Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not take on my mums cat?

88 replies

CatLoverButNotOwner · 27/09/2023 10:44

Mum went abroad for 3 months earlier this year. She didn’t need to go, it wasn’t for work or anything she just wanted to go.

At home she left 2 cats.

One is very laid back, spends most of the day sleeping and you can literally step on him and he’ll just sit there obviously I’m not advocating doing that but if it happens accidentally he literally just lies there looking at you as if to say “You’ll have to move not me”

The other is very younger and very very shy but loved my mum before she went, mum would talk about them sharing a bed or her handing feeding this cat.

I looked after the cats while she was away. Visiting twice a day.

For the first 4 weeks I didn’t see the younger cat at all. I knew she was okish as both food bowls where always empty and they had two litter trays with different kinds of litter in and the tray with younger cats preferred litter in was used – as was the other tray.

From about week 4/5 I’d see the younger cat in the corner of my eye, she’d run from under a bed or cabinet to another bed or cabinet, but as soon as I turned around she’d be gone.

By week 6 she was starting to come out but wouldn’t let me near her she’d watch me from under a cabinet or bed but disappear as soon as I got to close – which was fine, I was just pleased she was starting to accept me.

On week 9 the cat started to get closer to me but would still run and hide if I turned round a bit too quickly.

It was only in the very final weeks (week 12ish) did I actually get close enough to the cat for her to brush against me, but she still won’t let me actually touch her.

This was fine, all I cared about was her being fed and settled in her own home.

My DD has never seen the younger cat in person still just in pictures as the cat still hides when she’s there, which is also fine. She’d be with me for some visits and we’d only see older male cat.

Now to the issue.

My mums been home 4 weeks and younger cat is still hiding from her. She says she hears both cats at night but if she gets up to use the toilet she only sees the male.

The cats get on fine probably because the male cats basically horizontal.

She’s upset that younger cat hasn’t been to see her since she got home and is not considering rehoming her. She says that I should take the female cat as she obviously likes me and will settle with me.

But I don’t want to. I like cats, I’ve had my own cats before, but if I was going to take any of mums cats it’d be the older male because my DD likes him, played with him on her visits with me and he’s basically the type of cat I’ve had before. But I don’t really want a cat. I looked after hers so she could go abroad not because I want my own.

Mum says IABU though and I should just take her. I think she should give it longer given it took nearly the entire 3 months for said cat to come anywhere near me.

WIBU me or mum? Should I just take the cat and go through the whole process again in my home while also being a single parent to my DD?

OP posts:
marblesthecat · 28/09/2023 08:34

YANBU. Sounds like your Mum has basically taken the huff because the cat isn't her friend anymore. I'm sure the cat will come round and maybe she should take shorter holidays in future.

MrsSkylerWhite · 28/09/2023 08:29

Personally, I’d take the cat. With time, it could be really beneficial for your daughter. But, you’ve no obligation whatsoever and absolutely no need to feel bad about it for a moment.

Poor little thing, what a rubbish start. Your mum shouldn’t keep animals. Could you look into rehoming? Don’t suppose your mother will bother.

Peony15 · 28/09/2023 08:25

How utterly cruel and selfish of your mother to abandon her own cats for 3 months. They like companionship of other humans , not just food, water. Maybe for a weekend that's fine but not 12 weeks. I could never do that to mine. The cat must be traumatized. Maybe someone who truly loves her can rescue her and she'll be sociable again after a few weeks.

CatLoverButNotOwner · 28/09/2023 08:21

I'm not for one second suggesting it wasn't irresponsible or adaquate care. What I'm saying is I tried my best with what I was given and I mean I did my best.

It was a big tie, I couldn't just go away for half term with my DD or do very long days out over the summer as I had commitments. It was a huge tie and reminded me why I don't want another pet yet, especially the shy one. I will not be facilitating it again.

When I had my cats the max amount of time I went away for was 5 days, and even then I would panic and worry about them and come home early sometimes.

I have spoken to my mum about it, telling her she left for so long that they don't know who she is, but she just shrugged and said it was something she needed to do. It's a pattern yes, and I'm only just waking up to it. She's a gossip and will make up lies about you to anyone who will listen if she doesn't get her own way. So I am scared because my work relies on word of mouth

OP posts:
Messyhair321 · 28/09/2023 08:04

CatLoverButNotOwner · 27/09/2023 11:00

@cruffinsmuffin They were well looked after, they had food and I always put fresh water down every visit. Older cat did have treats as well and I did leave some in places where I knew the younger cat was hiding (hope she had them and not older cat).

Yanbu for not wanting to take on this cat however I think it is very unreasonable to think that leaving food out is enough to suggest that this amounts to what a domestic cat needs. This isn't caring for a cat, it's feeding them.
A domestic cat needs more than just feeding. That's what you ask people to do when you are away for a few days like asking a neighbour to pop in to feed them. Not for 3 months though. That's totally unreasonable & it's unbelievable that your DM doesn't get that this cat will be totally traumatised by her actions.
She needs to not own cats or any pets because she sounds totally selfish & doesn't understand that they are living breathing creatures, the way that this cat is, is a reflection of her neglect & lack of forethought & basic care. Tell her to get a stuffed toy she might have more luck looking after that.

Revolutionfrommybed · 28/09/2023 08:03

Those cats were not well looked after! This is neglect. Cats, especially house cats, need love and affection and attention, they need to be played with and socialised. No wonder little cat is freaked out.

Beangrove · 28/09/2023 07:56

Poor cats! How can you leave animals you're supposed to love for 3 whole months, that's awful. An empty, quiet house with someone popping in twice a day is no way for them to live.

No criticism of you OP, but your mum is horrid. I'd be taking both of them off her and trying to make sure she didn't get any other pets!

pizzaHeart · 28/09/2023 07:54

NoSquirrels · 27/09/2023 10:50

Your mother is being ludicrously unreasonable.

Urgh. I feel really sorry for you, she sound massively selfish.

Agree with this^

LovelyDaaling · 28/09/2023 07:51

Don't let your mother foist her cat on you. It's her problem, not yours. She is being selfish and also mean to her cats.

gamerchick · 28/09/2023 07:51

The only animal I'd be happy leaving somewhat is my snake and even then I'd fret because he's a bugger. Animals can get stuck places, they can have accidents, eat something they shouldn't . You don't leave them to just crack on with it. Especially when making no effort to lay eyes on them.

gamerchick · 28/09/2023 07:48

CatLoverButNotOwner · 27/09/2023 11:00

@cruffinsmuffin They were well looked after, they had food and I always put fresh water down every visit. Older cat did have treats as well and I did leave some in places where I knew the younger cat was hiding (hope she had them and not older cat).

They weren't well looked after. They were left alone for large chunks of time over a long period. You both sound utterly clueless

gamerchick · 28/09/2023 07:46

Your mother is a bit of a dick tbh. Who does that for 3 bloody months? Hmm she'd be getting told that animals aren't something you can stick in a box and expect them to be grateful when you take them out again.

She shouldn't have animals at all. Poor buggers

openallday · 28/09/2023 07:46

Your mum should rehome the cst to someone who can look after it properly

bellabasset · 28/09/2023 07:44

I left my cat for 5 months but I was in hospital. She has a feline friend who came in with her, I looked after him for axwhikexwhen his owners were away and he visits daily. My cat is happily asleep next to me. It took a few days though.

randomrandom · 28/09/2023 07:42

Well the poor cat is probably traumatised. Yes they were fed for 3 months but that is a long time to have no interaction with anyone

Icequeen01 · 28/09/2023 07:28

When we went away on holiday (for 10 days) we set up a camera as one of our cats can be a bit illusive and we didn't want our neighbour who was looking after them worrying if she hadn't seen him. Our cats still had access to the outside via a catflap. However, nothing prepared me for hearing them crying for us when they were in the house, clearly upset. How anyone could leave a cat for 3 months with someone just popping in to feed them is beyond me. It's pure animal cruelty.

Approaching · 28/09/2023 07:15

Your mum has been totally unrealistic, she needed to expect the cat to have gone backwards in their relationship, as she’s proven herself unreliable to her.

Being realistic though, you’re unlikely to get it rehomed. Cat charities have ridiculous numbers - I was trying to help someone with rehoming and ringing round I found waiting lists of 200+ cats for a place in a rescue or help with rehoming.

Definitely not your responsibility to take the cat. Personally I’d be tempted to take both - your DD will enjoy having the laid back one, the nervous one will come around very slowly, everyone will be happier than if they’re with your mum.

frumpalertt · 28/09/2023 07:03

I would show your Mum this thread, OP. I agree with PPs that she is treating pets as an accessory to her life rather than as the large commitment that they are. I do think the cats would probably be best rehomed, with someone who has the time and energy to treat them well.

RedHelenB · 28/09/2023 07:01

ambitchious · 28/09/2023 06:46

If you think that, you’re as much a disgrace as your mother. Where I live it’s against the law to leave cat’s to be on their own for more than 8 hrs.

What country is that? And how does it get policed?

RedHelenB · 28/09/2023 06:57

SillyDoriswithaDangler · 27/09/2023 10:48

Your mother should never own animals, what a terrible person, that poor cat. I’d take him just to get him away from her, it would be so traumatic for him to be rehomed to a completely different house other than yours.

This. Your mum is very selfish not to allow her cat time to get to know her again.

ambitchious · 28/09/2023 06:46

CatLoverButNotOwner · 27/09/2023 11:00

@cruffinsmuffin They were well looked after, they had food and I always put fresh water down every visit. Older cat did have treats as well and I did leave some in places where I knew the younger cat was hiding (hope she had them and not older cat).

If you think that, you’re as much a disgrace as your mother. Where I live it’s against the law to leave cat’s to be on their own for more than 8 hrs.

Flufferblub · 28/09/2023 05:55

It's her cat. She took it on. They all have different personalities, and this one is shy. So what? It's not bothering any one. She should just keep her cat.

I've had cats all my life. Some are much friendlier than others. Some are temperamental and spicy. I love their different personalities, but I obviously bond more with the more cuddly, loving cats. I could never get rid of a cat just because of their personality. Especially if they're not even causing any issues.

MiniBossFromAus · 28/09/2023 05:41

Does your mum understand that cats need more than just food, water and a clean litter tray.

For starters indoor cats need company, enrichment, physical contact, exercise through play.

They aren't just stuffed toys that require food.

Your mother does not have the necessary empathy or basic understanding of an animal's needs to be a pet owner. If she was known to me, I would have reported her for cruelty. Those poor animals, locked up, alone for 12 weeks.

Disgusting behaviour. She should surrender them to a rescue and NEVER own any sort of pet again.

SueDonnym · 28/09/2023 05:29

So if you took it on you couldn’t go away and leave it as it would be traumatised -no holidays for you for 15 years . I’m sure your DD would love that.

ttcat37 · 28/09/2023 04:23

Your mum is a disgrace for leaving her pets at home for 3 months to go on a jolly. Visiting twice a day is not enough. This cat has been deprived of the human company it needed. You are as much to blame for facilitating this awful arrangement. Rehome the cats and don’t get any more.