Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I've got any chance of getting this job with a criminal record?

188 replies

Ravenalasia · 25/09/2023 16:12

Hi, I applied for a Teaching Assistant job recently and the school phoned today to offer me an interview on Wednesday.

They then emailed me the self disclosure form which I've returned with the convictions on that the accompanying flow chart said I had to disclose... am I going to be laughed out of the interview?

Convictions: harassment charge which resulted in me getting a restraining order and having to pay costs to the victim (my ex) plus a caution (basically phoned him too much, was cautioned then kept ringing out of desperation and he went to the court to do an ex parte affidavit thing and I ended up with the harassment charge. Pleaded guilty obviously. This was 9 years ago. Also a caution for battery as we got into a fight the previous day (it was an abusive relationship)

I also had another incident of criminal damage with another abusive ex; he locked me out of his house at 3am whilst pregnant and I basically kicked at the cat flap to get his attention as he still had my purse in the house, damaging the door in the process.

So. I deeply regret all incidents obviously and have since been diagnosed and medicated for generalised anxiety disorder but are these incidents 'too' bad for me to be able to explain away?

How do I even explain them, as I'm worried if I say it the way I have done above, it sounds like I'm victim blaming?

Thanks in advance for any and all advice!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Purplegrapeglasses · 25/09/2023 17:46

gogomoto · 25/09/2023 17:45

Enhanced DBS's show everything, my dbs record (completely clean I should add) goes back to my 18th birthday over 30 years ago - I had to list every address I had lived at for my first dbs, then subsequently addresses since the last one

My caution for common assault was filtered off mine - because it is a summary offence not a specified offence and was more than 6 years old after 2020 it was filtered off

gogomoto · 25/09/2023 17:45

Enhanced DBS's show everything, my dbs record (completely clean I should add) goes back to my 18th birthday over 30 years ago - I had to list every address I had lived at for my first dbs, then subsequently addresses since the last one

Nc4001 · 25/09/2023 17:42

FWIW you do all realise there are people with spent convictions who can and do work in schools? "Worst" I've come across is GBH, was disclosed to me as a question - "I have a conviction for GBH but it's spent and I've not been in trouble since, will it stop me getting the job?" Answer was no, and it did not.

DBS checks aren't a failsafe method anyway, I work in education myself. I had my initial check, and every year simply have to confirm I've had no convictions since. This isn't checked in any way, I just tick a box on a form which is filed away by HR. I believe this is common practice after the initial check at recruitment stage.

gogomoto · 25/09/2023 17:40

I would consider any violent convictions to be a no. I'm a safeguarding officer.

Purplegrapeglasses · 25/09/2023 17:38

Downtherivers · 25/09/2023 17:36

I would hope it prevents you getting the job - that is a serious record to be working with children or vulnerable people. As a parent I would be withdrawing my children if I found out their TAs had that record (and these kind of things always end up getting found out). I would surprised if the school took the risk, for if nothing else the risk to their reputation

There are probably a few with cautions you’d never know about since the filtering rules were amended in 2020 - people deserve a second chance . I was overjoyed when it changed and applied for jobs immediately knowing that I wouldn’t have to disclose

MartinChuzzlewit · 25/09/2023 17:36

I would do what a PP suggests and accompany the form with a letter. I think it’s better to be honest and hope they see you’ve changed and you’re not hiding anything from them

Downtherivers · 25/09/2023 17:36

I would hope it prevents you getting the job - that is a serious record to be working with children or vulnerable people. As a parent I would be withdrawing my children if I found out their TAs had that record (and these kind of things always end up getting found out). I would surprised if the school took the risk, for if nothing else the risk to their reputation

ActDottie · 25/09/2023 17:35

In a school that’s a massive no.

My husband is a school site manager and they couldn’t hire a caretaker because he had a minor conviction for carrying weed. Caretakers barely interact with the kids and it was a massive no.

ASCCM · 25/09/2023 17:33

Sorry OP but I don’t think you’re getting any job working for children or vulnerable people with that record.

SpookyLadle · 25/09/2023 17:32

In all honesty I think you will receive a phone call from the school after the interview to say that unfortunately at this time, you were not successful. Whilst you could be the best interview, I highly doubt they will even want the hassle of approaching the local schools HR team about this.

As a previous poster said, if it got out to the local media somehow (perhaps someone who knows about your conviction, or an ex?) then even without an incident occurring it would still put huge strain on the school.

A SEN school have even more reason to be wary of any violent convictions, as their students are more vulnerable than most.

There is nothing to stop you having a professional career elsewhere though.

Nc4001 · 25/09/2023 17:31

Name changed because in my line of work I'm heavily involved with training and recruiting TAs (this with previous posts could have potentially identified me).

This is in my LA area, so may differ. If it were me recruiting, I would advise you to be upfront about convictions (they will come up on background checks anyway) and explain why they happened, and how you've changed since then. However, we do have blanket bans on certain types of conviction, but that may differ area to area.

TA vacancies are few and far between with lots of candidates going for every post - many of them with a specific TA qualification. Due to that, unfortunately one of them with a clean record would more likely get the job where I am. For example, in the past month, we've seen 40 people achieve the qualification in a highly saturated job market, and none of them have convictions.

That said, it varies everywhere, some areas may be crying out for TAs. It is worth going for, and I would never discourage anyone with a criminal record from going for it, I'd just be realistic with them in that it may affect their chances.

Purplegrapeglasses · 25/09/2023 17:26

More things are filtered now since 2020- I have a caution for common assault which so now filtered I didn’t even mention it at my interview and it didn’t come up on the enhanced dbs

UnctuousUnicorns · 25/09/2023 17:23

PollyAmour · 25/09/2023 17:20

Is there a time when these convictions won't show on your record?

Maybe wait until it's 10 years since your last conviction.

AFAIK convictions are never considered spent when working (or potentially working with) children or otherwise vulnerable adults?

PollyAmour · 25/09/2023 17:20

Is there a time when these convictions won't show on your record?

Maybe wait until it's 10 years since your last conviction.

clarepetal · 25/09/2023 17:17

Ravenalasia · 25/09/2023 16:34

Thanks all.

It's a special school and my own children have autism so I'm aware of some of the challenges involved with getting ehcps, the right kin of support in schools etc., it's an unqualified position and the lady who phoned me seemed happy with my application.

I've been on my children's ptfa and a parent helper in the past and in 2015 volunteered for a year with local homelessness charity, as stated before I pursued a MH diagnosis after my last arrest and was diagnosed with GAD, I've also done the freedom course.

Maybe put all of this in a covering letter. Best of luck 👍

Tribevibes · 25/09/2023 17:16

TAs are in demand but this doesn’t mean they scrimp on safety. There are so many checks due to the new keeping children safe in education policy. Personally I wouldn’t employ you after a battery charge. There is no room for people who have the capacity for violence in schools. I am sure you are aware that in special schools there is a risk that you yourself may get hit by a dysregulated student. There’s no way i would employ someone who could be triggered into reacting violently. Sorry if that’s not what you wanted to hear.

Spacecowboys · 25/09/2023 17:16

I wouldn’t want someone with harassment and battery charges on their record teaching my children. I’d be surprised if schools were happy to overlook it tbh.

Jeschara · 25/09/2023 17:15

I think it will affect your application, sorry to say this but if all applicants present well at the interview,are they going to pick the one one with or without the criminal record?

DriftingDora · 25/09/2023 17:13

Ravenalasia · 25/09/2023 17:04

Whilst I can see the point you're trying to make, I've had disagreements with many people and haven't been violent.

Both former relationships were abusive; one with a man who physically and emotionally abused me including whilst I was pregnant with his child and the second wad a man who lovebombed me, moved me in after my house wad broken into and then decided to ask me to leave the same day as his daughter moved in. I ended up homeless and my children being taken to live with their dad as I was literally on the street...it was that, I think, that triggered me phoning my ex begging him to speak to me and turned up at his door for him to let me in, offer me a bath and let me stay the night then the next morning engineered an argument that ended in a fight where he was on top of me and had the upper hand, only to roll off me and hit his head on the floor as his daughter walked in.

Anyway. I'm not excusing my behaviour but there is a lot to the story and I really don't have anger issues.

That's not the point. The point is that there are occasions when you HAVE been violent - and these were bad enough to have the police and the court service involved. What I'm saying is you have to accept ownership of this - and see it from the school's point of view. Would you risk it, if the boot was on the other foot? Be honest.

MichelleScarn · 25/09/2023 17:10

Is there really nothing more than a few phone calls? Convictions: harassment charge which resulted in me getting a restraining order and having to pay costs to the victim (my ex) plus a caution (basically phoned him too much, was cautioned then kept ringing out of desperation and he went to the court to do an ex parte affidavit thing and I ended up with the harassment charge. Pleaded guilty obviously. This was 9 years ago. Also a caution for battery as we got into a fight the previous day (it was an abusive relationship) and it was taken that far by police cps? I've known and seen on here case of psychological and physical abuse that weren't dealt with to that level!

PrincessHoneysuckle · 25/09/2023 17:06

Criminal record of any kind means no employment at the school i work at

Ravenalasia · 25/09/2023 17:04

Whilst I can see the point you're trying to make, I've had disagreements with many people and haven't been violent.

Both former relationships were abusive; one with a man who physically and emotionally abused me including whilst I was pregnant with his child and the second wad a man who lovebombed me, moved me in after my house wad broken into and then decided to ask me to leave the same day as his daughter moved in. I ended up homeless and my children being taken to live with their dad as I was literally on the street...it was that, I think, that triggered me phoning my ex begging him to speak to me and turned up at his door for him to let me in, offer me a bath and let me stay the night then the next morning engineered an argument that ended in a fight where he was on top of me and had the upper hand, only to roll off me and hit his head on the floor as his daughter walked in.

Anyway. I'm not excusing my behaviour but there is a lot to the story and I really don't have anger issues.

OP posts:
DriftingDora · 25/09/2023 16:42

Are you looking at this from the school's point of view, I wonder? What if there was an incident and you lost your rag? Working in schools can be very challenging, you'll have to take instructions from others and whilst I'm not saying for a minute you would harm a child, the teachers are adults and if you happen to have a disagreement with one of them, what then?

Can you imagine what the Press - and the parents - would say if something did happen? Would the Local Authority be sued into the middle of next week? I think you have to be very honest here - it will come out, anyway - and put yourself in the school's place.

ProfYaffle · 25/09/2023 16:35

I work in HR in education but an FE setting rather than a school. The factors we look at in assessing convictions are:
Nature of the offence - how relevant it is to the setting
How long ago was it
Have you taken steps to ensure it doesn't happen again?
Have you shown remorse?
Were there mitigating factors?

I'd suggest your diagnosis of GAD plus the fact that you were in a coercive relationship are potentially mitigating factors.

Your record wouldn't necessarily stop you working for us but our students are much older, I don't know whether a school may view things differently. My suggestion is to be honest about your conviction and be prepared to have a conversation, probably with HR. It shouldn't be part of the selection process.

Ravenalasia · 25/09/2023 16:34

Thanks all.

It's a special school and my own children have autism so I'm aware of some of the challenges involved with getting ehcps, the right kin of support in schools etc., it's an unqualified position and the lady who phoned me seemed happy with my application.

I've been on my children's ptfa and a parent helper in the past and in 2015 volunteered for a year with local homelessness charity, as stated before I pursued a MH diagnosis after my last arrest and was diagnosed with GAD, I've also done the freedom course.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread