Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not take on my mums cat?

88 replies

CatLoverButNotOwner · 27/09/2023 10:44

Mum went abroad for 3 months earlier this year. She didn’t need to go, it wasn’t for work or anything she just wanted to go.

At home she left 2 cats.

One is very laid back, spends most of the day sleeping and you can literally step on him and he’ll just sit there obviously I’m not advocating doing that but if it happens accidentally he literally just lies there looking at you as if to say “You’ll have to move not me”

The other is very younger and very very shy but loved my mum before she went, mum would talk about them sharing a bed or her handing feeding this cat.

I looked after the cats while she was away. Visiting twice a day.

For the first 4 weeks I didn’t see the younger cat at all. I knew she was okish as both food bowls where always empty and they had two litter trays with different kinds of litter in and the tray with younger cats preferred litter in was used – as was the other tray.

From about week 4/5 I’d see the younger cat in the corner of my eye, she’d run from under a bed or cabinet to another bed or cabinet, but as soon as I turned around she’d be gone.

By week 6 she was starting to come out but wouldn’t let me near her she’d watch me from under a cabinet or bed but disappear as soon as I got to close – which was fine, I was just pleased she was starting to accept me.

On week 9 the cat started to get closer to me but would still run and hide if I turned round a bit too quickly.

It was only in the very final weeks (week 12ish) did I actually get close enough to the cat for her to brush against me, but she still won’t let me actually touch her.

This was fine, all I cared about was her being fed and settled in her own home.

My DD has never seen the younger cat in person still just in pictures as the cat still hides when she’s there, which is also fine. She’d be with me for some visits and we’d only see older male cat.

Now to the issue.

My mums been home 4 weeks and younger cat is still hiding from her. She says she hears both cats at night but if she gets up to use the toilet she only sees the male.

The cats get on fine probably because the male cats basically horizontal.

She’s upset that younger cat hasn’t been to see her since she got home and is not considering rehoming her. She says that I should take the female cat as she obviously likes me and will settle with me.

But I don’t want to. I like cats, I’ve had my own cats before, but if I was going to take any of mums cats it’d be the older male because my DD likes him, played with him on her visits with me and he’s basically the type of cat I’ve had before. But I don’t really want a cat. I looked after hers so she could go abroad not because I want my own.

Mum says IABU though and I should just take her. I think she should give it longer given it took nearly the entire 3 months for said cat to come anywhere near me.

WIBU me or mum? Should I just take the cat and go through the whole process again in my home while also being a single parent to my DD?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SallyWD · 29/09/2023 08:55

user1492757084 · 29/09/2023 07:57

Your mother needs to find a way to refriend her kitten.
Seek ideas from a vet.
My idea would be to gradually get the kitten into a smaller space and then for your mother to go into that room and give the kitten food and attention regularly every hour or so.

Yes but I really don't think the mum can be bothered with this level of effort. Far easier to just get rid of the cat.
Reminds me of a friend who got two kittens. Found them annoying for just being cats and stopped bothering with them. In the end the cats ran away. I do hope they found loving homes.

user1492757084 · 29/09/2023 07:57

Your mother needs to find a way to refriend her kitten.
Seek ideas from a vet.
My idea would be to gradually get the kitten into a smaller space and then for your mother to go into that room and give the kitten food and attention regularly every hour or so.

LlynTegid · 29/09/2023 07:27

To have a cat or dog or other pet is a responsibility and if you are not 100% for it you should not do it. Regardless of where the pet's previous home is/was.

Nemesias · 29/09/2023 07:25

but she just shrugged and said it was something she needed to do.

Great. Making her cat feel settled in her home is something else she needs to do now. It really is as simple as that

Goldbar · 29/09/2023 07:19

This is bonkers. Why would you take on a cat you don't want rather than the cat going to a home that does want it and where it will be loved and given lots of attention? Just say no.

Donetrying1 · 28/09/2023 20:52

I think you’ve had enough replies now berating your mother and about which there is nothing you can do.
What is done is done, you mustn’t take the cat as you can’t care for it and nor do you want to-perfectly fair enough.
l think as you seem kind the best thing to do is phone an animal charity-eg Cats Protection, Blue Cross etc and get the poor cat rehomed to someone who can put the time and care into rehabilitating him-good luck!

ALJT · 28/09/2023 20:18

I just wonder who this 2% is who think you’re being unreasonable and why haha

ActDottie · 28/09/2023 13:48

Poor cat Yanbu I can’t believe your mum left them for three months :(

JustAnotherOpinion123 · 28/09/2023 13:33

cruffinsmuffin · 27/09/2023 10:55

I think your mum is being entirely unreasonable!

She left for 12 weeks without proper care for the cats? Visiting twice a day isn't enough for the cats imo - especially for 12 weeks! One maybe!

The cat is probably super spooked that someone was away for so long and is now in the house again, she needs to give them time.

This, completely. We have (far too many) cats and the longest we would ever have the "drop in on them" arrangement would be a week. When we went on honeymoon for 10 days, we put them in a cattery. For 12 weeks, I would have been looking at someone they could live with for that time.

Obviously you're not being unreasonable and you don't have to do anything you don't want to, but your mum really needs to put some work in to rebuild that relationship. We're away for a couple of days at the moment and I know ours are all going to be sulky/aloof when we get back and it's going to take a couple of days for them to come around.

ambitchious · 28/09/2023 11:37

RedHelenB · 28/09/2023 07:01

What country is that? And how does it get policed?

Scandinavian country. Difficult to police but often neighbours reporting if they see someone is away abd know they have a pet. It’s an important start either way, it’s simply not allowed to treat cats like this.

MuggleMe · 28/09/2023 10:39

I mean the younger cat is generally ok isn't it? Hiding isn't ideal but it's not ill or anything? Does she only want a cat she can see and play with? It'll come round in time and once it's brave enough to approach she can work with it to play with it and hand feed it etc to get it braver.

Cockmigrant · 28/09/2023 10:34

YANBU.
She went off for 3 months. The cat thought she had been abandoned. Now your Mum is back the cat will need a long time to learn to trust her again.
I know you did your best, but leaving a cat for three months with someone coming in twice a day is not enough. She should have found a housesitter or someone who was willing to let the cats move in with them for three months.

Two or three weeks with someone coming in a couple of times a day is ok, but longer than that, absolutely not.

Tell her no, she needs to give the cat more time to come around.

Cakeorchocolate · 28/09/2023 10:34

CatLoverButNotOwner · 28/09/2023 08:21

I'm not for one second suggesting it wasn't irresponsible or adaquate care. What I'm saying is I tried my best with what I was given and I mean I did my best.

It was a big tie, I couldn't just go away for half term with my DD or do very long days out over the summer as I had commitments. It was a huge tie and reminded me why I don't want another pet yet, especially the shy one. I will not be facilitating it again.

When I had my cats the max amount of time I went away for was 5 days, and even then I would panic and worry about them and come home early sometimes.

I have spoken to my mum about it, telling her she left for so long that they don't know who she is, but she just shrugged and said it was something she needed to do. It's a pattern yes, and I'm only just waking up to it. She's a gossip and will make up lies about you to anyone who will listen if she doesn't get her own way. So I am scared because my work relies on word of mouth

I don't think anyone is blaming you for what you did. No one is suggesting you should have done more. Everyone here is agreeing that your mother thinking this is ok is what's unreasonable. You were asked by your mum to help by keeping her pets alive, you did. So please don't take it as you did anything wrong. I would have done the same.
No one would have expected you to drop your life and move into her house to be there more, it's not realistic for most people to be able to do that. Going over there twice a day for 12 weeks is a big commitment as it is.

It's sad that your mum expects loyalty and affection from the cats when she thinks it's OK to disappear for months at a time. Encourage her to rehome them but don't let her guilt you into taking one or both.

123Squirrel · 28/09/2023 10:33

If she's likely to be nasty offer up compromise to help her find a rescue to re-home the cat as it's nervous nature would suit a quieter household (like hers) than yours with child/visitors. If she's not looking to offload responsibility of both cats I bet if you take/homed shy cat for her she will replace it with a kitten.

It's unlikely to take 12wks for shy cat to come round as she'd be home all the time and it will recognise her scent/voice. Mum just has hump as expected them to be ecstatic to see her and lacks compassion to realise she essentially abandoned them for months causing trauma/stress. I'm surprised the cat is so skittish if she's had from a kitten and from sisters pet cat rather than a stray cat birth rescue.

Honestly though she seems selfish and manipulative so I hope you consider reducing/cutting contact, a mum shouldn't even consider spreading lies as punishment, you'd not do anything to hurt your daughter I'm sure.

AlisonDonut · 28/09/2023 09:58

QueenCamilla · 28/09/2023 09:38

I assume you have made sure they're all neutered/spaded, get flea&worm treatments and vet visits, that you have provided a shelter for them and dig up a corner of your garden for them to toilet in?

I live next door to one of your type of "do gooders", and it's hugely unpleasant to be witnessing those sad animals and to be picking their diseased poop. Deal with the situation appropriately and then choose a better cause. Please.

Mate. I live in France and have a huge garden. All the barn cats that are abandoned end up being cared for by Brits here.

SallyWD · 28/09/2023 09:48

I feel so sorry for the poor cat. Not only was she abandoned for months but now she's very frightened and your mum reacts by wanting to rehome her.
If my cat was so distressed it would make me want to nurture her even more. Your mum doesn't seem to understand cats at all.
I think it's ridiculous to rehome a nervous cat but maybe it's best for the cat to find a sensitive and loving owner.

CherryMaDeara · 28/09/2023 09:43

CatLoverButNotOwner · 28/09/2023 08:21

I'm not for one second suggesting it wasn't irresponsible or adaquate care. What I'm saying is I tried my best with what I was given and I mean I did my best.

It was a big tie, I couldn't just go away for half term with my DD or do very long days out over the summer as I had commitments. It was a huge tie and reminded me why I don't want another pet yet, especially the shy one. I will not be facilitating it again.

When I had my cats the max amount of time I went away for was 5 days, and even then I would panic and worry about them and come home early sometimes.

I have spoken to my mum about it, telling her she left for so long that they don't know who she is, but she just shrugged and said it was something she needed to do. It's a pattern yes, and I'm only just waking up to it. She's a gossip and will make up lies about you to anyone who will listen if she doesn't get her own way. So I am scared because my work relies on word of mouth

No one is suggesting you did anything wroing OP. You did an admirable job going over there twice a day for three months.

I bet everyone knows that she is a nasty piece of work, don't worry about her gossip.

QueenCamilla · 28/09/2023 09:38

AlisonDonut · 28/09/2023 08:43

I treat the feral cats that live in our garden better than this. I'm out to see them and feed them and play with them morning noon and night. Cats need interaction, and lots of it. They need to play and it is no wonder the cat is scared of your mum. It is making sure it doesn't get attached again.

I assume you have made sure they're all neutered/spaded, get flea&worm treatments and vet visits, that you have provided a shelter for them and dig up a corner of your garden for them to toilet in?

I live next door to one of your type of "do gooders", and it's hugely unpleasant to be witnessing those sad animals and to be picking their diseased poop. Deal with the situation appropriately and then choose a better cause. Please.

Tryingmybestadhd · 28/09/2023 09:16

Your mum is not a brilliant owner and the cat senses her impatience. No young cat should be left alone this amount of time , just like dogs and other animals they need to be socialised while young . I’ve had a rescue cat that only ever been picked up by me , my mum and my dad . She came to me pregnant at 6 months when I fostered covered in cigarette burn marks so you can imagine why the distrust in humans. She was a wonderful cat to the few she trusted , I just had to accept she was not very social . It never crossed my mind to rehome her , that’s absurd and it will leave e the poor car trusting humans even less

Mothership4two · 28/09/2023 08:56

No-one should be forced to take an animal they don't want.

I cannot believe your mum left her cats alone for 3 months. Popping in is not adequate care. It sounds like she has reinforced the younger cats nervous behaviour by doing this. It would probably be in the cats best interest to be rehomed

Butchyrestingface · 28/09/2023 08:52

Your mother is an incredibly selfish, irresponsible person. If her parenting was anything like her approach to pet ownership, she should be paying for OP's therapy sessions, not putting pressure on you to adopt her inconvenient, abandoned pets.

That said, I'd be tempted to nod my head and agree to caring for both cats next time she goes walkabout for 3 months. Then rehome them. On her return, tell her you accidentally left a window open one day and ... whoopsie, who knows where they might be now?

Beargrumps22 · 28/09/2023 08:47

your mum is being horrible; to that poor cat your mum going away for such a long time meant the cat felt like it was being abandoned. Cats are funny like that even a weekend to them is a lifetime. its no good her thinking it should be like the other cat they are all different. we have housesat two cats for 7 years; the one cat is all over us the other in all that time have never made friends or hardly seen the other one. if your mum has not the patience and commitment she should not have this cat. I dont blame you for saying no it would not be an ideal cat for you either and to be honest you dont sound like you are mad keen on the idea of a cat either. i am not sure uprooting the cat will do it much favours but rehoming it has to be better than being in the situation it is in at the moment

AlisonDonut · 28/09/2023 08:43

I treat the feral cats that live in our garden better than this. I'm out to see them and feed them and play with them morning noon and night. Cats need interaction, and lots of it. They need to play and it is no wonder the cat is scared of your mum. It is making sure it doesn't get attached again.

DiaNaranja · 28/09/2023 08:36

You didn't want the cat, you didn't buy the cat, it's not your responsibility, and going in and feeding them, cleaning up after them for months on end was a big ask, now she's expecting you to take it on completely in your own home?! Absolutely not unreasonable to say no. It sounds as if the younger cat has gone slightly feral from a lack of presence in the house. She needs to give it more time to regain her trust, but equally if she's planning on more frequent long extended periods of leaving the cats alone, it's probably in the cats best interest to re-home them. They are domesticated, social animals, that crave that closeness from their care givers, and can easily turn wary if not getting regular companionship and human interaction. Sounds to me like she's almost blaming you for the cat turning feral, when in reality, she's the one that left them for months knowing you wouldn't be able to devote hours of time with them each day. If she wants to go away for an extended period again, maybe you should suggest she finds a cattery or house-sitter, so they are getting more constant interaction.

Bellyblueboy · 28/09/2023 08:36

These cats were clearly not well looked after. They had no company and no socialisation while your mum was away.

she doesn’t seem to take pet ownership seriously. You don’t have to take the cat if you do t want it but please try and influence your mum into taking better care of her pets.

this made me sad