Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It's a neighbours and driveway dispute one. Who IBU

142 replies

Whatthematter · 26/09/2023 19:28

Name changed as the the diagram required is very outing. No idea if my neighbours post on mumsnet, but if they do, hello!

4 houses all bought at the same time. The dotted yellow area was agreeed on purchase to be shared between the 4 houses. This is marked on land registry and the land is split between the 4. There's the right agreements in place for access to the yellow bit only. Fairly common in these kind of sets ups. It was explained when purchased any changes to this land would have to be agreed by all parties and costs etc. Shared equally. It was also explained that access must be maintained.

The yellow bit is gravel. The gravel wasn't well installed by the builders and as gravel does, it spreads a bit. Its also larger gravel not pea shingle type gravel. So a little more annoying generally.

When they moved in all the houses discussed potentially swapping the gravel to block paving. Nothing was formally agreed, but there was a consensus it may look better. But no one wanted to do anything until the rest of the development was complete. There was also some concerns about cost and finances as several parties explained they didn't have the money to hand.

So now to the Who IBU question.

Houses 2, 3 and 4 are now wanting to get the blocked paving done. They've been getting quotes. However house 1 are saying they no longer want to do the driveway with blocked paving.

The reasons cited are

  1. They had to replace a bathroom in their 3 year old house recently due to a water leak and resulting damaging. Costing they say £8k. The builders would not cover this or any of the resulting damage and the LABC cover would also not cover despite it being due to i stallation error. Houses 2, 3 and 4 have thankfully not had these issues. Although they apparently have some savings using them would mean they were left with very little as a contingency. Which with cost of living and job insecurity they're worried about.

  2. They have now decided they prefer gravel. Their driveway is 'blind' coming out so prefer the gravel as they can hear. They also have a young child so gravel is a good warning of car. Other parts of the development with blocked paving encourage high speeds from residents and delivery drivers, which they're concerned about. They also prefer gravel as it improves security.

  3. The driveway doesn't impact them hugely visually. They have tarmac to the front of their house. They struggle to see the benefit in spending potentially £6-7k on something that offers minimal benefit. They cite if they had that money spare they'd rather spend this on things they've not done in their home that would benefit them more.

  4. They have concerns about maintaince. The parking driveways for houses at the moment is block paved and has constant weeds. No one really maintains their own that well. They have concerns about long term maintaince of it.

They agree the current gravel isn't ideal. As an alterntive to blocked paving they have suggested getting quotes for laying pea shingle and a proper base. Which would cost less. They have also offered to put some gravel of the current kind and rake it out which they believe would improve the look. Houses 2, 3 and 4 are against this as gravel is too dusty and noisy.

So Who is being unreasonable?

YANBU = Houses 2, 3 and 4 are right. It needs block paving and house 1 should suck it up and find the cash.

YABU = House 1 is right. Their reasons are valid and houses 2, 3 and 4 should be more open to the alternatives.

Or other. Let me know.

It's a neighbours and driveway dispute one. Who IBU
OP posts:
PrimalLass · 27/09/2023 10:12

Just compromise on tarmac. Gravel is a pain in the neck.

Collaborate · 27/09/2023 10:06

As they have a right of way over the quarter of road you won they also have the right to make the surface better. They cannot force you to get involved but you cannot stop them improving it. You cannot be made to maintain it unless the deeds say you must.

Those who want the new surface should pay for it.

OlizraWiteomQua · 27/09/2023 10:00

Houses 2,3&4 cannot corporately decide anything that house1 doesn't agree to which will cost house1 money. If houses 2,3&4 really want this change and house1 consents if they don't have to pay up, then 2,3&4 should split the cost 3-ways between them with no detriment to house1.

If house1 doesn't consent to the change then it will come down to the exact wording of the agreement. If changes can only be made with unanimous consensus then they have every right to withold their consent. There may be another way to address their concern - if the main issue is that they appreciate the way that approaching vehicles make a noise, there could be a technical solution if a proximity sensor of some kind could be installed to make a chime noise when anyone uses the paved area?

alloalloallo · 27/09/2023 09:56

I’m with house 1 too.

We live in a little tiny private cul de sac which has been block paved

It looked great for the first few years, but now it looks awful. Loads of sunken blocks, some are missing, they’re faded and it needs weeding all the time.

Our driveway is still gravel and so is the house opposite - all laid at the same time - the gravel looks a million times better and a lot easier to maintain.

Originally we all had gravel driveways but some neighbours changed to block paving. Pretty much all of those who changed wish they hadn’t

ProbablyNotMad · 27/09/2023 09:54

I would stand my ground. I wouldn't be spending money on something I didn't want doing.

I would vehemently oppose a block drive that was shared. You would only have arguments over maintenance of it when it becomes full of weeds. Block drives look awful without regular depending and sweeping.

Our drive needs doing and I have been looking at what to do. I quite like resin but the cost is substantial as it is a large drive that can take about 6 cars. Gravel is an option but I don't like walking on it and it is messy. I have reluctantly decided that Tarmac is probably best. Not the prettiest but is practical - hard-wearing, tidy, and low maintenance.

If are open to changing it maybe suggest tarmac as a less maintenance, more cost effective option. If you like and want gravel then keep saying no and ignore them.

20cheeseomelette · 27/09/2023 09:42

I’m with House 1. Gravel better for security, looks better, less weeds, slower driving, less flooding, etc, etc.

It’s shitty to pressure people into spending thousands and the reasons for change are not compelling.

HalliwellManor · 27/09/2023 09:41

If house 1 can't afford it then they can't afford it,end of the matter.
If the other 3 houses want it so badly then they need to pay the costs between them.

Financiallyopposite · 27/09/2023 09:34

Stop giving them any explanation as to why you can't afford it/don't want to spend the money on doing it. It's none of their business and you'll get yourself in to a situation where they're waiting for you to have the money. I'm guilty of this as I think we all are when under pressure but don't over explain.
I can't believe someone said the gravel makes it look like a farmyard, I don't think I would have been able to keep a straight face! I'd just moo at them to be honest.
If they keep going on about it, stand your ground and either show them the blocked driveway nearby that's in disrepair and ask why that is preferable to them. Or passively aggressively tell them you don't think a house with a shared access driveway is for them.

5foot5 · 27/09/2023 09:26

Throwncrumbs · 26/09/2023 20:45

For what it’s worth I think houses 2,3 and 4 are being spiteful and nasty. I wouldn’t do it for that reason alone. How dare they decide how house 1 should spend their money!

Hear, hear!

@SisterMichaelsHabit Which number are you?

5foot5 · 27/09/2023 09:23

Crazycrazylady · 26/09/2023 21:17

I think the paving would look far better and I get why the other three houses would want it . I also probably think the other three houses don't believe your 'new' reasons for not wanting it after previously agreeing provisionally and probably think you are hoping that they will cover the complete cost. Have you don't them you won't agree even if they pay for it?
Of course you are within your rights not to agree but I'd hate to have frosty relationships with all my nearest neighbours but it sounds like ye don't get on anyway so that's probably not a consideration.

Quite apart from financial considerations I think their "new" reasons, as you call them, are perfectly valid and are the sort of things you would only realise when you had lived somewhere for a while.

Yes the blocked paving might seem ideal at first, but the OP's points about the state this gets in with weeds are very valid and they only have to look at other parts of their estate as proof. Are neighbours 2,3 and 4 willing to do all the maintenance to keep it looking nice. Or will they be proposing further expenditure to get someone in to maintain it?

Oooooooooooo1 · 27/09/2023 08:56

The agreement says you've ALL got to agree , you don't so that's the case shut
No discussion needed

Hatesf1 · 27/09/2023 08:54

I’m with house 1 in this scenario

Dotjones · 27/09/2023 08:50

I'm confused as to what you mean by the other people scrutinizing your expenditure? The properties were bought with their being gravel and everyone agreed that any changes would require the agreement of all four owners. So if one owner doesn't agree things just stay as they are. If house one agrees that the others can pay to have the work done then as long as there is a lawfully signed contract in which the others legally agree that house one doesn't have to pay anything there's no "scrutinizing" that can be done in legal terms. The only danger is if there's an informal agreement, the others could press on with the work and then rely on the original terms that costs were shared between all four houses.

DownNative · 27/09/2023 08:34

caerdydd12 · 26/09/2023 19:31

If house 1 can't afford it then they can't afford it, bottom line.

If house 2-4 are willing to share the cost between the 3 of them you might find house 1's no financial reasons don't matter as much to them.

The agreement states that not only do all residents have to agree on changes, but the costs have to be shared equally?

Even if the other three want to cover it, they still can't legally proceed.🤷‍♂️

IncomingTraffic · 27/09/2023 08:32

@SisterMichaelsHabit thats not what NIMBY means. It means preventing further development because it will spoil your view etc. Not refusing to pay for something, and be responsible for the ongoing maintenance, just because your neighbours want it. Even more so when it’s a shared resource and you don’t think the change is an improvement.

Or should the neighbours just get to decide how other people spend their money because they fancy some block paving?

GRex · 27/09/2023 08:28

Whatthematter · 26/09/2023 21:02

I wanted to try 'no is a complete sentence'. But I was blindsided by a woman on my doorstep moaning about dust and noise and caught off guard.

Edited

This one nails it. They can't force you to spend money upgrading when you don't want to, and whatever money you have, lack or spend is entirely your own business.

Personally I despise gravel and I'd prefer asphalt; cheaper at £10/sqft and easier to maintain than block paving. Could that be a future compromise?

VenusClapTrap · 27/09/2023 08:27

Nobody is right or wrong. If there isn’t agreement, then the status quo remains.

Shared drives/access are a bitch. They always cause trouble. We are on a private road that is basically a dirt track, full of potholes. We will never get all eight houses that are on it to agree to measures to sort it out, so potholes it is, forever.

Orders76 · 27/09/2023 08:02

House 234 do the blocks from the road after house 1 and everyone gets what they want?

MentholLoad · 27/09/2023 08:02

who pays £7k for unnecessary building work??

BillStickersWillBeProsocuted · 27/09/2023 08:01

I haven't RTFT but:

"It was explained when purchased any changes to this land would have to be agreed by all parties"

It's not agreed my all parties - where is the confusion?

Lemondrizzlelele · 27/09/2023 07:56

I have a block driveway too. We actually chose this and for 4 years it looked lovely. In year 6 I'm now having to weed it all the bloody time. And as a previous poster said, the ants bloody love it too. It's faded a lot (our fault for not dealing it I guess). No way would I get an actually drive that 4 cars share done with it!
My neighbours got that concrete done that they make impressions in? And dye? Looked lovely for 3 years but again has faded loads and now also has cracks.
Ultimately I've come to the conclusion that no driveway is excellent but I think resin is probably the best from what I've seen. Expensive though

Doingmybest12 · 27/09/2023 07:52

I wouldn't be happy with block paving from the look,maintenance and weeding situation. Sounds like a difficult position to be in OP.

Ohthatsabitshit · 27/09/2023 07:45

234
”Would you like to share the cost of changing the shared road surface outside our houses”

1
”No we wouldn’t we like it as is”

I suppose 234 could say
”if we pay for it would you like it”

but 1 could respond
“no I wouldn’t”

@Atticustheaardvark you owe your neighbour an apology.

Spodey · 27/09/2023 07:05

You may find that you need planning permission to convert the gravel to block paving. There’s a certain maximum area that you’re allowed to pave without permission, I believe it’s something like six square metres. If the area is bigger than that you need planning permission. This is often why large areas have gravel in the first place, because they couldn’t get planning permission to pave it.

Motnight · 27/09/2023 06:43

If house 1 can't afford it surely that's the end of the matter? You could agree to review in say 18 months time.

Really hope that house 1 isn't giving loads of reasons to the other houses about why they can't afford it. It's nobody else's business.

Swipe left for the next trending thread