Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it worth having 2 children so that they play together?

209 replies

NatMoz · 27/09/2023 06:00

I have an almost 2 year old (2 in December).

I'm feeling more one and done. Right now she sleeps through, has done on and off since 10 weeks and wakes between 7 and 8am.

She was an early walker and is quite lively and a bit of a climber. I keep her active during the week with church groups on my non working days, nursery and childminders the other days.

At the moment we can afford holidays abroad and we can maybe afford one child through private school.

She also is capable of independent play.

We look after her 50:50. There is no primary parent UNLESS my husband works away for a few days occasionally so it's me. I have had long weekends away myself with friends too so again 50:50.

My husband is at the stage where he's discussing a second, main reason being for a playmate.

I don't know if i want a second and I'm not sure playmate is a good sole reason to have one. He claims she will be more work when she's older as we will have to provide undivided attention to her as she will be bored otherwise. I said she would have playdates. I'm sure other mums will bite my hand off to take their child for the day/few hours.

Is playmate really a good enough reason?

OP posts:
Ohyesthankyouglitter · 27/09/2023 09:39

You can't guarantee that having a sibling = playmate BUT don't be unaware of the dynamics with an only child. My sister has one, and whilst her son has been very happy to play by himself, enjoys adult company, during the holidays and weekends, because there isn't really a 'melee' of family life for the kid to become part of, she often feels the pressure to be intentional about filling his time/arranging for him to do stuff. I look at my life, with the bustle, and think having multiple has, in some ways, actually taken the pressure off.

Echobelly · 27/09/2023 09:35

Nope, as others have said they may have nothing to do with one another and you can't control that!

thetrainatplatform4 · 27/09/2023 09:35

My 3 play together 90% of the time beautifully and they adore each other and yes it certainly does help parenting in that respect as I'm not required to play all the time like I was with my eldest.

But I do admit here my opinion is very much defined by the fact I don't really agree/understand the whole "one and done" movement. If you can afford private school and foreign holidays doesn't sound like finances are reason to stick at one. My children's sibling relationship with each other is worth more than a private education and foreign holidays.

givemeasunnyday · 27/09/2023 09:32

PinkRoses1245 · 27/09/2023 07:18

“To grow up together, to build a kinship, to share support and friendship over a lifetime,? I think so”

this is far from guaranteed. Most people I know don’t get on with their siblings as adults

Exactly. My exDH and his brother have had no communication for over 20 years, and weren't that close as children.

LittleMonks11 · 27/09/2023 09:15

Pleased to see the stupid attention seeking comment has been removed, which I reported.

OP I have an only child. We could have tried (being the operative word) for another one but my heart said no. We struggled with fertility and were so happy to have our beautiful DC.

There are no guarantees in life so you must follow your heart and your gut.

I wonder if your DH is projecting a little on his own wonderful sibling experience. Which would be understandable.

DiaNaranja · 27/09/2023 09:00

Is think having two close in age is great as they do entertain each other when they're older. Yes they obviously fight too, but the companionship outweighs that for everyone I know with two with a small age gap. You obviously get the families where the kids do fight non stop, but on the whole, everyone I know with two close together, the kids get on really well. There's a girl opposite us who's an only, and she comes knocking on the door everyday asking for the girls to play, as she's bored at home by herself, where as mine never tell me they're bored, as they have far too much fun playing together/winding eachother up! As a side thought though, you will have a bigger age gap if only just thinking about it now though, so not sure if you'd reap ALL the benefits from a sibling relationship as good company, as that tends to work best when the gap is around 2 years. May take longer for them to tolerate eachother as your eldest is definitely past the baby stage, and will be out of the toddler stage by the time a younger one would be wanting to play Peppa pig games!

Abfab63 · 27/09/2023 08:54

Definitely don't have a second in the hope they'll play together. I fought with my brother my entire childhood, it was exhausting for my mum. And my two don't play that well together now but still very young.

SleepingStandingUp · 27/09/2023 08:54

It's a real human life, not an add-on accessory.
Will he want to send it back if your daughter doesn't like the sex-setting, or it comes with an extra baby or a disability whereby it can't be a play mate?

I didn't feel our family was complete at 1, we had another making it 3. I still have a yearning for a fourth. But coupled with practicality, DH has a vasectomy. At no point were the twins or the one I'm not having about keeping DS entertained

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 27/09/2023 08:48

Imo yes because I think sibling relationships are so important- I lost my parents young and love having a sister. Seeing my two girls interact is the biggest joy for me

SlightlygrumpyBettyswaitress · 27/09/2023 08:43

We had the same reasoning for our No2.
They were chalk and cheese. Exactly 2 years between them. Never played together once!
Tricky teen years. Get on better as adults.

cakecoffeecakecoffee · 27/09/2023 08:40

My kids fight all day, it’s bloody draining.

And they are very jealous of each other, constantly vying for mine and DH attention.

Cerealforever · 27/09/2023 08:37

Catza · 27/09/2023 08:29

Definitely not a good reason. And there is absolutely nothing wring with being bored. Actually, we don't encourage children enough to learn to deal with boredom.
As a single child I had friends I played with all the time (granted, it was back in a day when you were allowed to play outside unsupervised all day long), I also was good at independent imaginative play. Was I bored at times? Sure. But that taught me a value of creativity, reading, imagination - something I draw on as adult so literally never feel bored or lonely now.

I used to think this, but now realise, as you point out, it’s so much harder for kids to ‘unbored’ themselves than it used to be. They can’t just take themselves off like they used to. Their lives are, socially and physically (I’ve seen research studies on how much kid physical roaming space in their neighbour hoods has dimished) much, much smaller.

kids need that freedom to learn how to occupy themselves.

Vettrianofan · 27/09/2023 08:36

Two is great if you want to play referee as they grow up due to constant fighting 😫

MariaVT65 · 27/09/2023 08:34

It’s your body, if you don’t want another one, then that’s the answer.

I’m pregnant with my second and I always wanted 2 kids, partly for the companionship. My experience is that my brother and I played together all the time and were/are very similar still. Yes we also physically fought but without him I would have been incredibly lonely. My parents then split and separated us, I didn’t live anywhere near my school friends and was very lonely during my teenage years. My brother as an adult is the closest member of my family. I also wanted to 2 kids as we don’t have a big family, they have no cousins etc.

However I do know a mix of siblings who get on, and some who have less in common just because they are different people, so it’s really the luck of the draw and should not be a sole reason for having another kid.

Cerealforever · 27/09/2023 08:33

For us it has been. Mine play together all the time and really love each other ( 7 and 10), though they do fight too, which is hard ( both boys).

But I am really glad they have each other, and will go through life having each other and that bond.

Play dates are not that easy to arrange as kids lives are so organized now. Everyone is at ‘activities’ or in family time at weekends. It’s hard to co- ordinate diaries. Kids don’t really just play in the street and organise their own time with other kids. It will help if you are good friends with another family, but that means you have to invest time in that.

My eldest would be spending a lot of time alone if he never had a sibling. So I am glad he dies have one and they get along. Three year age difference.

Catza · 27/09/2023 08:29

Definitely not a good reason. And there is absolutely nothing wring with being bored. Actually, we don't encourage children enough to learn to deal with boredom.
As a single child I had friends I played with all the time (granted, it was back in a day when you were allowed to play outside unsupervised all day long), I also was good at independent imaginative play. Was I bored at times? Sure. But that taught me a value of creativity, reading, imagination - something I draw on as adult so literally never feel bored or lonely now.

Feelinghawt · 27/09/2023 08:25

1 year 9 month between my 2 boys and they play together all day. 2nd DC was a bit of a suprise my DH was v much one and done and I would of waited but so glad I didn't. Obviously there will be a bigger gap between yours and they might not be into the same things like mine are but I actually feel I have more freedom to get on with stuff as they keep each other entertained and one of them doesn't constantly need me for one on one interaction. It's still has it demands generally I also just felt more fulfilled and complete as a family with 2 but that's just me everyone's different

Beezknees · 27/09/2023 08:22

No, not a good reason. I'm an only child with an only child. Having another child just for a playmate and to get "a break" is very selfish if that is indeed the sole reason.

Birch101 · 27/09/2023 08:22

I could have written this myself.
Our LG is 2 in Jan and after losing a parent this year I was grateful to have a sibling but when we were kids we didn't play together we have a 2.5yr age gap

We can cope now, hopefully be able to afford activities and clubs for our little one, as they get older possibly pay for a friend to join us on holiday.

My biggest fear is having another one and regretting it. We would have less options for childcare as GP wouldn't be able to have 2 at a time, as the lower earner more would fall to me, if something were to happen to my partner or if we split up I don't think I could cope being a single mum to 2.

Each has pros and cons but I don't have a big desire to have another one so we have drawn a line under it.

itsmyp4rty · 27/09/2023 08:21

I wish I'd been an only child, unfortunately I wanted a sibling when I was little and my mum thought she should have one for me. We have never got on and used to argue, fight and wind each other up no end. We were certainly each others entertainment - just not in any good or positive way.

My parents have sorted out their own old age, there's no reason it should have to fall on any child, I certainly wouldn't want mine to - but I'd much rather not have to sort out inheritance with my sibling, it already caused huge problems between DH and his sibling when their parents died.

I have an only and it's wonderful, everyone I know with 2 has had a much harder time of it. It's one of the best decisions I ever made IMO.

Clingfilm · 27/09/2023 08:19

Not a good reason, no.
Mine never fight, they've always played together and I get on well with my siblings.

These threads always seem skew towards people whose children fight and hate their siblings 😄

Growingouttogether · 27/09/2023 08:18

If it’s the only reason then no it’s not a good enough reason but DH and I said the other day how much easier it is having 2 now they play together. They’re 5 and 3 and the last 3 months have started to really become ‘friends’ and can play happily together for hours, but they do still argue. On the beach the other week they took turns burying each other for over an hour, which meant I didn’t have to! But they’re also very different personalities so it will be interesting to see what happens as they get older. For now though I am enjoying it!

bookworm14 · 27/09/2023 08:17

The people saying that you shouldn’t have more than one child because siblings fight are missing the point.

No one is saying that. They are saying that if you don’t otherwise want a second child, don’t have one solely for the purpose of being a playmate as they aren’t guaranteed to get along.

sashh · 27/09/2023 08:12

They might be best friends they might hate each other.

You just don't know.

If yo want playmate for you LO get a labrador.

Helpusg · 27/09/2023 08:12

The people saying that you shouldn’t have more than one child because siblings fight are missing the point. Learning to get along with others and, crucially, learning to share are things you practise every single day with siblings. You just don’t have the same sort of everyday practice of that as an only child.

You've got to do what seems best in your circumstances OP. I always set out to have more than one so I have a very different perspective. I love seeing their relationships develop and the fun they have together.