Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why are we not learning to fight?

57 replies

BMW6 · 25/09/2023 22:43

So often I see threads from women who are beaten, raped, abused.

Why can't we get together to teach each other how to defend yourself? Or attack if needs be?

OP posts:
cpphelp · 25/09/2023 23:48

Gerrataere · 25/09/2023 22:52

Why can’t men get together and teach classes to other men on not being monstrous, murderous, raping arseholes? Better use of time than self defence classes for women for simply existing.

I'll be teaching my three (currently under 5yrs) sons exactly this

Nicole1111 · 25/09/2023 23:43

Gerrataere · 25/09/2023 22:52

Why can’t men get together and teach classes to other men on not being monstrous, murderous, raping arseholes? Better use of time than self defence classes for women for simply existing.

This ☝🏻
👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

AgathaAllAlong · 25/09/2023 23:42

It is not our lack of fighting skills that makes us the victims of male violence. Most women are not strong enough to withstand an attack by a man, even if she can fight. Most abuse is from partners, and physically fighting back makes them more violent. The best advice in these situations (sadly) is to run away, lock the door, call the police. And in many many situations there is absolutely nothing to be done at all. Your body freezes, they overpower you because they are much much stronger. And it's very important that we don't send out the message that a woman is at fault for her abuse, or that violence happens to us because we're insufficiently prepared. Violence does not happen to us - men do it to us, no matter how many martial arts courses we've taken.

I guess at least in principle, it's not a bad idea to know some fight moves. Especially tactics that could help buy prescious time against a stranger turning forceful in a nightclub or something like that. It's a delusion to think that these measures would resolve the problem of male violence, though. The only thing that will resolve that problem is for men to stop being violent towards women: to stop raping, beating and killing us, just because they can.

ThCats · 25/09/2023 23:37

It's totally pointless. I did quite a bit of martial arts, one of the unusual street fighting styles. We were still taught to run asap as men are so much stronger.

Even in class young/slim inexperienced guys could easily overpower any of the women because they are stronger

Daisybuttercup12345 · 25/09/2023 23:36

Temporaryname158 · 25/09/2023 22:44

I’d love to learn but I’m not aware of where or how to do that

Google self defence classes?

GP78 · 25/09/2023 23:35

You'll likely lose in a fight with any man, the best thing you can do in a violent confrontation is try to get away. Do not advise any woman to try and fight back, this is not good advice.

Thatladdo · 25/09/2023 23:32

Another truth is you dont know how you'll behave when your attacked, until your attacked, like being suddenly flung into a stressful traumatic incident.

Forget the films and the short scenes you might run through your head.

Men and women alike, a lot of men and I would imagine the vast majority of women would be stunned / shocked into submission right away with a decent punch, elbow, headbut etc.

The kind self defence class wont teach you unless your into competitive fighting.
(Northern female dart teams in west cumbria exepted)

greenspaces4peace · 25/09/2023 23:27

i'm fully aware of how to cause serious bodily harm (poke out an eyeball, rip off a nose, bite off a finger, hit the larynx, oh dislocate a knee etc etc etc) but i don't know if i have the gumption to actually do it.

Almostwelsh · 25/09/2023 23:22

Because you have next to no chance against a man. Unless you recognise the situation early and run like hell.

Once he's got hold of you, one punch to your face, you'll go down. And he will be quite happy to do that, unlike the instructor you've trained with.

ReadingSoManyThreads · 25/09/2023 23:19

Wow! I cannot believe this post. You do realise that when a boyfriend or husband is attacking you that trying to fight them off tends to make them even more angry and in return gets you an even worse beating. Jeez, some people have no idea. Unless you've been through it yourself, then you really have no idea.

Goodornot · 25/09/2023 23:16

Oddearslongnose · 25/09/2023 23:12

There are times when it’s useful.
But let’s not kid ourselves that a woman has a chance in her own home against a man who has a violent outburst . He’ll break things, throw stuff, burn stuff , and probably while she worries about protecting her children.
Far better we teach women to identify the earliest red flags, to strive for financial independence, and we make studying Lundy Bancroft’s book compulsory for all teenagers.

The same Lundy Bancroft who is published via vanity press?

The same one who holds retreats for abused women and tries to groom them for relationships with him and allows men on those retreats too.

junbean · 25/09/2023 23:14

Have you been attacked, raped, etc? If not please refrain. You have no idea what you're talking about. This is really offensive to those who have been thru it. Go take your own self defense classes and stop talking about others' situations you clearly have no place to be speaking on.

HauntingSecrets · 25/09/2023 23:14

Or men could not kill or rape women, that would be nicer.

Oddearslongnose · 25/09/2023 23:12

There are times when it’s useful.
But let’s not kid ourselves that a woman has a chance in her own home against a man who has a violent outburst . He’ll break things, throw stuff, burn stuff , and probably while she worries about protecting her children.
Far better we teach women to identify the earliest red flags, to strive for financial independence, and we make studying Lundy Bancroft’s book compulsory for all teenagers.

WhateverMate · 25/09/2023 23:07

Bloody weirdest question I've seen on MN for a long time.

Are you asking why there are no self defence classes anywhere (there are) or why not everyone wants to do them?

And do you think most women would be confident and able to fight off a crazed rapist?

How about you spend your energy asking why rapists rape?

Goodornot · 25/09/2023 23:02

Because it's just that simple right?

You think you know what you'll do...

The reality is you freeze. You play dead and let them do it. It's an instinct / survival thing.

That's what happened to me the time my date wouldn't take no for an answer. I just froze.

Attitudes like the OPs make me sick.

cestlavielife · 25/09/2023 23:02

Krav maga is great
See if you can attend a women focused class

Ponderingwindow · 25/09/2023 23:01

I’ve taken classes to learn to fight off an attacker. The instructor really emphasized situational awareness, conflict avoidance, and bystander assistance. We did still practice or punches, kicks, and techniques for getting out of holds.

I would come home full of energy ready to show off my moves. My DH who had no desire to hurt me and therefore would not put any effort into being my demonstration partner could easily dominate me. If he had even a light grip on me anywhere, trying to get away was absolutely pointless.

there was a reason the instructor spent so much time on teaching us to avoid getting into those situations in the first place and then focused on learning to make a scene to get help as the real backup plan.

some women might have a chance fighting hand to hand against some men, but the simple reality is they are much stronger than we are on average. That doesn’t make them better than us, it just makes them better at this one thing.

Thatladdo · 25/09/2023 23:01

Women / Girls really should. Even if its just enough to be resilient enough to collect yourself quicker after a blow and flea.

Yes, generaly a fight is a bad idea, thats evolotion but situational awareness and weapons are completely illegal but its perfectly reasonable to have your keys on your hand almost any woman could cause great pain / mortal wounds.

AND regardless what anyone on youtube says or what special move your mate who went to self defence class shows you the best defence is almost always run, and if anyones about be noisy about it.

My DD did Judo in her younger years and has played rugby the past 6 years too,
can take a hell of a knock but knows when to run, its just not worth the risk.
Equaly so for meek, skinny men.

RoseAndRose · 25/09/2023 23:01

You're making quite a lot of assumptions about the nature of violence against women, especially that it comes down to a situation where fighting would be the solution.

But on the general basis that there are some scenarios where it would apply, and assuming that you don't get the "freeze" reaction to threat, then the question is how effectively will someone - who is likely to be shorter, lighter, with a smaller frame and less muscle mass - defeat the assailant? Answer is not terribly encouraging - best you can hope for would be to cause a bit of a shock (by striking back at all) to buy yourself time to start running and yelling for help. And if that works rather depends on where you are and the presence of other people.

But YY to self-defence classes. Done well, they teach situation awareness and give confidence.

HerrenaHarridan · 25/09/2023 22:59

#500Rising

Many people are. Lots of the women I have met training started from wanting to be free of domestic violence.

Its more complicated than being able to physically defend yourself… you’ve also got to believe you are worth defending

Mummy08m · 25/09/2023 22:57

I think self defence is really valuable but much more valuable is teaching girls and young women how to identify and avoid the creepy, angry and/or violent men. Above all, avoid. And this is not victim blaming. It's pre-emptive self defence. Don't warm to them. Don't "be kind" to them. Avoid them like the plague because they're the biggest threat to our safety and well-being.

The flip side is learning how to identify the non-creepy, non-violent men. Difficult. But less urgent because you can generally live without any man

MintJulia · 25/09/2023 22:56

You mean why aren't you learning to fight? There's no reason why you can't. I've spent the last 9 years learning a martial art. It's all terribly disciplined and controlled, the same sequences over and over.
During lockdown a local teen tried to hurt me and I tripped him up and put his arm up behind his back - before running away. I was surprised how naturally it came. I was a bit shaky later but I haven't had any trouble since. 😊
Brilliant for suppleness and flexibility too, and costs about £7 a week.

GrumpyPanda · 25/09/2023 22:53

Martial arts practitioner here. There are self-defense classes around, they just aren't anywhere as widespread or popular as they could be. I've heard good things about Model Mugging type classes that use a padded attacker so students don't need to pull their punches. If no specialized classes are available I'd look for beginners classes in Israeli Krav Maga or similar for quick results. But ultimately it's all about getting body confidence (which most women have had trained out of us - we don't take up space) and reactions when flooded with adrenaline. Oh, and stamina to run away when necessary!