Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it worth having 2 children so that they play together?

209 replies

NatMoz · 27/09/2023 06:00

I have an almost 2 year old (2 in December).

I'm feeling more one and done. Right now she sleeps through, has done on and off since 10 weeks and wakes between 7 and 8am.

She was an early walker and is quite lively and a bit of a climber. I keep her active during the week with church groups on my non working days, nursery and childminders the other days.

At the moment we can afford holidays abroad and we can maybe afford one child through private school.

She also is capable of independent play.

We look after her 50:50. There is no primary parent UNLESS my husband works away for a few days occasionally so it's me. I have had long weekends away myself with friends too so again 50:50.

My husband is at the stage where he's discussing a second, main reason being for a playmate.

I don't know if i want a second and I'm not sure playmate is a good sole reason to have one. He claims she will be more work when she's older as we will have to provide undivided attention to her as she will be bored otherwise. I said she would have playdates. I'm sure other mums will bite my hand off to take their child for the day/few hours.

Is playmate really a good enough reason?

OP posts:
bookworm14 · 27/09/2023 15:48

But there are lots of people on this thread who have said they are happy as only children. Stop wildly generalising from your own experience.

Mamai90 · 27/09/2023 15:45

It's only on here I see siblings hate eachother and are NC as adults, I only have 1 friend irl like this, in all other cases the siblings are all very close.

My sister and I fought growing up like all siblings do, but we always had a friend in eachother on holidays and days out etc. There is a 2.5 year age gap but we always had the same group of friends and still do even in our 40s. She is so precious to me, my best friend, I couldn't imagine life without her. For that reason I always wanted DD to have a sibling, I wanted two anyway but probably a driving force was knowing they'd always have eachother. I'm expecting another girl and there will be a 2 year age gap, I know there are no guarantees but I hope they'll be as close as my sister and I.

I probably wouldn't have another just for the sole reason of giving my child a playmate if I didn't want one myself but I think in the majority of cases only children always wish for a sibling. I think its extra difficult when you lose your parents too. My cousin is an only and when I was pregnant with DD she told me to make sure I try for a sibling, she's looking after her elderly mum with dementia and struggled when she lost her Dad. My mum is an only too and said she'd always wanted a brother or sister.

ImthatBoleyngirl · 27/09/2023 14:49

In my case yes, DD and DS are 2 years apart and play lovely together. I wouldn't have a 2nd for the sole purpose of giving the 1st one a playmate though, as they might not get on.

BrokenButNotFinished · 27/09/2023 14:38

It isn't about 'playing'. Until I had children myself, I didn't realise how much socialisation comes from a sibling relationship. But even aside from that, as an only child myself I would never have had just one, in so far as I was able.

MsFrost · 27/09/2023 14:32

NatMoz · 27/09/2023 06:33

@MsFrost

Bit concerning that your husband is worried about your child needing undivided attention from her parents. All children need this.

Does he think he will need to give less attention to his children if he has two?

No of course not! Don't be daft🤣

It was more the statements from him of his brother being his best friend to the point he struggles to make non biological friends which has got him into a pickle as his brother is in US

Well you did say 'He claims she will be more work when she's older as we will have to provide undivided attention to her'

How am I being daft if that's true?

He's saying he doesn't want the 'work' of giving undivided attention to his child. If he doesn't want to give it to one, he's not going to want to give it to two.

pigsDOfly · 27/09/2023 14:02

As pps have said, you've absolutely no guarantee that the children will even like each other, let alone want to play together.

And as for caring for elderly parents, again there's no guarantees that either, or any, of the children are going to be willing to put any effort in in that respect. And having children so that they will be there to take over your care in old age is an appalling reason to have a child.

I have three children. I'm close to one of them who lives 20 miles away but would most definitely not want her to have to spend part of her life looking after me in my old age, I rarely see one of them because they live in another country and the other one has cut herself off from most of the family.

Your life sounds good. If you have another child the impact on you will be greater than the impact on your husband. Unless you are very eager to have another one don't do it for him and his rather strange reasons.

TammyJones · 27/09/2023 13:47

Absolutely not.
My mum did this.
My sibling Hasn't spoken to me for years.
Your life sounds perfect.
Your child will make her own friends and as a only child will probably end up more independent and self reliant (good traits to have)
Out of my 4 adult children , 3 are fairly close ....though don't see each other much due to distance.
One has completely cut everyone off, years ago.

ilovesooty · 27/09/2023 11:53

MrsTerryPratchett · 27/09/2023 06:17

My brother was awful to me and the worst thing about my childhood by a mile.

So you don;t know. At least with friends you choose them so you can change.

DD is an only and happy.

I didn't want to play with my sister from the word go either. My mother had been told we'd be lovely playmates 🙄

Tell your husband that he's talking about children with their own personalities, not kittens.

Mary46 · 27/09/2023 11:48

Not a given they will get on! I have 2. Only downside of one my friend says her mams care will fall on her but her mam is not demanding thank god. I have 2 sisters not overly close to them.

IdealisticCynic · 27/09/2023 11:13

We had a similar discussion when our DD was a toddler. In the end I realised we were only thinking of having a second for her sake, not for ourselves or for the potential child. And I think that’s a terrible reason to create another person. I think you should actively want a second child because you want another child, not for your first child.

YeOldeBuxomWench · 27/09/2023 11:06

I don't want this to put you off as we all love our youngest child immensely, he is s real joy to be around, but he also has severe autism and is never likely to be independent. He barely acknowledges his older brother, although I know my eldest loves him dearly. It will likely change when my youngest grows as he responds very well to adults.He is also probably going to need his eldest siblings support in one form or another when he is older. This wasnt what i planned for and had a second for similar reasons to you. My elsedest has much older half siblings, so at least he has that too. I know they will have to lovely relationship when older, but they don't play together at all now.

I wouldn't change things, but if you are having a child to entertain or support another child you will need to think about it a lot. Some siblings don't even get on, especially with a strong willed older sibling! I know loads of siblings that constantly bicker and fall out.

Goldbar · 27/09/2023 10:43

It depends on the personalities involved. I have a 5 year age gap between my two, but my older child (6) is the type of child who will play with anyone of whatever age (10 year olds, 2 year olds) and if there's no one around to play with, then they'll pretend a paper bag is alive and play with that. So actually the older one does play with the little one a surprising amount... We'll see if that continues. Conversely, I know siblings close in age who can't stand each other or largely ignore each other. I'd agree that the only reason to have another is because you want another. Also, I wouldn't worry about larger age gaps if you want to wait... they have their downsides but also many, many positives.

mrlistersgelfbride · 27/09/2023 10:37

DD is an only child (5, nearly 6). Our house is always full of kids 😆 I live on an estate and every night there is someone at the door wanting to play with her. By the way, most of these other children have siblings. Often they say to me their brother or sister is annoying or their mum/dad does not have time for them because of their siblings.
DD is never far from a party invitation and makes friends everywhere we go. There were times when I thought about another but my relationship couldn't take it and I don't want to go through poor mental health again.

I certainly wouldn't have another to give a sibling.
Every child is different. You really don't need to do it because of what your husband wants or societal pressure.
If you have an only, they will never be lonely as long as you are happy to do child friendly activities and invite other kids round sometimes.

I have a brother. We were never allowed friends in the house or sleepovers and spent weekends hiking with my parents.
As soon as my brother was old enough, he rebelled, went to uni and now at 36 is a drug addict with no money. He will be absolutely no help to me when my parents are elderly.

Mariposista · 27/09/2023 10:29

You are done OP, and your reasons for being done are excellent.
RE elderly care - if it helps, my mum is one of 4 and it was all dumped on her.
Not all siblings get on.
Give your lovely current child the very best life and enjoy her.

bookworm14 · 27/09/2023 10:04

Honestly, people are so bloody weird.

bookworm14 · 27/09/2023 10:03

There isn’t a ‘one and done movement’. What on earth gave you that idea? More people are sticking at one, either because there’s less of a stigma, because they can’t afford more, or because they just want to. It’s not an organised movement.

kagerou · 27/09/2023 10:02

My parents had two so that we would play together but it absolutely did NOT go as they planned

I never liked the same thing as my sister and as we grew up we just really disliked each other. Very different people with nothing in common.

As adults we have been completely NC for years and long may that continue 😂

Olika · 27/09/2023 09:59

I wouldn't for this reason only

LittleMonks11 · 27/09/2023 09:56

What is the 'one and done' movement when it's at home?

IStandWithACrutch · 27/09/2023 09:55

The sheer terror of being alone or bored is quite amusing.
OP think beyond the next few years. Kids don’t stay little for long and they get more expensive as they get older.

ManateeFair · 27/09/2023 09:54

Just because they're siblings, that doesn't mean they will get along and play with each other. They might fight like cat and dog, or have nothing in common.

And if your child is two now, they'd be three or four by the time the baby was born, and six or seven by the time the younger sibling is at an age where they can really play properly with other kids. A three-year-old and a six/seven-year-old are at different stages and won't necessarily want to do the same things.

Plus, it's actually quite a burden on the older sibling if they're expected to play with a younger child all the time. As the older one they end up being responsible for the younger one, having to show them how to do things, keeping an eye on them etc. Some kids are happy to do that and quite like bossing the younger one around and playing the grown-up but plenty of kids just find it annoying or stressful.

klhfd · 27/09/2023 09:47

But I do admit here my opinion is very much defined by the fact I don't really agree/understand the whole "one and done" movement.

I don't agree or understand having 3 kids; I don't agree with dividing my time, money and affection 3 ways, my 2 children get much more value from DH and I than they would an additional sibling. You had a third baby for your own selfish reasons (as I had did mine) you're making a moral judgement on someone else's decision just because it's different to yours.

cadburyegg · 27/09/2023 09:44

Ohyesthankyouglitter · 27/09/2023 09:39

You can't guarantee that having a sibling = playmate BUT don't be unaware of the dynamics with an only child. My sister has one, and whilst her son has been very happy to play by himself, enjoys adult company, during the holidays and weekends, because there isn't really a 'melee' of family life for the kid to become part of, she often feels the pressure to be intentional about filling his time/arranging for him to do stuff. I look at my life, with the bustle, and think having multiple has, in some ways, actually taken the pressure off.

I agree with this as well.

Despite the bickering, the only time my two ever say they're bored is when they're apart!

That being said, as an only child myself I used to get bored as a kid but I learnt how to entertain myself. as an adult I'm used to doing things on my own whereas I notice others tend to want adult company more.

I had a lot of play dates though and sleepovers which my parents were happy to facilitate. I'd often have friends over to stay for several days or even a whole week in the holidays which helped their parents out a lot! My two rarely ask to have play dates and I wonder if it's because they have a playmate at home.

SleepingStandingUp · 27/09/2023 09:42

thetrainatplatform4 · 27/09/2023 09:35

My 3 play together 90% of the time beautifully and they adore each other and yes it certainly does help parenting in that respect as I'm not required to play all the time like I was with my eldest.

But I do admit here my opinion is very much defined by the fact I don't really agree/understand the whole "one and done" movement. If you can afford private school and foreign holidays doesn't sound like finances are reason to stick at one. My children's sibling relationship with each other is worth more than a private education and foreign holidays.

You don't understand that some people only want one child??
Why do you have three? Because you wanted to? Why don't you have more? I don't understand the three and done! I'm sure they'd like a sibling. Everyone should have ten each regardless of personal choice because people are weird if they have their own preferences

cadburyegg · 27/09/2023 09:39

I wouldn't have a second just for the playmate reason. The only good reason to have a second is if you both want one.

I love having two and it's worth it but it's a lot of work too. I'm an only child though.

Swipe left for the next trending thread