Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People shortening your child's name

70 replies

Dramatic · 26/09/2023 13:40

I've just seen a comment on another social media platform where a mum said she screamed at another child for shortening her son's name from Jackson to Jack (she was being deadly serious too)

Was she reasonable? Unreasonable? Do you think parents should have absolute control over what nicknames other people call their children? (Within reason of course) Or should it be expected that if you give a child a name like William they will become Will to their friends?

OP posts:
Cakecakecheese · 26/09/2023 16:29

My baby is Edward and when he's older he can choose to be Ed, Eddie, Ted etc but for now he's Edward. A photographer called him Eddie and instantly corrected herself, I may have automatically made a face but I certainly wouldn't be screaming at anyone over it.

Gerrataere · 26/09/2023 16:23

MrsMarzetti · 26/09/2023 16:03

Other children shortening a name doesn't bother me but teachers and Nursery staff doing it is wrong unless the parent has told them they can.

I had the opposite problem. My eldest hates the full version of his name and will only answer to the shorten version. His school insisted on referring to him as the full version all through reception and he really became quite distressed until I put my foot down (I should add, he’s autistic and only really heard the short version his whole life so I appreciate what’s on paper but I hated seeing upset more).

HonoriaLucastaDelagardie · 26/09/2023 16:19

Other children shortening a name doesn't bother me but teachers and Nursery staff doing it is wrong unless the parent has told them they can.

Even if the child doesn't mind, or prefers it?

NooNooHead1981 · 26/09/2023 16:13

I named my DD Isabella, but we have called her Izzy most of her life and her nursery is going to call her that too, even though we have obviously told them her full name. If she wants to change it to Bella, Ella, or even keep her full name later on life, she can do whatever she wants.

Similarly with my name, my parents called me Nicola but I don't really like it, so I shorten it to Nikki. My dad often calls me Nic.

I'm pretty sure most names will be shortened at some point unless you specifically tell others that you name must remain in its full state, or you tell others exactly what you prefer. If you have a name that can't be shorter like Ian, then you just have to love it and live with it 😉

HAF1119 · 26/09/2023 16:12

Bit unhinged yes, mine gets lengthened rather a lot (to the traditional name, his birth name is a nickname for some) and I just ignore it!

Scorchio84 · 26/09/2023 16:10

Gerrataere · 26/09/2023 14:47

This is true. And if your name can’t be shorted you’ll be given a nickname that will stick so hard no one remembers your real name until it’s on your gravestone…

silimar to Ireland, my son's name is Irish & it can't be shortened so in essense it gets lenghthened & I have no issues with this, it's a name & once we give our child a name surely it's out there (within reason) for people/family to shorten/lenthen or give a nickname, especially with surnames, I'd step in if he hated being called "such & such" that's different

ThroughThickAndThin01 · 26/09/2023 16:09

ManateeFair · 26/09/2023 15:28

Much less easy to shorten with different words for nicknames Alexander/Sacha, James/Jim, Joseph/Jos, these have to be worked at

The standard shortened version of Joseph is Joe, not Jos. No work required. And the standard short version of Alexander is only Sacha if you're Russian. In England it would Alex (or for the posh, Xander) and in Scotland it might also be Alec or Sandy.

I think things like James/Jim, Henry/Harry, Richard/Dick, Robert/Bob etc were completely standard, work-free nicknames until fairly recently. My grandparents would absolutely have assumed it was normal to call a James 'Jim' or a Robert 'Bob' - they'd never in million years have called a Robert 'Rob', definitely only Bob. It's just a change over time.

Well that’s exactly what I mean. It has to be worked at if you want your Joseph called Jos and not Joe, and your Alexander called Sacha not Alex - you’ve illustrated my point.

PyramusandThisbe · 26/09/2023 16:07

Screaming isn't OK. Fine to correct.

TokyoSushi · 26/09/2023 16:03

I have a DD with a name that is unexpectedly shortened, think Rachel to Rach, Sophie to Soph, in fact, more people call her by the shortened name than her full name. I didn't see that coming, but it doesn't really bother me.

MrsMarzetti · 26/09/2023 16:03

Other children shortening a name doesn't bother me but teachers and Nursery staff doing it is wrong unless the parent has told them they can.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 26/09/2023 16:01

Will depend to some extent to me on whether the child likes the shortened name. I’ve known a Philippa who absolutely loathed being called Pippa, but a teacher carried on using it regardless.

The other way round, someone christened Katie had a teacher who insisted on calling her Catherine, despite being repeatedly told that Katie wasn’t short for anything. In the end she just had to stop answering if the teacher called her Catherine.

If the child doesn’t like it, I’d tell them simply to stop answering to the wrong name.

muddyford · 26/09/2023 16:00

A friend's son is Alexander and I have never heard him called anything else by anyone.

havingmetime · 26/09/2023 15:51

I think it's inevitable, people call me by the initial of my first name and I have a one syllable name.

BarbedButterfly · 26/09/2023 15:30

I think unreasonable. I go by a nickname. My full name is only used by my mum and work.

ManateeFair · 26/09/2023 15:28

Much less easy to shorten with different words for nicknames Alexander/Sacha, James/Jim, Joseph/Jos, these have to be worked at

The standard shortened version of Joseph is Joe, not Jos. No work required. And the standard short version of Alexander is only Sacha if you're Russian. In England it would Alex (or for the posh, Xander) and in Scotland it might also be Alec or Sandy.

I think things like James/Jim, Henry/Harry, Richard/Dick, Robert/Bob etc were completely standard, work-free nicknames until fairly recently. My grandparents would absolutely have assumed it was normal to call a James 'Jim' or a Robert 'Bob' - they'd never in million years have called a Robert 'Rob', definitely only Bob. It's just a change over time.

smallshinybutton · 26/09/2023 15:13

I find the evolution of my shortening interesting. Since zoom and teams were introduced I noticed people are shortening names to the shortest version possible. And it happens to be what I prefer but if it wasn't I'd be annoyed and probably say something. But no I wouldn't scream.

ManateeFair · 26/09/2023 15:13

A child isn't a possession and you can't really control what other people call them - nor can you control what the child chooses to call themselves. It's pretty standard, in most languages and cultures (or certainly most European ones anyway) for names to get shortened and nicknames to be used. Perfectly OK for the person whose name it is to say 'I don't like being called that, I prefer my full name please' but parents need to get over themselves and suck it up.

My parents never called me by the shortened version of my name but they never made a fuss when literally everyone else other people did. However, there was another girl in my class with the same name as me and her mother regularly snapped at other kids (and our teachers) for shortening her name.

Once we started secondary school the girl then insisted on being known only by the shortened version, and still uses the short version now in her late 40s, so I guess her mum's overbearing approach ultimately backfired.

TheMurderousGoose · 26/09/2023 15:07

thebellagio · 26/09/2023 15:02

@TheMurderousGoose MM's wife also came out recently and said how his mum was an utter bitch to her for years - literally called her by his ex girlfriends name deliberately, and would undermine her at every possible chance. I think 'abusive' may be more accurate than a bit of a "character!"!

she sounds a delight!

She probably makes a big deal of being an old-fashioned Texan gal as cover for being a total cow.

IDoughnutKnow · 26/09/2023 15:07

She shouldn’t have called her child Jackson if she didn’t want Jack imo

You could have stopped at "she shouldn't have called her child Jackson", @ThroughThickAndThin01

Swearwolf · 26/09/2023 15:02

I have a name that has multiple shortenings, as well as a couple of similar names that people mix up. You can't really control what people call you! I used to correct people when I was younger but there isn't really any way to do it without sounding petty, and it's usually awkward. I don't love some of the shortenings, and I really don't like when someone uses a name that's not quite my name but similar, but it just is how it is. I introduce myself with my name and it morphs into something else, I still know they mean me.

thebellagio · 26/09/2023 15:02

@TheMurderousGoose MM's wife also came out recently and said how his mum was an utter bitch to her for years - literally called her by his ex girlfriends name deliberately, and would undermine her at every possible chance. I think 'abusive' may be more accurate than a bit of a "character!"!

TheMurderousGoose · 26/09/2023 14:59

thebellagio · 26/09/2023 14:18

I'm sure Matthew McConaughey once said that his mother slapped him for answering to Matt once. It's how he always knew he was never allowed to shorten his name. to me, thats absolutely insane and crazy

His mother seems to be a bit of a 'character'.

'According to Matthew, when paramedics arrived at his parents' home, his mom refused to allow her husband to be covered. “She kept ripping the sheet off going: 'Uh-uh, I want the world to see why his nickname was Big Jim, don't you cover him,'” he recalled'

Totes normal.

HonoriaLucastaDelagardie · 26/09/2023 14:59

It's up to the child as soon as the child is old enough to express a preference.

Parents can't control what a child is called by his friends at school or other times when parents aren't there.

And a person will probably acquire more shortenings/nicknames as they move through life and meet different people. How long do parents expect to control it?

Mollyplop999 · 26/09/2023 14:55

I named my daughter Rachel as I didn't want it shortening. She's 38 and some people call her Rach. She hates it

Niinja · 26/09/2023 14:48

Parents can't police it forever. I do think it's rude of people though to shorten without asking. DS much prefers his full name but is autistic and often can't get the words out to complain. Most adults are good but there are a few teachers every year who shorten it without asking. I do correct them at parents' evening, not because I want "ultimate control" but because he is upset by it and can't fix it himself. If he had chosen the shortening then I'd support him with that... probably.