Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you're an only child, did you ever wish you had a sibling?

164 replies

redmalt · 27/09/2023 20:14

I've always thought I was one and done but here I am having a second! I never envisioned my son having a sibling.

I've always wondered though, do those who are an only child ever wish they had a sibling? There is me and my older brother and I couldn't imagine being an only child.

Interested to hear opinions Smile

OP posts:
mummy21blueeyed · 27/09/2023 22:29

For me this is a tricky one. I have 3/5 siblings 3 in my life who are mums kids 2 others that are just dads which I never had much contact with and still don’t even though my dad is dead.

i love my siblings ( 2 sisters,1 brother) however not one of us have a good partner between us and life is stressful. They bring me drama and headache however I do have fun with them too and I know in the future as we all get older we will become each other’s rock even further but it is hard. My brothers only just left school but he’ll be totally the opposite to us.

i have a two year old and I’m debating now whether I’d have another because on one hand I’d love for me and mu daughter to go abroad live life together but also give her the best shot at creating her own life better than the one I’ve got. But I also don’t want her to be lonely. That being said her dad has 4 children 2 of them no contact but the eldest she does see regularly however I don’t think this is the same as look at the state of me and my dads other children.

im only 29 next year so I’ve got time but I really am thinking about it but it’s also about where life takes me. I’m not wanting to even consider it until she’s 4 though.

GettingOldWithoutStyle · 27/09/2023 22:21

I'm the youngest of four so I can't answer your question directly. However, I now have three kids knowing I didn't want one child in case they were lonely. I loved being part of a little tribe myself. My boys do argue sometimes, they're nearly 6 and 4 BUT, if either of them get hurt, the other is the first to be there, check on each other and look after one another. That's not scripted from me or DH. When they play together it's pretty amazing 😍. I now have a 1 yo DD and the way they treat her is pure magic 🥰 I'm very happy with my brood. We're three and done (I think)

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 27/09/2023 22:16

merrymelodies · 27/09/2023 22:04

Yes! Being an only child means I have to deal with elderly parents on my own. It's a huge and difficult responsibility.

It is indeed difficult, but what makes you think having a sibling would mean that the responsibility is automatically shared?

More often than not, the burden of caring for older parents falls to one child. In my mum's case, it was her. In my case, it's me. I have friends who have fallen out with their siblings over this issue and gone NC. Simply having siblings is no guarantee that you won't have to deal with elderly parents alone.

Honestly, I often feel that it would be easier if it was just me, and then at least I wouldn't feel any resentment towards anyone for not doing their fair share. Then again, if I was an only child, perhaps I would just wish that i did have a sibling based on the erroneous assumption that they would help if they existed!

MrsMariaReynolds · 27/09/2023 22:15

Nah. I'm an only raising another only. I have no deluded or romantic notions of what could have been. It was (still is) so much easier being the only kid in the family. I have good memories of a close knit relationship between myself and my parents whilst growing up. And I hope DS looks back fondly at the ease, privilege and dynamics of his own childhood.

OspreyLambo · 27/09/2023 22:14

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 27/09/2023 21:56

Some people are worse off for having siblings. Most people are on balance better off, though.

Actually, I think the research on this is mixed. Some studies suggest that close sibling relationships have a positive impact on health and well-being. Others suggest that children become less content and less confident with each sibling that is added to their household.

There are so many other factors that feed into whether a child is happy. We always planned to have two but ended up with one due to secondary infertility. I wouldn't have it any other way now, as there have been so many benefits and so few negatives. DD has never wished for a sibling.

I do have a sibling and we get on well, but it definitely made aspects of my childhood much harder and I have no doubt that it had a negative impact on my confidence. And I'm still dealing with elderly parent care by myself, so no benefits there.

I really don't think that you can generalise. There are pros and cons to having siblings, and there are pros and cons to being an only child. How exactly it pans out for each individual will depend on multiple other factors. I don't think one type of family is necessarily any better than another.

Agreed. I don't there any piece of 'research' can prove the benefits, or otherwise of sibling relationships conclusively.
You can have easy or difficult children. Just the same way you can have easy, or difficult siblings.

FOTTFSOFTFOASM · 27/09/2023 22:11

ActuallyYes · 27/09/2023 21:29

And left you a single parent?

Really sensible of him.

He did something unforgivable. I left him.

I am glad I had more than one child as being a single parent without a break is not easy, but my children and I have overall had a noisy, chaotic, reasonably happy family life without him. I would say that they have overall benefited from having one another more than DC1 would have benefited just from having me. Their father has also been quite a big shared experience for them, and one which only they understand.

Inthetropics · 27/09/2023 22:06

I've only wished I had a sibling when my dad had cancer and sometimes when I wonder how I'll do it all when my parents are older and need more help.

merrymelodies · 27/09/2023 22:04

Yes! Being an only child means I have to deal with elderly parents on my own. It's a huge and difficult responsibility.

Beezknees · 27/09/2023 22:03

PeggyPiglet · 27/09/2023 21:59

I'd be very surprised if someone thought they had a miserable and lonely childhood purely because they didn't have a sibling, with no other factors involved. It surely can't affect you that much?
If it did, I'd be questioning the parenting. If an only child felt lonely, I'd like to think their parents would do whatever they could to arrange play dates, see wider family, etc.

They're just being dramatic honestly. If the worst thing to happen to you was being an only child, then you're lucky. Of all the things that happened to me in childhood that have negatively affected me, being an only doesn't even factor on the list. Actually I'm quite glad I'm an only because I wouldn't have wanted another child going through what I did!

StansRealityStruggle · 27/09/2023 22:03

I'm an only and loved it to the extent that I was genuinely frightened that my parents would spring a sibling on me. Actually had nightmares about it as a child.

If only I'd known my Dad had had a vasectomy when I was 3 months old 🙄

PeggyPiglet · 27/09/2023 22:00

@MrsBennetsPoorNerves I agree 100%.

PictureConsequences · 27/09/2023 21:59

Yes but I think mainly thanks to the very complicated relationship with my mother.

PeggyPiglet · 27/09/2023 21:59

I'd be very surprised if someone thought they had a miserable and lonely childhood purely because they didn't have a sibling, with no other factors involved. It surely can't affect you that much?
If it did, I'd be questioning the parenting. If an only child felt lonely, I'd like to think their parents would do whatever they could to arrange play dates, see wider family, etc.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 27/09/2023 21:56

Some people are worse off for having siblings. Most people are on balance better off, though.

Actually, I think the research on this is mixed. Some studies suggest that close sibling relationships have a positive impact on health and well-being. Others suggest that children become less content and less confident with each sibling that is added to their household.

There are so many other factors that feed into whether a child is happy. We always planned to have two but ended up with one due to secondary infertility. I wouldn't have it any other way now, as there have been so many benefits and so few negatives. DD has never wished for a sibling.

I do have a sibling and we get on well, but it definitely made aspects of my childhood much harder and I have no doubt that it had a negative impact on my confidence. And I'm still dealing with elderly parent care by myself, so no benefits there.

I really don't think that you can generalise. There are pros and cons to having siblings, and there are pros and cons to being an only child. How exactly it pans out for each individual will depend on multiple other factors. I don't think one type of family is necessarily any better than another.

blushroses6 · 27/09/2023 21:55

I’m an only child of a single parent, when I was younger I wasn’t bothered about having a sibling at all. It’s only as i’ve got older, I realise that once my mum is gone i’ll be really alone and there will be no one to say “remember when…” to. I have no cousins or wider family really either. While I know there’s no guarantees you’ll get along, my partner has a lovely relationship with his sisters. I have a baby now and if I can, I will definitely be giving her siblings. The fact she already has cousins and a wider family on her dads side provides some comfort.

OspreyLambo · 27/09/2023 21:55

Only child, nope no siblings. Had cousins and while they were nice always happy to return to my own peaceful home!
A 'sibling' IMO is a bit like marriage many people have an idealised view but life doesn't work like that.
All the 'lonely onlies' here think about how nice it would be to have a siblings, a close relationship etc. Not about the possibility of a sibling who hated them, was difficult/had high needs etc.

I got diagnosed with ADHD as an adult looking back it probably escaped notice for so long thanks to being an only child. I don't think I'd have coped with another sibling, especially if they had higher needs than mine.

lavendersbluedillydilly12 · 27/09/2023 21:55

I'm the eldest of four and we're quite spread out age wise. We weren't especially close growing up because we were sort of pitted against each other. Lots of 'you're like this' and 'he's like that.' I thought we'd get closer as we all grew up but actually the collaboratesd to try and ruin my life in an extraordinarily nasty way.

My DH has two siblings we are a lot and they're nice and normal and great.

kitchenSink5 · 27/09/2023 21:53

Yes I would have loved a sibling. Now I've lost both parents, i would love one even more. But saying that - I know it would have changed my relationship with my parents and I wouldn't have wanted that. Also very aware that I have a rose-tinted view of siblings which isn't always a reality.

I only have one DC after a long time trying. I know I'm sooo lucky to have him but still feel guilty I haven't been able to give him a sibling.

Oxonc3 · 27/09/2023 21:48

yes. I saw the arguments and problems but still
would have liked a sibling. There seems an unspoken bond that just does not seem the same as with even the closest friends. But wasn’t miserable. Definitely did not want to have an only myself and feel lucky was able to have a bigger family than my mum

Msblueskies · 27/09/2023 21:47

I feel like I was practically an only when growing up. I have one half-brother (from my mum) who was 9 when I was born. He had moved out by the time I was 10 (and I barely remember him being around in the years before that, was a typical teenager bush and always out the house)

I found it very lonely growing up, and definitely relate to a PP saying you always feel like a third wheel to your parents. One saving grace was that my parents were both from big-ish families and I had lots of cousins nearby, including at my school. We would often all holiday together and I got to experience big family Christmases. I hated the holidays where it was just me and my parents.

I feel like I’ve reconnected with my brother in adulthood as we both have similar age kids and I adore my nephews and nieces. But I’ll always feel a bit sad that I didn’t have the whole proper growing up with a sibling experience.

ChestnutShell3 · 27/09/2023 21:43

DH says he’s always wished he had a sibling. Me and DB get on brilliantly, always have, and I think he sees in us what he has missed out on. No guarantees of course, not all siblings are friends, but when we got married he was very keen for us to have 2 children (as was I). He gets on well with my brother and does feel a lovely brotherly bond with him though, which is lovely.

DM is also an only child and wanted a sibling. She has a best friend who is an only child too and they are each other’s chosen sister.

DustyLee123 · 27/09/2023 21:42

No

pontipinemum · 27/09/2023 21:41

I have a fairly unique perspective on this, I was raised from a few weeks to 12 years by my grandparents they had a lot of kids and I slotted right in, my aunt is only 2 years older than me so I had 'siblings'

I then went to live with my mum ages 12. I missed the Hubble, comradery, support, care and love I had from my 'siblings'. I would have loved to have a 'real' sibling. To share my experiences with.

Funny someone said about big age gaps and not being close. DH is 12 yrs younger than his sister and they are very close

CaptainJackSparrow85 · 27/09/2023 21:39

If anyone should feel guilty it's only children who are bitter at their parents for not having more children that they obviously didn't want.

I don’t think many people have said they’re bitter at their parents about being only children, have they? Just that they didn’t like being only children or have wished on occasion that they had a sibling.

Not liking something/wishing things had been different doesn’t mean you’re bitter towards other people about it.

Also it’s worth pointing out that lots of people have only children not through choice. Medical reasons for my parents. I don’t blame them at all. But that doesn’t mean I’m required to like it.

NotDonna · 27/09/2023 21:38

I HATED being an only child growing up. Every Christmas I’d ask Santa for a sibling. You’re always the 3rd wheel to your parents. It was very lonely. I’ve got used to it but I do envy friends who have siblings - or at least those with pleasant siblings.