Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think schools shouldn’t tell kids what to say to Ofsted

32 replies

Lessexpected · 25/09/2023 23:12

Just that. Ofsted are coming. All kids been told what to say when asked by an Ofsted person. Aibu to think schools should encourage freedom of
expression?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
saraclara · 26/09/2023 21:30

YouJustDoYou · 26/09/2023 21:26

Worked in schools and nurseries and the trouble kids get taken away when Ofsted comes, normal kids get told the right things to say. The system is shit.

That absolutely does not happen these days. With only half a day's notice, getting 'problem' kids out of school simply couldn't be done, even if schools could get away with it.

YouJustDoYou · 26/09/2023 21:26

Worked in schools and nurseries and the trouble kids get taken away when Ofsted comes, normal kids get told the right things to say. The system is shit.

Newrumpus · 26/09/2023 21:25

I remember a challenging Y11 lad being asked complex questions by an OFSTED Inspector in my lesson. He looked at her like she was mad and shrugged at her. She left the lesson and before the door had closed behind her he asked ‘What the fuck is she asking me for? I’m never here’. He was
utterly embarrassed in front of the whole class and the incident undid weeks of meticulous work to get him attending and engaging in lessons.

cansu · 26/09/2023 20:55

Ofsted sometimes ask kids very adult questions. They will ask kids with very obvious difficulties questions they can't answer. They then use this as evidence that the school hasn't taught X or y. It is nonsensical. They also ask leading questions. They don't allow for the fact that many kids can't remember what they did yesterday.
E.g. How does this learning connect to your prior learning? Here they are expecting kids to parrot back that in term 1 they learnt about X and that this connects to the learning in term y where this was revisited and developed.

Does your teacher tell you how you can improve? What did she say about this piece of work? Here they will get the child's book and pick out a piece of work. The kid is expected to remember what Mrs X said as she walked around the classroom. Chances are the kid won't remember and will say either I can't remember or she didn't say anything.
Does your teacher explain things well? This is quite a big question. Which things? When? Does the child pay attention? Do they like the teacher? Is it better to say yes or no. If I say no then this gives me an excuse for not doing well or completing my work.
Is the work easier than in Year ... I heard a kid answer this one. They said the work was easier than last year. I taught the child two years running. The content and skills were much harder. He was doing really well so he thought the work was easier. It wasn't.

I say all this to explain why schools try to teach kids to answer questions. You are right that it is bonkers but it is all part of how stupid the system is and how it is about ticking boxes and answering the questions correctly. Schools also coach teachers in what to say as well.

crumblingschools · 26/09/2023 20:34

@Ikeepmybumcheekshidden what country are you in?

electriclight · 26/09/2023 17:09

It is extremely rare for any pupil to remember anything a teacher says, so I don't think you need to worry.

We spend months and years filling them with facts that they forget in an exam, so being 'told what to say' is unlikely to stick after one telling.

I also think this is very unlikely. No school would be stupid enough. Of course the kids will let it slip and Ofsted will frown on any suggestion that the school coached them.

More likely the kids asked one of their teachers 'what do we say if they ask us about...' and the teacher tried to help, to avoid any anxiety about an unscheduled conversation.

Ikeepmybumcheekshidden · 26/09/2023 17:05

noblegiraffe · 25/09/2023 23:52

All the fake rehearsed lessons and naughty kids sent on trips that used to happen can’t happen anymore as schools only get told lunchtime the day before. I can’t imagine they’d have had much time to drill kids into a comprehensive script, maybe more some useful pointers. Kids often don’t want to let the school down.

My DC's old school got told 2 weeks ahead of time! We got a letter about it. They came last week before summer holidays! I immediately thought hang on, aren't they meant to get a call the day before but nope! They knew ahead of time. Primary school

givemushypeasachance · 26/09/2023 09:12

Ofsted inspectors are all senior teachers (mostly current headteachers who inspect a couple of times a year). They have met plenty of kids before, and it's not easy to completely bluff your way through an inspection. The school only gets called and told Ofsted are coming just before lunchtime on the day before it starts, so it's not like back in the day when you got weeks of notice. If you send all the "naughty kids" to a local theme park for the day, as used to be rumoured happened, they can see there are a handful of kids missing in every classroom and will ask why attendance is so low. The inspectors pick which kids to have a formal discussion with, but they also speak to kids in each classroom they observe, at lunchtime and in the playground. They ask questions like "is this a typical maths lesson?", as well as asking about what is being taught and what kids can recall, and more importantly do kids feel safe, do they enjoy school, do they feel supported by adults, what would they like more or less of, what extracurriculars do they do, what have they covered in PSHE.

If you were to randomly sample a classroom and pick five kids out and speak to them away from the teacher - would the teacher feel confident that their coached answers would be given? Or is it just as likely at least one kid would say: Mrs X told us to say blah blah blah but ACTUALLY...

TeenDivided · 26/09/2023 09:04

Not the same thing, but I worked in an industry where we had assessors coming in to see if we met certain award standards. I used to brief the department beforehand. My message was 'be truthful, be positive, be open - in that order'. ie Don't volunteer negative information unless directly asked but always be honest.

So if asked 'Do you do XYZ on your project?' if the answer is yes then say yes. If the answer is yes and this is absolutely standard on all projects I've ever worked on, then say so. But if the answer is Yes but I know Joe's project doesn't, then don't volunteer the 'but'.

I did however remind people what certain questions might mean / cover. e.g. Say PHSE is covered in tutor time at a school. If the inspector asks 'Do you have PHSE lessons?' a pupil might just say no. But if they have been reminded it is covered in tutor time they might give a different, more correct, answer.

Zola1 · 26/09/2023 08:54

I work in children's services and they've tried to tell us what to say to ofsted too 😂🫠

CwmYoy · 26/09/2023 08:50

I wish parents would realise that many Ofsted inspectors are failed teachers who have their own agenda.

Onheretoomuch · 26/09/2023 08:47

At my children’ last school all pupils had to complete an anonymous questionnaire given to the school by the Inspectors. A complete waste of time as the teachers were supervising while they were completed and they questioned every answer they weren’t happy with which resulted in the pupils changing their answers. That was the final nail in the coffin for us with that school.

crumblingschools · 26/09/2023 08:41

Also some kids are very good at expressing themselves and how they feel about something, others not so! So instead of a teenager answering ‘I dunno!’ they will be coached in answering those type of questions

twistyizzy · 26/09/2023 08:35

And this is the problem with Ofsted. Of course schools will coach/prep kids because one of the things Ofsted look for is long term retention of learning plus 1 million other random things that the kids will never remember. If the school doesn't get a tick in the box for the kids remembering about Prevent/British Values/E+D/Safeguarding etc etc then the school won't get a favourable report and then parents such as yourself are less likely to send their kids to that school. That's why you should always take Ofsted reports with a bucket load of salt and read beyond the headline number.

MrsElijahMikaelson1 · 26/09/2023 08:35

I suspect the teenagers are exaggerating somewhat. They’d have been told, it’s important, behave yourselves and tell them things about our school such as…

And the kids will say exactly what they like on the day🤷‍♀️

crumblingschools · 26/09/2023 08:31

How much conversation do some adults get with teenagers! As some have said they may have been given guidance on what questions they may be asked and reminders of what school has been doing in that area.

Ofsted will probably also talk to the school governors who should have examples of pupil voice too as part of their role

Starlightstarbright2 · 26/09/2023 08:30

Parents put such faith in Ofsted this is why they are coached .

opposite end - my Ds was having an assessment for dyslexia.. I was a childminder at the time . So was aware of Ofsted - he had to write a poem so wrote one about how lovely his teacher was 🤣

smallshinybutton · 26/09/2023 08:26

Depends what they've been told to say really.

This is why ofstead is rubbish though. They shouldn't get warning.

Conkersinautumn · 26/09/2023 08:24

Ofsted inspectors don't listen to kids anyway, barely look at the parental feedback but I'd certainly be filling out the survey about my child being drilled in a standard response

Shinyandnew1 · 26/09/2023 08:21

If it’s a ‘don’t forget to tell the inspectors that we do x, y and z’ as a reminder, I don’t see the problem. I work with KS1 who are supposed to be able to link their learning with previous learning. At 5/6, they often have no recollection of learning about minibeasts before Christmas unless you have a big discussion about it and remind them of the trip they did, when they made a model, when they made an advert or when X came into visit

Doingmybest12 · 26/09/2023 08:13

Not a school but we had briefings at work about what to say or not. I don't think there is harm in reminding people what they say might have consequences so take seriously what you say and a measured approach. But direct coaching is not ok and could back fire.

saraclara · 26/09/2023 08:01

Lessexpected · 26/09/2023 07:04

This is secondary for context where children have their own opinions on being coached on what to say.

In which case there's little danger of them conforming.

But genuinely, I think there's a big difference between being given a heads up on what they might be asked and what the inspectors are looking for, and being told what to say or to lie.

Teenagers are likely to ask their own questions.of a teacher when told that the inspection is happening, and the teacher needs to be able to answer those questions. It's a requirement to warn pupils that inspectors might approach them with questions, and conversations are going to arise from learners being given that information.
That's very different from an orchestrated effort to tutor pupils in what opinions they should express. I think the latter is very unlikely.

Lessexpected · 26/09/2023 07:04

This is secondary for context where children have their own opinions on being coached on what to say.

OP posts:
Restinggoddess · 26/09/2023 00:45

Children being reminded of a few things about the school is not a problem
Inspections place a lot of stress on staff and pupils - to instantly recall and give examples of any random shit the inspector wants to know about - it's a grilling and very stressful if relying on young children to remember something or make weird links ( because the inspectors do)
Children go blank , get shy and in the end sometimes say anything the inspector leads them to say
Children forget stuff because they do t know just how much is riding on saying the right thing about PE/ music/ history/ reading/ lunchtimes/ assemblies/ maths/ PSHCE/ etc etc

noblegiraffe · 25/09/2023 23:52

All the fake rehearsed lessons and naughty kids sent on trips that used to happen can’t happen anymore as schools only get told lunchtime the day before. I can’t imagine they’d have had much time to drill kids into a comprehensive script, maybe more some useful pointers. Kids often don’t want to let the school down.

Swipe left for the next trending thread