Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Social housing and inheriting a share of a house

136 replies

howdoesitworkthen · 26/09/2023 23:05

I'm living in a housing association home and have an elderly mother.
She will leave the house about 500k to me and my sister.
My sister already owns a house and suggested we rent out our parents house as a retirement income.
I'm not sure if we could buy a home each if we sold and split.
How does this work if you have a housing association assured tenancy and inherit part of a property.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
InspectorGidget · 28/09/2023 12:34

I agree with pp who have said that any tenant renting a £500k house will have high expectations.
Not to mention if the value goes up and you sell later you'll be clobbered for tax.

Sell the house. And then you have the freedom to buy your own home / invest / support your kids etc.

And absolutely do not transfer to your sisters name. The issues in doing that are huge.

Poontangle · 28/09/2023 08:30

I do hope OP's mother isn't on MN.

I also hope she lives happily in her lovely £500k house until she's 120, having revised her will to leave everything to the donkey sanctuary.

FarEast · 28/09/2023 08:05

If every SH tenant knows that as soon as they do a bit better they have to move into market housing (shit and wildly insecure) we incentivise people having no social mobility. Basically encouraging people not to improve their lives.

@MrsTerryPratchett I'm appreciating & learning a lot from your posts. But I don't think I'm suggesting that the OP should contemplate moving into the private rental market. An inheritance of £250 k is a substantial amount to purchase a home, thus offering @howdoesitworkthen far more security in her housing than any kind of renting.

And yes, social housing tenants pay rent, but it is not a current market rent generally.

I agree that current market rents can be pretty usurous (I have a rental property myself and reduced the rent by 20% while my tenant was furloughed in 2020, and haven't increased it since. They're good tenants & happy in the house).

BUT - it's the perception of an unfair disparity in rental opportunities. Those secure in social housing still pay rent (and taxes) but - I would assume from what you say - they are not paying current market rates. This is a good thing, but must be very very hard to see for those people unable to secure social housing, although they are eligible for it, who are forced to pay market rents, and suffer all the precarity of housing involved.

There needs to be a solution which balances individual need and social need. Allowing a social housing tenant to remain in scarce social housing when they have the capital means of housing themselves securely, is not that fair or transparent balance.

Sunshinenrain · 28/09/2023 06:50

healthadvice123 · 28/09/2023 00:24

@Sunshinenrain i live in a ha property and my tenancy says no such thing.
your not meant to own another home but left as inheritance between 2 not wuite the same
personally if I inherit enough to byt a house ever or go a long way towards a house i would buy though and guve my house back so someone else can benefit as that seems the moral thing to do

Ok that’s fair enough. But I know 3 LA authorities where it is written in the tenancy agreement and PPs have said it’s in their tenancy agreement too.

It does seem crazy that there are people who are homeless or living in awful conditions and being on the council list for years, whilst there are people who are rich and owning multiple homes and still keeping their council house.

healthadvice123 · 28/09/2023 00:24

@Sunshinenrain i live in a ha property and my tenancy says no such thing.
your not meant to own another home but left as inheritance between 2 not wuite the same
personally if I inherit enough to byt a house ever or go a long way towards a house i would buy though and guve my house back so someone else can benefit as that seems the moral thing to do

JenniferBooth · 27/09/2023 23:51

You cant talk about the shortage of social housing without acknowledging that some of it is down to developers.

IdleAnimations · 27/09/2023 23:40

Farmageddon · 27/09/2023 23:23

Most people on this thread weren't criticising social housing tenants, but the idea of being able to hold onto a tenancy in spite of receiving a windfall of several hundred thousand pounds.

Thank you! I don’t know how people are missing this.

Farmageddon · 27/09/2023 23:23

JenniferBooth · 27/09/2023 23:11

And if you are so concerned about that why doesnt Heygate or Balfron Tower bother you. You SH tenant haters make that hate more obvious with every word you post

Most people on this thread weren't criticising social housing tenants, but the idea of being able to hold onto a tenancy in spite of receiving a windfall of several hundred thousand pounds.

IdleAnimations · 27/09/2023 23:14

JenniferBooth · 27/09/2023 23:11

And if you are so concerned about that why doesnt Heygate or Balfron Tower bother you. You SH tenant haters make that hate more obvious with every word you post

Honestly Jennifer, I’ve already said that I was a recipient of social housing and I’m immensely grateful. My issue is a quarter of a million in the bank alongside the house which you’ve all conveniently forgotten and not commented on instead it’s a ‘them and us’ classic response.

Give your head a wobble.

JenniferBooth · 27/09/2023 23:11

And if you are so concerned about that why doesnt Heygate or Balfron Tower bother you. You SH tenant haters make that hate more obvious with every word you post

IdleAnimations · 27/09/2023 23:08

HerMammy · 27/09/2023 22:56

Why do people repeatedly say SH is part funded/subsidised, it's not; it's affordable rent, private rent is way over inflated. Sh tenants pay rent, council tax, income tax, it's not just for unemployed people, teachers, NHS staff, emergency service staff live in SH.
The Netherlands has 35% of their population in SH, England 18%, home owning will never be in many peoples reach and it is not necessary to be the aim in life.

If not using any benefits - You’re still getting lower rent from a property that was originally bought by public funds (the council). Many private renters (myself included) who’ve been on low incomes would’ve bitten at the chance to have lower rent than private. It’s not a right and social housing stock is rare so holding onto one when not needed is selfish.

Secondly house ownership should be the aim if you have £250k, a very easy aim all things considered. That’s a golden ticket. Its a whole different kettle of fish that people are seemingly forgetting. A quarter of a million pounds. Even if not received yet, if it is - most people would say that “£250k given as a gift will never be in peoples reach”.

HerMammy · 27/09/2023 22:56

Why do people repeatedly say SH is part funded/subsidised, it's not; it's affordable rent, private rent is way over inflated. Sh tenants pay rent, council tax, income tax, it's not just for unemployed people, teachers, NHS staff, emergency service staff live in SH.
The Netherlands has 35% of their population in SH, England 18%, home owning will never be in many peoples reach and it is not necessary to be the aim in life.

Babyroobs · 27/09/2023 21:19

IdleAnimations · 27/09/2023 21:04

I can sort of see what you’re saying and I mean this as respectfully as possible - how many people have £250k, even in assets? How many people would inherit such a large sum?

Do you not see how that is grossly unfair when your financial circumstances change so dramatically in an upward way to continue to have subsidised housing? Especially during a cost of living crisis. People with over 16k in savings can’t claim any benefits, so why is this fair?

I am from that social housing demographic. As someone whose circumstances also changed in an upward way (thanks to the roof over my head, free education etc), I couldn’t imagine going back and taking a subsidised property off someone in far greater need - and I don’t/didn’t have access to £250k. Because what? I’d graduated from my poverty circumstances so I should stay for diversity? No, I can now pay for myself and should move aside for that same mother and kid (who was me a long time ago) in desperate need of social assistance.

Those homes are for people in need, I am glad my taxes have helped contribute for it - I do not resent social housing. What I’m not glad of or willing to support is subsidising someone who now has the means to house themselves after inheriting a giant whack of money. In fact this will put the OP in a far better situation that the vast majority of the population. I am highly doubtful I’m alone.

OP should look into property ownership, they have the means to do so now.

Op is just assuming she will inherit this anyway, nothing is anywhere near guaranteed.

IdleAnimations · 27/09/2023 21:04

MrsTerryPratchett · 27/09/2023 20:53

Awesome. If you can’t see that someone having 250k and being in HA is a disgrace than no wonder the system is broken.

But they pay rent. It's just an affordable rent. She doesn't claim HB or UC or anything.

I think she should look into buying because it's probably better than being a LL with her sister. But I don't begrudge people 'graduating' from needing help and still having a secure tenancy.

I can sort of see what you’re saying and I mean this as respectfully as possible - how many people have £250k, even in assets? How many people would inherit such a large sum?

Do you not see how that is grossly unfair when your financial circumstances change so dramatically in an upward way to continue to have subsidised housing? Especially during a cost of living crisis. People with over 16k in savings can’t claim any benefits, so why is this fair?

I am from that social housing demographic. As someone whose circumstances also changed in an upward way (thanks to the roof over my head, free education etc), I couldn’t imagine going back and taking a subsidised property off someone in far greater need - and I don’t/didn’t have access to £250k. Because what? I’d graduated from my poverty circumstances so I should stay for diversity? No, I can now pay for myself and should move aside for that same mother and kid (who was me a long time ago) in desperate need of social assistance.

Those homes are for people in need, I am glad my taxes have helped contribute for it - I do not resent social housing. What I’m not glad of or willing to support is subsidising someone who now has the means to house themselves after inheriting a giant whack of money. In fact this will put the OP in a far better situation that the vast majority of the population. I am highly doubtful I’m alone.

OP should look into property ownership, they have the means to do so now.

MrsTerryPratchett · 27/09/2023 20:53

Awesome. If you can’t see that someone having 250k and being in HA is a disgrace than no wonder the system is broken.

But they pay rent. It's just an affordable rent. She doesn't claim HB or UC or anything.

I think she should look into buying because it's probably better than being a LL with her sister. But I don't begrudge people 'graduating' from needing help and still having a secure tenancy.

sgtmajormum · 27/09/2023 20:50

Your sister is in a very different position to you. She already owns a house, where you do not.
I'm not sure what part of the country you live in, but where I am (SE) £250k would only just get you a one bed flat.

Renting the house out might be an option, for you, but if you inherit sufficient money to house yourself, would that not be the moral thing to do? Free up a HA property for another family on the housing register.

Whatever you decide, I would seek advice on how inheriting that kind of money would affect your tenancy.

MrsTerryPratchett · 27/09/2023 20:39

JenniferBooth · 27/09/2023 20:38

Nah this is just another excuse to denigrate social housing tenants If people really gave a shit about those in temp accomodation they would also be objecting to what happened at Heygate and Balfron Tower.

We see you!

Yup.

IdleAnimations · 27/09/2023 20:39

MrsTerryPratchett · 27/09/2023 20:38

You won’t convince me on this.

That's alright @IdleAnimations I don't have to convince you. Since I work in the field I get to develop policy and advocate for and to the sector.

Awesome. If you can’t see that someone having 250k and being in HA is a disgrace than no wonder the system is broken.

JenniferBooth · 27/09/2023 20:38

Nah this is just another excuse to denigrate social housing tenants If people really gave a shit about those in temp accomodation they would also be objecting to what happened at Heygate and Balfron Tower.

We see you!

MrsTerryPratchett · 27/09/2023 20:38

You won’t convince me on this.

That's alright @IdleAnimations I don't have to convince you. Since I work in the field I get to develop policy and advocate for and to the sector.

DragonflyLady · 27/09/2023 20:30

There are no one beds around here. It’s mostly three bed and a couple of two bed. There isn’t much difference between the price of a HA and private rental here. Also when a HA property does come up, they struggle to rent out due to location.

IdleAnimations · 27/09/2023 20:23

MrsTerryPratchett · 27/09/2023 19:49

I agree. Social housing should be for those in need, not those with sold house funds (250k!) in the bank or landlord profiteering. The system is fundamentally broken quite clearly.

I’m pretty shocked by the callousness of some posters here not realising that they’ve received a windfall but continue to take up a property someone desperately in need (such as a woman with kids escaping DV) could have.

Quite incredible.

If every SH tenant knows that as soon as they do a bit better they have to move into market housing (shit and wildly insecure) we incentivise people having no social mobility. Basically encouraging people not to improve their lives.

If all SH tenants are in active crisis, the housing becomes unmanageable. Rather than lovely, diverse, mixed communities of people at different stages. This is one of the reasons 'estates' get a reputation. If everyone is fleeing violence or suffering from trauma, mentally unwell or otherwise struggling, it's not conducive to a settled, happy home.

I know people believe their uninformed, ignorant reckons are more important that experts' but the people who manage SH have done some thinking. As opposed to politicians and 'taxpayers' (we're all taxpayers).

You won’t convince me on this. Why do you deserve a part funded property whilst inheriting a significant amount of money? How does that make you better than the 1% diddling tax payers as you earn interest on that and pay less for your housing than the private market? Why is it okay you’re taking that from someone in need when you’re technically no longer in need?

I say this as someone who comes from council. Council saved me as a child, but you think it’s okay to remove that from another family in need because of wanting to keep a huge chunk of money in the bank?

Being council also didn’t give my family the right if they inherited a quarter of a million to sit pretty because of some nonsense about social mobility and ‘diverse’ communities. Ultimately - you’re robbing off someone more in need if you have that amount of inheritance. It’s immoral.

If you have 250k - you’ve already moved economically whether you like it or not, in fact you’re probably far more better off than most people - even the ones with mortgages who are paying a wealth of interest. You could buy a pretty decent chunk of a property with that amount if you were clever.

I stand by my comments, the entitlement here is insane and shameful.

JenniferBooth · 27/09/2023 20:18

The same people who want social housing estates turned into ghettos are the same people who wouldnt buy a place near one "because its a ghetto"

Well no shit Sherlock Its what you wanted.

Velvian · 27/09/2023 20:08

Sell it and buy your own place. If your sister wants a rental income, she can buy a small place with her share to rent out.

TheRussiansAreComing · 27/09/2023 20:03

One option is for the both of you to open a limited company and be equal share holders. Then transfer the house into the limited company. You will have to pay stamp duty on the value, however, the value of the property can be considered as a Director’s loan, therefore, you will not pay tax on the income until the value of the loan has been paid off. You may find this is the best way. You then won’t own half a house but half a limited company.

You may find this beneficial when passing it on to your children to avoid them having to pay inheritance tax. Hopefully that’s a long way off though.

Swipe left for the next trending thread