Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you're an only child, did you ever wish you had a sibling?

164 replies

redmalt · 27/09/2023 20:14

I've always thought I was one and done but here I am having a second! I never envisioned my son having a sibling.

I've always wondered though, do those who are an only child ever wish they had a sibling? There is me and my older brother and I couldn't imagine being an only child.

Interested to hear opinions Smile

OP posts:
IAmAnIdiot123 · 28/09/2023 09:01

Nope never! But i have very good friends from childhood. We pretty much lived at each others houses as kids so I have them for support with my parents, as they have mine also. Our families holiday together even now. I don't know how I would have felt if I didn't have this.

givemeasunnyday · 28/09/2023 08:56

Beezknees · 28/09/2023 08:31

I'm an only and nothing about this resonates with me. I just don't care I suppose. 😂

It doesn't resonate with me either.

BrokenButNotFinished · 28/09/2023 08:50

All the time. Some of my closest friends over the years have been other only children. Sometimes we've joked about having 'sibling envy'.

Beezknees · 28/09/2023 08:31

Laiste · 28/09/2023 08:29

My parents were basically good people, and their marriage was happy, and my life was 'normal' in that there was no abuse or hardship. I was allowed friends round and was allowed to other kids houses ect. Bou can't have mates round all the time. 'Playing out' was a big thing when i grew up (80s) and winter and Xmas holidays ect, ... well you can't be playing out in all weathers. Seeing my friends going on holiday with their siblings ect., I roamed around on my own a lot on holiday like a lost soul! Once when i was about 10 i was allowed to bring one of my friends on our summer holiday and i loved it so much. Someone not adult and not sensible to bugger about with.

Also, being an only put a certain weight of expectation on my shoulders which i still feel today. The best parenting in the world doesn't remove the logic of the fact that you are IT. And for some onlys that weighs heavy. Not all obvs, but it did for me. At 10 or 11ish i guess i began to feel it.

I felt that i alone had the responsibility for reflecting my parents in a good light. If that makes sense? There's no one else to blame for anything when you're an only. No one else to providing joy. No one else causing anger. This search light shines on you all your life.

Later on in life it's changed to just a general sadness that i'm the only one. Yes some of my friends have siblings they don't see eye to eye with all the time, but others have sisters and brothers who have a special bond. No one else remembers my childhood the way it was from a child's perspective. It's hard to explain.

My own older DDs (20s and early 30s) are there for each other and love each other dearly. They are loving sisters to their youngest sibling also. 12 year gap.

I'm an only and nothing about this resonates with me. I just don't care I suppose. 😂

Laiste · 28/09/2023 08:29

My parents were basically good people, and their marriage was happy, and my life was 'normal' in that there was no abuse or hardship. I was allowed friends round and was allowed to other kids houses ect. Bou can't have mates round all the time. 'Playing out' was a big thing when i grew up (80s) and winter and Xmas holidays ect, ... well you can't be playing out in all weathers. Seeing my friends going on holiday with their siblings ect., I roamed around on my own a lot on holiday like a lost soul! Once when i was about 10 i was allowed to bring one of my friends on our summer holiday and i loved it so much. Someone not adult and not sensible to bugger about with.

Also, being an only put a certain weight of expectation on my shoulders which i still feel today. The best parenting in the world doesn't remove the logic of the fact that you are IT. And for some onlys that weighs heavy. Not all obvs, but it did for me. At 10 or 11ish i guess i began to feel it.

I felt that i alone had the responsibility for reflecting my parents in a good light. If that makes sense? There's no one else to blame for anything when you're an only. No one else to providing joy. No one else causing anger. This search light shines on you all your life.

Later on in life it's changed to just a general sadness that i'm the only one. Yes some of my friends have siblings they don't see eye to eye with all the time, but others have sisters and brothers who have a special bond. No one else remembers my childhood the way it was from a child's perspective. It's hard to explain.

My own older DDs (20s and early 30s) are there for each other and love each other dearly. They are loving sisters to their youngest sibling also. 12 year gap.

erlangshen · 28/09/2023 08:02

Beezknees · 28/09/2023 06:34

From reading this thread, it sounds like a lot of people who don't like being an only child had difficult parents. That's the crux of the issue, not being an only.

I agree! I had a happy childhood being an only mostly because my parents were always there for me. They have a good marriage, never seen them arguing in front of me. There was never financial struggles and they did everything they could to support me. My extended family too, we were very close and always had good time getting together. When I think about childhood, I know I was surrounded with lots of love.

Mxflamingnoravera · 28/09/2023 07:42

Only now in my sixties do I wish I had a sibling. I have full responsibility for my mum and her sister (both in their eighties one with dementia and the other neurotic) and it's exhausting.

whatchagonnado · 28/09/2023 07:26

Btw, they not me not to intervene with the arguments

whatchagonnado · 28/09/2023 07:24

FOTTFSOFTFOASM · 27/09/2023 20:30

BTW, my children fight endlessly, even now they are adults, but they are still better off for having one another.

It's really interesting, that one.

My two DCs (15 and 17) bicker and argue a lot - but are good to each other a lot too. I've tried to intervene to keep the peace when they're arguing. I've been told not to, because they like the argument. It's an eye opener to me - that's how they like sorting things out between them. Which is fine. I let them get on with it now.

We went on holiday recently and I asked if they wanted separate rooms - nope, they like being in with each other. Confused

DutchCowgirl · 28/09/2023 07:14

I am an only child and only grandchild. I was very lonely as a kid and always dreamt of having a sibling. When my parents got elderly and my mother died it was a very hard time making difficult decisions on my own. And now there is nobody left to share childhood memories with.

Beezknees · 28/09/2023 06:34

From reading this thread, it sounds like a lot of people who don't like being an only child had difficult parents. That's the crux of the issue, not being an only.

PeloMom · 28/09/2023 06:05

@JoanChitty there’s never a guarantee. My uncle (younger than my mom) passed away recently and their mom (my grandma ) is still alive.

Fruitandclottedcream · 28/09/2023 05:28

Not in terms of loneliness. I had the odd bit of jealousy as a child. It was because I was an only child to a single mum and all my friends had "perfect" families with a dad and siblings. I didn't like being the odd one out.

But once I got over that I was more than fine with being an only child. I got to do lots of things, I wouldn't have been able to do if I had siblings; including going to Australia as a milestone birthday present.

Also... I did acquire step siblings as a teen. The experience just reinforced why I like being an only child. I do dread when my mum is old and frail though. It's a lot of responsibility for me.

LemonTreeSkies · 28/09/2023 04:43

Yes. I had a horrible childhood with parents both verbally and physically abusing each other. As a kid I wished I had a sibling for support instead of having to hear and watch what I did alone.

FiveShelties · 28/09/2023 04:24

I never missed having siblings growing up. But my Mum died in May and I would have loved to have had someone to help sort out the funeral etc. Also, I have to return to UK again next week to empty the house and it would be very very good to have someone to share that with.

Hailandsun · 28/09/2023 04:12

Yes, I desperately wanted a sibling. I was very lonely and it framed a lot of my childhood. I always imagined having two kids but then I was hit with secondary infertility. It took me years to conceive and I needed IVF. But thankfully got there eventually. I would have been devastated if i we had never got there

HamBone · 28/09/2023 01:33

Yes, being an only myself definitely made me decide that I wanted to have more than one child.

My parents were loving, but had health problems (one physical, the other mental) from my early childhood and it was a lot to cope with. I had friends, but as a child/teen, you can’t really share what it’s like to be constantly worried about one or both parents!

My teenagers are very different personalities and inevitably bicker/ sometimes, but we’ve tried to teach them to always have each other’s backs and I think they will. My DH was brought up to be like that with his siblings and even though they’re v. different people, they’re always kind and nice to each other, and boost each other up. It’s nice to see.

Greetingsfellows · 28/09/2023 00:51

Always. My parents had a very unhealthy relationship and I was always the 'adult' whilst they were the children. It was a lot to deal with and I longed for a sibling to share the load with.

Mamai90 · 28/09/2023 00:51

My Mum was an only and always wished for a sibling.

My Dad was one of ten so she married into a huge family.

My sister is so precious to me, I'm so grateful to have her and I always wanted two so they'd have eachother. I have 1 DD and another on the way with the same age gap as my sister and I.

givemeasunnyday · 28/09/2023 00:43

I don't remember ever being lonely when I was a child. I had friends who I spent a lot of time with, and the two other girls in my neighbourhood only had brothers so we spent a lot of time together.

I also had a good relationship with my parents, and they didn't have unrealistic expectations of me doing well at school, work, etc. - they simply accepted me as I was. I did attend a lot of adult functions, which I think was good for me. I think I can cope better with problems than others do - there is only me, so I just have to get on with it.

JolteonBolt · 28/09/2023 00:31

Only when my parents briefly separated when I was about 25. It was very hard being the only emotional support child and mediator for both instead of telling them both to piss off and talk to Pippa or whatever my made up sister would be called.

but apart from that, no. I used to say stuff about wanting a little sibling when I was small, but I didn’t really mean it or understand it. By the time I was in my teens, I loved my calm home and opportunities I had as an only.

I see friends with very close siblings and get a slight pang, but it’s never guaranteed. I know plenty of apathetic siblings who don’t bother with each other minus a text at Christmas. In some situations there were 3+ kids but only one sister was left to care for their parents with no help. To the more extreme end of the spectrum, I know someone who was sexually abused by their brother for years. You cannot promise that siblings will help, support and enhance your existing child’s life.

I have my own family now. My child will be an only (unless I have a surprise, late-discovered pregnancy….but i’m actively planning for OAD). I don’t want another child and there are no guarantees that any sibling will benefit or enhance her life. Probably would. But maybe not.

Saggypants · 28/09/2023 00:02

funny how no-one ever starts a thread questioning whether people despised their siblings growing up

Nobody needs to start one - those posters always crash the threads about only children!

MrsAlgernon · 27/09/2023 23:12

I was sad at being the only child and I really loved being with my cousins and having them over. Would draw fantasy family pics where I pretended my cousin is my little sister.

After that didn't think too much about it.

My DH has nice siblings, couple much closer than another.

WrylyAmused · 27/09/2023 23:01

Nope.
Would theoretically have liked to have been a twin, but since I wasn't, didn't ever want any other siblings. Very grateful parents were one and done.

Don't have any living relatives left now, but have friends and partner, so don't feel any lack.

Everyonesliverlovesparvo · 27/09/2023 22:37

Only child here. Rest of my cousins were all one of 2 or even 3. All my parents’ friends had 2 kids at least. Most of my friends too. Always felt like the odd one out. Had a particularly unhappy childhood. All my parent’s expectations centred on me which put a lot of pressure on me to conform. Rightly or wrongly I always felt a sibling would have equalled out that attention which was quite toxic. I ended up having 2 DC who now they are older actually really get on and on the whole are far more relaxed and confident than I have ever been..