Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you put your 1 year old in nursery if you didn’t work

311 replies

Comeonautumn · 27/09/2023 11:57

And didn’t need to work-financially ok, other child in school. Would you put your 1 year old in nursery every day?
NOT being judgey, just trying to understand the reasons someone would.
I stayed off with my dc for a while, we were skint and it was so hard at home sometimes, but looking back, they were some of the best times and I wish I could do it all again with my dc especially at 1, when they didn’t yet walk and it was all cuddly and lovely
Friend mentioned to me that our other friend was doing this.
Completely different if you have to work

OP posts:
Mummy2Babba · 27/09/2023 13:55

I think everyone's circumstances are different and nobody should judge.
All three of my children have been in nursery full time 7 am starts from small babies due to work. I personally get really bad mum guilt sometimes but I know they are happy and well looked after and we do lots of things as a family.
However if I have ever got away early or maybe had some days off I have on occasion still kept them in to do things at home , run errands etc. if you have everything done and organised you can parent better by having your full attention on them when they are home so I can see it from both sides from personal experience xx

RTHJ14 · 27/09/2023 13:54

Worked for us .. couple of days a week at the same nursery as her brother. She loved it, and has always been happy to try new places and things.

Her brother was at home with me longer - we went to loads of groups and activities - but when he went to nursery he really struggled to settle, and remains a naturally more introverted child. Probably just their personalities.

As an only child, cared for at home until school I found it really hard to be away from my Mum, and I was keen to try and avoid that with my kids.

When they were there I got loads done at home and weekends were then family time.

Divebar2021 · 27/09/2023 13:54

People are really missing the point. It’s not about 1 or 2 days it’s about 5 days a week. So no I would not have done that. And I don’t care who the parent is that’s at home ( mum or dad) I wouldn’t do that. It’s not at all like having a grandparent come and babysit ( and I’ve never heard of GPS doing 5 day childcare for a SAHP in any case). It’s not like having a nanny in your own home. There’s only so much downtime / sleep time / leisure time / cleaning time ANY person needs. ( let’s not get into the volunteering suggestion). The only way I’d think it was appropriate is if the parent was suffering with a significant illness that required active medical treatment. But it’s not as if I’d express an opinion in the unlikely event of knowing someone who did this.

Shadowchaser · 27/09/2023 13:53

@storypushers no idea really. A few things happened to DS in nursery I was glad he could tell me about, nothing serious at all and very minor but at least he could say X hit me or whatever. Babies can’t do that. As professional as people are, I don’t know them bar a 2min encounter on a morning or at collection time.

I just felt uneasy about leaving my babies with someone I didn’t know.

VivaVivaa · 27/09/2023 13:52

I just wonder why, maybe there are problems we don’t know about

Why does there have to be problems? It could just be personal choice? Sure, it’s not what I would chose. I’d probably send them a couple of days a week so I have time for myself. But I wouldn’t assume someone had ‘problems’ if they sent their child to nursery full time despite not working.

storypushers · 27/09/2023 13:49

Shadowchaser · 27/09/2023 13:42

No I wouldn’t.

I strongly believe young children/babies should be with family until they are old enough to tell you there’s something wrong. I also love being at home with my children (as hard as it can be!) so wouldn’t want them there for no reason.

I did send my oldest at 3 ish just before school to ease him in to reception. I’ve not noticed any problems with mine not attending nursery until 3, my oldest is sociable and top of the class so I don’t feel he missed anything and I’ll do the same with the others.

I was lucky enough to be able to do this though as I have a DH who shares my views, supportive grandparents and I can work nights. Not everyone is able to or wants to. I suppose what they do with their children is none of my business but I’ll do what i think is right for mine.

Why should they be with family over trained professionals until they can talk? Statistically they are far safer with trained staff rather than family members.

RidingMyBike · 27/09/2023 13:49

Coyoacan · 27/09/2023 13:34

I remember a neighbour of mine, who we could frequently hear screaming at her little one, telling me that she wouldn't put her in a nursery because she had been told that she should enjoy her. The rest of the building really wished, for the little girl's sake, that the mother hadn't felt obliged to pretend that she was enjoying being a mother.

THIS. I was at home with my SAHM until I went to school. She thought it was something she ought to do. She was dreadful at it - no patience, screaming, shouting, smacking. No understanding of child development so a lot of chidlren should be seen and not heard.

It's had an impact throughout my life, and I so wish she'd used childcare - nursery five times a week with people who actually like children would have been amazing!

whattodo22222 · 27/09/2023 13:48

@AllTheChaos can I ask what the health issues were please? We are seriously struggling with sleep despite cosleeping and responding to DD all night.

Strokethefurrywall · 27/09/2023 13:47

Comeonautumn · 27/09/2023 13:28

I wasn’t trying to be judgemental, although I can see why some think I am. As I said, I found it so hard too and have no family around. I can see part time, but full
time every day, I just wonder why, maybe there are problems we don’t know about.

With respect OP, you don't need to know if there are problems. Parents don't have to have "problems" to utilize childcare from any age, for any reason. Nobody needs to justify themselves to you.

AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 27/09/2023 13:46

Not at 1 - mine did 3 days a week from 11 months because I work. In hindsight, now he is 5, I'd have been a much better mum if I'd given myself at least a morning to myself on one of my days off when he was small.

Shadowchaser · 27/09/2023 13:42

No I wouldn’t.

I strongly believe young children/babies should be with family until they are old enough to tell you there’s something wrong. I also love being at home with my children (as hard as it can be!) so wouldn’t want them there for no reason.

I did send my oldest at 3 ish just before school to ease him in to reception. I’ve not noticed any problems with mine not attending nursery until 3, my oldest is sociable and top of the class so I don’t feel he missed anything and I’ll do the same with the others.

I was lucky enough to be able to do this though as I have a DH who shares my views, supportive grandparents and I can work nights. Not everyone is able to or wants to. I suppose what they do with their children is none of my business but I’ll do what i think is right for mine.

user123212 · 27/09/2023 13:42

No, personally not. But really depends on the mother's mental health and her supporting cast (other family members).
This article really got me - a hunch at why adults now need to be constantly validated by strangers
https://reactionaryfeminist.substack.com/p/denying-my-existence

“Denying my existence”

Institutions cannot replace the mother's gaze

https://reactionaryfeminist.substack.com/p/denying-my-existence

storypushers · 27/09/2023 13:41

I did for 2 days a week, was great for me and my son. 5 days seems too much really and must be very expensive.

UndertheCedartree · 27/09/2023 13:37

I think it would depend on the situation. I put my 2.5yo into nursery a year ahead of needing to as I wanted her to get used to it. She only went 2 mornings, though.

However if my mental health was suffering and I needed a break to be the best mum I could then I probably would consider it. At 1 I'd probably prefer a childminder and hopefully only need 2 or 3 days. But it would depend on the situation.

Preferably I'd have them at home at that age but life doesn't always go to plan 🤷 which I know only 2 well. I had a mental breakdown when mine were 5 and 10 and didn't live with them full time for 3 years. Why don't you reach out and see if she is ok?

Lentilweaver · 27/09/2023 13:37

I didn''t find the small baby stage and early toddler stage much fun. Dull and mundane describes it. Both were terrible sleepers. DH worked long hours. So I farmed out some of the care to a nanny, so I could read a book, go to the pool, see a friend, or just catch up on sleep, take a shower. If there had been nursery instead, I might have send them there.

Gerrataere · 27/09/2023 13:36

I didn’t for my children, and I wouldn’t have with my eldest. I would have paid £1000 an hour if I could have afforded to for my second at 1, I was broken. He didn’t sleep (still doesn’t but much better), didn’t communicate, screamed everywhere I took him. Nursery would have not only been a break but may well have picked up on his autism much sooner. A decent nursery that is, the first one he went to at 2.5 were awful and sent me into a deeper spiral….

fearfuloffluff · 27/09/2023 13:36

I'm a much better parent to my children when I'm not with them 24/7

Coyoacan · 27/09/2023 13:34

I remember a neighbour of mine, who we could frequently hear screaming at her little one, telling me that she wouldn't put her in a nursery because she had been told that she should enjoy her. The rest of the building really wished, for the little girl's sake, that the mother hadn't felt obliged to pretend that she was enjoying being a mother.

Daisymae55 · 27/09/2023 13:34

My dd was in nursery from 8 months old because of my work. If I hadn’t needed to go back to work and we could afford it I’d definitely put a 1 year old in for maybe 1 day/2 half days a week. I wouldn’t put her in as young as I did if I didn’t work though.

ive found nursery excellent for her development. She’s also super social and hates being stuck at home so I absolutely would put her in nursery a little bit if I wasn’t working.

GingerKombucha · 27/09/2023 13:31

My 18 month old has a full time nanny and goes to nursery two mornings a week - it's helpful with socialisation, independance and development and that's a perfectly fine reason in itself.

Lentilweaver · 27/09/2023 13:31

I was in another country and not working much when I had small DC, plus no family help. I hired a daily nanny. Big deal. I could afford it, so I did. I am not interested in being a martyr.

Iamnotastick · 27/09/2023 13:29

I think everyone is missing the point here.

This isn't about doing it part-time, or when they are older. This is full-time childcare age 1 when its not a work requirement. I know how much of a reprieve childcare is to give mum a break, but five days seems quite extreme and probably an indicator that something else is going on. I would feel quite sad for them tbh.

Lentilweaver · 27/09/2023 13:29

Then you should have put your son in nursery, instead of struggling on and finding it hard.

Comeonautumn · 27/09/2023 13:28

I wasn’t trying to be judgemental, although I can see why some think I am. As I said, I found it so hard too and have no family around. I can see part time, but full
time every day, I just wonder why, maybe there are problems we don’t know about.

OP posts:
Lentilweaver · 27/09/2023 13:26

Why not? If they liked it. Your missing your DC is irrelevant. People are diffrent and have different DC.
I smell the whiff of Mummy Martyr.

Swipe left for the next trending thread