Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be profoundly saddened by this story

615 replies

Changeditforyou · 27/09/2023 13:28

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12565699/Police-rush-scene-incident-outside-busy-Croydon-shopping-centre.html

They tell us to help our daughters to protect themselves from male violence by thinking about what they wear, how much they drink, how late to stay out, where they go…
Are we supposed to add to the list ‘not rejecting a bunch of flowers in case you get stabbed to death’. This is horrifying.

I’m so so sick of male violence. It feels everywhere and inescapable. More luck than anything that your daughter isn’t the one. This poor girl and her family.

Teenage boy stabbed girl, 15, to death with 'a machete after argument'

Met Police officers rushed to Wellesley Road outside the Whitgift shopping centre. Paramedics battled to save the 15-year-old's life but she was pronounced dead at the scene.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12565699/Police-rush-scene-incident-outside-busy-Croydon-shopping-centre.html

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
dogmandu · 28/09/2023 10:52

AlexandriasWindmill · 27/09/2023 19:38

A man coming on a thread about this to build strawmen tells us everything we need to know about you @jm9138 You're encroaching boundaries here. Your very posts on this thread show your lack of respect for women and your lack of insight into how profoundly male violence affects women's lives. So you do you. And we'll continue to see exactly what you are.

I'm a grandmother of 5 boys. I'd bet my life on it that not one of them would even consider violence against women. JM9138 has every right to the opinion that 'all' men shouldn't be tarred with the same brush.
There are other criteria that play a part here as well, which have been highlighted by some posters above. We should look at all of them if we're to make this a safer place for women.

Brefugee · 28/09/2023 10:44

SweetcornFritter · 28/09/2023 08:37

I’m glad it wasn’t a completely serious suggestion because it was seriously bonkers.

It is SERIOUSLY less bonkers than telling woe to stay home, don't drink, always smile, don't flirt, be kind, carry your keys, don't make men angry.

All I'm seeing from the Man Defenders is "wah don't be mean to MY boys"

What do YOU think should happen that doesn't curtail women's freedom?

A taste of their own medicine would do a lot of men, boys and the NAMALT gang some good

Brefugee · 28/09/2023 10:40

NumberFortyNorhamGardens · 28/09/2023 08:21

No more ludicrous than lockdown. And look how many people complied with that.

It’s not a (completely) serious suggestion anyway, more of a thought experiment to show how equally ludicrous and ineffective are the restrictions we as a society place on women ‘for safety’.

It amazes me that people don't get this

RavingStone · 28/09/2023 10:03

On the one hand I think there's a desperation to know the details. It's partly our brains working overtime - how will I keep myself safe, stop my son growing up like this boy, keep my daughter safe etc.

But, as a South Londoner, I've been thinking of other recent violence and its reporting. The spate of attacks on gay men were described as having homophobic motivation, right? Without the details of what, precisely, it was about the gay men which so offended the attacker. Because that would be disgusting victim blaming.

So why is the narrative with male violence against women different? Shouldn't the emphasis be that it was a misogynist attack, and the attacker knew the victim or victim's friend?

EarthlyNightshade · 28/09/2023 09:55

millymog11 · 28/09/2023 09:41

what i find terrifying is that it feels like there is no disbelief anywhere in the reporting of this incident that the supposed provocation of the boy who did this was literally that the girl in question had said "I don't want to be your girlfriend".
This is reported like "oh well that is why he did it, that was the reason".
In a different time it was men murdering other men over women they both liked. Now it is men murdering the women who don't do what they want, every other man is nowhere to be seen and the press report it like it is a totally common sense explanation for what happened.

They are saying now that it was not the girlfriend but the girlfriend's friend, who intervened and was murdered.
No justification whoever he murdered, he's needlessly taken a life.
RIP, poor girl.

millymog11 · 28/09/2023 09:41

what i find terrifying is that it feels like there is no disbelief anywhere in the reporting of this incident that the supposed provocation of the boy who did this was literally that the girl in question had said "I don't want to be your girlfriend".
This is reported like "oh well that is why he did it, that was the reason".
In a different time it was men murdering other men over women they both liked. Now it is men murdering the women who don't do what they want, every other man is nowhere to be seen and the press report it like it is a totally common sense explanation for what happened.

AuntieBadge · 28/09/2023 09:34

Women started to get somewhere, get some rights and men do not like it. Men were starting to feel threatened that women may end up with some sort of equality. I remember my ex being absolutely awful to me when I ended up in a job where I earned more than him, he felt emasculated. This was an educated man. He started to hit me, he did some awful things to me, he threatened to kill me, we looked the height of respectability and no one knew. I left him and moved miles away but I had a complete breakdown a year later.

The awful violence that we read about like this poor young woman is the actual tip of the iceberg. I live in a nice road with a lovely DH but I know even in this very safe suburban area women will be suffering and hiding the bruises.

SkippingOnSand · 28/09/2023 09:33

The blame lies with both the parents and the courts.
The parents aren't bringing their sons up to be respectful and inclusive towards females.
Half of the time, they can't be bothered to bring them up at all.
How many times have we heard about a young man being stabbed or beaten and stabbed by a young teen, or young teen gang in the early hours?
Why aren't the parents of these teens ensuring that they're not just at home, but in bed asleep where they should be, instead of our on the streets getting up to God knows what?
They're not bringing them up to respect anyone or anything, let alone females.
They're not encouraged with their education and to succeed in life, half the time they're not even at school and their parents don't give a shit.
When they do get caught breaking the law, they laugh. They think it's hilarious that their brain dead kid has been given an asbo or a tag.
The kids see it as a badge of honour, something that elevates their status amongst their mates!
That is where the law fails. The courts have jurisdiction to hand out much stiffer punishments than they do, but for their own reasons they give out the minimum instead.
That is also a huge part of the problem.
Until the parents start instilling discipline from the moment their kids can walk and talk and the courts start issuing discipline from the first offence, then it will never change.
Most of us when leaving our homes check that we've got our purses, phone and keys, not purses, phone, keys and a kitchen knife!
Parents need to start bringing their sons up to respect females and indeed, everyone else.
I have sons, who are now married with their own sons and daughters. If I thought for one moment that they were mistreating their wives or children in any way, shape or form, they would feel the wrath of both me and their father. No excuses!
As for running wild with the contents of my cutlery drawer in the early hours, that wasn't going to happen either. They were asleep in bed where they belonged ready for school the next day!

millymog11 · 28/09/2023 09:30

If I have understood it correctly and the girl who died was not the girl the boy was interested in but her friend who was trying to defend her from him that is so so sad. Someone prepared to defend their friend for all the right reasons gets murdered. Not one boy/male/ in sight defending this girl. Just her female friend.

SofiYol · 28/09/2023 09:29

AzureBlue99 · 28/09/2023 08:11

@SofiYol The answer is if you take a life you should get life. Simple. It would not matter if you were rehabilitated or not, you are incarcerated for life.

I agree, but it will never happen.

MealsWithPeas · 28/09/2023 09:25

The identity of the victim has been reported, Eliyanna a 15 year old girl from a West African Christian family. It's gut wrenchingly sad and I hope the murderer will get a very long prison sentence.

MealsWithPeas · 28/09/2023 09:17

I agree @Stressedafff . It needs to be controlled.

We are in an area that couldn't be more different to Croydon nice communities, nice schools etc. Yet, there are also dodgy men, black, Asian and white roaming the park and roads. They smoke cannabis as they walk or cycle in groups, look and act loud and menacing, there is drug dealing going on and they are basically groups of violent men that act in a threatening way. It's a minority but enough to make the streets unsafe for women and girls to walk by themselves.

Some of the boys on my dc's form what's app are also bang out of order. There is a roughness and depravation with our young men and I believe it stems from violent online content and access to cannabis and more. Poverty and a difficult home life are obviously a contributors too.

Fuckthatguy · 28/09/2023 09:17

@twostraws You’ve raised such an important point about early intervention at school age. There is such a lack of support for children in the UK comparatively, and I also wholeheartedly agree with @Stressedafff that organisations needs to be held accountable for the lack of moderation which is warping the minds of our children with the distorted reality that is social media - msm is also pretty toxic of course.

There are not enough mentoring programmes or easy access to outreach programmes in my view. No, I don’t prescribe to the let’s molly coddle these poor darlings until they feel better about themselves and stop harming others, they don’t have enough self awareness nor empathy in the first place to understand their behaviours needs to be modified. Lack of parenting isn’t going to solve itself but there needs to be a hard line somewhere on this.

millymog11 · 28/09/2023 09:10

Not read the whole thread.
But went to bed last night (i) feeling incredibly sad and scared for my 14 year old daughter. She asks me for dating advice, i just feel utterly unprepared to advise her anything apart from if you have even the most tiny bit of concern about a boy then keep your distance. This girl clearly did not like this boy and it has a feel about it of the girls involved being in the wrong place at the wrong time (ii) a general depression about the whole of society being driven by male sex drive (literally all of it) because it is, isn't it?

Stressedafff · 28/09/2023 08:58

I think the media that’s aimed at our children needs to be held to some account

They’re being raised on drill music, the likes of Andrew Tate and programmes like Top Boy

This level of violence and misogyny is normalised to them, they have no repulsion to it
Something seriously needs to be done

twostraws · 28/09/2023 08:49

This story made me think of my male friends and the way they look after me and keep me safe. It's all automatic - they don't even think about it.

Clearly, men are capable of treating women considerately, even though their biology makes them capable of doing otherwise. So, if nature isn't dictating their actions, it's got to be nurture. This boy was only 17 - so something has gone wrong in childhood.

There needs to be a massive intervention at school age. I don't know what shape that takes, but I do think we need to do something whilst our boys' brains are still malleable and can be taught that girls are worthy of respect. More policing re knife crime is tackling the symptom rather than the cause. We need to tackle why little boys can even think a certain way in the first place and stamp it out before they turn into big, scary men who kill.

God, I just feel so sad for the girl's family. I also feel sorry for the bus driver (what a human) and for the girl's friend, who is going to grow up with a huge amount of survivor's guilt.

SweetcornFritter · 28/09/2023 08:37

NumberFortyNorhamGardens · 28/09/2023 08:21

No more ludicrous than lockdown. And look how many people complied with that.

It’s not a (completely) serious suggestion anyway, more of a thought experiment to show how equally ludicrous and ineffective are the restrictions we as a society place on women ‘for safety’.

I’m glad it wasn’t a completely serious suggestion because it was seriously bonkers.

SweetcornFritter · 28/09/2023 08:35

Brefugee · 28/09/2023 07:51

How do you think we'll get the message home? Being kind?

Curfews are easy to enforce tbh

Explain “curfews are easy to enforce” in the context of ALL men, for 24 hours a day, seven days a week.

beAsensible1 · 28/09/2023 08:25

Just the other day a man was on here being wildly misogynistic about “modern day women” saying we were gold diggers and IG obsessed and essentially one night stand whores.

many women on here were excusing it when we called it out due to him being ND
and saying some people have different opinions.

there were suggestions he go to church to meet like minded women!

if us on this mostly women’s forum are not robust in recognising and calling out misogyny and incel rhetoric and even go further in offering up other women to men such as that we have no chance.

you may be traditional, liberal, progressive, socialist, conservative whatever. Misogyny and patriarchy underpins VAWG, call it out in your own spheres we need to protect each other.

solidarity to every woman and Rest in Peace to that poor girl ❤️

bombastix · 28/09/2023 08:22

calyxx · 28/09/2023 08:17

There's a massive staffing crisis in prisons. Building more is not going to help. The answer is in pouring money into regeneration, opportunities and intervention, and in making careers working with those convicted rewarding.

I am completely aware the prison service is on its knees. It has been decimated by cuts. People do not want to work in them. They are very dangerous places. You can thank the Conservative Party for ruining what existed. That needs fixing.

NumberFortyNorhamGardens · 28/09/2023 08:21

SweetcornFritter · 28/09/2023 07:29

Sure. And just how do you plan to enforce a 24 hour a day curfew on all men for a week and quite what do you think it will achieve? It’s an utterly ludicrous suggestion imo.

Edited

No more ludicrous than lockdown. And look how many people complied with that.

It’s not a (completely) serious suggestion anyway, more of a thought experiment to show how equally ludicrous and ineffective are the restrictions we as a society place on women ‘for safety’.

LuluBlakey1 · 28/09/2023 08:18

TheAverageJoanne · 28/09/2023 08:01

The women killed by the Yorkshire ripper were described as innocent victims if they weren't sex workers. That was abhorrent.

Yes, I made exactly that point earlier up the thread. We have learned nothing in the last 45 years.

calyxx · 28/09/2023 08:17

There's a massive staffing crisis in prisons. Building more is not going to help. The answer is in pouring money into regeneration, opportunities and intervention, and in making careers working with those convicted rewarding.

bombastix · 28/09/2023 08:12

The point about prison is that it protects the public from dangerous people. That is a legitimate idea.

I do not care if it is a badge of honour. It protects, for a period of time, the general public.

It may not be a deterrent but that says something about the kind of upbringing and depravity of these child offenders. By the time they have harmed someone with a knife it is too late. Knife carriers are dangerous. That it is why it is a criminal offence.

The other thing is this; this is a youth crime. It's done by the young. People above 25 largely do not commit these type of crimes with anything like the same type of frequency as teenagers.

People talk about prison as a nasty place. Yes it is. I have been to a few. But that is where violent people and people who carry knives deserve to be.

Regrettably over years in the criminal justice system I have seen rehabilitation rise as an aim and dominate youth justice all very well and it's part of the law but I would put violence in a different category. The actual law is failing because it does bit address that for some gangs, it's far better to have children carry weapons or run drugs because of lower penalties. Gangs exploit children and they are setting the agenda in terms of "protection".

There would be absolute uproar if knife carriers all went to prison; parents and youth outreach but the truth is that is failing. These offenders would be off the streets. It's not the only answer but will start to protect society. Oh that level, prison works.

AzureBlue99 · 28/09/2023 08:11

@SofiYol The answer is if you take a life you should get life. Simple. It would not matter if you were rehabilitated or not, you are incarcerated for life.