Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand why people are so anti medication?

57 replies

Tambatamba · 26/09/2023 20:13

Specifically for mental health issues.

My 19 year old daughter has been really unwell and seems to have panic disorder. Finally, after not being able to start uni again because she was having 5 panic attacks a day, the GP agreed to give her some fluoxetine and TG it seems to be helping. I could cry, actually because it has been so hard watching her struggle.

The thing is that as a family, we all seem to suffer with MH. Quite a few of us also have autism (she doesn't though). Most of us are on SSRIs. I've been on sertraline for 10 years and even kept taking a low dose whilst I was pregnant.

All I hear, though is people sending me articles about how awful the side effects are. You 'can't take them forever.' Why can't you? If you lack enough serotonin to feel well why is it not ok to take meds to help this?

I feel like we haven't moved on much in terms of understanding that MH illness is not any different from having physical illness.

OP posts:
Nat6999 · 27/09/2023 03:35

I've been on AD'S since I was 17, so for 40 years. I look at it that if one of my other organs wasn't working without medication, I wouldn't question it. In my case, it's my brain that doesn't work.

Thethuthinang · 27/09/2023 02:22

I was treated with ADs for over 10 years. Over time, they became less and less effective, despite changes in the formula and the dose. One theory is that the brain becomes disturbed by the flood of serotonin and begins to shut down its own serotonin receptors, so that one becomes more and more resistant. One psychiatrist warned me that ADs are not intended for long term use, but I didn't really listen to her at first. At the end, my condition would not respond to any med at any dose. The side effects got bad, including memory loss so severe I had to quit my job. I became intensely suicidal. I realized I was going to die if I didn't come up with a plan B. The answer turned out to be EMDR, through which I realized that my depression was fundamentally driven by childhood trauma and some other factors. My new non-medication treatment put my depression into remission within months and resolved most of my anxiety. Today I view the medication as an unfortunate distraction from the real issues, a distraction which almost ended with me dead or in an institution. I recommend reading some peer reviewed studies of ADs concluding that they are neither as safe nor as effective as they are supposed to be. One author is Dr. Ed Piggott (not sure I spelled that right). His work has found that data showing adverse events and poor results was dropped without justification from initial studies. Other studies show that AD use increases the likelihood one will need more ADs in future.

Rudderneck · 27/09/2023 02:17

All medications can have significant side effects - potentially also unknown ones - and many doctors prescribe without taking the appropriate other measures.

A good example is medication for high cholesterol, prescribed on a massive level. which in fact only helps a tiny fraction of people. It should be retested and if not helping, be discontinued, as there are side effects. But few doctors check this. It's fast, easy medicine. Great for drug companies of course.

Psychiatric drugs are not really well understood, many have significant side effects, their effectiveness is tricky to measure because the placebo effect can be significant in many of those kind of illnesses, and there is some thought that recovering from depression without resorting to drugs is more long term than if drugs are used. There is a fair bit of consensus that they are over-prescribed. Possibly because it involves dealing with the deeper causes of the problem, or ameliorating them, by another .

The side effects aren't minor either. My father is currently in stage 4 kidney failure, largely die to decades taking these kinds of drugs. It will probably be what kills him. He's 70, so not young by any means, but younger than the average person who died of covid. Did he need them? Probably to some extent, but his psychiatrist made little attempt to minimize them, keep dosages as low as possible, or anything like that, despite them causing weight problems that contributed to the development of diabetes.When the drugs were finally looked at due to the kidney issues, most were stopped with no ill effects, other than clearing of a brain fog he didn't know he had.

Rudderneck · 27/09/2023 02:01

kizziee · 26/09/2023 20:36

The serotonin theory has been debunked recently which has led to increased criticism of anti depressants - but that doesn't mean that many people aren't helped by them.
If they work for you and you are happy taking them then ignore what other people say.

Not recently, it was always known to be false in the scientific community, and really the medical community too.

It was seen as a nice way to explain things to people and encourage them to take the drugs.

RobertaFirmino · 27/09/2023 01:27

I've been taking venlafaxine since 2009. It was the seventh AD I had tried and it was bloody miraculous! I've stopped a few times and have been back at rock bottom within 3 months.
I've been diagnosed with all kinds of psychiatric disorders over the years, usually with whatever is 'trendy' at the time. In my mind it is simply that my body cannot make enough serotonin and norepinephrine to keep my mood stable. The last psychiatrist I saw agrees with me.
If you had any other condition where your body wasn't making enough of what it needed to stay healthy, you'd accept it and take the relevant medication. This is no different.
BTW, antidepressants do not make you happy. If they did, they'd be called euphorics. They just prevent depression. You have to do the rest of the work yourself but the tablets give you the 'oomph' to do it.

Fallingthroughclouds · 27/09/2023 00:39

kizziee · 26/09/2023 20:36

The serotonin theory has been debunked recently which has led to increased criticism of anti depressants - but that doesn't mean that many people aren't helped by them.
If they work for you and you are happy taking them then ignore what other people say.

Interesting. Have any alternatives been suggested? and I'm not talking about talking therapies, mindfulness etc.

NooNooHead1981 · 27/09/2023 00:36

DaisyWaldron · 26/09/2023 22:42

Ooh, I got tardive dyskinesia too, from fluoxetine, but I was lucky as mine cleared up shortly after I came off the fluoxetine.

I'm so glad to hear yours got better 💖✨ It's a condition that I wouldn't wish upon my worst enemy 😱😫

kizziee · 26/09/2023 22:43

Thanks @DirectionToPerfection
(I take them.)

DaisyWaldron · 26/09/2023 22:42

Ooh, I got tardive dyskinesia too, from fluoxetine, but I was lucky as mine cleared up shortly after I came off the fluoxetine.

ilovebagpuss · 26/09/2023 22:37

I agree with your sentiments op. My DD has had her later teens saved by medication and who knows possibly her life.
I have always seen it as the same as physical medication as we learn more about the brain and hormonal/chemical issues.
Of course there are those that worry I do too but I can see the benefits and am grateful for that.
I also appreciate medication for mental health is not always for everyone and respect their choice.
My DD's psychiatrist said you can't expect a teen to think themselves out of a mental health crisis anymore than you could think yourself better from a chest infection, you need help to fight.
Then you can build in strategies and so on as they feel less under attack.

Beezknees · 26/09/2023 22:22

I dislike taking medication myself for physical pain, I only do if it's really bad. For regular coughs and colds I just ride it out. Personal choice though. Very fortunately I've never had issues with mental health but I absolutely wouldn't judge anyone taking medication for it.

DirectionToPerfection · 26/09/2023 22:22

kizziee · 26/09/2023 20:36

The serotonin theory has been debunked recently which has led to increased criticism of anti depressants - but that doesn't mean that many people aren't helped by them.
If they work for you and you are happy taking them then ignore what other people say.

Debunked, really?

You should have a read of this, from the very reputable BMJ:

https://www.bmj.com/content/381/bmj.p1419

Review that questioned serotonin theory of depression was flawed, say researchers

A group of scientists have said a review which concluded there was no consistent evidence of a relationship between serotonin and depression was biased and seriously flawed.1 Last July a systematic umbrella review, published in Molecular Psychiatry ,...

https://www.bmj.com/content/381/bmj.p1419

loseridiot · 26/09/2023 22:14

Sorry to all those who are suffering.

I'm supposed to take AD's but don't because I'm ashamed and also believe I deserve to suffer rather than take them and maybe feel better.

Greenfinch7 · 26/09/2023 22:10

I'm saying both. When people say to take medication for mental illness because you wouldn't hesitate to take antibiotics for an infection or ibuprofen for pain, I just find myself thinking: the brain is even more complex than the rest of the body, and the treatments are not as well understood.

WrongSwanson · 26/09/2023 22:09

NooNooHead1981 · 26/09/2023 22:04

Me too. Can I ask you what the neurological condition you have is please? Mine is called tardive dyskinesia and it was caused by an off label first generation typical antipsychotic called Pericyazine.

Myasthenia gravis

NooNooHead1981 · 26/09/2023 22:04

WrongSwanson · 26/09/2023 21:25

I took various psychiatric medicines and whilst they probably saved my life, one caused substantial weight gain and the other triggered a lifelong neurological condition. So whilst I am glad they saved my life,.they definitely aren't something I would take lightly.

Same with any medicine, I recently became desperately ill and eventually doctors worked out it was the medication I was taking.

So yes, medicines are sometimes necessary but a degree of caution is sensible too

Me too. Can I ask you what the neurological condition you have is please? Mine is called tardive dyskinesia and it was caused by an off label first generation typical antipsychotic called Pericyazine.

NooNooHead1981 · 26/09/2023 22:02

DaisyWaldron · 26/09/2023 20:41

I'm all for medication for people who find it effective, but I've had a lot of serious/extremely unpleasant side effects from a quite a few drugs, so I tend to choose other options if they are available/reasonably effective. Not in a "drugs are bad" way, but in a "my body really doesn't tend to react well to drugs" way.

This, the same for me too.

I have a medication induced neurological involuntary movement disorder called tardive dyskinesia that was caused by some prescribed off label antipsychotic during a breakdown after a head injury and post concussion syndrome.

Unfortunately, after nearly a decade of living with this shitty disorder where literally parts of my body will move on their own without my control - like my tongue in my mouth - I have a few hang ups about psychotropic drugs, as you can imagine.

Plus, I have had terrible adverse effects from seemingly innocuous substances too after, including things like antifungal creams like Canesten - so you can see why I am not so in love with medication.

But of course, this is just my opinion and is subjective. If I'd never been injured by psychotropic meds, I'd not be so biased or against them.

vipersnest1 · 26/09/2023 21:57

@Greenfinch7, can you clarify your post please? I'm not sure whether you are saying that mental illnesses are not comparable to physical illnesses, or that mental illnesses are more difficult to diagnose (or maybe both)?

Greenfinch7 · 26/09/2023 21:37

I don't really agree with what you say in the OP: 'MH illness is not any different from having physical illness'. Perhaps some mental illnesses can be compared to complex issues like autoimmune conditions or post viral fatigue, but I don't think depression or anxiety can be compared to a broken leg or a bout of pneumonia. They are not as well understood, have complex causes and effects, and are often more difficult to diagnose. Doctors understand how antibiotics or ivermectin work (of course nothing is 100%), but the working of the human brain is very complicated, poorly understood, and poorly controlled.

Velvetpaws75 · 26/09/2023 21:28

Any decision about medication is between you and your doctor
Nobody else's business

Even if they prefer to rub themselves with crystals and run widdershins around a rowan tree or whatever best of luck to them
Personally I will stick with the meds that help me
Your body ( and mind), your choice

WrongSwanson · 26/09/2023 21:25

I took various psychiatric medicines and whilst they probably saved my life, one caused substantial weight gain and the other triggered a lifelong neurological condition. So whilst I am glad they saved my life,.they definitely aren't something I would take lightly.

Same with any medicine, I recently became desperately ill and eventually doctors worked out it was the medication I was taking.

So yes, medicines are sometimes necessary but a degree of caution is sensible too

vipersnest1 · 26/09/2023 21:22

@Tambatamba, I can identify with you - one of my DCs had to drop out of sixth form due to extremely poor mental health. Mental health services here were, at the time, absolutely useless (kept downgrading the referral, eventually offered a telephone call seven months later, which DC would not take as they were so anxious).

Somewhere around two years after the initial 'breakdown', they, eventually, were receptive to the idea of medication (they had looked it up on the internet and all of the advice was to not be medicated).

Two and a half years down the line, after starting fluoxetine, things gradually started to improve - so much so that recovery meant wanting to do something with their life, starting to study an A level of their choice, but then going on to do an apprenticeship in the same subject.

It's a couple of years on now, DC was successful in their apprenticeship, now has a permanent job, and is lined up to do the next stage of their qualification (via another apprenticeship), which will then mean they can work for themself if they want.

It's been amazing. We've gone from the days of not even being able to get dressed to go to school, to DC living and working independently.
It was awful at the time and took a toll on my own mental health.

In answer to your question, I think that poor mental health seems to have a stigma still, and that if you suffer from it, you are somehow lesser. That's not true of course, and totally negates what those experiencing it and their families go through.
Meanwhile, I am taking antidepressants - I started back on them when DC was going through their bad patch, and then came off them afterwards, but am now taking them again due to a life-changing diagnosis which impacts my daily life.
I'm not ashamed of it. Life has given me a few hard knocks and I've found it difficult to deal with. Many people don't feel comfortable in saying that, I know.

That was a huge word bundle, but in essence, I think you're a fabulous mum for sticking with it for your DD. I know how tough it is. Flowers

Shadypaws23 · 26/09/2023 21:20

Even for physical illness
I get "oh you should take vitamins for that"
If a vitamin worked for my immune system I wouldn't be injecting a bone marrow drug would I?!

Or "oh I could never take a drug with those side effects/increased cancer risk"
It wasn't really an option...

pizzaHeart · 26/09/2023 21:14

@Ahwig it’s such a horrible thing to say and completely untrue.

pizzaHeart · 26/09/2023 21:12

I think any medication should be considered seriously and I’m in “be careful “ camp for all of them. I was prescribed setraline once but the list of possible side effects was quite scary so I delayed (we were about to go on holiday) and then I felt a bit better and decided against it. In my case there was also feeling that instead of looking carefully into all possible medical aspects GP just prescribed AD. She didn’t check my vitamins level, blood, etc. I suppose I fitted certain profile: early 40s, exhausted anxious mum of disabled child of course I needed AD to cope with my difficult life. There was no counseling available just Silver Cloud online, unsupported - so not much choice.
My point is that I’m not against medication for MH, however I feel that in some cases medications for MH issues are prescribed too quickly. I’m for careful checking of all medical aspects and offering to patients a range of options. But this is my approach for all medications, I don’t discriminate against e.g AD in particular.

Swipe left for the next trending thread