Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it worth having 2 children so that they play together?

209 replies

NatMoz · 27/09/2023 06:00

I have an almost 2 year old (2 in December).

I'm feeling more one and done. Right now she sleeps through, has done on and off since 10 weeks and wakes between 7 and 8am.

She was an early walker and is quite lively and a bit of a climber. I keep her active during the week with church groups on my non working days, nursery and childminders the other days.

At the moment we can afford holidays abroad and we can maybe afford one child through private school.

She also is capable of independent play.

We look after her 50:50. There is no primary parent UNLESS my husband works away for a few days occasionally so it's me. I have had long weekends away myself with friends too so again 50:50.

My husband is at the stage where he's discussing a second, main reason being for a playmate.

I don't know if i want a second and I'm not sure playmate is a good sole reason to have one. He claims she will be more work when she's older as we will have to provide undivided attention to her as she will be bored otherwise. I said she would have playdates. I'm sure other mums will bite my hand off to take their child for the day/few hours.

Is playmate really a good enough reason?

OP posts:
Jllllllll · 28/09/2023 19:35

Don’t have an only child. Not nice for anyone. Short term long term gain for them.

Lorralorr · 28/09/2023 16:45

As children they’d be playmates but you’d also be giving them both a lifelong gift. Out of curiosity are you an only child OP? Or do you get on with your siblings?

I have two and ‘playmate’ wasn’t my only reason but it did factor in, that I wouldn’t have wanted my eldest to be on his own, especially in later life when he doesn’t have parents any more. It’s lovely to have someone throughout life. So I think it’s a good reason, if not a good only reason.

I have to say, some of my favourite bits of being a parent have been watching my two sons form their little bond and interact with each other - it’s been amazing (they are 1 and 3).

FlitterBug · 28/09/2023 11:53

I contemplated an only child when my firstborn was little. I asked some of my only child friends and I will say all of them said that when they were older they missed having that someone especially if an older parent was ill or passed away!

Gowlett · 28/09/2023 11:28

There’a all sorts of pros & cons to having a kid / kids in general. I’d say have another if YOU want to have one.

Appleblum · 28/09/2023 11:18

It really depends on your luck I think. I knew I wanted another child and I wanted them to be close in age so that they could play together. My two DDs are one year apart and they are so close to each other, they often tell me they wish they were twins so that they could be in the same class together! (They already do everything together)

I do have friends whose children are not as close though so I don't think it's really something you can control.

Laguerita · 28/09/2023 11:09

My DH is an only child and now that his parents are elderly their care will fall on him (and also then me) and care of their home and finances etc etc etc. It’s a lot and I dread the upcoming years. I wish he had siblings to share this with.

This can be an issue but like pretty much every aspect of this it can also go both ways! I am starting to get to this point now and my brother and I are already falling out over how best to handle things.

I love him, and we in some ways do have a good relationship, but we fought like cats and dogs growing up (my parents certainly couldn’t leave us to entertain each other, it was more like refereeing/ trying to prevent bloodshed) and now that we’re getting to the difficult bit with parents and other elderly relatives it is to be honest quite awful, far from being support it is really upsetting. I don’t know whether we will be able to maintain a relationship in the long term even.

All of this depends so much on the individuals and you can’t really predict that.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 28/09/2023 10:57

I have identical twins and even they never played together reliably.

Having a second for a playmate is a bad idea.

Portakalkedi · 28/09/2023 09:38

Absolutely not. You should not have a child just because you wish it to serve a particular purpose.

felisha54 · 28/09/2023 08:37

I'm one of 5 and have an only dd12. She has never asked for a sibling apart from when she was 3 and she wanted a baby sister. She's never lonely and is very sociable. You do have to make more effort though to facilitate social things. She's lucky she has same sex and age cousins so weekends are usually sleepovers at one house or another. Of her cousins both have siblings of the opposite sex and there's quite an age gap, so whilst they get on they have no common interests.

Of my friends who have 2dc, only one sibling group get on and are very cute together. The other 3 fight like cat and dog.

Needaholi · 28/09/2023 08:17

JaninaDuszejko · 27/09/2023 23:06

I suspect the OP is an only herself and so has very intense female friendships (my Mum's schoolfriends from her boarding school were substitute siblings for her) and looks at her DH's more typical relaxed male friendships and thinks 'he doesn't have friends' when actually he does but a friendship made in adulthood can never be as close as a good life-long sibling relationship.

As an adult my three siblings are the only people that have gone through life with me. They know my extended family, my good friends from school, university and the friends I've made as an adult. They shared my grief when our Dad died and we'll grow old together. Your siblings are truly your lifetime companions in a way that nobody else is. Friendships can fade over time but your siblings are always there, even if they live on another continent.

This.
Absolutely spot on.

Pushkinini · 28/09/2023 08:16

I have two. One DD, one DS with 22 months between them. They have always been close and played together as children, notwithstanding the odd childhood squabble or teenage strop. Even now at 24 and 26, they live close to each other, 200 miles from us, and socialise quite a lot together. However, don't have another if you want a playmate. It might not work out like that.

Luckyduc · 28/09/2023 07:20

I was an only child and I had an incredible life.....for the reason I decided to be one and done and I now have a 8 year old.
Big mistake!!!!!!! When they are small it's easy to think exactly what you've just said but nobody told me as a new mum that life as I knew it wasn't wasn't same.....parents don't let their children outside anymore!!! As a kid I had plenty friends and was allowed out all day to play but now, if I send my child outside, he noone. He's literally bored playing on his own and it looks so so sad. Playdates....no parent likes them. And your child is still at the age where he's happy on his own....wait until age 6 kicks in and higher, he will want you to play every waking moment of his life.
There definitely are more perks tho with one child....it is far more peaceful, no fighting and arguing, more money ....which is brilliant as we have a crazy amount of days out and holidays and for us we also had to remind ourself that they arjt kids forever .....they grow up into adults so it's not like they need a play friend for many years. We put our child into a lot of after school clubs to fill the voids.

HashtagDerekSays · 28/09/2023 07:10

I'm an only child, and I have such a close bond with my parents. Even though I'm married and have my own kids now, I still love being with them as the three muskateers 😂

Now I'm mid 30s and my parents are getting older, I feel like I wish I had a sibling that could be with me when they pass. I'll be completely on my own to sort funerals ect, which I'm hoping will be a long time away obviously, but it just seems so daunting.

I have three boys that are 11, 10 and 5. I do feel comfort knowing they'll have each other when I pass, my 11 year old doesn't really play with his brothers, but the 10 and 5 year old spend all their time together. It's tricky.

My DH has two brothers and one sister, but only sees his one eldest brother (by 18 months) semi.reguarly, and we live in the same small town. I try and keep in touch with his other two siblings, (same dad, different mum) but they wouldn't just meet up for a drink or anything.

My dad's one of 7 and doesn't see his siblings muxh, my mum's one of three and they're very close and message everyday.

Sorry such a mixed bag! I might have had a sibling that I now hate, or a lovely one. But I was never lonely when I was growing up.

larlypops · 28/09/2023 07:02

Me and my brothers fought like cat and dog as kids but very close as adults.
my two are just under 3 years apart and did go through a stage of constantly fighting but they’re still protective of each other.
don’t do it for companion do it because you want another.

Baba197 · 28/09/2023 07:02

The only reason to have another is because you both want one- siblings don’t always get along so having another as a playmate is silly! I’ve been a nanny for nearly 30 yrs and in so many of the families I’ve worked for the kids didn’t like each other!! I have one child, I’m an only child myself as well, if I had more then we wouldn’t be able to afford the nice days out/basic holidays that we can now and my son and I are very close so I don’t feel the need for more kids

Ffion21 · 28/09/2023 06:59

I’m a one and done child and we flip flopped on a second. However, like you financially we are at a point where we can do all the things we want, when we want and no worries. We could afford private school if we wanted and we go on nice holidays and do lots of fun days out. If we had a second that wouldn’t have been quite as feasible. I also think a lot of siblings in adulthood don’t really talk anyway, so the long term aspect shouldn’t really be considered so much.

I have friends with children a similar age and at 6.5 he is SO easy. So so easy. I love spending time with him, he’s so funny. We no longer have to do pretend play (he was into playfood for longer thank I think most kids are). He’s moving into gaming (like Roblox - I work in IT Security before anyone jumps on this, know what I’m doing online!) and fun board games like labyrinth and monopoly. He’s sooooo much fun. My friends with siblings can’t easily sit and play all this as they’ve got a little one to entertain/watch too.

As such, I think it gets easier far quicker with one and them needing undivided attention won’t last long. we are starting to see this tail off now his interests are changing. However with one it’s easy to switch out with each other. It really isn’t hard work!

We are very glad we were one and done. He’s very outgoing because he has to be to make friends and I ensure he gets involved etc so he has the same experiences than he would with a sibling, to some extent. We take school friends for the day in summer holiday etc - friends are always grateful as you suggest, as they have more kids.

Dont let society tell you what works for you. one kid is literally the best of both worlds. It’s a breeze as they get a little older, totally fun and you still get to do adult stuff without having to organise months out for childcare options.

Don’t have a child if you aren’t 100% convinced because you can’t plan that scenario, they may dislike each other then you’re in the land of nappies and juggling both independently for years longer. It’s mostly just unfair on the children too.

Casperroonie · 28/09/2023 06:59

My second came along as a surprise and it was an absolute delight to have been blessed with a second. My 2 play together all the the time and are thick as thieves. Of course they bicker too but mostly they adore each other.

Having 2 was the best thing for us as it really feels like we are complete and we have lived having 2 children.

TheLightProgramme · 28/09/2023 06:48

I'd 100% agree its the parents fault when DC have no bond at all.

Parents can unconsciously pit kids against each other, not handle differences in abilities well, are often frankly impartial, tolerate one DC hurting or being nasty to others.

You see countless threads where people don't value their siblings - because they were scapegoated or there was a golden child, because parents played favourites, because parents didn't nip aggressive behaviour in the bud early. most of the time the causes could have been dealt with through different parenting .

CoreopsisEverywhere · 28/09/2023 06:44

You can’t assume they will.

My sons, with a 20 month age gap, have never been close and barely give each other the time of day. They’re teens now, and can go for days without speaking to each other at all

TheLightProgramme · 28/09/2023 06:39

Omg its SO worth it.

Mine (boy and girl) get on brilliantly. Eldest is so so caring towards his little sister and they are just so sweet together.

Mothership4two · 28/09/2023 06:29

MinnieMountain · 27/09/2023 06:20

But siblings don’t necessarily share the care @MaggieBsBoat . My uncle left it all to my dad.

That's good for me to hear Minnie (not so good for your dad though!) as I am an only child and have often worried about my parents needing care in the future and how it would be helpful to be able share it and any decisions with a sibling (even if it was just having someone as a sounding board) but like you say it's not necessarily the case that a sibling will be supportive.

JaninaDuszejko · 28/09/2023 05:33

Of course it's the parent's fault. I'm not talking about childhood bickering which is obviously normal. I'm talking about adult siblings who don't have a relationship with each other (one of the main reasons people say no siblings is fine). That only happens when the family environment they grow up in is toxic, and that is created by the parents.

PeggyPiglet · 27/09/2023 23:18

JaninaDuszejko · 27/09/2023 22:48

My Mum was effectively an only child (not her parent's choice, my uncle died in infancy). She hated it and I'm one of 4 because she never wanted us to experience being only children. I have 3DC.

Children benefit greatly from having siblings and if they don't get on with them it's the parents' fault. And private education and expensive holidays are not worth denying your child a sibling for.

Sorry what? If the siblings don't get on it's the parent's fault?

What a load of nonsense.

Fixyourself · 27/09/2023 23:13

Being an only child is lonely when you get older.
No one to share the burden of aging parents. No aunties or uncles for their children (on their side). No blood nieces or nephews. This is what I find the hardest being an only child.

ProfSleepzz · 27/09/2023 23:11

NRTFT. Oooh it’s hard. I have b/g twins (so, no choice over the play mate!) 50% of the time they’re best, best friends. 50% of the time they will happily tear actual chunks out of each other. They also love bickering about inane shit until my ears bleed. I love having two because I know if the worst happened (I’m a solo mum) they’d have each other. I also love their polar opposite personalities. I get a lot of joy out of each of them. I have also known, right from the start, these are the only children I want. I hated the toddler years vehemently. Genuinely cried most weeks for about three years. I would never put myself through that again. It’s a discussion obviously but having a second just to be a playmate is not a good enough reason in my opinion. Typing that also makes me think it has to be considered that this fictional second playmate is a real person with all the wants and needs they’ll have. You shouldn’t be brought into the world to be a playmate. Lastly, I have two very good friends who are singletons. Both are well adjusted, lovely humans. Both loved being the only child. One is a mum to an only child and loves it. One is a mum to two and loves it. Knowing and communicating what you want is key here.