Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I've got any chance of getting this job with a criminal record?

188 replies

Ravenalasia · 25/09/2023 16:12

Hi, I applied for a Teaching Assistant job recently and the school phoned today to offer me an interview on Wednesday.

They then emailed me the self disclosure form which I've returned with the convictions on that the accompanying flow chart said I had to disclose... am I going to be laughed out of the interview?

Convictions: harassment charge which resulted in me getting a restraining order and having to pay costs to the victim (my ex) plus a caution (basically phoned him too much, was cautioned then kept ringing out of desperation and he went to the court to do an ex parte affidavit thing and I ended up with the harassment charge. Pleaded guilty obviously. This was 9 years ago. Also a caution for battery as we got into a fight the previous day (it was an abusive relationship)

I also had another incident of criminal damage with another abusive ex; he locked me out of his house at 3am whilst pregnant and I basically kicked at the cat flap to get his attention as he still had my purse in the house, damaging the door in the process.

So. I deeply regret all incidents obviously and have since been diagnosed and medicated for generalised anxiety disorder but are these incidents 'too' bad for me to be able to explain away?

How do I even explain them, as I'm worried if I say it the way I have done above, it sounds like I'm victim blaming?

Thanks in advance for any and all advice!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Wrongsideofpennines · 26/09/2023 20:05

I know a social worker who had a conviction for assaulting a police officer. She was a teenager and it was accidental but it was never 'spent' so she always had to declare it. She was in her 60s and had clearly got on ok in life as she was able to work as a social worker. She was one of the best social workers I've ever met.

If you haven't cancelled then don't. Go to the interview and get interview experience at least for when you don't have to declare your convictions.

lightpineapple · 26/09/2023 19:22

Go to the interview @Ravenalasia. I can't comment on whether these convictions make you ineligible for a TA role but it sounds like you will need to practise disclosing them in this kind of setting anyway, so you may as well see how it goes this week.

I don't think anyone on the thread can answer the specific q but I would echo the PP who have suggested getting touch with charities who support people getting back into work.

Do agree with others that the explanations - rightly or wrongly - would make me a little bit concerned as it sounds like you feel you have two convictions that were not your fault from two different people. Would be good to chat to someone who knows more about whether it is better to take more responsibility - however completely appreciate that may not be appropriate and people do unfairly end up in these situations. Good luck Flowers

Concannon88 · 26/09/2023 19:15

The reason they wont be filtered is because theres more than one, therefore ineligible

Ascendant15 · 26/09/2023 19:06

Poppysmom22 · 26/09/2023 19:01

I am all for second chances and rehabilitation just not in close proximity to vulnerable people. Maybe choose a career where this doesn't matter so much.

Actually some of the best people to be around "vulnerable people" are those who've been there. But that is why it is critical to make informed decisions based on clear evidence. Some of the most inspiring people I've ever met have criminal records that would make your toes curl....

Poppysmom22 · 26/09/2023 19:01

I am all for second chances and rehabilitation just not in close proximity to vulnerable people. Maybe choose a career where this doesn't matter so much.

Hanlonsamazer · 26/09/2023 16:11

JSMill · 26/09/2023 15:51

There's no way you'd get a job in school. That would come up on the DBS check and domestic violence is a major safeguarding concern.

Don’t make shit up! You’d tell your kids off for lying. Set an example.

OhmygodDont · 26/09/2023 16:05

Anything under 18 pretty much is wiped after 11 years.

Think of how many current teacher could have massive teenage records your never know about. Unless they involved sex/children/terrorism.

Should a was silly 14/15/16/17 year old never be allowed to work near a child ever because they were a twat as a teenager?

Now it ops case she was an adult and she’s sought help, it’s nearly been her time limit with nothing again since the last one. She never did anything to a child etc already volunteered there too.

JSMill · 26/09/2023 15:51

There's no way you'd get a job in school. That would come up on the DBS check and domestic violence is a major safeguarding concern.

Comedycook · 26/09/2023 15:34

And I do feel some sympathy for the op...but I'd be pretty horrified if she was employed at my dcs school and if I was a recruiter I would not hire her.

Comedycook · 26/09/2023 15:21

DriftingDora · 26/09/2023 14:17

How do you know what Jimmy Saville had, or didn't have, on his record from past years?

It would be interesting to see how many people here who are telling everyone else they are being 'judgmental' would be equally 'judgmental'(?) if they discovered a TA with a record like this was at their child's school? My guess is rarer than hen's teeth, but nothing unusual there..it's the 'do as I say, not as I would do in real life' syndrome again. As someone has rightly said upthread, there are very poor relationship choices indicated here - and what would happen if a domestic argument spilled into confronting the partner outside the school gates - or inside? Cross your fingers and hope nobody else gets damaged?

I don't know for sure. Was he ever arrested? I'm pretty sure he was never convicted...if he was I'm fairly sure we'd know about it. But regardless, I'm just pointing out that there are probably plenty of people who have clear DBs checks simply because they've never been caught. It's not a perfect system but it's better to have it in place than no checks at all.

Hanlonsamazer · 26/09/2023 14:58

DriftingDora · 26/09/2023 14:17

How do you know what Jimmy Saville had, or didn't have, on his record from past years?

It would be interesting to see how many people here who are telling everyone else they are being 'judgmental' would be equally 'judgmental'(?) if they discovered a TA with a record like this was at their child's school? My guess is rarer than hen's teeth, but nothing unusual there..it's the 'do as I say, not as I would do in real life' syndrome again. As someone has rightly said upthread, there are very poor relationship choices indicated here - and what would happen if a domestic argument spilled into confronting the partner outside the school gates - or inside? Cross your fingers and hope nobody else gets damaged?

If you don’t trust your DC’s school to get their employment risk assessments right, you should probably pick another school.

DriftingDora · 26/09/2023 14:17

Comedycook · 26/09/2023 11:02

A dbs check certainly isn't a perfect system...I mean let's face it, Jimmy Saville was never convicted so would have got through a dbs check no problem! However, it is better than nothing. Lots of people have convictions for incredibly minor things .. motoring offences, non payment of a rail fare etc which probably wouldn't exclude them from working with children. I think the problem the op will have is the fact that it involves violence and there are multiple ones. My concern if I was a potential employer is that if the op has been in several abusive relationships, what if she enters another one and an abusive partner comes to her workplace and it kicks off? On the plus side, she's been volunteering and it hasn't proved a problem. That might strengthen her case. Who knows?! I think she should definitely still go to the interview. There is nothing to lose.

How do you know what Jimmy Saville had, or didn't have, on his record from past years?

It would be interesting to see how many people here who are telling everyone else they are being 'judgmental' would be equally 'judgmental'(?) if they discovered a TA with a record like this was at their child's school? My guess is rarer than hen's teeth, but nothing unusual there..it's the 'do as I say, not as I would do in real life' syndrome again. As someone has rightly said upthread, there are very poor relationship choices indicated here - and what would happen if a domestic argument spilled into confronting the partner outside the school gates - or inside? Cross your fingers and hope nobody else gets damaged?

Ascendant15 · 26/09/2023 12:42

I think there are two different things being confused here. People are certainly entitled to second chances, and having a criminal record, with a few exceptions, is no barrier in and of itself to almost all employments. Even having multiple offences is not a barrier, although clearly it doesn't help. But the way that it is explained, the route that has been taken to rehabilitation, a self- awareness of one's journey to commit a crime, and taking responsibility is the test of the degree of risk an employer takes. So if the OP goes into an interview explaining, as they did here, how none of it was their fault and they are really the victim, then their chances go through the floor.

It is not being a "hyena" by pointing that out, and many people on this thread have made the point that it isn't the offences in themselves that are the problem, but the fact that the OPs explanations lack an awareness of their own responsibilities in the offences.

Concannon88 · 26/09/2023 12:33

She hasnt done that at all. You say shes the one with he criminal conviction, how do you know the other person didnt receive one aswel?

Concannon88 · 26/09/2023 12:29

Yeah that's illegal

Ladyoftheknight · 26/09/2023 11:45

I fully believe that most people with criminal and violent pasts can be rehabilitated and go on to be safe people. But multiple records of violence and unhinged/dangerous behaviour will not go down well in a special school. Staff in most schools, but particularly in special education settings need to be calm and collected, not likely to become enraged or violent

TheLuckyOnes · 26/09/2023 11:14

Hanlonsamazer · 26/09/2023 10:48

Because it’s a lazy way to judge people. You don’t have to know whether they are povs or feed their kids chicken nuggets for breakfast. You can judge them and consign them to the “not worthy of respect” pile without having to do any further analysis.

Its a disgusting attitude and one which smacks of some sort of misplaced middle class snobbery.

As the context to the OP's question is about a school TA job for which there are expected to be a large number of applicants, the question is why a selection panel would fall over themselves to make allowances for someone with a criminal record when there are presumably large numbers of applicants who did an excellent interview and are suitable without a criminal record?

As someone just reading this thread, while I am sympathetic to the OP, whose past is constricting her job opportunities (though that is, obviously part of the point of a criminal record, that someone is aware that if they are charged or cautioned, this is going to follow them around longterm, even if they avoid a fine or imprisonment), I do find myself wondering whether, given that two of the offences involved two different abusive exes, this person had an established pattern of poor relationship choices that was still ongoing, and liable to interfere with her working life.

VesperLynne · 26/09/2023 11:07

Imagine if this was a man applying to work in school.

Comedycook · 26/09/2023 11:02

A dbs check certainly isn't a perfect system...I mean let's face it, Jimmy Saville was never convicted so would have got through a dbs check no problem! However, it is better than nothing. Lots of people have convictions for incredibly minor things .. motoring offences, non payment of a rail fare etc which probably wouldn't exclude them from working with children. I think the problem the op will have is the fact that it involves violence and there are multiple ones. My concern if I was a potential employer is that if the op has been in several abusive relationships, what if she enters another one and an abusive partner comes to her workplace and it kicks off? On the plus side, she's been volunteering and it hasn't proved a problem. That might strengthen her case. Who knows?! I think she should definitely still go to the interview. There is nothing to lose.

Hanlonsamazer · 26/09/2023 10:48

Hadebough · 26/09/2023 09:55

I don't understand why so many people think that having a criminal record from years and years ago instantly makes someone a risk to children? It's not a very good indicator, realistically all having a clean criminal record proves is that someone's never been caught commuting a crime.

Because it’s a lazy way to judge people. You don’t have to know whether they are povs or feed their kids chicken nuggets for breakfast. You can judge them and consign them to the “not worthy of respect” pile without having to do any further analysis.

Its a disgusting attitude and one which smacks of some sort of misplaced middle class snobbery.

Hadebough · 26/09/2023 09:55

I don't understand why so many people think that having a criminal record from years and years ago instantly makes someone a risk to children? It's not a very good indicator, realistically all having a clean criminal record proves is that someone's never been caught commuting a crime.

Gnomegnomegnome · 26/09/2023 09:25

Don’t withdraw the application. See what happens.

Longtimelurkerfinallyposts · 26/09/2023 08:59

Please don't withdraw before the interview just because of what some people have said on here!

Having criminal convictions does not automatically bar you from working in a school (not even a SEN one)! I know this because I've worked in dozens of schools, and not been considered a risk at all.

There are certain offences which would never be filtered, and which should arguably prevent someone from ever working with children (for example, things like child kidnapping and sexual offences) but you haven't committed any of these.

I'm actually pretty disgusted by all the "i work in a school and we'd never employ you" responses - it's like all these people haven't heard of the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act and think it's acceptable to discriminate in this way, even decades after the offence took place.

DriftingDora · 26/09/2023 07:57

BoDidley · 25/09/2023 23:10

I work for a regulatory body for teachers not in E&W. Disclosure of such convictions would result in us wanting to ask some questions about the circumstances but would in no way automatically rule you out. Insight, remorse and remediation are all important. Go to the interview.

Yes, and people can put on a convincing 'act' at an interview and pretend all sorts of things. But some facts speak for themselves. And how can you know from an interview whether someone is truly remorseful? This is very naïve.

Let's be realistic and look at things from the point of view of any school concerned for its reputation.* * You'll never be able to legislate for every eventuality when interviewing a prospective member of staff, but as I said before, some facts speak for themselves - and one fact here that is disturbing is OP seems to be largely blaming others/events in her past for what happened - and what happened includes violence, remember?

BoDidley · 25/09/2023 23:10

I work for a regulatory body for teachers not in E&W. Disclosure of such convictions would result in us wanting to ask some questions about the circumstances but would in no way automatically rule you out. Insight, remorse and remediation are all important. Go to the interview.

Swipe left for the next trending thread