Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Uninvited from Christmas Day

384 replies

Bs0u416d · 25/09/2023 19:01

So, myself and my siblings (all adults in 30s) alternate Christmas day between our parents and our respective DP's parents. Thus, we have a big family christmas every two years. This year, my DM has asked us (me and DP) not to come because her dogs (two young dogs that have replaced now deceased family dogs) are nervous of my dog. Not only that, she was upset when I suggested we might have siblings and neice here on boxing day to compensate. My view was the dogs would just be expected to all muddle through for 48 hours for the sake of family. My dog is a great dane but very placid and uninterested in their smaller dogs. We'd also have been quite amenable to confining him to the utilty room but no such compromises were sough, just 'we'll miss and its a sad situation'. So, AIBU for being upset that my mother would choose her dogs over her child?

OP posts:
Baffled1989 · 25/09/2023 22:25

Childish?! What?!? 😂😂

Bs0u416d · 25/09/2023 22:24

theresnolimits · 25/09/2023 22:17

I think you have to realise that your parents are getting older and that things change. What was acceptable when she had two calmer dogs, isn’t working now and she’s clearly getting stressed. As my parents got older their previous openness and generosity seeped away and we had to adapt. Be a bit sympathetic to her feelings and try to understand. Also realise that this may be the start of a decline and things, by necessity, will not carry on unchanged indefinitely.

I’m sorry she phrased it badly and upset you; look for a solution and then go back to her and present it and I’m sure she’ll accept it. I don’t think that can involve taking the dog though.

I do have to say if you choose a statement dog like a Great Dane, you have to accept that brings its own issues. And that was a mean thing to say to your mum ~ do you really equate her death with that of your pet?

Another wonderfully wise and measured response. Exactly what I came her for. Of course I don't equate her to a pet!! She just made me mad and she made her own mistakes in the conversation and I lashed out, shes 72, not 92. But your words measured and you're right. Thanks.

OP posts:
PixieLaLar · 25/09/2023 22:24

YANBU! I agree ignore all the dog hating comments that aren’t relevant here. The point is your dog was welcome the previous years and no bother but now they have two yappy untrained dogs who haven’t been properly socialised suddenly your “massive scary great dane” is the problem….Ridiculous.

sandyhappypeople · 25/09/2023 22:24

I think you need to go full on guilt trip on this one OP.

I'd apologise for being a dick with what you said, but say the thought of being told that you can't all be together at Christmas, through no fault of your own, has upset you quiet a lot, and as you "don't know what could happen in the next couple of years" it may be the last time you're all able to be together in a big group.. big sad compo face.

We are exactly the same here, everyone's got dogs, kids, everyone is welcome, its what Christmas is about!!

Is there any chance you can take your dog over a few times between now and then to see if her dogs can get used to him a bit more?

AndromacheAstyanax · 25/09/2023 22:23

Just dropped in to say how heartening it is to read the balance and reserve on this thread. OP, a lot of this resonates with me because my late mother couldn’t cope with our large dog (greyhound- another gentle giant) in her house. She had no problem visiting us, but just couldn’t deal with it at home. From our point of view, the dog is part of our family and we couldn’t countenance Christmas without her, so it was accepted that family gatherings would not be at my parents’ house. I hope you find a solution and have a lovely Christmas when it comes.

BellaAndDave · 25/09/2023 22:22

Bs0u416d · 25/09/2023 19:38

A fair and balanced point of view. I suppose, as with so many things, emotions cloud ones take on the situation.

Your response to my first post.

category12 · 25/09/2023 22:21

Noimnotstillonmumsne · 25/09/2023 22:14

Yes her home the rules, but getting upset about OP then wanting to host the family in her own house the following day does suggest she’s being controlling. It seems she wants to be the sole host and it all has to be on her terms.

I disagree, I think this was the middle of a heated and emotional conversation, and probably OP saying she'd just see other family on Boxing Day felt like a tit for tat thing that her mum found hurtful in the moment.

OP's said her mum is a good egg generally.

Hibiscrubbed · 25/09/2023 22:21

I really like you, OP. You’ve dealt with the usual Mumsnet black-and-white bollocks from posters either too excited to have a go at you, or too stupid to see beyond ‘large dog’, with grace.

You and your Dane can come to us for Christmas.

Fallingthroughclouds · 25/09/2023 22:21

Ponderingwindow · 25/09/2023 19:11

Hire a pet sitter and attend without your dog. Brining your dog to someone else’s home for an overnight stay is rude.

What an odd suggestion. It's Christmas day and unlikely any sitters would be available. And she's not just taking her dog anywhere, it's to her family, who are usually accommodating and warm. I hope that yours is similar otherwise it's a pretty miserable Christmas around.

MaryJanesonabreak · 25/09/2023 22:21

I think you can get house sitters in while you are away that will also look after your dog. They are free.

Would it be possible to go and visit your mum before Christmas and have a chat. She sounds overwhelmed. Ask her if she’s ok. Apologise for your mean outburst. Basically build some bridges and show her that you are there for her and appreciate all the hosting she has done over the years.

If you go without a solution in mind, the right one will present itself.

Bs0u416d · 25/09/2023 22:21

BellaAndDave · 25/09/2023 22:13

At first I believed the OP of this thread, it’s turned into yet another “its me or the dog” thread.

If someone is so uneducated in canine behaviour to think putting numerous family dogs together My view was the dogs would just be expected to all muddle through for 48 hours for the sake of family they’re deluded. Who in their right mind would throw dogs together at a busy time of year?

Some people have too much time on their hands 😂

Genuine thread. That comment was simply to reflect that all of these dogs have spend numerous family occasions together! As recently as June. Its just my mother that seems to have problem. Their dogs are anxious and yappy but that doesnt seem to matter if we are there or not! Open to constructive critique though.

OP posts:
theresnolimits · 25/09/2023 22:17

I think you have to realise that your parents are getting older and that things change. What was acceptable when she had two calmer dogs, isn’t working now and she’s clearly getting stressed. As my parents got older their previous openness and generosity seeped away and we had to adapt. Be a bit sympathetic to her feelings and try to understand. Also realise that this may be the start of a decline and things, by necessity, will not carry on unchanged indefinitely.

I’m sorry she phrased it badly and upset you; look for a solution and then go back to her and present it and I’m sure she’ll accept it. I don’t think that can involve taking the dog though.

I do have to say if you choose a statement dog like a Great Dane, you have to accept that brings its own issues. And that was a mean thing to say to your mum ~ do you really equate her death with that of your pet?

InWalksBarberalla · 25/09/2023 22:15

It sounds like you haven't really accepted that your mum is aging and finding things harder than she used to.

Noimnotstillonmumsne · 25/09/2023 22:14

Nanny0gg · 25/09/2023 22:05

She IS entitled to be a control freak over her own home though

Yes her home the rules, but getting upset about OP then wanting to host the family in her own house the following day does suggest she’s being controlling. It seems she wants to be the sole host and it all has to be on her terms.

BellaAndDave · 25/09/2023 22:13

Bs0u416d · 25/09/2023 21:35

That ia your (sensible) porogative. But my dog has been in and out of my parents homes and lives for nearly 4 years now. Would you exclude a child for thier dog or do you think you'd move heaven and earth to make sure your family could be together at christmas?

At first I believed the OP of this thread, it’s turned into yet another “its me or the dog” thread.

If someone is so uneducated in canine behaviour to think putting numerous family dogs together My view was the dogs would just be expected to all muddle through for 48 hours for the sake of family they’re deluded. Who in their right mind would throw dogs together at a busy time of year?

Some people have too much time on their hands 😂

Bs0u416d · 25/09/2023 22:11

JudgeRudy · 25/09/2023 22:07

Your mother hasn't chosen her dogs over her child. You've chosen your dog over your parents. I'm pretty sure you can all go, just the dog can't. You have the choice of making arrangements for it or staying at home. What do you normally do if you go out somewhere or on holiday that's unsuitable for dogs?

So we use doggy day care and dog sitters (heavily but neither are an option over Christmas and we have always previously just taken him to my parents.

OP posts:
JudgeRudy · 25/09/2023 22:07

Your mother hasn't chosen her dogs over her child. You've chosen your dog over your parents. I'm pretty sure you can all go, just the dog can't. You have the choice of making arrangements for it or staying at home. What do you normally do if you go out somewhere or on holiday that's unsuitable for dogs?

MsRosley · 25/09/2023 22:06

smallshinybutton · 25/09/2023 22:02

I'd never say something so nasty to my mother no

If one of my kids said that to me, I'd just laugh.

VWdieselnightmare · 25/09/2023 22:06

OP, we won't be going to my in-laws this Christmas as scheduled because we have an elderly and rather grumpy dog and they recently took in two kittens, which will only be six months at Christmas and which will drive our old boy berserk and potentially end in major trouble. It can't be helped.

We're not hurt or angry about it, it's life. Create a better, more interesting Christmas for you and the dog. Go to a dog-friendly hotel, host friends at home, volunteer — whatever you fancy. Things change and being flexible and trying to find a positive solution is the way to go.

MsRosley · 25/09/2023 22:05

I would feel hurt too in your shoes, OP. But what I don't understand is what your DM is proposing long term. That you never see each other again? That you never again share a Christmas together? Because unless you can both find a solution, that seems to be the outcome. Surely she can see that?

I haven't RTFT, but could you not stay somewhere nearby, so the dog issue isn't at play in the evening/night. It might be a compromise, along with keeping the dogs in different rooms when you are there. We have a family member who is very nervous of dogs, so ours have to be shut away when they visit.

Nanny0gg · 25/09/2023 22:05

Noimnotstillonmumsne · 25/09/2023 22:01

Your mum sounds like a bit of a diva and control freak OP. She has to be the host, your dog is banned without discussion, and you’re not even allowed to host the family the next day!

She IS entitled to be a control freak over her own home though

ThirstyMeeples · 25/09/2023 22:04

Oh OP- I have no idea either way about the dogs but you have made me chuckle. You've handled this thread with good grace. And if I'm honest, I suspect the apple hasn't fallen far from the tree and you and your mother are quite similar in temperament. I hope you get it sorted and I'm sure you will.

Nanny0gg · 25/09/2023 22:04

Bs0u416d · 25/09/2023 21:56

No, not a comedian. And I am contrite. We all say things we don't mean when we are upset or backed into a corner. If you don't, then perhaps you're a saint and we'll all be seeing you at Christmas.

That was particularly vile though

That sort of comment wouldn't cross my mind

Bs0u416d · 25/09/2023 22:03

mcmooberry · 25/09/2023 22:00

I wouldn't have taken that news one bit well OP, those previous family dogs would have welcomed your GD into the fold, no doubt about it. Loads of reasons why you can't leave your dog at Christmas and GDs don't do well in kennels imo.
All extremely disappointing, you probably don't want to be spending Christmas with just your DP and DDog, could you go somewhere else? Definitely host your siblings on Boxing Day so at least you'll see them all. Although hopefully your DM will reconsider and find a way to invite you all.

Thanks for the understanding. My GD (new mumsnet lingo) is a complete baby and we only leave him with known sitters that wouldnt be available at chrismtas. I think it will all come good, we have plenty of time to iron things out and this thread has given me renewed perspective re my mother.

OP posts:
Nanny0gg · 25/09/2023 22:03

Bs0u416d · 25/09/2023 19:57

Oh my goodness yes. This in spades. Everything you have said resonates. My dog ignores their pair and usually just sleeps on the sofa or finds a fire to flop infront of. But she we will wanter into a room and complain he's on a sofa when so are hers! Their dogs are prone to nervour yapping and urination, whether he is there or not. But when he is there, it is his fault.

I love dogs and they would be welcome in my house

But there is no way a great Dane is going on my sofa!

I assume if your siblings go to you on Boxing Day then your parents won't come because the dog situation would be the same?

What breed are hers?