Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not block this work WhatsApp?

63 replies

bingbangbongding · 27/09/2023 15:30

Seeking a little assistance/honest feedback on how to deal with a situation at work.

A person on a team i manage has posted in the Teams chat ‘please can we not have WhatsApp groups outside this chat unless you want me to feel left out and not part of the team’

This person does not have the ability to access WhatsApp (by choice they do not have a smartphone) and the WhatsApp group was set up to facilitate meeting offsite (and out of network) with a team member we hadn’t met in person before. The person complaining didn’t come on this trip. The group wasn’t set up by me and I can’t delete it.

The WhatsApp group has not been used since the trip apart from once, when a person was going to be late and was away from their computer (which to be honest, I find reasonable).

One person has replied before I managed to and they’ve explained why the group was set up and they’ve said they will stop using it.

I replied and said I agreed with the intent of the group and that it hadn’t really been used.

I also added that I wasn’t going to agree enforcing the team to stop using it as it was a private group. I said if there were any team messages that had to go to all I would of course text her separately meaning she won’t miss out on anything.

I reiterated that there were no personal messages in the chat (there really wasn’t)

She has replied in the Teams chat with further discontent and now said she’s upset.
I will send a private message and ask to chat but I suspect she won’t be satisfied.

What do you advise?

OP posts:
Ormally · 27/09/2023 19:33

...And while you are at it, I recommend speaking to whoever is the expert in your company about FOI requests and work comms, especially as they can apply to personal and employee data if sought by an employee. I know broadly what the response should be, but this may give you some things to think through.

BetterWithPockets · 27/09/2023 18:56

I’m going to reread policy on comms tools this evening. Which is sad because WhatsApp had been used entirely professionally.
**
And I will speak to her about her communication style. I'm glad you mentioned emotional manipulation because that's how I felt about it. She talks about falling out with people (her sister, her friends, her last team) and I just think I should have been smarter having been aware of this.

Please speak to HR too, OP — they may be able to give you further advice. And they should be aware of what’s going on, partly so that you’re covered if things escalate.

HappyToSmile · 27/09/2023 18:25

I'd be wondering why she is mentioning this in this way, especially as the chat hasnt been used in a while. And especially as she has just moved teams for issues.

Lizzim18 · 27/09/2023 18:20

I don’t have WhatsApp (even though I have a smart phone).

I would suggest that there is no use of WhatsApp for work comms as it is likely bit to comply with public sector policy regardless.

If someone needs to send an “I’m late” or similar message they can do so via text message or email to an appropriate person (line manager or colleague).

If the team want to use WhatsApp for personal comms (specifically non work) then that is their choice.

Personally I am glad to not have WhatsApp 🤣

Ormally · 27/09/2023 18:13

She's ostracising herself.

  • For some people in this position: she's protecting herself. And this is going to get more common as WhatsApp inches into this space.
OK, she sounds irritating and just abrasive . But the truth behind boundaries like this, can be something murky that a person's workplace has no right to require.
avocadotofu · 27/09/2023 18:12

pastaandpesto · 27/09/2023 15:50

Personally I think using WhatsApp for work is blurring a line and is unprofessional, for exactly the reasons stated by this person. Is there a reason why you can't use Teams chat instead?

I agree with this. I don't think it's very professional to use WhatsApp for work communications.

Dacadactyl · 27/09/2023 18:09

tescocreditcard · 27/09/2023 18:04

I'm the same too. I expect to get work related information in work. Don't want whatsapp pinging on my phone 24/7 - it's like a form of harassment.

Can't you just email her the information she needs to do her job?

The complainant is not happy with this though. She's moaning she'll feel left out, but is then refusing to get WhatsApp.

It's fair enough if you don't want WhatsApp, but then for her to whinge that shes being left out is ludicrous. She's ostracising herself.

No wonder she got moved from her other team.

tescocreditcard · 27/09/2023 18:04

Ffsmakeitstop · 27/09/2023 16:06

We have a work WhatsApp set up especially for work related info. I don't have a smartphone because honestly I don't need one. I just accept that if there is anything urgent someone will text me otherwise I find out what's going on when I'm actually at work. Her choice same as it is mine.

I'm the same too. I expect to get work related information in work. Don't want whatsapp pinging on my phone 24/7 - it's like a form of harassment.

Can't you just email her the information she needs to do her job?

dcsp · 27/09/2023 17:59

So to be clear do you have any messaging tool which is:

  1. approved for use for work-related messages
  2. able to be used on a non-work phone
  3. able to be used on your work computer

?

If you don't have any that tick meet all three criteria, does WhatsApp tick 1&2 or just 2? Does Slack meet 1&2?

bingbangbongding · 27/09/2023 17:50

It's even more annoying that our version of slack can be on our phones but not on our cloud first computers.

It's public sector silliness.

OP posts:
Rockschooldropout · 27/09/2023 17:36

bingbangbongding · 27/09/2023 17:22

She said she feels bad about the rare earth minerals smart phones use. Which is fine, but we work in tech and our equipment is full of them.

Right 🤔 she’s in the wrong job then

gerrithedom · 27/09/2023 17:34

She sounds like a complete pain in the arse.

Couldyounot · 27/09/2023 17:34

bingbangbongding · 27/09/2023 17:22

She said she feels bad about the rare earth minerals smart phones use. Which is fine, but we work in tech and our equipment is full of them.

Good grief

Dacadactyl · 27/09/2023 17:27

God, some people are just so bloody AWKWARD!

It's a wonder this fruitloop gets through daily life.

Smellslikesummer · 27/09/2023 17:25

Ask the admin to delete the existing whatsapp group. Tell everybody that they are obviously free to message eachother privately by any means they want but that there won’t be an official work whatsapp.
Then if some colleagues want to communicate via whatsapp when they don’t have access to Teams, stuck during commute for ex, they can. Not something another colleague could complain about, is it?

bingbangbongding · 27/09/2023 17:25

NumberTheory · 27/09/2023 17:04

If your workplace don’t allow you to put WhatsApp on your desktops, it doesn’t sound like a suitable medium for work conversations (though it also doesn’t sound like you’ve really been using it for that except the once).

I think you have two issues and you need to tackle both of them -

  1. Communication tools. If the company isn’t requiring/supplying smartphones you need to ensure your communications tools don’t rely on them. Forwarding messages is not the same as her being involved in the conversation and is pretty liable to error. As someone else said - she’s setting up the groundwork for an harassment claim (even if that’s not her conscious intent). If you don’t address it, she may have a point.

  2. Her communication style with the team. Her tone and language was inappropriate and I think (especially given her history) you need to be quite clear about that. Raise it at your next supervision meeting - that her tone was unprofessional and so inappropriate. That reminding people she isn’t on What’s App is reasonable, or coming to you as her manager, but the emotional blackmail angle was not. Tell her you take her concerns on board about the possibility of being left out, but so far she hasn’t been left out of any relevant work conversations (I think - I didn’t entirely understand the bit about the colleague coming in late, but it sounded like that was an announcement that was forwarded on to her, not a conversation) and you’re looking into the tools you use to communicate as a team to make sure it won’t become an issue (see point 1.).

Yes, I agree with all of this.

I'm going to reread policy on comms tools this evening. Which is sad because WhatsApp had been used entirely professionally.

And I will speak to her about her communication style. I'm glad you mentioned emotional manipulation because that's how I felt about it. She talks about falling out with people (her sister, her friends, her last team) and I just think I should have been smarter having been aware of this.

I really don't want this turning into a grievance etc.

OP posts:
bingbangbongding · 27/09/2023 17:22

openallday · 27/09/2023 16:38

Gosh. What a painful person

Who doesn't have whatsapp?

Even my Granny is on it

Doesn't she have a tablet at home?

Can you still do group text chats?

She said she feels bad about the rare earth minerals smart phones use. Which is fine, but we work in tech and our equipment is full of them.

OP posts:
dcsp · 27/09/2023 17:21

bingbangbongding · 27/09/2023 16:00

We don't have work phones and Teams is locked down by our org so that it can't be used on personal phones.

We are allowed to use Slack Messenger on our personal phones for work stuff but she doesn't have a smart phone so she can't get that anyway.

We can't have WhatsApp on our desktop as the work computer doesn't allow it.

So there isn't a one size fits all solution, so the guy who created the group did what he thought worked best.

If you used Slack, then presumably everyone (including her) could access it on their computer, and those who wanted to could use it on their phones?

Also, if it's an approved method of communication, it ensures you're not breaching any work rules by using a non-work communication method to discuss work things.

That sounds like the solution.

44PumpLane · 27/09/2023 17:21

You can download WhatsApp chats to a readable doc.....download the WhatsApp chat and send it to her via email to show her that the WhatsApp chat has simply been used to coordinate an event she didn't attend and an "I'm sorry I'm late" message so she has proof that it's literally that boring.

Ask her to suggest another type of group communication tool that work could employ that she would be able to access on her non smart phone. Unfortunately the issue is that if you choose to opt out of smart tech then you may miss out on things.

It's perfectly reasonable for work colleagues to be able to contact each other out of hours if they have agreed to it.

I have a work WhatsApp with my team where we confirm if anyone is going to be in the office on a given day. It's not heavily used but means we can sometimes plan to be in together as it's more pleasant. Usually we just plan it week to week when we are in but if someone has been away they might message to ask when everyone is in this week.

ETA we also have Teams on our phones but all agree WhatsApp is more convenient.

nutellacrepe · 27/09/2023 17:21

pastaandpesto · 27/09/2023 15:50

Personally I think using WhatsApp for work is blurring a line and is unprofessional, for exactly the reasons stated by this person. Is there a reason why you can't use Teams chat instead?

Agreed! I don't do work WhatsApp (unless it's on a work phone with a work number).

pastaandpesto · 27/09/2023 17:15

bingbangbongding · 27/09/2023 16:00

We don't have work phones and Teams is locked down by our org so that it can't be used on personal phones.

We are allowed to use Slack Messenger on our personal phones for work stuff but she doesn't have a smart phone so she can't get that anyway.

We can't have WhatsApp on our desktop as the work computer doesn't allow it.

So there isn't a one size fits all solution, so the guy who created the group did what he thought worked best.

Sounds like laziness on behalf of your IT Team. We are cyber essentials plus accredited and take data security pretty seriously but we are able to use Teams on our personal devices because our systems admins guys put work into making it secure. Likewise DH works for a massive international company which locks everything down but he is still able to use Teams on his own device.

I agree with the PP who said that if instant group messaging is a requirement for you to perform your roles, the onus is on the company to find a solution that is accessible for everyone. For me, WhatsApp is personal - no way would I routinely use it for work.

JudgeRudy · 27/09/2023 17:13

I don't have a TV. Shall I complain if work colleagues start talking about what they watched last night? I'd close the current group and say that colleagues are of course at liberty to contact each other for out of work socialising by any means they chose.

Ormally · 27/09/2023 17:10

If the app is not provided by the company (or the tech it is used on), it's unprofessional to expect that people will be able to access it.

I would not blur business with WhatsApp use and I have very good reasons why not, that I would only share at work if unavoidable.

bingbangbongding · 27/09/2023 17:09

I doubt any WhatsApp groups other than this have been set up. The team is almost brand new and we don't live near each other or socialise together.

OP posts:
NumberTheory · 27/09/2023 17:04

If your workplace don’t allow you to put WhatsApp on your desktops, it doesn’t sound like a suitable medium for work conversations (though it also doesn’t sound like you’ve really been using it for that except the once).

I think you have two issues and you need to tackle both of them -

  1. Communication tools. If the company isn’t requiring/supplying smartphones you need to ensure your communications tools don’t rely on them. Forwarding messages is not the same as her being involved in the conversation and is pretty liable to error. As someone else said - she’s setting up the groundwork for an harassment claim (even if that’s not her conscious intent). If you don’t address it, she may have a point.

  2. Her communication style with the team. Her tone and language was inappropriate and I think (especially given her history) you need to be quite clear about that. Raise it at your next supervision meeting - that her tone was unprofessional and so inappropriate. That reminding people she isn’t on What’s App is reasonable, or coming to you as her manager, but the emotional blackmail angle was not. Tell her you take her concerns on board about the possibility of being left out, but so far she hasn’t been left out of any relevant work conversations (I think - I didn’t entirely understand the bit about the colleague coming in late, but it sounded like that was an announcement that was forwarded on to her, not a conversation) and you’re looking into the tools you use to communicate as a team to make sure it won’t become an issue (see point 1.).