Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you put your 1 year old in nursery if you didn’t work

311 replies

Comeonautumn · 27/09/2023 11:57

And didn’t need to work-financially ok, other child in school. Would you put your 1 year old in nursery every day?
NOT being judgey, just trying to understand the reasons someone would.
I stayed off with my dc for a while, we were skint and it was so hard at home sometimes, but looking back, they were some of the best times and I wish I could do it all again with my dc especially at 1, when they didn’t yet walk and it was all cuddly and lovely
Friend mentioned to me that our other friend was doing this.
Completely different if you have to work

OP posts:
PeloMom · 27/09/2023 16:45

Yes I would.

piscis · 27/09/2023 16:38

Yes, but not every day at thay age, maybe three mornings a week or something like that. Not full days at 1 year old.

Diamondcurtains · 27/09/2023 16:32

No I wouldn’t and I didn’t. I’ve always been a sahm. The kids went to school for the first time in reception. I know plenty that do though and that’s their choice.

Dolores87 · 27/09/2023 16:30

Not every day but 2 or 3 times a week yes if I had the money. I am a far better mother when I have some breathing space. Although at 1 I'd probably have a decent childminder.

autumnmakesmehappy · 27/09/2023 16:24

My little one is only 5 months old but I previously worked in a nursery setting. Plenty of stay at home parents would place their children in our care for a couple of days a week or a few mornings. It was unusual for a stay at home parent to do it at baby age but common from 2.5 years. There are so many benefits for the child (builds up their confidence, helps them to make friends and prepares them for school), plus it gives the parent a bit of peace and time to catch up with things at home. I plan on being a SAHM whilst my child is small but I would have no hesitation in using a nursery once they are of preschool age and close to going to school.

Comeonautumn · 27/09/2023 16:19

@SapphireOpal Charming.

No, I didn’t find it mind numbingly dull, the odd yes, I find work pretty dull, but there you go.

OP posts:
whatdidshedotogetahillnamedafterher · 27/09/2023 16:15

yes I would for a few days a week

Sprogonthetyne · 27/09/2023 15:54

I sent my DD in a couple of morning a week from 1, while I was a SAHM. The reason was that we were just coming out of covid, there were no groups anything, and she was modeling all of her social/ play skills from her autistic brother, as he was the only child she knew. Nothing wrong with that really, they play amazingly together, but I wanted to expose her to NT children as well.

These reasons probably don't apply to your friend, but there will be a reason that makes sense for their family.

AnnieApple123 · 27/09/2023 15:43

Personally no. I don’t work and my child has only just started nursery now at 3 years 4 months and only then 2 mornings a week.

Oliotya · 27/09/2023 15:41

Shadowchaser · 27/09/2023 15:15

@Hufflepods I honestly believe that for my children 1-1 (or 2-2 in my case) care in a grandparents home is preferable to nursery. I don’t believe my child’s grandparents are a danger because I’ve known them 30 odd years. I actually pretty much am a SAHM bar the odd day a month but in my opinion a bonded family member in a home is a better option than childcare regardless of money. I could have afforded nursery but I don’t think there’s any benefit to the child until almost school age (unless from a home where they don’t get the care or stimulation) hence why it’s always been free for 3+.

It’s always the same on these threads, people get very defensive when nursery is criticised as if those of us who don’t use nursery are lazy and don’t work or just scrounging off family…not the case, sometimes some people just don’t believe it’s in the best interest of the child to be there 30+ hours a week at that age.

It always seems to be those with plenty of outside help who are first to criticise those who use paid childcare. "Odd day a month" would you say the same if it was 2 days in 7 years? No, you'd probably pay for childcare as well.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 27/09/2023 15:40

Depends wholly on the situation.

People judging, and saying “oh I wouldn’t want my child to be away from me, why pay for something you can do yourself“, but have family handy, a supportive partner, perhaps just a baby/ toddler who naps and sleeps well, can’t really judge a person who doesn’t have those things for wanting a bit of time to themselves.

I mean, if it’s 5 full days and you don’t work, then yes it’s probably a bit rubbish. But a couple of days or half days, could be just what a person needs, and allows them to be a better mum over all.

AllTheChaos · 27/09/2023 15:33

whattodo22222 · 27/09/2023 13:48

@AllTheChaos can I ask what the health issues were please? We are seriously struggling with sleep despite cosleeping and responding to DD all night.

I’d been told she couldn’t have a dairy allergy because she didn’t get a rash, but when I finally got her an appointment with an NHS dietician, they confirmed she had an intolerance. She’d been very vomity, being sick multiple times a night, and cried a lot as was in pain, plus didn’t gain weight as she should have done. Took till she was nearly a year and a half old to get that reference, despite my constantly asking the doctors if it could be an issue with dairy. It still makes me angry how dismissive the doctor was, and I’m still grateful to the doctor who said she would refer her ‘just in case’ as something clearly wasn’t right. I’m also angry that I didn’t listen to my instincts. But I was scared and alone and frightened to do the wrong thing. Good luck, I hope you get to the bottom of it! Do push for referrals to anywhere you think might help, no one knows your baby like you do!

Hufflepods · 27/09/2023 15:32

@Shadowchaser *
It’s always the same on these threads, people get very defensive when nursery is criticised as if those of us who don’t use nursery are lazy and don’t work or just scrounging off family*

I don't think anyone has said anything like that, I do however take issue with your suggestion that nurseries are inherently less safe environments for children who's speech is still developing compared to family members when statistically that is not actually the case. You can feel that way but it doesn't actually make it the reality.

CaptainJackSparrow85 · 27/09/2023 15:30

I would have been the most negligent parent in the world if I left my child in the care of their alcoholic grandparents. I only did it once, for 45 minutes, and vowed never again.

I totally get it if people have fantastic grandparents in their lives and feel that’s a better option than nursery for their family. But statements like ‘children are better off in the care of grandparents than nurseries’ are just ridiculous (and not supported by statistics).

AmazingSnakeHead · 27/09/2023 15:27

I would like to gently suggest that "friend mentioned that other friend is doing this" is perhaps not the most reliable source of information. So many things might have got lost in the chain. Perhaps your friend is mistaken, perhaps "full time" just means mornings, maybe there's reasons you don't know about (like she's applying for jobs or looking to retrain).

In general I'd send. Mine two mornings a week at that age if I were a SAHM.

Mumof2teens79 · 27/09/2023 15:23

Shadowchaser · 27/09/2023 15:15

@Hufflepods I honestly believe that for my children 1-1 (or 2-2 in my case) care in a grandparents home is preferable to nursery. I don’t believe my child’s grandparents are a danger because I’ve known them 30 odd years. I actually pretty much am a SAHM bar the odd day a month but in my opinion a bonded family member in a home is a better option than childcare regardless of money. I could have afforded nursery but I don’t think there’s any benefit to the child until almost school age (unless from a home where they don’t get the care or stimulation) hence why it’s always been free for 3+.

It’s always the same on these threads, people get very defensive when nursery is criticised as if those of us who don’t use nursery are lazy and don’t work or just scrounging off family…not the case, sometimes some people just don’t believe it’s in the best interest of the child to be there 30+ hours a week at that age.

But you are criticising nurseryand people that use them, and it makes no sense.
There are hundreds of threads on here about useless grandparents. Grandparents looked after 1 or 2 children 20-30yrs ago ...some will be great, others will be just OK.
Just like parents

A nursery is run by child care professionals, staffed by people that are trained and experienced and love kids, and have all the tools and materials to hand to create fun learning experiences.

It would be extreme arrogance to think I was better at child care than the nursery staff because I have a child...when many of them have kids of their own too, plus years of experience caring for hundreds of different children.

pacificoceanwhale · 27/09/2023 15:20

If I could afford it then yes but only for a few hours per week. It would be beneficial for social skill, speech etc.

Mumof2teens79 · 27/09/2023 15:17

Just because someone is paying for a full time place (and can clearly afford it) doesn't mean they are using it.
They are paying for flexibility- being able to use it when it suits them.

Just because they don't have a salaried full time job doesn't mean they don't have things to do. Some (wives especially) unofficial role might be being a visible and presentable wife at functions, may be coordinating a house building project, may be a carer for adult relatives.
Is it not better for a child to be in a nursery setting designed for their needs than dragged round supermarket's and banks, sat in hairdressers and nail salons, being bribed to be quiet and calm?

Shadowchaser · 27/09/2023 15:15

@Hufflepods I honestly believe that for my children 1-1 (or 2-2 in my case) care in a grandparents home is preferable to nursery. I don’t believe my child’s grandparents are a danger because I’ve known them 30 odd years. I actually pretty much am a SAHM bar the odd day a month but in my opinion a bonded family member in a home is a better option than childcare regardless of money. I could have afforded nursery but I don’t think there’s any benefit to the child until almost school age (unless from a home where they don’t get the care or stimulation) hence why it’s always been free for 3+.

It’s always the same on these threads, people get very defensive when nursery is criticised as if those of us who don’t use nursery are lazy and don’t work or just scrounging off family…not the case, sometimes some people just don’t believe it’s in the best interest of the child to be there 30+ hours a week at that age.

OlizraWiteomQua · 27/09/2023 15:02

I wouldn't sign up for 5 full days a week - but I would totally go for 15 hrs pw - either 3x5hrs or 5x3hrs. It's good for 1-2 yos to start being aware of other kids and being part of a nursery group and it's definitely good for mums to have a bit of respite.

Hufflepods · 27/09/2023 14:58

@Shadowchaser I strongly believe young children/babies should be with family until they are old enough to tell you there’s something wrong.

So childcare is okay as long as it is provided by grandparents for free?

Ironically a child has more chance of suffering abuse or neglect from a family member than in a nursery setting so this strategy doesn't actually do much to limit that.

SapphireOpal · 27/09/2023 14:58

Comeonautumn · 27/09/2023 14:42

But if you’d out them there to keep on top of housework, couldn’t you pay a cleaner and take the dc out for the day-would be cheaper!
By full time I mean 9-4/5 every day

Yes of course you could. You could do any number of things.

Your friend has chosen one of those options. It's not "wrong" just because you can't see the logic and would have chosen another one in the same circumstances.

zurala · 27/09/2023 14:58

No. Both of mine stayed home till age 3 when they went 2 days a week, and then went to school for 4 days a week till they were compulsory school age which for them was in year 1.

SapphireOpal · 27/09/2023 14:56

You absolutely are judging though aren't you, with your faux naiveté and wide eyed "I couldn't possibly..."

It's got fuck all to do with you why her son is going to nursery. What matters is they've decided it's best for their family. Nose out.

Since we're "not judging, just asking", didn't you find it mind numbingly tedious being at home full time with a 1 year old?

Give0fecks · 27/09/2023 14:53

Totally depends on the child. My first was a bloody nightmare, just screamed. I couldn’t do anything, she wouldn’t sit in the pram, nor the car seat, I couldn’t put her down. It was absolutely horrific and I felt like a prisoner in my own life. She went 2 days a week and even at that age adored being with other children. My youngest is now 1 and the easiest baby ever. I just bring him along, I can go to cafes, dog walks, shopping, and he is a joy to be around.

if you haven’t had that type of child there’s no way you would understand, so don’t be so judgey when you have no idea.