Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I've got any chance of getting this job with a criminal record?

188 replies

Ravenalasia · 25/09/2023 16:12

Hi, I applied for a Teaching Assistant job recently and the school phoned today to offer me an interview on Wednesday.

They then emailed me the self disclosure form which I've returned with the convictions on that the accompanying flow chart said I had to disclose... am I going to be laughed out of the interview?

Convictions: harassment charge which resulted in me getting a restraining order and having to pay costs to the victim (my ex) plus a caution (basically phoned him too much, was cautioned then kept ringing out of desperation and he went to the court to do an ex parte affidavit thing and I ended up with the harassment charge. Pleaded guilty obviously. This was 9 years ago. Also a caution for battery as we got into a fight the previous day (it was an abusive relationship)

I also had another incident of criminal damage with another abusive ex; he locked me out of his house at 3am whilst pregnant and I basically kicked at the cat flap to get his attention as he still had my purse in the house, damaging the door in the process.

So. I deeply regret all incidents obviously and have since been diagnosed and medicated for generalised anxiety disorder but are these incidents 'too' bad for me to be able to explain away?

How do I even explain them, as I'm worried if I say it the way I have done above, it sounds like I'm victim blaming?

Thanks in advance for any and all advice!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Goodgrief83 · 05/10/2023 08:42

I've been on my children's ptfa and a parent helper in the past

and you weren’t DBS checked to do this?!

Concannon88 · 26/09/2023 23:51

If you mean supporting the underdog then yes. I've double and triple check and I'm not wrong, they will only be filtered if it's a basic or standard check. Not enhanced.

LittleMousewithcloggson · 26/09/2023 23:38

There’s a lot of wrong information on this thread. I have worked in employment law fields for years both as an HR director and a consultant
Regarding jobs with children and vulnerable adults, convictions are never spent and have to be disclosed
There are certain crimes that automatically ban a person from working with children and this cannot be changed. Otherwise it is up to the recruiters.
The recruiting board (safer recruitment policies have to be followed for the job role so there should be more than one interviewer) will need to complete a full risk assessment when a criminal record has been disclosed. This will take into account the crime, the circumstances, the length of time that has passed since and - this is a key one - whether the applicants circumstances are now so completely different that the chance of a repeated crime is basically zero.
I have hired a few applicants with criminal records into roles with children and have never had a single incident or concern

ThinWomansBrain · 26/09/2023 23:13

have you been in touch with the charity Working Chance?
https://workingchance.org/

they work with women with convictions to help them get back into work - may not be able to help with this specific vacancy, but may be helpful generally

Working Chance

Working Chance is the UK's only employment charity solely for women with convictions. Support us today.

https://workingchance.org

Grushenka · 26/09/2023 22:52

I won’t offer any opinion on your ability to do the job, I don’t have to risk assess you and the world isn’t fair.

What I will say is that I wish to high heaven I’d fought back the man who abused me, beating the daylights out of me for years on end from the age of 16 - I was a child when it started. I wish even once I’d hit back. I don’t blame any woman in the world who hits out in that situation, in fact I’m in awe of what you’ve been through and got through.

If they don’t give you the job because of this - so be it. But DO NOT give yourself a hard time for trying to protect yourself against a violent man.

fettuccini · 26/09/2023 22:43

I can't comment on your issue as I have no experience of this, but have you looked into any jobs working with youth offenders? You've done really well to turn your life around and often that kind of experience is welcomed in rehabilitation of offenders.

I do still think you should go for the interview and answer any questions they have honestly. If anything do it for the experience.

momtoboys · 26/09/2023 22:16

I hope your life has become more peaceful in the past 9 years. I would think that if there are any other candidates you would be passed over. I admire your honesty, though.

Cascais · 26/09/2023 22:13

Just be honest. I don’t think it should exclude you from getting the job. You sound great :)

DriftingDora · 26/09/2023 22:12

Concannon88 · 26/09/2023 20:18

That's not a fact, just your opinion and a bitchy one at that.

Schools and educating settings are in the top 10 employers in the uk that recruit rehabilitated offenders.

Both my mother and stepfather have pgces and have worked in schools, colleges and universities for over 30 years and both have criminal records, and also know numerous teachers with criminal records, including one with a previous 18 month prison sentence for punching a flight attendant on a plane. It's more than obvious that you dont really understand the recruitment process and how many ex offenders are employed in schools.

You mention schools and reputations, and you are right, schools are concerned about reputations, and having a blanket ban on applicants with previous criminal convictions breaks rehabilitation of offenders act and employment law.

What employers value and respect is honesty, which the op has demonstrated already, simply by making this post. I really hope she continues with her application and isnt put off by bigoted responses.

Your post just screams pure ignorance and you come across as not just judgemental but completely out of touch.

I think something touched a nerve here. Was it because it was pointed out earlier that you'd got your facts wrong? If you have so much personal knowledge in the family, then I'm surprised you didn't know.

Furryrug · 26/09/2023 22:04

@Ravenalasia I understand completely x

DontLeanOnTheKeyboard · 26/09/2023 22:01

The common denominator in your convictions is you. Regardless of the situation, you were found guilty and of similar offences. Safeguarding would make employing you in this role a difficult situation to defend should anything happen in the future.

Ravenalasia · 26/09/2023 21:56

Crazycrazylady · 26/09/2023 21:38

Honestly no I would t give you a role in a school with multiple convictions. One maybe bit more than one. I'm also unconvinced of your excuses re it all being your two ex's fault and you really being a victim of abuse. A judge obviously felt differently. I'd have a lot more sympathy for you if I felt you were more honest about your history instead of it being everyone else's fault.

Not going to keep posting but just wanted to make one point; the harassment charge was made (as I stated in my op) 'ex parte', which means without the other party present. He had his reasons, but genuinely I had phoned him more than I should have done (10 times in a row) to try and get him to speak to me, then turned up at his home twice and knocked his door. These aren't things I should have done, but in my mental state at the time, I did them. I remember a friend of his messaging me saying I was driving him crazy and a few weeks later I had a restraining order delivered to me. There was no court case (or, not one I was notified of due to being homeless at the time).

The criminal damage charge, I never denied. I waited for the police to arrive after he said he was phoning them, explained what had happened, was arrested and subsequently went to court and admitted what I had done. I was given a conditional discharge due to the mitigating circumstances and my level of remorse at the time.

I've never said what I did wasn't absolutely disgusting and looking back now I can't believe I allowed myself to do those things but at the time, I know how I felt; a state of pure desperation, panic, not really caring about myself or what would happen to me....I was so, so emotionally unwell and a completely different person to how I am now. I never intended to imply it was all their fault and I know it sounds unbelievable but from suffering childhood sexual abuse to this pattern of not ever wanting a relationship but getting into them somehow, I genuinely feel like I've been preyed on a lot in the past and that does really skew your logic, emotional age, reactions... etc.

I've worked on that since and am continuing to do so- therapy will be a lifetime thing for me, I think, to unpick the past. It's not a quick fix for me at all but I'm getting there.

OP posts:
Furryrug · 26/09/2023 21:51

burgundytoday · 26/09/2023 21:33

Just genuinely curious – would that not be classed as self defense? Generally the police and the law are very generous with the remit of self defense by women in cases of abusive men. Afaik prosecutions are mostly limited to murder by the woman.

In my case, I would hope so, the police weren't involved in this particular incident (I was pregnant, had endured hours of verbal abuse, he had his hand round my throat and when he let go, I threw a fork at him ) . I became a totally different person in the last few months of the relationship, almost deranged at times, I felt I'd lost my mind.

Crazycrazylady · 26/09/2023 21:38

Honestly no I would t give you a role in a school with multiple convictions. One maybe bit more than one. I'm also unconvinced of your excuses re it all being your two ex's fault and you really being a victim of abuse. A judge obviously felt differently. I'd have a lot more sympathy for you if I felt you were more honest about your history instead of it being everyone else's fault.

burgundytoday · 26/09/2023 21:33

Furryrug · 26/09/2023 21:17

For what it's worth, I would employ the op , having been pushed to my limits by an abusive partner and behaving in a way that was not how I would normally behave and have never behaved like it since, I understand that people can act out of character when under extreme emotional and physical abuse.
Having said this, I don't work in education so I guess it's easy for me to say when I don't actually have to make the decision and take the risk.

Just genuinely curious – would that not be classed as self defense? Generally the police and the law are very generous with the remit of self defense by women in cases of abusive men. Afaik prosecutions are mostly limited to murder by the woman.

Furryrug · 26/09/2023 21:17

For what it's worth, I would employ the op , having been pushed to my limits by an abusive partner and behaving in a way that was not how I would normally behave and have never behaved like it since, I understand that people can act out of character when under extreme emotional and physical abuse.
Having said this, I don't work in education so I guess it's easy for me to say when I don't actually have to make the decision and take the risk.

burgundytoday · 26/09/2023 21:15

@beeswaxinc I think many people want to believe and give second chances. I believe people are simply a product of their upbringing and environment, and have volunteered with both current inmates and ex-offenders. But it's impossible to believe when all the explanations are so convenient (just a tiny kick here, merely a light slap there) plus inconsistent. OP also hints that there are more convictions she hasn't mentioned.

Yes, of course there are always unfortunate circumstances and trigger points that push one to violence. The problem is that in school, there will be plenty of these trigger points. Children behaving like animals, bitchy or snappy colleagues, unreasonable parents, stressful salary issues, etc.

I think the crux is OP's stories all come across as "I had no choice" or "it was reasonable in that situation". Will she say that after a potential incident in school too? As an interviewer, that's what I would worry about. Hence my earlier advice to her to just cut out the convoluted justification and speak in general terms at the interview.

Gwendimarco · 26/09/2023 21:13

I have to be honest, it’s a major point against you. If you are known to the staff already as a person of good character, and if they are desperate to hire, they may give you a chance, but it’s by no means a given.

goldennavy · 26/09/2023 21:09

Well, you're not who I'd like teaching my grandchildren.
Once, forgivable, more than that, not acceptable.
I hope they turn you down.

beeswaxinc · 26/09/2023 21:05

Really sorry to say this as well but as they will only have your side of the story and they will expect you (as in anyone, general you) as a job applicant to paint yourself in the best light to get the job.

If the only “fact” they have is your conviction record which shows multiple convictions of domestic violence related incidents that occurred in adulthood, then I’m not sure you would be considered as the optimal applicant without them knowing you.

Any mitigating factors you provide will be open to subjective interpretation, you might get a lady interviewer who has been in a similar position as yourself or you might get someone who reads your account of events as poor excuses and who would think the pattern shows you in a certain way.

I think that if you believe you have the skills for the job then you should absolutely go for it with all your heart. it’s easy to judge people off one aspect but I believe that people can change and I also believe tbh that even without change as such, people are capable of having difficulties in some contexts but not others.

Hadebough · 26/09/2023 21:02

Concannon88 · 26/09/2023 19:15

The reason they wont be filtered is because theres more than one, therefore ineligible

No that was changed recently, offences eligible for filtering will now be filtered regardless of how many.

burgundytoday · 26/09/2023 20:52

Your stories all sound wild! Would the police really press charges against a pregnant woman for merely kicking at a cat flap while locked out at 3am? And how likely is it that the other guy automatically rolled off you and smashed his own head on the floor like a self destructing robot? Then in the next post it turns into a little push and slap from you?

Domestic abuse (and separately, police sexism) is still a HUGE problem but generally once there's any physical altercation between a man and woman, the police tend to be hyper alert for signs of the woman being abused. You had no bruises, marks or even anything to verbally tell the police?

I've no doubt those were unhealthy relationships (and probably mutually abusive IMO), and yes men will always end up physically overpowering women if both get into a physical fight. But you sound like you were/are provocative, violent and unstable, not just acting in self-defense.

I do wish you the best, provided you know/feel you are ready to keep your temper around children. I'm not just saying all of the above as a pile on. To give constructive advice, I think you should just speak in general terms and sound remorseful.

Don't go into convoluted stories like the above. Even on the vvvv off chance it's 100% true, it won't sound true to them. Plus the longer you talk, the more inconsistent your story gets.

Simply say it was abusive or unhealthy relationships (do not elaborate like claim you were a battered woman etc), you had a poor childhood and you have since done a lot of work.

Stompythedinosaur · 26/09/2023 20:19

Sorry, but I don't think you'll be considered for the role.

Concannon88 · 26/09/2023 20:18

That's not a fact, just your opinion and a bitchy one at that.

Schools and educating settings are in the top 10 employers in the uk that recruit rehabilitated offenders.

Both my mother and stepfather have pgces and have worked in schools, colleges and universities for over 30 years and both have criminal records, and also know numerous teachers with criminal records, including one with a previous 18 month prison sentence for punching a flight attendant on a plane. It's more than obvious that you dont really understand the recruitment process and how many ex offenders are employed in schools.

You mention schools and reputations, and you are right, schools are concerned about reputations, and having a blanket ban on applicants with previous criminal convictions breaks rehabilitation of offenders act and employment law.

What employers value and respect is honesty, which the op has demonstrated already, simply by making this post. I really hope she continues with her application and isnt put off by bigoted responses.

Your post just screams pure ignorance and you come across as not just judgemental but completely out of touch.

Hurrahitsraini · 26/09/2023 20:11

@Wrongsideofpennines i totally agree. OP you’d be surprised those working in the social care world, probation and youth justice service world who have criminal convictions. I know people who’ve been to prison and working in the youth justice world….