Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you're an only child, did you ever wish you had a sibling?

164 replies

redmalt · 27/09/2023 20:14

I've always thought I was one and done but here I am having a second! I never envisioned my son having a sibling.

I've always wondered though, do those who are an only child ever wish they had a sibling? There is me and my older brother and I couldn't imagine being an only child.

Interested to hear opinions Smile

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Embarrassednamechangeadoddle · 29/09/2023 07:45

I mean we are having yet another screaming match before school today because the kids needs are polar opposite. It’s never ending. Having a sibling isn’t the be all and end al and doesn’t guarantee a happy relationship.
don’t have a second child for your first child, have a second child only if it’s really what you want.

Bookish88 · 29/09/2023 06:34

No, never have. Was always so relieved after playing at friends houses growing up that I got to go back to my nice, quiet house. DS is also an only.

Poudretteite · 29/09/2023 05:52

I didn't have siblings until much older and yes, was always desperate for them and envious of my friends with siblings

trewsa · 29/09/2023 05:45

Sorry for typos. Meant to say

I now** think

trewsa · 29/09/2023 05:45

Yes - very much so. But, I realise as an adult that this was because my parents were emotionally immature and as a consequence abusive than because I was an only child. I've seen so many confident, happy only children that know think 'only child' can be a good thing if you have positive, emotionally mature parents.
But thinking about it, surely this applies to kids with siblings as well?

JustAMinutePleass · 29/09/2023 00:37

I have 4 siblings and I wished I was an only. My siblings are awful. My son is an only (and looks like he’ll remain one) but that was because I’m infertile & lucky to have him even. I wouldn’t have minded having 2

PrincessFiorimonde · 29/09/2023 00:24

Clearly, everyone's experience is different and I'm so sorry for people who have abusive siblings, or who are estranged from their siblings.
And it's great that several pp have said they are only children ('onlies') and are happy with that.
Oddly enough, though, I was thinking about this the other day (don't know why) and I realise I know eight women who are only children. Aged from their 30s to their 70s. Of these, one has no children, but the other seven each have two or three children. It just seems interesting to me that none of the 'onlies' I know has gone on to have an 'only' herself. But obviously I know that's not a scientific sample!

OrigamiOwl · 28/09/2023 20:31

I am an only and never had any desire for a sibling.

RedRobyn2021 · 28/09/2023 20:30

Yes

AnotherEmma · 28/09/2023 20:23

Technically I'm an only child as I have no full siblings; my parents separated when I was a toddler. I did want siblings and I acquired them when each of my parents found new partners - I then had step-siblings and half-siblings soon came along. Having grown up with those siblings, I don't feel like an only child. I'm very glad I have my siblings and they enrich my life as an adult.

I've always wanted two children and I'm lucky to have two.

I know that not all siblings get on but I think you can enable/encourage it with good parenting. And even if they have little in common, you can encourage them to treat each other with kindness and respect, without forcing them to be friends.

Pebbles16 · 28/09/2023 20:21

I have a sibling (5 year age difference). I love her but have often wished I remained an only (I know that sounds awful, but am guessing on an anonymous forum, I can be honest). I just wanted to be quiet and alone, and remain this way many years on

Paramummy3 · 28/09/2023 20:16

I did, every single day.

and still do now I am grown up and my parents are aging, and my kids don’t have cousins…..

Fancyfencepost · 28/09/2023 20:15

@Mary46
exactly!

No-one can generalise, only child or one of 6, we all have our own opinions and experiences.

Mary46 · 28/09/2023 19:49

Think people have this romantic notion of siblings. Not reality. I only hear from my sisters if its an errand for our mam and who is doing it.

Fancyfencepost · 28/09/2023 19:39

For those of those saying that it helps when your parents are older….

I have elderly parents, one is currently in hospital and this is the first time this week that I’ve been home before 9pm. I don’t begrudge my parents at all, I want to do my best for them.

I’m not an only child but I’m only getting a rest as one of the grandchildren is being great and helping tonight.

Caring for elderly parents is not always easier if you have siblings.

FOTTFSOFTFOASM · 28/09/2023 19:31

whatchagonnado · 28/09/2023 07:24

It's really interesting, that one.

My two DCs (15 and 17) bicker and argue a lot - but are good to each other a lot too. I've tried to intervene to keep the peace when they're arguing. I've been told not to, because they like the argument. It's an eye opener to me - that's how they like sorting things out between them. Which is fine. I let them get on with it now.

We went on holiday recently and I asked if they wanted separate rooms - nope, they like being in with each other. Confused

That made me laugh. Mine would be exactly the same. One minute it's "banter", and the next minute it's mortal wounding. But they still can't stay away from one another. There have been some memorable flounces in our house (Child 1 declaring they are leaving home FOREVER because they are not spending a single second more with Child 2, etc).

I am sure there are lots of good things about being an only child or having an only child. However, I think all of mine would have been insufferable if they hadn't had one another to tell them "you're a dick" on a regular basis. Siblings can do this in a way that parents can't. Parents of more than one child also tend to be more able to see their children's faults because they witness their children being foul to one another - whereas parents of only children often find it hard to believe that their children are imperfect because they don't have the evidence to the contrary regularly presented to them.

I personally liked growing up with noise and chaos and built-in people to play cricket with, and my DC have been the same. I have loved having more than one child for the 'noise and chaos' aspect, but maybe if I'd only ever known peace and quiet, I'd have felt happy with one child.

BrawnWild · 28/09/2023 18:41

I have a blood sibling I have virtually no relationship with. Lots of lovely step siblings. I was an only pretty much all of my teen years and it was amazing. As a child my sibling and I fought almost constantly.

So on balance, glad i have siblings as adults.

shellyleppard · 28/09/2023 18:41

Single child so yes I was very lonely growing up. Now have two sons (18 and 15) but......they have really struggled to get on with each other. Only past year they have become closer. 🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️

Rimmer08 · 28/09/2023 18:33

I am an only child . I never felt lonely growing up . My parents gave me loads of attention , I was and am pretty creative and happy in my own company . I never wanted a sibling growing up . I can’t even remember thinking about it . It seems to be other people who are obsessed with the idea I might be lonely . My daughter is also an only child and openly says she doesn’t want a sibling !

Glitterbiscuits · 28/09/2023 18:03

Yes, every single day and more so after I had children and my own parents passed.
My DC have no family outside of our house.
I married an only child too.

TheLightProgramme · 28/09/2023 17:52

*MereDintofPandiculation · Yesterday 20:20

No, never wanted a sibling. Have always been able to amuse myself. Think I got more say in family decisions than I would have got had I merely been one of “the children”*

This is a very good reason to have more than one children. Children who "have a say" are a PITA.

This with spots on

5128gap · 28/09/2023 17:50

Yes. Throughout my childhood and more so as an adult who's parents are both dead.
But I'd also have liked to be musical, to have grown up by the sea and have a wealthy aunt who'd leave me her fortune. Its something that I feel would have enhanced my life, but my life hasn't been ruined it by its absence.

crystal1983 · 28/09/2023 17:40

Used to ask my mum for a sibling for my birthday but that was more kids being kids rather than being desperate for one. I was/am very independent and good at entertaining myself so it didn’t bother me too much.

now I’m older I would have liked a sibling or two as everything family wise falls on me and would feel nice to be part of a larger family, but I know it’s not straightforward as that!

HamBone · 28/09/2023 15:31

One trait they I’ve noticed in myself, my friends who are onlies and my children’s only friends is that we tend to think we’re abit special. 😂. Not in an arrogant way, I think it’s just having more parental attention and no siblings to spar with and tell you that you’re annoying, etc.

I think having siblings or cousins whom you spend a lot of time with knocks those corners off you earlier which is a good thing. My corners are gone now, it just took more life experience.

Laiste · 28/09/2023 09:06

@Beezknees - lol, well this is it isn't? We all have different childhoods within different cultures and within different dynamics in the family, and we all feel differently.

I had no cousins either incidentally. Both my parents were onlies too. Maybe in my case that made things just that little bit too ... isolated? I don't know the word i'm after. Every single one of my relatives were my parents age or elderly. Or elderly and living in Australia!

I can honestly say though, that even though i'd class myself as not content to be an only, i don't resent, or feel bitterness or blame towards my parents. The way i feel about my lack of siblings doesn't define me. In response to a straight 'Do You Wish You Had A Sibling' question (which this thread is) then i say yes. In response to a 'do you resent your parents choices' i'd say no. No bitterness. I just wish they were different.

Without wishing to start the argument back up, i really don't think it's fair to call an only child expressing the way they feel as ''bashing''. I took that badly.