Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It's a neighbours and driveway dispute one. Who IBU

142 replies

Whatthematter · 26/09/2023 19:28

Name changed as the the diagram required is very outing. No idea if my neighbours post on mumsnet, but if they do, hello!

4 houses all bought at the same time. The dotted yellow area was agreeed on purchase to be shared between the 4 houses. This is marked on land registry and the land is split between the 4. There's the right agreements in place for access to the yellow bit only. Fairly common in these kind of sets ups. It was explained when purchased any changes to this land would have to be agreed by all parties and costs etc. Shared equally. It was also explained that access must be maintained.

The yellow bit is gravel. The gravel wasn't well installed by the builders and as gravel does, it spreads a bit. Its also larger gravel not pea shingle type gravel. So a little more annoying generally.

When they moved in all the houses discussed potentially swapping the gravel to block paving. Nothing was formally agreed, but there was a consensus it may look better. But no one wanted to do anything until the rest of the development was complete. There was also some concerns about cost and finances as several parties explained they didn't have the money to hand.

So now to the Who IBU question.

Houses 2, 3 and 4 are now wanting to get the blocked paving done. They've been getting quotes. However house 1 are saying they no longer want to do the driveway with blocked paving.

The reasons cited are

  1. They had to replace a bathroom in their 3 year old house recently due to a water leak and resulting damaging. Costing they say £8k. The builders would not cover this or any of the resulting damage and the LABC cover would also not cover despite it being due to i stallation error. Houses 2, 3 and 4 have thankfully not had these issues. Although they apparently have some savings using them would mean they were left with very little as a contingency. Which with cost of living and job insecurity they're worried about.

  2. They have now decided they prefer gravel. Their driveway is 'blind' coming out so prefer the gravel as they can hear. They also have a young child so gravel is a good warning of car. Other parts of the development with blocked paving encourage high speeds from residents and delivery drivers, which they're concerned about. They also prefer gravel as it improves security.

  3. The driveway doesn't impact them hugely visually. They have tarmac to the front of their house. They struggle to see the benefit in spending potentially £6-7k on something that offers minimal benefit. They cite if they had that money spare they'd rather spend this on things they've not done in their home that would benefit them more.

  4. They have concerns about maintaince. The parking driveways for houses at the moment is block paved and has constant weeds. No one really maintains their own that well. They have concerns about long term maintaince of it.

They agree the current gravel isn't ideal. As an alterntive to blocked paving they have suggested getting quotes for laying pea shingle and a proper base. Which would cost less. They have also offered to put some gravel of the current kind and rake it out which they believe would improve the look. Houses 2, 3 and 4 are against this as gravel is too dusty and noisy.

So Who is being unreasonable?

YANBU = Houses 2, 3 and 4 are right. It needs block paving and house 1 should suck it up and find the cash.

YABU = House 1 is right. Their reasons are valid and houses 2, 3 and 4 should be more open to the alternatives.

Or other. Let me know.

It's a neighbours and driveway dispute one. Who IBU
OP posts:
HakunaMatiÅ‚da · 26/09/2023 20:55

Why didn’t you go through home insurance for
the leak?

SilentHedges · 26/09/2023 20:53

I'm in agreement with you OP and House 1. Although no one is wrong or right in their preferences, the wording of the terms is clear and House's 2-4 can't just go ahead without your contribution either. I have a gravel drive and agree with a lot of reasons you've cited. It's low maintenance and incredible for security or to know people or a car is approaching. I get that's its annoying for the other houses if that's what they want to do, but you can't force House 1 to pay for something they don't want doing, or don't have the funds for. Their retaliation is incredibly petty and I'm sorry you're in this situation.

Louchelizard · 26/09/2023 20:53

No one is being unreasonable, but if House 1 don’t want it, whatever the reason, it’s the end of it isn’t it?

Whatthematter · 26/09/2023 20:52

IncompleteSenten · 26/09/2023 20:50

Ignore me. I apparently can't read the difference between 1 and 4 🤦
I also can't figure out how to delete the useless picture 😂

Edited

No because house 4 wants block paving.

OP posts:
Vitriolinsanity · 26/09/2023 20:51

If gravel is a driving security measure they need to seriously rethink their driving license, otherwise if they can't afford it that's down to the other three to suck up or put up.

IncompleteSenten · 26/09/2023 20:50

Ignore me. I apparently can't read the difference between 1 and 4 🤦
I also can't figure out how to delete the useless picture 😂

It's a neighbours and driveway dispute one. Who IBU
smallshinybutton · 26/09/2023 20:49

House 1 just has to say sorry I can't justify the expenditure

OhmygodDont · 26/09/2023 20:46

Look they already don’t like you so who cares. You don’t want to spend what little savings you still have left and that’s fair.

If they want to pay though I’d also let them too hell with worrying About them judging any spending. You also purchased your house knowing it was blind access so that’s a silly point.

Hate this whole house 1,2,3,4 to start with it was always clear to to see the house 1 would be the one posting as nobody else would know that much about house 1.

Throwncrumbs · 26/09/2023 20:45

For what it’s worth I think houses 2,3 and 4 are being spiteful and nasty. I wouldn’t do it for that reason alone. How dare they decide how house 1 should spend their money!

CallieTR · 26/09/2023 20:44

We’ve been in a similar situation recently and couldn’t afford the work the neighbours wanted done.

We just shut it down with ‘we can’t afford it’. It’s none of their business what we choose to spend our money on.

Throwncrumbs · 26/09/2023 20:42

SisterMichaelsHabit · 26/09/2023 19:41

I think house 1 is being ridiculous and just scraping the bottom of the barrel looking for reasons to avoid spending money on this driveway that would benefit all of them. House 1 is not very prosocial. Some examples:

They have now decided they prefer gravel. Their driveway is 'blind' coming out so prefer the gravel as they can hear. They also have a young child so gravel is a good warning of car. Other parts of the development with blocked paving encourage high speeds from residents and delivery drivers, which they're concerned about. They also prefer gravel as it improves security.

Total rubbish. When house 1's DC can't ride their ride-on toys on the gravel, can't cycle on it when older so go and play out of sight of their house, or when they're running on it and faceplant and house 1's adults have to clean cuts on the DC's hands, knees, elbows and face, and deal with a very upset child, they'll realise what a ridiculous stretch this argument is.

They could also put a speed bump in to slow people down.

According to the diagram, if they think their driveway is "blind" they're too blind to be driving vehicles. They should at the very least start reverse parking but really they need to stop driving until they get an eye test.

The driveway doesn't impact them hugely visually. They have tarmac to the front of their house. They struggle to see the benefit in spending potentially £6-7k on something that offers minimal benefit. They cite if they had that money spare they'd rather spend this on things they've not done in their home that would benefit them more.

Very NIMBY of them. It would directly benefit them by making a place near their house where their DC can play and explore more easily. It would directly benefit them in 12-18 months time when the road is pitted with massive holes from where the gravel has subsided due to the way cars, bin lorries, delivery vans etc drive over it. Giant gravel is notorious for this. This damages cars.

I feel sorry for the other houses that house 1 are being so obstructive tbh. I mean fair enough if they just couldn't afford it at all ever, but it sounds like they've overspent on doing their house up (why wasn't it insured?) and instead of responding with "let's block pave it in 6 months or a year or two when we've saved up" their response is all these nonsense made up non-reasons why they don't want to do it.

Edited

Why would house one let their kids play outside on the gravel or block paving if there’s cars, bin lorries and delivery drivers driving around there, that’s a ridiculous statement!

Birch101 · 26/09/2023 20:39

Maybe get some information about gravel grids from reputable sources and see if that will help address neighbour's concerns.

I don't personally understand the dusty comment but have always had smaller gravel.
I get their noise comment on a shared road

AnonAnonandAriston · 26/09/2023 20:34

It's pretty much a moot point, to change it requires all parties to agree (and pay) and house 1 doesn't want to. The other 3 can't force them so they have to just accept it

ActDottie · 26/09/2023 20:33

If house 1 can’t afford it or don’t want it then not much can be done. You can’t touch the bit on their deeds.

Lovingitallnow · 26/09/2023 20:25

I feel for house one. If it were me I'd rather spend my money on a holiday or couch or whatever. I can understand how youd be worried that if the other three split it they'd be raising an eye brow at every take away or delivery that arrived. "Couldn't afford the driveway but plenty of asos bags rocking up etc"

Whatthematter · 26/09/2023 20:18

caerdydd12 · 26/09/2023 20:05

I'm assuming you are house 1 then?

If it isn't really about finances then you need to look at what your contracts say about non agreement and whether the majority can proceed if they cover the cost. If not, then only you know whether houses 2-4 will seek legal action to force it through anyway.

Houses 2,3 and 4 have been quite hostile to house 1 for a while. Ignoring them, deliberately driving on their driveway to bate them.

House 1 cannot afford it without risking having no savings and with insecure jobs and the prospect of further children is a huge risk. House 1 did have money set aside for this as was aware it was wanted by the other houses. However this money went to fixing their bathroom and the subsequent water damage.

Houses 2,3 and 4's recent actions suggest that they would be likely to scruitise house 1's expenditure. They have been clear they don't like them. However no idea if they'd force it. As i know at one point they didnt have the money for the driveway either. So not sure they could afford a legal route.

Yes I am house 1.

OP posts:
NoSquirrels · 26/09/2023 20:17

House 1 doesn't want houses 2, 3 and 4 to split the cost as it leaves them fearful for their every expenditure being scrutinised going forward. It also doesn't outweigh their other concerns.

If I was your neighbours I’d be pissed off with you, but if you don’t want it done and you’re able to insist it isn’t done, then don’t worry about it.

The wording of the agreement is the key. Because if I was houses 2, 3 &4 and I REALLY wanted it done, I’d think I was in the majority and might as well press ahead and pay for it.

Cosycover · 26/09/2023 20:16

Just say you're house 1

Whatthematter · 26/09/2023 20:09

Crazycatlady83 · 26/09/2023 19:55

Does the agreement you have in place provide for what to do in the event it cannot be agreed between the houses, what happens with the maintenance of the yellow bit?

I dont believe it does. We were advised this was the downside to this arrangement. It was hashed together pretty quickly so I doubt this was thiught of. But a good point that i'll check.

OP posts:
Redbushteaforme · 26/09/2023 20:09

I think House 1 is being quite reasonable. Also, you will have to think about who pays for the cost of maintaining the block paving going forward. It can be a nightmare for attracting weeds and moss etc, and gets discoloured so will likely need pressure-washed every so often. Plus, gravel is rain-permeable so better for the environment/less likely to contribute to flooding problems.

Whatthematter · 26/09/2023 20:07

SisterMichaelsHabit · 26/09/2023 19:41

I think house 1 is being ridiculous and just scraping the bottom of the barrel looking for reasons to avoid spending money on this driveway that would benefit all of them. House 1 is not very prosocial. Some examples:

They have now decided they prefer gravel. Their driveway is 'blind' coming out so prefer the gravel as they can hear. They also have a young child so gravel is a good warning of car. Other parts of the development with blocked paving encourage high speeds from residents and delivery drivers, which they're concerned about. They also prefer gravel as it improves security.

Total rubbish. When house 1's DC can't ride their ride-on toys on the gravel, can't cycle on it when older so go and play out of sight of their house, or when they're running on it and faceplant and house 1's adults have to clean cuts on the DC's hands, knees, elbows and face, and deal with a very upset child, they'll realise what a ridiculous stretch this argument is.

They could also put a speed bump in to slow people down.

According to the diagram, if they think their driveway is "blind" they're too blind to be driving vehicles. They should at the very least start reverse parking but really they need to stop driving until they get an eye test.

The driveway doesn't impact them hugely visually. They have tarmac to the front of their house. They struggle to see the benefit in spending potentially £6-7k on something that offers minimal benefit. They cite if they had that money spare they'd rather spend this on things they've not done in their home that would benefit them more.

Very NIMBY of them. It would directly benefit them by making a place near their house where their DC can play and explore more easily. It would directly benefit them in 12-18 months time when the road is pitted with massive holes from where the gravel has subsided due to the way cars, bin lorries, delivery vans etc drive over it. Giant gravel is notorious for this. This damages cars.

I feel sorry for the other houses that house 1 are being so obstructive tbh. I mean fair enough if they just couldn't afford it at all ever, but it sounds like they've overspent on doing their house up (why wasn't it insured?) and instead of responding with "let's block pave it in 6 months or a year or two when we've saved up" their response is all these nonsense made up non-reasons why they don't want to do it.

Edited

Think i've found that my neighbours do post on mumsnet haha.

The parking is blind. The fence from.the rear back garden juts out quote far. They can't reverse park as they have a hybrid car they charge from the garage and the charger doesn't go far enough...they've tried.

As for cycling etc. Houses 2,3 and 4 bought the houses knowing the situation and the gravel. There is plenty of other space to cycle, scooter or whatever.

House 1 has done far less to their house than the other houses. They havent really decorated, or done much really. They had a baby just after moving in. Changed jobs through no fault of their own. Other neighbours have landscaped their gardens, installed swimming pools etc. House 1 has no done this type of work. The bathroom wasn't covered by insurance. Despite appeals. Legal advice co firmed the builders were liable but advice was even if they won getting the money would have been near on impossible.

OP posts:
Fleasbane · 26/09/2023 20:06

It was explained when purchased any changes to this land would have to be agreed by all parties and costs etc. Shared equally. It was also explained that access must be maintained.

That seems pretty clear. I do think if houses 2-4 are willing to pay for block paving though that house 1 should thank their lucky stars.

caerdydd12 · 26/09/2023 20:05

Whatthematter · 26/09/2023 20:02

House 1 doesn't want houses 2, 3 and 4 to split the cost as it leaves them fearful for their every expenditure being scrutinised going forward. It also doesn't outweigh their other concerns.

I'm assuming you are house 1 then?

If it isn't really about finances then you need to look at what your contracts say about non agreement and whether the majority can proceed if they cover the cost. If not, then only you know whether houses 2-4 will seek legal action to force it through anyway.

GrumpyPanda · 26/09/2023 20:03

Depends what the decision-making rules are. I'm based in Germany and under local laws decisions on jointly owned property are taken by majority decision and binding on all owners. (If the 3 majority owners had decided to install Carrara marble all over the shared access I imagine house 1 might have legal recourse. Then again, the city of Böblingen, home of Daimler Benz, installed zebra crossings in said marble and claimed it was because they were being frugal - the stuff lasts longer doncha see...)

AnSolas · 26/09/2023 20:02

If the contract agreement is maintain that is "keep the same"
Block etc is bettermet so house 1 has a right not to pay for the change of materials.

If house 1 has not got the money they are not going to agree to pay for any change.

So the question is can they veto the other 3 paying for the change and are the 3 houses willing to take on the extra cost.