Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you put your 1 year old in nursery if you didn’t work

311 replies

Comeonautumn · 27/09/2023 11:57

And didn’t need to work-financially ok, other child in school. Would you put your 1 year old in nursery every day?
NOT being judgey, just trying to understand the reasons someone would.
I stayed off with my dc for a while, we were skint and it was so hard at home sometimes, but looking back, they were some of the best times and I wish I could do it all again with my dc especially at 1, when they didn’t yet walk and it was all cuddly and lovely
Friend mentioned to me that our other friend was doing this.
Completely different if you have to work

OP posts:
Fiddlesticks25 · 28/09/2023 13:02

Yes definitely, a few mornings a week at least. Mine slept terribly at night and would only nap on me. Also I'm an introvert and value alone time. I needed a break. (As it was I got to go back to work for my "break")

ZickZack · 28/09/2023 12:58

No, I couldn't put my 1 year old in 5 days a week if I were at home. A few mornings I could understand...us mums need breaks too and some 1 year olds are harder than others.

I was with ds1 at home full time until he turned 2yrs 3 months. Then he started nursery 2 mornings a week. He's 3 now and just started going 3 mornings a week.
My youngest is 8 months and he'll likely start next September at 20 months for 2 mornings a week. We have no family and it's the only break I get during the days when DH is working.

ClemFandango1 · 28/09/2023 12:58

Yes. The childminder gives her activities I can't provide, the company of other kids, and decent food.
Not all of us enjoy the baby years, or we find them hugely anxiety provoking.

Cookiecrumblepie · 28/09/2023 12:55

No. I would cherish the time with my child. Would be a privilege to have the option.

MrsZargon · 28/09/2023 12:45

Absolutely not!!!!!! Most people have to work, therefore nursery is necessary. If you do not need to work but would still choose to put a child in nursery every day why on Earth would you have a child in the first place!! If there are mitigating factors like your health or commitments to other children or disabled or elderly family that is fine, but if you are spending your day doing hobbies/relaxing/pottering about whilst someone else is looking after your child then I would question whether you should be a parent at all as that is not going to make for a good parent-child relationship. Kids need to know that they are special so how are they going to feel if they are sent off to nursery so you can get your nails done or whatever!! Most parents would love to spend more time with their kids, or ones like me that are lucky enough to have the option to SAH realise how precious the time is (even if it is relentless and exhausting at times and I am much poorer money wise for it).
Also to add I’m talking about 1yr olds as per your post, I think it is a completely normal step at age 2/3 to start a part time preschool in preparation for going to school and at that point it’s fine to send them if you are at home.

Graciebobcat · 28/09/2023 12:32

No I wouldn't. And I picked a lovely childminder when DDs were that age, I didn't like the look of local nurseries at all for babies.

mindutopia · 28/09/2023 12:15

If I could afford it, yes, if I was otherwise home every day with them and not working. You need time for yourself and even going back to work and putting dc in nursery made a massive difference to my mental health and sense of self. I love my kids, but we don't need to spend every waking moment together. I have friends who stayed home with their dc until school age, despite the significant financial impact that not working had. And I have friends who never transitioned back to work and have kept their dc home to home educate. Not my cup of tea, but it seems to work for them - though one is a bit self righteous about it (even though it was only facilitated by a trust fund and the inheritance of the family country pile which has meant they don't need to work like the rest of us).

Cakeandcardio · 28/09/2023 12:10

I had to go back to work when mine was 1. I was so sad to leave him. But now he's older, I realise he did probably benefit from being with other kids. So it wasn't such a big change when he was, say, 3 etc but it was also only part time.

Atticustheaardvark · 28/09/2023 12:07

I'm a 60's child and 'back in the day' very few Mums worked until the children started school, me included.

I think I did struggle at bit more in the first few weeks at school, compared to those who had been to nursery (or playgroup as it was called then!). However, my memories of spending my early years doing all sorts of lovely stuff with Mum are still vivid and so precious to me even now.

Did I miss out on a touch of early learning and socialising with other kids? Yes, probably. Did it go on to affect me as an adult? No way. I love that I am equally as happy with my friends as I am being at home with my own company. Interestingly, I have a friend my age who did spend her early years in playgroup as her Mum was a full time GP - she absolutely hates being on her own and is much happier when surrounded by a group of people. I do wonder if there might be a connection?

Mumma212 · 28/09/2023 11:56

No I absolutely wouldn’t but if other women want to that’s up to them.
The science proves that it is best for babies to be cared for by the primary caregiver for as much time and for as long as possible.
Everyone has different priorities thought.
I m curious why you’re asking?

GreyhoundGurl · 28/09/2023 11:48

Umm, so you are being judgey??! Extremely so. I went back to work when my son was 1 so wasn't in this position - but work was, and is, a 'break'. My son didn't start sleeping more than 2 hours at a time until he was 2. I was fighting with GPs to get medical issues diagnosed. I was exhausted and really at the end of my tether. This woman is likely doing what she can (taking a well deserved break a couple of days a week) so she can be a present and focused mummy the rest of the time. I note she didn't tell you this herself - I wonder why, when you're "friends"....?

SpideyWoman1 · 28/09/2023 11:41

The vast majority, if not all the people defending this are from people saying they sent their DC to nursery part time when they weren’t working.

OP made it very clear it’s the full time aspect she took issue with.

Which makes the majority of the replies irrelevant as they don’t really explore the main point, but project to something else.

Tryingmybestadhd · 28/09/2023 11:35

No , there is nil benefits to putting a baby in school unless there are other issues as home as disabled parents or the child needs extra care

KvotheTheBloodless · 28/09/2023 10:57

Full time? No. Part time? Depends on other factors, such as sleep deprivation, mental health, other things requiring my involvement.

I think everyone needs a break, so I'd not be judging another parent who is presumably just trying to parent and live as best she can like most of us do.

Abbie22222 · 28/09/2023 10:47

'NOT being judgey' 😂

My second child was a difficult baby, and I had PND for months afterwards. He didn't sleep, wouldn't be put down for more than 5 minutes, and quite frankly pushed me almost to breaking point. He was supposed to start nursery at 9 months old when I went back to work, but I started sending him a couple of days a week from 5 months. It saved me.

Before being in that situation, would I have judged someone who sent their child to nursery at 5 months when they weren't back at work yet? Most probably. Would I have started a post asking strangers on the Internet to join in with that judging? Nope.

Until you've been in a situation, you can't possibly know why that mum needs/wants that time to herself. It's great that you didn't need it, but you're not every person. You don't need to understand why someone else is doing something different to you, and you don't need to start a post asking everyone else to judge a strangers decisions.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 28/09/2023 10:45

Blackcoffee1 · 27/09/2023 12:20

Yes; from 18 months. I think nursery is hugely beneficial. Only a few days a week.

Not everyone will have the same opinion as you.

So....no, then? As the question is daily from 1 year old?

@Comeonautumn Mine were in nursery from 8 months but that was because we both worked. I think I might have considered half days for a couple of days a week if we could have afforded it. Not full time though,

Mariposista · 28/09/2023 10:42

I would never not work. I'd rather set my kids an example that if we want things in life we have to work for them.

Mummma9420 · 28/09/2023 10:30

Absolutely not, my son (3.5) now attends preschool attached to the local primary and I hate that he’s now gone for half the day every day :( I see the pluses of course! It’s great for his development and helps get him used to the atmosphere and structure of school but unless you have to for work reasons, I wouldn’t. I don’t judge those who do, we all have different capacities but I personally wouldn’t

Libra24 · 28/09/2023 10:00

This is how we hold each other back as women.
These posts make me sick.

None of your business. You are being judgey, there's no other way around it.

Thinking because a parent isn't employed they should spend their time with their child is madness. None of us would choose to do all the house work, shopping, life admin, staying fit, mindful etc etc with one eye on a child and feel strung out if we have the choice.
So if your friend is choosing to use childcare and live their life focused on other things when they aren't around who are you to judge.
Imagine making a post to get strangers to judge another mum.

Shame on you.
We seem to want others to agree with us to validate our struggle and it drives me mad.

Sunandsea26 · 28/09/2023 09:39

ColleenDonaghy · 28/09/2023 09:32

Loads of people do this. You have to pay to keep the spot, and if the DC like nursery you may as well keep them in their routine and entertained and settled. Then you get nice one on one time with the baby. Worked really well for us (especially because it was covid so I wouldn't have been able to do anything with them!).

Agree! I wanted quality time with my baby! Eldest was in 2 days a week as that’s what I could afford and she loved it.

Sunandsea26 · 28/09/2023 09:38

These things are very individual. We don’t need any mums judging other mums. You don’t know what people’s financial situations are, their mental health, what they have to juggle. What’s right for someone is different for someone else. Just let people do what they need to do

ColleenDonaghy · 28/09/2023 09:32

Beachywave · 28/09/2023 07:53

My friend carried on sending her 2/3 year old to nursery full time at great expense when she was on maternity leave. Madness to me but they can afford it.

Loads of people do this. You have to pay to keep the spot, and if the DC like nursery you may as well keep them in their routine and entertained and settled. Then you get nice one on one time with the baby. Worked really well for us (especially because it was covid so I wouldn't have been able to do anything with them!).

Mew2 · 28/09/2023 09:27

We did from 14 months- she has done 3 x 5hr sessions Mon, weds, Fri since then... hubby is the stay at home dad- has epilepsy and fits became weekly when he was at home full time with her whilst i work fulltime in the nhs.. she loves it.... and my little one was crawling at 3. 5 months, and walking by 8 months so it wasn't easy at that age either... to be fair if we have another one I will pop them in nursery from about 10 months for 15hrs a week... his fits since her being at nursery have become one a year- so very much more manageable for everyone!! She is now 3 and still does 15hrs a week

Hufflepods · 28/09/2023 09:15

@Beachywave My friend carried on sending her 2/3 year old to nursery full time at great expense when she was on maternity leave. Madness to me but they can afford it.

Why is it madness?
I'm doing this with my 2 year old. Full time fees for a private day nursery.

Why would I risk losing her place, messing up her routine, keep her stuck with me 24/7 while I'm also attending to a baby and therefore her play is much more limited, plus force her to adapt to not being in nursery only to resettle her again towards the end of maternity leave?

To me it is madness to do that and put costs above providing consistency for your young child. Pulling kids in and out of different settings is unnecessarily disruptive.

SallyWD · 28/09/2023 09:10

I did for only two mornings a week - it was just so I could get chores done really.