays, etc. We weren’t in such a good position a few years ago so I totally get where you’re coming from. It all really adds up.

DsTTy · 28/09/2023 07:11

As others have said, you are on a low income and spending in areas including your phone and car could be reduced.

ploddingalong2023 · 28/09/2023 07:09

@pompomdaisy definitely not, also not born in the 00s.
We live in one of the more expensive areas of the South, the mortgage we have is one of the lowest we would’ve been able to find.

Yes we could have moved away but chose to stay locally as I think it’s important for our son to have his family around him

OP posts:
Didimum · 28/09/2023 07:07

pompomdaisy · 28/09/2023 02:50

Your mortgage payments should equal about 20%. Yours are 33% of your income. I'm afraid you're over stretched on your mortgage by a considerable amount.

Where are you getting this rule? Most experts suggest no higher than 28-35% of your pre-tax income or 45% of your post tax income. OP’s mortgage is balanced.

NoSquirrels · 28/09/2023 07:05

plus credit card payments and the odd extra payment.

Aside from the childcare, this is your issue. You must have relatively high payments? £250 a month? Are you only paying minimum payments or paying them off? You must stop using them. I know it’s hard. You need to save an emergency fund for the things that come up.

You might not feel like you live an extravagant lifestyle, but you’ve got a fairly expensive car payment, your house bills suggest you’re in a relatively high council tax band with the insurances and heating costs etc to go with that. You are living a bit above what you can really afford. You say your outgoings are ‘reasonable’, I say they’re on the high side.

Then you say you don’t go on holiday but you are going abroad, you don’t go out but you do go out for family birthdays etc, eat out once a month or so.

It’s not that those are unreasonable things to do, they’re not. But I think you don’t appreciate that you’re actually spending above average on a lot of costs (housing & cars) for your level of income. If you can’t cut costs, you need to try to up the income to pay off your debts. It’s only then you can properly get ahead.

Spodey · 28/09/2023 07:05

We have about the same income as you but our mortgage is half of yours. And we don’t pay for childcare because we juggle the kids between flexible working hours and grandparents. You must live in an expensive place and not have any help with your kids?

pompomdaisy · 28/09/2023 07:04

I personally think some people born in the 00 just expect to have it all when they first start off. We lived in a tiny terrace with a baby for years because it was all we could afford. My nephew and his wife want a big new house. Therefore they are now over stretched on their mortgage. There's plenty of terrace housing here to buy that would not give you a repayment amount of 1200 a month but younger people aren't prepared to live in it.

ploddingalong2023 · 28/09/2023 07:04

@PurBal nice to hear it’s not just us though!
We are both very content and knew having a child would make thinks tight and would never change that. I am happy with a weekend in over a weekend out etc. just a little concerning having the cards used at the end of the month

guess this post was more to see if we were doing something drastically wrong, and see if people were in the same boat.

OP posts:
NoNeedToHurry · 28/09/2023 07:03

In almost exactly the same situation as you OP (income around 3600, mortgage 1200) and I am baffled how you afford to run a car! We don't have a car and I've no idea how we would afford to if we wanted to. I don't know where the space in the budget would be! I guess we all make things work the way we need to.

On paper our budget looks fine, I microbudget the shit out of everything but there's no money for luxuries, no savings, and fuck knows how we are gonna manage Christmas this year as my DH has been told he won't get his usual bonus (usually around £500 after tax, which pays for our whole Christmas!)

Its just a bit shit isn't it.

ploddingalong2023 · 28/09/2023 06:59

@ZeldaWillTellYourFortune 100% our child is a luxury, a luxury choice and wouldn’t change that for anything.
but also don’t think it’s unreasonable to want to have the money to do something fun with him after a full working week 😂

If this IS life for everyone, then that is sad!

I assume you don’t have children ruining the world then???

OP posts:
namechange23947 · 28/09/2023 06:58

I think UC threshold is different depending on the area you live aswell.
We have a similar income to you OP. I suspect you are from the south? I live in the north and my mortgage is less than half of yours (for now anyway).

Poniesandrainbows · 28/09/2023 06:56

Pebstk · 28/09/2023 06:10

I have to be honest I don’t think £3600 after tax is a lot in this day and age. I earn c£4200 after tax and my husband has income of £2400 so about £6600 per month and no childcare costs but lots of teenage children and son at Uni - I find it tight enough.

I was going to say this. I think it's quite a low salary and you have a high mortgage. Do you have any opportunity to increase earnings?