Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it worth having 2 children so that they play together?

209 replies

NatMoz · 27/09/2023 06:00

I have an almost 2 year old (2 in December).

I'm feeling more one and done. Right now she sleeps through, has done on and off since 10 weeks and wakes between 7 and 8am.

She was an early walker and is quite lively and a bit of a climber. I keep her active during the week with church groups on my non working days, nursery and childminders the other days.

At the moment we can afford holidays abroad and we can maybe afford one child through private school.

She also is capable of independent play.

We look after her 50:50. There is no primary parent UNLESS my husband works away for a few days occasionally so it's me. I have had long weekends away myself with friends too so again 50:50.

My husband is at the stage where he's discussing a second, main reason being for a playmate.

I don't know if i want a second and I'm not sure playmate is a good sole reason to have one. He claims she will be more work when she's older as we will have to provide undivided attention to her as she will be bored otherwise. I said she would have playdates. I'm sure other mums will bite my hand off to take their child for the day/few hours.

Is playmate really a good enough reason?

OP posts:
PurBal · 27/09/2023 08:11

There’s no right or wrong. We were also on the fence and decided to see what happened. If nothing in 6 months then we’d stick to one. I got pregnant and welcomed our second 3 months ago, 23 months between them. Can’t imagine it differently now of course. Like you our reasons for sticking with one was to do with what we could provide for an only. Having another was less about playmates as children and more about the relationship DH and I both have with our siblings as adults. My siblings are my closest friends, most likely to tell it how it is and have been there through ups and downs. Friends are transient. But I’m aware not everyone has that relationship.

liveforsummer · 27/09/2023 08:07

My dc hate each other. They have and do play occasionally but mostly they fight and argue and it's extremely stressful. Have a second only if you really want one despite this potentially or even likely being the outcome

novacancy3 · 27/09/2023 08:04

In our naivety we had two children, quite close together, for exactly that reason. They didn't play together, they squabbled endlessly.

They are now adults and although they love each other, they are different people, living different lives, in different parts of the country and aren't in contact with each other more than a few times a year.

NoSquirrels · 27/09/2023 08:04

You should have put this in your first post:

the statements from him of his brother being his best friend to the point he struggles to make non biological friends which has got him into a pickle as his brother is in US

Do you have siblings yourself, OP? It’s obvious where he’s coming from - he valued his brother so highly he wants to give that relationship to his own children. If you don’t have siblings of your own then I’m sure it seems like a ‘get playmate’ choice but it’s more than that, I think.

cheddercherry · 27/09/2023 08:03

No, it’s not if that’s the sole reason. I have one (DS 4 and done) and he is kept very busy with clubs, play dates etc. He has lots of cousins and a large wider family so I don’t feel he’s missing out tbh. We also are in a good position where we can take him on a few abroad holidays a year, pay for any classes or activities, have friends over regularly. I feel his quality of life would be reduced by a sibling in terms of what we do now with him. For example, I took him interrailing over summer for a solo trip as my DH was away for work for two weeks. I’d simply not have done that with a 1.5 year old in a buggy too.

Most of his friends have younger siblings from ages 7 months to 2.5 and no, they don’t play together unless you class fighting as play? I know this could change as they get out of the toddler age but it looks like bloody hard work and my mum friends always say that they envy me doing travelling/ having full days or evenings out with my DS because they say they just couldn’t do it alone with two. I have two friends in particular who are often tearful that they feel they never get time with their eldest, and one has gone so far to feel she ruined their family. Of course she hasn’t, but she’s had a particularly hard birth recovery, PND and a baby who doesn’t like to sleep unless held and cried relentlessly. I really feel for her and we all really round but it’s just hard luck as she had a good birth experience and a very “easy” first child as just figured that would be repeated and it’s just not turned out that way for her second time around.

It’s luck of the draw really. I know my DH was the child “born to be his brothers best friend” and they just simply never got on, and still don’t. Perhaps I’m clouded by my DH’s experience of this, but in all honestly I do tire of the narrative that families are “complete” only with two or more kids, or that we are somehow depriving of children of social interactions if they’re an only child. Fact is people have many reasons and experiences for having one or more, all are valid. However basing the decision on something only “possible” like them being close or best friends forever isn’t the way to go.

BertieBotts · 27/09/2023 08:03

IMO yes, but I think this is personal, there's really not a one size fits all answer.

One and done has advantages but also downsides. I had an only for 10 years then had DS2 and DS3 three years apart.

It's very intense with just one. You only have them to focus on and you don't get a lot of mental space. When there are more then you kind of have to relax a little bit. It's also tough because you're in that stage that it feels like your excellent parenting is what's caused your child to be the most awesome child in the history of the world whereas really we're just biologically programmed to think they're amazing, and much of their temperament is just down to personality. This fades a bit once they get over about 4 IME or when you have another child as you realise fairly quickly that they are not all blank slates you can mould and they are pretty different right from the get go!

It's less busy which some people prefer but I didn't, I love how full our house feels now. I'm more of a clutter and chaos person. If you're more fond of calm, quiet, minimalism, then one child is much easier to maintain this kind of environment with.

It was the requests to play from around 3-7 that I found the most hard and draining. DS3 is only 2 so only just starting to be able to play properly with DS2 but even that has been a real help. Though DS2 is much more independent than DS1 was. DS1 has ADHD and is very very very extroverted and basically wants the stimulation of social input 24/7 - he's a teenager now and seeks this from his friends rather than me.

CarrotJanice · 27/09/2023 08:00

I would say yes. Sorry going against the majority. My two are best friends, very close and opposite genders. It's fucking expensive and tough when they're both little but worth it (I think).

payaklw · 27/09/2023 07:58

The money you will save by not having a second child will be phenomenal, and then you can use it to pay for activities to stop DC getting bored!

ThreePointOneFourOneFiveNine · 27/09/2023 07:58

My parents had me to be a playmate for my sister. It worked quite well when we were small, we fell out a lot in our teenage years, now as adults we vare best friends. But I know a lot of people who don't get on with their siblings at all and never did, or who played together as kids and have very little to do with each other as adults.

If you do decide to have a second child, one thing I would suggest from having seen friends raise siblings differently to me, if you want them to play together don't police it too much. If you keep telling the older child to leave the baby alone, they may end up not building much of a relationship to start with.

cheapskatemum · 27/09/2023 07:58

I remember when I was pregnant with DC2 so soon after DC1 (there's 17 months between them), thinking how nice, they can play together. DS2 has ASD and is non verbal. Though they have a lovely bond, they rarely played together. DS1 was just 3 when DS3 was born and they mostly fought all their childhood - despite my best efforts! DS4 is 3 years younger than DS3 & they then fought throughout their childhood. It certainly disabused me of the "siblings playing together" notion. Now they're all adults, 1, 3 & 4 are thick as thieves & get along really well, whilst taking time to visit their disabled sibling who's in residential care & take him out.

IHopeThisFindsYouWell · 27/09/2023 07:57

Mine do fight and bicker a lot. They also play together loads and help each and teach each other loads.

I am not against only children AT ALL. In some ways it looks pretty great. I think for me it's the intensity (can't think of a better word) that comes from the dynamic of one child and 2 adults. It wouldn't suit us. The kids in our family are a wee gang, they have each other AND they have us. And it's amazing. I hope they are close as adults - DH and I are still close to our siblings.

Regholdsworthswaterbed · 27/09/2023 07:57

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

What the fuck!

Regholdsworthswaterbed · 27/09/2023 07:56

BusyBees1234 · 27/09/2023 06:55

Bringing a second child in to the world purely to provide entertainment to your first child sounds like an awful idea. It's why most people have a second child though which I've always found bizarre

It certainly isn't why most people have a second child, where did you get that from?

cheezncrackers · 27/09/2023 07:54

No, it's not a good reason. Many siblings don't play together, many fight a lot and cause a lot of grief to each other and their parents, many actually have nothing in common - sharing the same parents is no guarantee that DC will be alike in their personalities. Of course, there are siblings that get on great, but you will have no idea in advance whether your DC will fall into that category or not. Have a second DC if you really want a second DC, but if you feel you're done with one, then feel secure in your decision.

LittlePlumTree · 27/09/2023 07:50

Children are different. All mine do is fight

ProfessionalCornflake · 27/09/2023 07:49

My 2 dc are very close in age but very rarely get along. Hopefully they'll be fine once they're older but right now will hardly ever play together. It's more just me breaking up constant petty arguments. I actually think my eldest would have been far better as an only. I'm an only child and it did me no harm at all. Don't let that be your reason for having another child!

klhfd · 27/09/2023 07:47

No. 3 year gap, same sex, fight like cat and dog, makes our lives really stressful. I obviously have no regrets and love them both endlessly, individually, but they are not, nor have they ever been, play mates; they are adversaries despite trying so very hard to avoid that. The value they bring each other is quite limited. Never have a child for the sole reason of providing a play mate.

Needanewnamebeingwatched · 27/09/2023 07:47

And all the parents of two plus children laughed.....and once the laughter died down said "no" 🤣

Mine, 2 girls and 1 boy, fought, laughed, played together, caused havoc, cried and fought some more. Life was never just peaceful.

For clarity on ages.
Youngest Boy, 21 months between middle girl, then 7 years between eldest girl.

But they are all grown and left home, so I have some sanity back.

Ragwort · 27/09/2023 07:47

Dino what a ridiculous comment .. you can't possibly relate all only DC to Lucy Letby.

My DM is an only DC ... even as a (very!) mature woman she is the most sociable, outgoing person I know ... never has difficulty making new friends, still in touch with friends (those that haven't died ☹️) from school and college days.

We had an only DC (by choice) ... he is also sociable, confident and outgoing. We never felt 'pressurised' into having to entertain him ... we all did things as a family or split by interest ... just as most families do and he could also amuse himself. He was/is very sporty so lots of evenings/weekends involved in sporting activities with his friends... if anything it was a lot easier than having to split parenting duties between more than one DC. I have seen friends run ragged trying to support different interests in their DC.

And don't assume that having siblings means care for elderly DPs is shared ....

DynamicK · 27/09/2023 07:46

My dc get on great. They're very close, have fun together, watch films together, they'd play together constantly.
I had lots of time where they'd be playing in the garden, playing with toys or watching tv together and I'd just do my own thing.
They were happy to go for a walk or the park because they had each other.

I still dont think that's a good reason to have another dc because there are no guarantees.

Christmasbroughtmeback · 27/09/2023 07:44

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Charles Manson had a sister. Myra Hindley had a sister. Harold Shipman had a brother and sister. 🙄

bookworm14 · 27/09/2023 07:44

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Oh fuck off, you twat. I don’t care if I get deleted. And people wonder why the parents of onlies get defensive. Give your child a sibling or they’ll turn into a serial killer!!

OP, have a second child if you want one and feel broody for one. That’s the only reason to do so.

BookishBabe · 27/09/2023 07:43

I have a 4 and 6 year old.
Same thinking, everyone said they'd play together, have similar likes and be amazing to grow up together.

All they do it fight, argue, shit stir, refuse to share.
Sometimes me and DH have to have 1 each to keep them separate.

Maybe when they're 11 and 14 it'll be different, but at this point I doubt it.

whatkatydid2013 · 27/09/2023 07:42

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

That’s just utterly ridiculous.

ivfbabymomma1 · 27/09/2023 07:39

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

How would you know someone was an only child without asking them?

Swipe left for the next trending thread