Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Driver regretting offering lifts to non driver

162 replies

Billie0900 · 26/09/2023 22:09

I have a new-ish friend of 2 years who I met through our sons making friends at nursery.

I can't drive (for a medical reason) and she does but it has never been an issue until now.

Just before the summer holidays started she enrolled her DS in a martial arts club once per week on a thursday afternoon just around the corner from where they live (which is quite a way from us) and was keen for me to enroll DS as it was something he'd enjoy too.

I was reluctant as it starts at 4pm and I knew I'd have to take him straight from school via two busses once school resumed. The group only lasts 45 minutes and if you're more than 10 minutes late you can't come in so it just didn't seem feasible for us. I said I'd think about the logistics then decided not to go ahead.

That's when she (very kindly) offered to pick us up from school after she's picked up her DS and have us ride with her. Her DS school is a 5 minute drive from my DS school. I didn't like the idea of being reliant on her for transport and said that but she insisted it wasn't a problem and that her DS would be so happy if my DS came along so I reluctantly accepted and said I'd contribute to petrol.

Very long story short it has become obvious that picking us up is a hindrance which is exactly what I was worried about and why I was reluctant to accept the offer in the first place.

For the last two weeks she (understandably) asked if we can make our own way there. The first time was a nightmare, I ordered an uber which cancelled so we jumped on the bus and then the bus terminated 5 minutes down the road and kicked everyone off. There was no way we were going to make it so I had to cancel.

Last week we got there just short of the 10 minute 'too late' cut off point due to the after school traffic. It just doesn't work.

I think the whole thing has left a bit of a bad taste for both of us. DS is now fully invested in the group will be upset when I inevitably have to bring it to an end but it is what it is.

I mean, I know drivers must find non drivers annoying when asked for lifts and that's exactly why I never have (or ever would of) asked or expected her to ferry us about. It didn't even occur to me as an option until.

AIBU to think she shouldn't have insisted?

OP posts:
Billie0900 · 26/09/2023 23:33

I've just looked into the holiday problem and the cost is for the accommodation itself not per person so the price won't change if me and DS are removed from the booking but she may incur an admin fee for removing us which I will offer to pay.

This will be an awkward conversation no doubt.

OP posts:
Billie0900 · 26/09/2023 23:31

My city is a lot like yours user there's not much need to own a car here as it's generally quicker getting about by tube. It's sods law that this particular group isn't easy to access by the tube and requires 2 busses.

OP posts:
user1477391263 · 26/09/2023 23:26

She doesn't sound very nice. And as a non-driver (I live in a nation/city where there is no need to drive and it's expensive to run a car and very hard to get a driver's license, so I've never bothered) I get annoyed by people who push lifts on people in a Mrs Doyle manner (refusing to take no for an answer) and then start moaning and carping about it. It's not an issue where I live, but my parents' town is very car dependent and it has happened during visits there. It really is the most frustrating behavior and I've learned to be really assertive in refusing after a bad experience like yours.

Billie0900 · 26/09/2023 23:26

FallingStar21 · 26/09/2023 23:18

@MariePaperRoses sounds like the trip has already been booked and now OP has to keep paying their share, so likely no option to get her money back. And the trip was booked before the issues with the lifts happened, so why wouldn't OP trust her friend?
OP I feel so sorry for you, I wish I could take you and your son to the club after school. That woman is a user and not caring about the difficult situation she's put you in, or how your DS would feel knowing he has to either quit or make a stressful journey which may result in being too late to even attend... Awful.
I say have a chat with your DS about a different hobby which is easy to get to, if he'd only started this club very recently he wouldn't be too invested anyway. Re: the trip, if you can't get your money back and have to continue paying, I'd still cut the losses and pay but not go and not bother with the "friend" again.

Thank you that's very kind.

It's crap for DS as does love it and would be sad not to go but I'm sure he'd get over it quickly if presented with an alternative.

He was quite upset when we had to cancel the week before last due to the travel issues when we were already on our way and it wouldn't be fair to make him deal with that on a regular basis.

I'm looking online now to see what else is available in our area.

RE the trip away it is already booked yes and is paid for monthly. I need to find out what happens when somebody amends a booking to remove guests. Hopefully it's a simple case of removing guests and recalculating. I'm paying her £30 a month (third month coming up)

OP posts:
FallingStar21 · 26/09/2023 23:18

@MariePaperRoses sounds like the trip has already been booked and now OP has to keep paying their share, so likely no option to get her money back. And the trip was booked before the issues with the lifts happened, so why wouldn't OP trust her friend?
OP I feel so sorry for you, I wish I could take you and your son to the club after school. That woman is a user and not caring about the difficult situation she's put you in, or how your DS would feel knowing he has to either quit or make a stressful journey which may result in being too late to even attend... Awful.
I say have a chat with your DS about a different hobby which is easy to get to, if he'd only started this club very recently he wouldn't be too invested anyway. Re: the trip, if you can't get your money back and have to continue paying, I'd still cut the losses and pay but not go and not bother with the "friend" again.

Billie0900 · 26/09/2023 23:17

MariePaperRoses · 26/09/2023 23:06

I can't believe you would trust someone like that!

Kiss your money goodbye!

I think you need to tell you want the money back NOW and that you won't be paying he want more!

Why on earth have you agreed to this? It beggars belief!

What is she was a lovely person but died? hour money would be gone.

The trip was planned before any of this cropped up and there were no issues at the time (beyond me not being that excited about going away with another family, not being able to do your own thing etc - I'm a bit of an introvert)

The idea that we go together was raised infront of the boys who were over the moon at the prospect. I was under a bit of pressure for an answer as booking it was time sensitive so I thought meh OK why not, I'll step outside my comdort zone and it'll be nice for the kids.

..and now this.

I'm going to pull out. Not sure what happens to her booking then, I assume they will just recalculate the amount required.

OP posts:
purpleme12 · 26/09/2023 23:10

You trusted her at her word. It's her that's in the wrong. You should be able to trust people

Billie0900 · 26/09/2023 23:09

I can definitely accept my part in that I shouldn't have accepted the lifts with no long term get out. I wasn't sure whether it was something DS would even want to stick at because he can be shy in groups but but it turns out he loves it.

I'm thinking I might try to arrange a weekly taxi to get us there for the rest of this term on the understanding that we will then have to find something closer to home as it's not something I can sustain all year round.

OP posts:
MariePaperRoses · 26/09/2023 23:06

Billie0900 · 26/09/2023 23:03

Thank you all for your take on it. It's good to get feedback.

I do wonder whether pulling back a bit is the best thing to do but there's an additional complication, we're supposed to be going away with them next year and I'm already paying X amount every month towards that (the trip is booked under her name as she gets a work related discount, I send her our contribution when she pays her installment every month)

Come to mention it, that's another thing I was on the fence about, was talked into and I'm now regretting.

I can't believe you would trust someone like that!

Kiss your money goodbye!

I think you need to tell you want the money back NOW and that you won't be paying he want more!

Why on earth have you agreed to this? It beggars belief!

What is she was a lovely person but died? hour money would be gone.

Billie0900 · 26/09/2023 23:03

Thank you all for your take on it. It's good to get feedback.

I do wonder whether pulling back a bit is the best thing to do but there's an additional complication, we're supposed to be going away with them next year and I'm already paying X amount every month towards that (the trip is booked under her name as she gets a work related discount, I send her our contribution when she pays her installment every month)

Come to mention it, that's another thing I was on the fence about, was talked into and I'm now regretting.

OP posts:
MiIaMae · 26/09/2023 23:02

Shes a user

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 26/09/2023 23:00

Yeah, she used you and your DS and now she doesn't need you she wants to stop giving lifts.

However, it must have been obvious that an arrangement like this would need to have an end date? If the boys have drifted away from each other, surely you could see this was coming?

Signing up for a long term club with this type of lift arrangement was very foolish on your part. Unless you were in the process of getting your own car and this was only ever going to be temporary, or the club was only for a young age group and they would move to a different location after a period of time.

Lou670 · 26/09/2023 22:55

I think the same as some of the other replies is that she was using your son to her own and her son's benefit. It sounds like her son would only attend if he was going with someone familiar to begin with. He has now probably got to know other students there. I think you have done nothing wrong and have offered petrol money. She should have thought about the logistics of the arrangement before insisting on it. Not very fair of her to let down your son like this. I would pull away a bit and enrol your son in an activity closer to home that you can get to easily with no stress.

Billie0900 · 26/09/2023 22:55

pinkfondu · 26/09/2023 22:49

Wow so she doesn't need you to entertain her anymore, your poor ds

:(

I do feel sad for him. He's a really sensitive and sweet little boy. He sees it as 'Ben and Jacks' club that they do together (not their names ofc)

I think my friend sees her DS friendships as more 'quantity above quality' if that makes sense. She's always on the look out to network and meet new people, which is great in terms of making friends, but then certain people move down the list as somebody more interesting or beneficial comes along.

OP posts:
Embarrassednamechangeadoddle · 26/09/2023 22:54

I can see why you would be annoyed. She insisted when it was convenient for her and her DS and now it isn’t it’s a problem. Leaving you with having to withdraw DS from the group.
A lesson for the future maybe that long term lifts rarely work as often the one giving them feels put out after a while whatever the circumstance. I feel for your Son though, is there another lesson anywhere that is more accessible?

padsi1975 · 26/09/2023 22:53

I take my kids friend to a club once a week. I offered and it's no problem. Sometimes it's a pain if we are running late but that's my problem, not theirs. I wouldn't dream of refusing to take the kid now, I'm going anyway. And I don't take petrol money as....I'm going anyway! Dick move on her part.

pinkfondu · 26/09/2023 22:49

Wow so she doesn't need you to entertain her anymore, your poor ds

Billie0900 · 26/09/2023 22:48

I think the boys have naturally grown apart a bit now that they've left nursery and gone off to different schools which is bound to happen, plus the additional factor of her DS now having another two of his friends at the group, my DS has become (as PP put it) a bit disposable.

I didn't know at the time that she was actively trying to recruit other friends to join the club. I thought it was something her DS wanted my DS to do with him specifically, which is largely why I agreed to the lifts.. so her DS would have somebody he knows there and it was something fun they could do together whilst we enjoyed a weekly catch up over coffee.

OP posts:
NutellaNut · 26/09/2023 22:47

I totally agree with the view that she used you and your DS when it suited her and now you’ve both become surplus to requirements. It’s not feasible to continue going by public transport for all the reasons you considered initially. I’d find a fun new activity somewhere near where you live for your DS to get involved in and back away from this friendship as she sounds like a user.

WandaWonder · 26/09/2023 22:45

You knew it was going to be trouble so you should not have arranged this, just withdraw and organise something local

IreneGoodnight · 26/09/2023 22:37

Your friend is being very unkind. She insisted on giving you lifts (which you chip in for) so your DS could keep her's happy. Has her DS found a new BF? These things happen but if so your friend owes you an honest explanation rather than leaving you and your DS in the lurch.

Flying724 · 26/09/2023 22:35

I know your DS will be disappointed but I would not continue with the class anymore because you can't guarantee you will get there on time. At the same time I will look to find something similar over the weekend or later in the evening the he can go to.Also don't tell her if you decide to pull him out and don't book a taxi there every week that is unsustainable in the long run but if you can afford it I don't see why you can't use that option.

Gymnopedie · 26/09/2023 22:35

So she didn't offer because she was being nice, she offered (and insisted) because she saw a big benefit to her. Now that benefit is no longer needed she is happy to drop you - and DS - without a second thought.

Not someone I'd call a friend. Leave her to the other mums, who will in their turn discover she's a bit of a user, and don't be available next time she insists you do something that actually is for her convenience.

Billie0900 · 26/09/2023 22:31

DelurkingLawyer · 26/09/2023 22:29

Unfortunately I think that your DS became dispensable. When she wanted her DS to have a friend there, giving a lift was a price she was prepared to pay. Now he’s got other friends he doesn’t need your DS and she very promptly extricated herself from giving a lift. A rare case where the lift giver was the CF.

This is pretty much exactly what I think too. I was reluctant to say as much in the OP as I was worried I'd sound bitter for my observations.

OP posts:
DelurkingLawyer · 26/09/2023 22:29

Unfortunately I think that your DS became dispensable. When she wanted her DS to have a friend there, giving a lift was a price she was prepared to pay. Now he’s got other friends he doesn’t need your DS and she very promptly extricated herself from giving a lift. A rare case where the lift giver was the CF.