Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to leave kids home alone?

31 replies

GreenDancingKitten · 25/09/2023 18:43

I’ve been doing a dance class for a while once a week, it’s the only thing that is for me. It’s term time only, and over the summer while I wasn’t going my DH started playing football on the same night of the week. He said it was just a few weeks and wouldn’t disrupt my class. Now he wants us to both go out and leave out DD12 and DS9 home alone (7.30-9.15pm on a school night).

I get that the football is good for him and he isn’t suggesting I should give up my dance - but I really am not comfortable with leaving the kids at this time. He thinks it’s fine. We’d both be leaving our phones at the side where we might not hear if kids ring too.

We’ve left the eldest home alone for a few hours sometimes now she’s in high school, that’s usually her letting herself is after school if we’re both working in office on same day. The youngest we’ve left in her care for short bursts of time (10 mins or so). They’re both sensible and well behaved but it doesn’t feel right to leave them at bedtime at this age (youngest especially).

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
lottiegarbanzo · 26/09/2023 22:29

12yo by themselves for a bit, yes, during the day.

Supervising a younger one - no way!!

9yo without adult supervision - no way!!!

if something goes wrong they'll get scared, wind each up and do stupid things. If something goes really wrong they won't know what to do at all.

There must be lots of football teams. Why doesn't he find one that meets on another night? Or get a babysitter?

autienotnaughty · 26/09/2023 03:19

No they are too young. Maybe in a couple of years. I'd be annoyed at your dh for putting you in this position. I'd say no, continue with your dance class.

TheOpen · 25/09/2023 21:41

I think the 12 year old would be ok but you have to consider what happens if the 12 year old has a problem which the 9 year old then has to deal with (eg they faint)

My kids are a similar age and are happy home alone while I pop to the shop down the road but I wouldn't plan for both parents to be out for that long and at that time. It would also hamper your enjoyment of it

Antst · 25/09/2023 21:09

@pentuppetula
>>Only 20mins at 15?! That's ridiculous.

Well, that's how long it took to get to the shop. I'm sure they would have left us for longer at 15 if they had needed to (I was a busy kid and it wasn't often I had to stay home), but not overnight. The point is, 13 is too young. We forget as adults.

Things might be fine but at that age, the chances are higher they won't be. Creeps really do pay attention to who's home. I also think the OP needs to find out what the insurance situation is if something happens to the house when there's no adult at home.

SillySausagez · 25/09/2023 21:09

10 and 13 yes but 9 and 12 no

caban · 25/09/2023 21:02

Personally, my children would have been fine at those ages.

But if you're not comfortable, then DH either stays home or finds a babysitter.

pentuppetula · 25/09/2023 20:36

Antst · 25/09/2023 20:00

I grew up with minimal supervision. My parents were completely fine with my going off to a pretty hostile country for a year at 16. If I wanted to sleep outside in a tent for weeks, they were OK with that.

However, they would never, ever leave me and my sibling at home alone at 12 (or 13 or 14). I think they started going on 20-minute trips to the shop when I was 15.

Honestly, I think they made the right decision. I absolutely would have ended up burning the house down or breaking something. Or the local creeps would have taken note that my parents were gone.

I recently returned to the UK after years overseas and have no idea what the law is about leaving kids at home, but in three different countries where I lived previously, it would be illegal to leave a 13-year-old home alone.

You need to stand up to your husband. If your dancing came first, then you should see out the season (i.e., he doesn't get to do his activity that clashes with your dancing). Renegotiate once your current season is over.

Only 20mins at 15?! That's ridiculous.
OP I think yours are still a bit too young. Mine are now in year 9 and 7 and I haven't yet left them for that long in the evening but plan to fairly soon.
Your DH needs to step up I'm afraid.

AvengedQuince · 25/09/2023 20:24

Is there a very local friend or relative who would agree to be on call if you can not keep your phone on you?

Fleasbane · 25/09/2023 20:22

Do you think it's a coincidence that he found a football thing that was on the same evening as your dance thing?

sleepyscientist · 25/09/2023 20:21

What year is DS? Our DS is 9 soon to be 10 and would enjoy that time. Can you get a smart watch so they can text you and you can read the message if needed.

Surely the 12 year old gets herself home from school and DS is in year 5 so will be in 18 months time maximum?

AvengedQuince · 25/09/2023 20:19

I'd be uncomfortable leaving a 9 year old that late unless it was summer and light for most of it. 10 and in year 6 I would likely be okay with it, or if the older child was a teenager. I wouldn't consider a 12 year old to be a babysitter so I would be considering the children separately.

ToniTTtopaz · 25/09/2023 20:17

Their too young to leave for that amount of time.

You started yours first and he said his was 'only a couple of weeks'

He's BU

Holidaydiscosinglemum · 25/09/2023 20:16

I wouldn't do it with mine (same ages)
I have once or twice left them to walk 5 mins to collect takeaway but nit fir hours in the evening.
I leave the 12 yo for a couple of hours while 9 yo is doing gymnastics and she's fine - super sensible and still home by 8:30

Dragonsandcats · 25/09/2023 20:11

I was planning an evening out with my dh leaving my 2dc’s 15&13 until half 10 ish. They’re sensible kids, it would be a weekend so they wouldn’t go to bed earlier than that anyway 🤷‍♀️

Dragonsandcats · 25/09/2023 20:10

I’m surprised by some of these posts. Your parents wouldn’t have left you in the house for 20 minutes when you were 14? Seriously?!

Beezknees · 25/09/2023 20:09

Too young. I'd do this now with my 15 year old but not 12 and 9. Going to the shops in the daytime for half an hour, fine. Not an evening out.

Greenfinch7 · 25/09/2023 20:06

I would have left mine at that age occasionally, but that is because we live in a village with two sets of neighbours who would have been happy to be on call if there was any kind of emergency or if the kids got a bit nervous.

When she was 12, my daughter used to baby sit our neighbour's daughter (who adored her), but only on the understanding that I was at home and would be a 30 second walk away if anything went even a little wrong.

It can work if there is an adult nearby on the end of a phone.

Antst · 25/09/2023 20:00

I grew up with minimal supervision. My parents were completely fine with my going off to a pretty hostile country for a year at 16. If I wanted to sleep outside in a tent for weeks, they were OK with that.

However, they would never, ever leave me and my sibling at home alone at 12 (or 13 or 14). I think they started going on 20-minute trips to the shop when I was 15.

Honestly, I think they made the right decision. I absolutely would have ended up burning the house down or breaking something. Or the local creeps would have taken note that my parents were gone.

I recently returned to the UK after years overseas and have no idea what the law is about leaving kids at home, but in three different countries where I lived previously, it would be illegal to leave a 13-year-old home alone.

You need to stand up to your husband. If your dancing came first, then you should see out the season (i.e., he doesn't get to do his activity that clashes with your dancing). Renegotiate once your current season is over.

lizzy8230 · 25/09/2023 19:25

Why on earth wouldn't you get a babysitter? I assume that's what you've done so far whenever you've both been out?

Newestname002 · 25/09/2023 19:07

I assume he is hoping you will give up your hobby.

I wondered that also. Agree with posters saying get a babysitter - and DP should equally share the cost of this. 🌹

RedHelenB · 25/09/2023 19:03

If they're happy to be left then I don't see a problem.

UsingChangeofName · 25/09/2023 19:00

Ask around your friends / neighbours / colleagues if anyone has a 6th former who would come and sit with them to earn a few quid.

If you can't find anyone, then your dh has to give up as yours was already in place first.

He might find that one of his footballing team mates has an older dc who might do it, if he asks.

AngryAndAnxious · 25/09/2023 18:59

TheLightProgramme · 25/09/2023 18:54

Too young. Get a babysitter. A proper one, not a 12 year old.

Yep. Baby sitter, and he should pay!

Awaywiththewhisk · 25/09/2023 18:57

I mean if you had to nip down to the shop for 10/20 minutes okay. But not for that length of time.
Isn’t that round about the youngest’s bedtime? So they’d have to put themselves to bed? Bit depressing for them too. Especially if it’s avoidable.

Ozziedream · 25/09/2023 18:56

Even if they were “safe” I wouldn’t do this on a regular basis on a school night. At that age my DC had homework that I supervised (loosely) and music practise and dinner…and if we had all that done by 7.30 (unlikely as often only getting home from after school activities at 6pm) then they would need some unwinding and chatting to me.

when dh and I had a week night clash like that (or more likely I wanted to go out as dh not home from work) we would get a babysitter; usually just a local student who was happy to be paid for 2 hours for a short job.