Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It’s a money one!!

216 replies

TheLizardQueen · 26/09/2023 18:35

DH and I have been together for over 20 years, one DD (16) While we have never been rich but we have always managed, but no spare cash for anything. Anyway, 10 years ago I started earning money from my hobby, around £10k per year. I still work in an office Tuesday - Friday then weekends and evenings are taken up with my self employed job. When my business started to take off DH also went down to working 4 days (office job, minimum wage) This was agreed by both of us so that whilst I’m working all weekend and evenings he would be responsible for the housework, admin, cooking, cleaning etc.
To the point… my DD and I have a great relationship and we love going to gigs (lots of gigs!) together. I spend a lot of money on this but it’s the first time I’ve been able to afford to do this and I work really hard so I deserve to treat us. DH announces tonight that he wants the equivalent of what I spend on gigs to be put in account for him as it’s “not fair” I always ask if he wants to come with us but it’s always a no.

I really resent this but I don’t know if I’m being unreasonable. Our finances have always been separate. He gives me £700 per month for bills, and I put £700. But I pay for all the food shopping, petrol, holidays, Christmas, birthdays, days out, car repairs, house repairs, vet bills, clothes for everyone, all of the driving DD everywhere (DH doesn’t drive), driving lessons for DD, and everything else!! Which is fair because I am the high earner BUT the promises of taking over housework etc hasn’t came to fruition, he does the washing, ironing, and we cook together each day. I do everything else including food shopping, admin, cleaning, hoovering, etc. my house is not cleaned as often as I would like because I don’t have the time (or energy)

I think he is jealous of the time and money I spend on my DD and wants his share, which I get, but he’s not pulling his weight in household chores and he works 4 days a week when I work my ass off 7 days a week and most evenings whilst he sits on his PlayStation. He never wants for anything. It feels really nice to be able to spend money on DD and I doing something we both love but he’s making me feel terrible about it.

So… what would you do? Is it fair for me to give him the same as what I spend on gig tickets? I really can’t afford to, and I really feel like telling him if he wants more money he should go back to working full time. AIBU?

OP posts:
Graciebobcat · 29/09/2023 14:28

MotherOfLunatics · 29/09/2023 14:15

There are two separate issues here. The money and DH not adequately performing household chores.
I believe all money earned is family money and you should both have equal rights to access the money and decide how it is spent.
You then need to have a conversation with DH about your expectations with regard to housework and chores.

I believe all money earned is family money and you should both have equal rights to access the money and decide how it is spent.

And the OP doesn't see it that way, and why should she just because you see it as family money?

He isn't going without financially and his request is unreasonable. He's not facilitating OP's work in anyway like someone providing childcare while someone else works, he's gaming and his only costs are £700 out of a minimum wage job. He has £500 disposable income every month already.

Goldbar · 29/09/2023 14:27

There are a number of issues here:

First, why is your money 'family money' and his isn't?

Second, there are lots of expenses that you're currently paying for which should come out of the joint pot. So you need to recalculate 'family expenses' and each pay a proportion according to your income (assuming you don't go down the joint finances approach). It might be that he ends up paying significantly more than £700 once these expenses are taken into account and funded jointly.

Third, his non-monetary contribution to the family is out of whack with yours. He needs to step up his game at home, or go back to work 5 days a week and you can use the extra money towards a cleaner.

Fourth, if he wants to buy a £3k guitar and other expensive items like this, has he looked at increasing his hours or getting a better-paid job? There aren't many people paying towards a family on MW jobs who could afford things like this, especially when not working full-time. Tbh there aren't many people on extremely comfortable salaries who would have this amount spare from the family budget either!!!

Nanny0gg · 29/09/2023 14:19

Mouldyfoodhelp · 29/09/2023 13:35

So if a woman doesn't work or works PT then she has to do all domestic duties or the DH can say she gets no spare money?

Not when they're at home together. Thats shared. But he doesn't get to go back on what he said he would do and leave it all to her

therealcookiemonster · 29/09/2023 14:18

him asking for a 3k guitar has brought the real problem to your attention. which is that he sits around doing nothing for almost half the week while you are working yourself to the bone earning AND doing most of the housework.

I think you should sit him down and say you are no longer happy with this arrangement. he should go back to work full time and with the increased funds you can employ a regular cleaner/housekeeper. that way you get some much needed downtime. because at this rate, you will burnout.

if he refuses to do this, just tell him that you will be going part time because you just can't do it all anymore.

the 3k guitar is a no because you just don't have the money and emergency savings are there only for an emergency.

even if he starts earning, the 3k guitar is a no because for too long you've been doing everything. he needs to grow up and do this share.

personally OP, a man who sits around playing PlayStation while you are working so hard would be a complete turn off for me. is this really what you want?

MotherOfLunatics · 29/09/2023 14:15

There are two separate issues here. The money and DH not adequately performing household chores.
I believe all money earned is family money and you should both have equal rights to access the money and decide how it is spent.
You then need to have a conversation with DH about your expectations with regard to housework and chores.

travailtotravel · 29/09/2023 14:14

So redraw the finances and the family jobs all at the same time. Gigs come out of the family pot from now on, so you put in and he puts in. If he doesn't want to go to the gig, he can have the equivalent cash BUT the critical factor is that here he has put more into the pot to start with. Do the financial split based on jobs and main earnings not on hobby on the side money if you could manage the household without it. There's nothing stopping him also earning on the side so that seems fair and equal way of dealing with it.

Jobs shared too - the whole list of things that need doing. And no bins once a week and mowing the lawn is NOT the same as dinner - because dinner is every day, and needs planning shopping etc. So make sure the toil is equal to the reward!

WanderinStar · 29/09/2023 14:04

One partner has extra time the other has extra money. You make your choices in life. It's not your fault he doesn't like his choice

MrsElijahMikaelson1 · 29/09/2023 14:03

He’s pathetic-sounds like he’s jealous of what you spend on your daughter and he wants his cut Hmm

Pipsquiggle · 29/09/2023 13:57

I think you need to separate out the domestic work from the finance query.

Domestic duties - whoever is at home more, whilst the other works, needs to step up on the household duties. This should be a given. Maybe you need to make this crystal clear - discuss it, write it down, whatever works for you 2.
My DH isn't working at the moment and he is doing nearly all household tasks and childcare. When he gets a job we will re-assess what works for our family.

Finances - Things do need to change. It sounds like you are giving him pocket money which isn't great. Are you and your DD spending all the discretionary spend spare cash on going to gigs? If so I can see why your DH might be a bit annoyed. Maybe do an activity that you can all enjoy.
You do need to work out how much money you have as a family at the end of each month and how you are going to allocate it - it can be for gigs, his hobby, going out for meals etc.

FunnysInLaJardin · 29/09/2023 13:53

it sounds to me that you rather resent his lack of ambition @TheLizardQueen and are almost treating him like another child rather than an equal partner in your marriage

OrianaBanana · 29/09/2023 13:51

His ‘share’ can be spent on a cleaner.

PivotPivotmakingmargaritas · 29/09/2023 13:45

Ohh see I am petty and would have to take the petty route with this one. I would say ‘ok but from now on 50/50 on holidays, Christmas or birthdays, DD’s driving lessons, clothes, vet and pet expenses also as you I am left doing the majority of the housework we will go 50/50 on a cleaner as I am tired working more than full time and being left doing the majority of the housework’ bet he shuts up very quickly!!!

Bikechic · 29/09/2023 13:44

Just tell him he has the equivalent of a gig ticket in his own money already and that you have generously decided not to charge him for his 50% contribution to DD's ticket.

Graciebobcat · 29/09/2023 13:41

It's not the same as a parent of young children being unable to work for childcare cost reasons, or someone unable to work through ill health, he chooses to work 4 days a week and earn less money and be partly supported by the OP.

I wouldn't pay him the money but I'd probably pay for a cleaner, in your shoes, OP.

SurprisedWithAHorse · 29/09/2023 13:35

The money should be shared and he should be using his day off work to do household stuff.

Graciebobcat · 29/09/2023 13:35

Finances don't have to be completely shared in marriage if that's not how you want it to work.

We have been married nearly 20 years, two DDs, and have our own bank accounts our salaries go into, but also have a joint account we pay into for mortgage, bills and food. I earn 50% more than DH and I pay for more things for DDs, and more of the cost than him for holidays and trips. Neither of us go without, and spend our own money after bills are paid on what we want without the other person asking "Why did you buy that?"

I've just spent £300 on a short course and spent similar on another one not long ago. That doesn't mean I have to give DH £600 because I spent that much on myself. How odd 🤔

Mouldyfoodhelp · 29/09/2023 13:35

Nanny0gg · 29/09/2023 13:24

Not if he's working part-time and leaving domestic duties to his wife

So if a woman doesn't work or works PT then she has to do all domestic duties or the DH can say she gets no spare money?

HowIsItSeptemberAlready · 29/09/2023 13:33

TheLizardQueen · 26/09/2023 19:38

@BetterWithPockets i probably spend more on DD, but I did buy him an E-bike and any time he needs cycling stuff I pay for, as well as PS games etc

I think my vagina self-sealed at this point.

Your financial arrangements have unwittingly left you now in some kind of mother role - you're here comparing how much you spend on taking your daughter to gigs vs buying PlayStation games for your husband...and now he's asking for extra pocket money to make things "fair" with how much you spend on your DD? This is just so unsexy I don't know how you manage. He must equally feel totally infantilised by this arrangement as well, surely. This "separate but not separate" financial setup has created a strange power imbalance.

He needs to step up at home, and work more. But you need to review your finances as equals. Unless he's happy essentially being a cocklodger.

WowOK · 29/09/2023 13:27

He needs to work FT and contribute fully to the household. He isn't a SAHP. Your child is 16 and not a baby. He needs to earn more in order to have savings.

Nanny0gg · 29/09/2023 13:24

VesperLynne · 26/09/2023 18:50

But surely is all " family money" , isn't it ?????.

Not if he's working part-time and leaving domestic duties to his wife

babyproblems · 29/09/2023 13:23

I’m torn.. his behaviour is shit I agree. BUT you are married and therefore your earnings should be pooled- both of you, all money into one pot. Then essentials paid and then the rest split between you. There should be some budget for family outings etc. He can choose to come or not. I don’t think you should just give him money but instead reorganise your finances so that all income is pooled. And then you need to ensure it’s a fair split in terms of workload. If he is part time to pick up extra load at home so you can work, that needs to be stuck to or he goes back full time and you pay someone to do the chores. It may seem unfair to you but If you’re married there’s no point in having separate finances and the legal expectation is that you are considered one unit.

moose62 · 29/09/2023 13:14

I would work out, taking DD and the gigs out of it, how much extra you pay a month compared to him. I would then suggest that he contribute to a portion of that as it seems that you pay 2/3rds to his 1/3rd - if that.
If he expects more money from the pot he needs to put more into it....therefore perhaps he could work more or find something that earns money in the evenings and weekends as you have...after all he isn't busy doing the housework or cooking.
My DH and I shared all of our income when I worked part time and he full time, long hours. But...I did all the housework, all the cooking and cleaning and took on all the mental load.

midgemadgemodge · 29/09/2023 13:12

I guess if he leaves you he may be better off ?

Bored1000 · 29/09/2023 13:06

Simple, if he wants more money, he works more / or does All the chores you discussed previously.
You currently have more disposable money than him as you work a lot more than him, by right he should also be contributing towards the gigs for your daughter as at the moment you seem to be paying for all her entertainment when he is also a parent.

ohdamnitjanet · 29/09/2023 13:01

DonaNobisPacem · 26/09/2023 19:29

This scenario reminds me a bit of when a friend of mine offered to buy a girl a drink and she said, "No thanks, but I'll have the cash" 😭

That’s so wrong but hilarious 😆