Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Being made to sit on the floor

277 replies

MandaLo · 27/09/2023 17:10

I'm genuinely interested to hear what others thoughts are on this.

DS10 is in a class with a teacher new to their school. She's very young but seems quite pleasant when I've spoken to her.

He told me last week that as a punishment for talking the teacher is making children sit on the classroom floor for 30 minutes each time. It hadn't happened to him though.

Today he came out of school to say that he'd asked the child next to him what book they'd chosen from the library and was made to sit on the floor for half an hour. He wasn't massively upset, just said that his bum went numb from it.

I've never come across this before. DS said some children are constantly on the floor. Does this sound ok?

OP posts:
sophiasnail · 29/09/2023 06:33

I'm sure we used to sit on the floor at primary school a lot anyway. Why is your son constantly talking over the teacher?

Annio82 · 29/09/2023 06:29

This really speaks to a teacher who either doesn’t know how to manage her class, or isn’t confident in doing so. I’d be interested to know if there is any evidence for this being an appropriate management technique, because while I don’t think it’s a physical punishment, it is humiliating though, and disproportionate to what the child reports he did.

I also find it interesting the number of people saying ask the teacher what actually happened - the implication being that we should believe the teachers version of events, because children always lie/misremember, but adults being held to account over their behaviour always tell the truth.

i personally would consider asking other parents if they’re hearing similar stories from their children about this punishment. I think context around where exactly children are made to sit is important, I’ve never seen a year five or six classroom with a carpet area to sit on. And then I would hold the school to account - does this fit into the behaviour policy, is it school policy or just this one teacher.

Leeanne922 · 29/09/2023 06:28

*sorry for typos above typing with one hand on the phone

Leeanne922 · 29/09/2023 06:27

I wouldnt want for started to sit on the filthy carpets- I went to school in another country,all hard floors washed daily, students had outdoor shoes that were echanged for indoor shoes as soon as students arrived in the school at the changing rooms. Teachers regularly checked the soles of the shoes that they would be clean.

and we never ever-sat on the floor. Not even in the assembly rooms,largest room of the school filled with chairs enough tot ake 4x35 student class.

Why are british schools so minging, no changing shoes and then put kids in clea clothes sit on top of filthy carpets?

Another thing i never had at school ir ever ib my life-headlice, seems to be common in victorian/modern britain amongs schoolchildren...

Coyoacan · 29/09/2023 06:27

jenpil · 27/09/2023 17:42

Asking a child sitting next to him which book he chose isn't exactly constant chatting and disrupting the class.
It's positive communication and shows an interest in both others and the subject.

The teacher sounds like she's drilling down on every little thing, and with a class of excitable ten year olds, that's going to be a difficult thing to do, and to be honest, not necessary.

I'd sooner have a chattering excited bunch of pupils, than a whole class of miseries being made to sit in silence - or go and sit on the floor!

Sitting on the floor is also a safety hazard...what would she do if someone else tripped over them?

You are taking what a schoolchild told their about why they were punished as gospel? How saintly would a child have to be to tell the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth in those circumstances?

Ihateusernames91 · 29/09/2023 06:20

Hahaha wowwwww people who are claiming it as physical punishment. Geez, when I went to primary school sitting on the carpet for lessons was just the norm. Entire class sat on the floor listening to the teacher and we were only sat at tables/desk for actual activities. People are so precious these days.

ThoughtEvokingReflectiveFemale · 29/09/2023 06:13

It is very common for the younger years to all sit together in the carpet for the input. Also, if the space is smaller with no spare desks and they aren’t concentrating, moving them back into the carpet to work for a bit can help them refocus.

Awfulteacher · 29/09/2023 06:11

My daughter had her chair taken for a week. She had to kneel at her desk.

Leeanne922 · 29/09/2023 06:06

I don't get it..if a parent used same punishments at home at the school, the parent would get a SS referral-as all these methods isolation etc. have been found detrimental to mental health.

My kids are home educated, for hundreds of reasons my children wont enter these aslyms.

Gypsum5 · 29/09/2023 05:27

Years ago we used to sit on the floor at school for assembly, watching TV, or story time. It wasn’t a punishment it was just the way that it was. The floor was no worse than the wooden chairs we sat on to do our written work.

AuntieJoyce · 29/09/2023 04:30

AllTheChaos · 29/09/2023 03:59

Oh this makes me feel old, teachers used to Chuck blackboard rubbers at our heads to make us shut up!

I nearly came on to say this. It wouldn’t be a school day without the usual suspects walking round with a rectangular shaped chalk mark on their person.

This thread is very eye-opening as to how little recourse teachers have to behaviour deterrents nowadays. I feel like I’m reading the Onion

AllTheChaos · 29/09/2023 04:00

Just read @pollyglot last reply - very well put.

AllTheChaos · 29/09/2023 03:59

Oh this makes me feel old, teachers used to Chuck blackboard rubbers at our heads to make us shut up!

BarbaraWoodlouse1 · 29/09/2023 03:43

Sounds Victorian. Clearly not working if it’s happening a lot. I wouldn’t be happy. Much better methods these days.

user1492757084 · 29/09/2023 03:02

I would not call sitting on the floor a harshity when often primary school aged children sit on the carpeted floor for all types of discussions and learning sessions.
It is being used to separate the child from their usual person with whom they are interupting the class.
I could not judge how disruptive each child is without being there. Though separating them would make them more quiet and over time the child would clearly learn that they could work just as quietly beside their friend as they could sitting alone on the floor.

I am a big advocate for quiet classrooms when working on core subject content (not when discussing, interacting role plays, working in groups, asking for input etc.)
And I trust that the teacher knows best when either quiet and noisy is advantageous for the classroom.

SammyScrounge · 29/09/2023 01:53

JFDIYOLO · 29/09/2023 00:54

Physical discomfort plus treatment that could be viewed as humiliating - literally lowering them beneath the other children?

I'd be down that school first thing tomorrow morning

Many Mumsnetters threaten to be 'down that school in the morning'? or an equivalent threat, but they never say what they are going to do when they get there. Would you care to enlighten those of us who so often see a certain type of parent making much ado about nothing.

pollyglot · 29/09/2023 01:46

MidnightOnceMore · Today 01:05

pollyglot · Today 00:20

MidnightOnceMore · Today 00:09

pollyglot · Today 00:06

Oh FFS! We used to sit on the floor for 30 minutes 3 times a week at school assemblies. And chose to sit on the floor in the library to read. What a snowflake. Just don't go to live in Japan.
These situations are entirely different.

How??
Because one is the norm and one is punishment? Is it child abuse as a punishment, but perfectly acceptable as a pragmatic solution to lack of chairs?
It's an ineffective approach to classroom management.

The library and assembly examples are obviously not the same.

Here was I thinking that the issue was the actual sitting on the floor. That it was seen as cruel and unnatural punishment in all contexts. Because it is uncomfortable, or is seen to be.
I would never have used it as a classroom management tool because there was apparently no punitive component in being made to sit on the floor. My "flop corner" - sitting on the floor beside my collection of exciting and relevant-to-the-subject books, and being able to choose one when work had been competently completed was a huge hit. Sprawled out, perched or sitting upright, reading Horrible Histories or Asterix was a reward, so far removed from being a punishment.
Ergo, it's not the sitting on the floor that's the issue. It's the being singled out as a result of bad behaviour, whether it be standing in the corner, outside the door, separated from the others to avoid disrupting their learning that's at the heart of the matter.
QED - children need to learn to respect their peers' rights to learn, to follow instructions and to realise that actions have consequences-(gasp)-even having to sit on the floor. Otherwise, they will indeed become little snowflakes, incapable of recognising that they are "not the only pebble on the beach" as my Granny used to say.

SammyScrounge · 29/09/2023 01:40

Mmhmmn · 29/09/2023 00:54

They're doing that out of choice in their own home.
Very different to being told to do it as punishment by an authority figure at school.
It’s a ridiculous punishment by a brain dead moron of a teacher.

A brain dead moron of a teacher? Do you always feel so intellectually superior?

CalamityKate20 · 29/09/2023 01:21

I had teachers in year 3 and year 5 that used to do this with us so it doesn't seem weird to me, just maybe a bit old fashioned (it was the late 90s)

MidnightOnceMore · 29/09/2023 01:05

pollyglot · 29/09/2023 00:20

MidnightOnceMore · Today 00:09

pollyglot · Today 00:06

Oh FFS! We used to sit on the floor for 30 minutes 3 times a week at school assemblies. And chose to sit on the floor in the library to read. What a snowflake. Just don't go to live in Japan.
These situations are entirely different.

How??
Because one is the norm and one is punishment? Is it child abuse as a punishment, but perfectly acceptable as a pragmatic solution to lack of chairs?

It's an ineffective approach to classroom management.

The library and assembly examples are obviously not the same.

Mooshamoo · 29/09/2023 01:05

I wouldn't let it be done to my child. We do t have to put up with everything the teacher does

MidnightOnceMore · 29/09/2023 01:03

pollyglot · 29/09/2023 00:25

You people in the UK are creating your own future nightmare. Entitled , self-important little snowflakes, unable to take any kind of correction, their egos fed by entitled mumsies.

'snowflakes' Hmm

Mmhmmn · 29/09/2023 00:57

JFDIYOLO · 29/09/2023 00:54

Physical discomfort plus treatment that could be viewed as humiliating - literally lowering them beneath the other children?

I'd be down that school first thing tomorrow morning

Yep. This teacher may seem nice - to an adult - but is a bit too bloody ready to dole out punishment to children.

Mooshamoo · 29/09/2023 00:57

Im just thinking from my own personal experiences. I've worked in schools. I personally feel like ive seen a lot of good practice by teachers.

Amd i also feel like I've seen a lot of abuse by teachers. A lot.

Teaching is very prone to abuse. Any position around children. I remember working in a private school where the parents were paying a lot of money to send the children there. And I was shocked at what some of the teachers were like. I was thinking if the parents only knew what went on.

I remember teaching a class there , and one of the little girls was telling me about another teacher abusing them. I did pass that information on to the head teacher.

I saw a lot of it going on. People abuse their power in those situations.

Mmhmmn · 29/09/2023 00:54

Ladyj84 · 27/09/2023 17:24

Physical punishment are you joking. My kids sit on the floor voluntarily for longer reading before bed lol.

They're doing that out of choice in their own home.
Very different to being told to do it as punishment by an authority figure at school.
It’s a ridiculous punishment by a brain dead moron of a teacher.