Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell my boss how unreasonable his comments are

29 replies

Cluelessat33 · 25/09/2023 17:29

I've posted about my boss on here before. Over the last 8 years I've dealt with some pretty unreasonable behaviour. Constant critical and unpleasant comments, often in public. He picks apart and corrects my work constantly (think criticising me for using single spacing, kind of level). He's once threatened me with disciplinary action for something I didn't do. At one point I was put under investigation for gross misconduct with some team members, again for something I didn't do, and after one meeting with HR, it was thrown out and we were told it should never have been brought to them.

He is often critical in front of other people. Or makes 'joke' remarks which are pretty critical and unnecessary in leadership meetings. My performance reviews are always excellent. I've never (other than the two examples which were unfounded above) had my conduct questioned. I'm a hard worker, I go above and beyond because I feel passionately about what I do, despite the challenging working environment.

He is leaving soon. Thankfully. But today once again he made a comment in our leadership meeting which quite clearly implied I'm often slacking. He said afterwards it was a joke, but at a time when I'm doing more than one person's job on part time hours, and feel stressed about the number of plates I'm spinning, the comment hit a very raw spot.

Would I be unreasonable to use him leaving as an opportunity to tell him how demoralising I have found his comments over the years, particularly at time when he knows I'm under significant pressure. I believe his public putting downs have lead to another male colleague doing the same, something I will be putting a forceful stop to me, as he is a lower grade to me. Or should I just leave it as he's leaving and there is no point.

OP posts:
Aquamarine1029 · 25/09/2023 18:09

Why have you stayed in this job for 8 years?

Canyoudigityesyoucan · 25/09/2023 18:07

If you think he’s going to take onboard your feedback or grow/learn from it, give it to him on exit.

if you want to give it to him to make you feel better and get a loaf off your chest, don’t bother. It’s a waste of your energy, just be grateful he’s off and see it as a learning opportunity for you to nip these things in bud earlier.

Sorry he was an arse to you!

JoinInBetty · 25/09/2023 18:04

Why didn't you speak up when he was being a twat in the meeting.
If nothing is ever said then they will never have the chance to change. Or you speak up and they carry on being a twat just like my ex manager

HappiestSleeping · 25/09/2023 17:34

Personally, I would ask if he is open to feedback. If he says yes, word it neutrally, but give him both barrels. If he says no, then you know there's no point. Use examples as evidence. You did x, and y was the consequence which you may not be aware of. Additionally, it made me feel demotivated. Try and balance it with some things he does well. The old 'shit sandwich' so to speak.