Sorry, I haven't read this whole thread, but having one person organise for everyone seems really odd.
When my DS started his new school last year, he was invited to a joint birthday party by two boys in his year and their mum's told me that they were organising collections for a joint gift rather than everyone buying separate gifts. It seemed odd, but I agreed and dutifully paid cash into the Collection Pots. Since then loads of other parents have done it, and a few weeks ago I did the same thing for my own son.
I think it is a great idea so long as it is voluntary. My son got to buy an amazing gift that was actually much more expensive than anything we bought him, and we avoided having to deal with loads of small presents that he wasn't interested in, probably had been bought without much thought and just fill the house with more c**p!
Until I organised a Collection Pot for my son, I didn't realise the downside that I got to see exactly how much everybody contributed, and I think that puts pressure on people to be even more generous than perhaps they would normally be. Many of the contributions were very, very generous. On the one that meant my son could choose something amazing for his birthday, but I would hate to think that people felt pressured to contribute more than they could afford.
And I think suggestion at the OP's school, that one person keeps a record of everyone's contribution to each gift, will make that a million times worse. That list will get out. People will know that you gave more to one than to another, or that you gave less to one child than their parents gave to yours.
I think it sounds a nightmare. The joint gift thing is I think a good idea so long as it is voluntary, but let each parent organise their own and maybe agree a spending limit.