Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Re friend bringing dog everywhere

370 replies

Toomanythalias · 25/09/2023 13:41

My friend got a dog a couple of years ago and now insists on bringing him everywhere. If we want to go for a coffee we have to go to a dog friendly cafe. If we want to go for a meal we have to go to a dog friendly restaurant. If she calls over to any of our houses she assumes it's ok to bring the dog. We probably should have said something before now as it's been really irritating us.
Anyhow, we're going away early next year for a few days to celebrate a couple of big birthdays in the group. We were planning to spend a weekend in a hotel somewhere like the Cotswolds, and just enjoy a couple of days relaxing, chatting, eating nice meals etc. However this friend is just assuming she can bring her dog, and is sending lists of dog friendly hotels for us to check out. We told her yesterday that we don't want the dog to come and we don't want to stay in a dog friendly hotel and she needs to sort out care for the dog while she's away. She is now in a huff, says she doesn't want to come, she's obviously not wanted ..... I'm torn between feeling bad and feeling exasperated with her attitude.
Were we being unreasonable to have put our foot down?

OP posts:
Gagaandgag · 26/09/2023 19:24

I’m interested why this annoys you so much, is he a demanding and attention seeking dog. This isn’t a dig but genuine question

I get the finding dog friendly places might be slightly annoying but it wouldn’t annoy me. Maybe her dog has separation anxiety

pollymere · 26/09/2023 19:18

My cat is a rescue. We realized after a few months that she's seriously clingy and probably wouldn't cope in kennels. It means we don't all go away at the same time anymore and haven't had s holiday since!

If this dog is like that then it's not just simply a case of putting it in kennels. Your friend may bring the dog because it can't cope without her.

Alternatively, the dog may be what gives your friend the safety and confidence to leave the house. She may not be able to go anywhere without the dog...

openallday · 26/09/2023 18:45

totally reasonable to want a dog free holiday

its so restrictive

dog goes in kennels or she doesn’t come

pictoosh · 26/09/2023 18:37

I feel a wee bit sorry for your friend. She clearly thought that no one minded her bringing the dog along. She has just found out that it is something you have discussed with each other and have a problem with. She's probably mortified and hurt that she was oblivious, while you were all gritting your teeth and slagging her off. Embarrassing and hurtful for her. Give her time...but also stick to your guns about not having to prioritise her dog when making arrangements.

RedSquirrelsRock · 26/09/2023 18:22

Where I live there are more dogs than kids, majority of people have a dog but more often than not two.
So annoying having to put up with the yapping, barking and stupid owners giving their dogs free rein on the leash all over pavements.

CoffeeCantata · 26/09/2023 17:51

iamwhatiam23 · Today 09:31

I own dogs and would never presume to take them with me when invited somewhere! Its weird and rude! Not everyone is comfortable around dogs.

The most succinct and sensible post. Yes - it's not about dog-hating - that's far too dramatic. It's about people who have chosen not to have a dog feeling uncomfortable. I know I do when a dog rushes up to me, possibly jumps up or sticks it's nose in my crotch etc etc. And these things do happen.

I know lots of people with dogs and because they are sensible, considerate people, there's never a problem. They understand that the big, life-changing decision to have a dog is THEIR choice and wouldn't foist it on others without checking everyone's OK with it.

I once had to sit next to a dog which produced the most noxious farts known to science while I ate my meal. Absolutely nauseating. All kinds of unsavoury things come along with dog-ownership and good owners are aware and do their best to prevent them.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 26/09/2023 17:46

Toomanythalias · 26/09/2023 17:11

Except Fido isn't sitting under the table, he's yapping and wanting to sit on friend's lap. Also we don't want to be confined to dog friendly activities, cafes and restaurants for the weekend. Why is that mean spirited?

It’s not mean spirited at all.

You’re being quite clear what you’d prefer and she’s foisting the dog on you and just expecting you to roll over (like the dog!) and welcome the dog every time!

Tartantotty · 26/09/2023 17:13

I would be diplomatic. Remind her that you are happy to have to dog in your company most of the time, but this is a special occasion and you want to be free to choose where you want to go. If he's still in a huff, let her stew.

Toomanythalias · 26/09/2023 17:11

Bedofnail · 26/09/2023 13:20

Loads of “nice” hotels in the countryside are dog friendly, you must have searched hard to find one that wasn’t. Does it really matter if Figo is sitting under the table? Especially if it means your friend is comfortable and relaxed, and spared the expense and faff of finding somewhere for Fido to board.

You come across as rather mean spirited.

Except Fido isn't sitting under the table, he's yapping and wanting to sit on friend's lap. Also we don't want to be confined to dog friendly activities, cafes and restaurants for the weekend. Why is that mean spirited?

OP posts:
DangerousAlchemy · 26/09/2023 16:55

This reminds me of lunch I had months ago with an old friend I'd not seen in ages. She suggested a pub for lunch that was 30 min drive away (for me) & said she'd bring the dog she looks after with her (she's a nanny). OK, bit odd but she know I used to be a vet nurse so assumes I love animals (I do, but also happy to have lunch without one lol). We sit inside & she has dog ( cockerpoo called Betsy or something) on such a long lead the staff were having to step over the lead & dog half the time. It was weird & awkward. We spent 45 mins there as we both ordered salad & it arrived quickly etc then we left 🤣 all a bit pointless & hard to chat as dog was whining & being a bit annoying. I probably won't bother reaching out again. Plus I foster cats and have my own cats (enclosed garden so they don't wander or shit in other people's flower beds before someone comments!) but loads of my dog-owning friends are always telling me I should get a dog 🙄 bugger off lol 😆 cats are WAY better plus I don't foist them onto my friends constantly.

Taketurn · 26/09/2023 16:54

Bedofnail · 26/09/2023 13:20

Loads of “nice” hotels in the countryside are dog friendly, you must have searched hard to find one that wasn’t. Does it really matter if Figo is sitting under the table? Especially if it means your friend is comfortable and relaxed, and spared the expense and faff of finding somewhere for Fido to board.

You come across as rather mean spirited.

Yes, it obviously matters to the OP and her group of friends! Not wanting to be around dogs ALL the pissing time is not mean spirited.

ManateeFair · 26/09/2023 14:53

YANBU if you don't want to look for a dog-friendly hotel. Personally I'd actually love it if my mates brought their dogs with them when we went out - but that's just me! Obviously not everyone would feel like that, and why on earth should they? I wouldn't want to only eat in child-friendly places and stay in 'family' hotels just because one of my friends insisted on bringing her child with her, so I wouldn't expect people to fit around a dog!

queenMab99 · 26/09/2023 14:14

It is difficult when you are single, to leave a dog at home for more than 3 hours or so. Did you tell her clearly, that you don't always want a dog with you? If you did she is being unreasonable, if you didn't you are being unreasonable.
I got a dog for companionship as I am widowed, in my 70s and not interested in another relationship. If friends are planning an outing of more than 3 hours, where dogs are not welcome, I opt out immediately. My dog is company all the time, friends are only around when they want to be, I chose to have a dog, I don't expect other people to plan outings or holidays round him.

Wetblanket78 · 26/09/2023 14:08

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Milkand2sugarsplease · 26/09/2023 14:08

@GonnaGetGoingReturns yes I'm fully aware it's down to the owner which is why I said she's probably feeling a bit silly now because she knows she's created this issue by not leaving the dog regularly for short periods.

We have a dog, and have always had dogs from me being small, we also knew it was sensible to teach him early on that he would be left alone at times. Had we mollycoddled him and never left him, he'd be less well adjusted, and more likely to whine at being left due to separation anxiety.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 26/09/2023 13:59

YANBU - said as a dog owner who takes my dog with me when I can. But not always, I dont assume it is ok, and would be ok not to.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 26/09/2023 13:58

Milkand2sugarsplease · 26/09/2023 09:25

She's probably ended up in the realms of having a dog she can't leave now due to it never having learned it ok to be left.
It probably creates holy hell when she leaves it so she doesn't leave it. I imagine her attitude to you guys saying something is her feeling a little silly that she's never trained her dog to be alone and realisation that her life is quite restricted because of it.
You were all well within your rights to say something to her - perhaps it would have been better sooner but that's by the by.

Make your plans, include her, but don't be surprised if she doesn't participate. If her dog has separation anxiety, it can be difficult to manage - but she's only got herself to blame and she'll have to manage it because it's not fair on the dog otherwise.

Most dogs are fine left by themselves. Had 2 as a child/young adult.

It’s the owner who generally creates separation anxiety in my experience/opinion by treating the dog as a substitute eg child so the dog gets nervous every time the owner goes out. Slightly different for rescue dogs maybe but they can still be worked with so they can be left alone.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 26/09/2023 13:54

LightSpeeds · 26/09/2023 11:37

Well, she knows now how you all feel and I guess you're going to have to have a very honest (and uncomfortable) talk with her - assuming she wants to talk to you at all.

If you value her friendship, then you're probably going to have to meet in the middle as regards dog-friendly cafes, etc. (maybe agree to occasionally let the dog come 😂). Not the holiday though 🚫🐕🚫

The thing is if you do it occasionally, like my example. We did it a few times with her and the dog (and this was about 5 years ago when venues were getting more dog friendly gradually) and after that the dog owner assumed and expected we’d be happy with Fido coming every time. If you get a bossy owner who thinks more about their pet than their friends then you’re onto a losing battle.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 26/09/2023 13:51

This killed a friend of a friend’s mine friendship off, they were best friends. The friend got a rescue dog who’s lovely but since she got him he had to come everywhere with her. I once asked when I saw him at home if he’d be happier there rather than out sign us and got daggers aimed at me and “no”. The final straw was when the friend wanted to take her dog to an all day event in the searing heat, my friend expressed concern at the dog getting too hot and got loads of abuse. Now they’re not friends.

Friend with dog made new doggy friends before this anyway.

You’re not being at all unreasonable and to be honest you shouldn’t have to have a dog at meals, cafes etc with you unless you all agree this is ok. I’m sick of people infantilising their dogs, they’re not humans. Doggy day care and kennels are there to be used for holidays and weekends away. Too many dog owners assume that because eg a hotel is dog friendly etc then they assume most other venues will be similar and their friends will back them up.

Afterrain · 26/09/2023 13:48

I am a dog lover.
I don't assume that my friends want my dog in their home or garden. She is left at home if we are going out locally.
If we are going on a hike I take the dog. It is usually me who organises the hikes as they only got into it during lock down. Afterwards we may go to a country pub that has always allowed dogs. Or leave her in the car if not too hot.
If we are travelling and pop into a friends we leave the dog in a very large cage in the boot with a special air vent on the hatch back of our estate car.
If I was having a weekend away with friends the dog would go into kennels as I would want the break to enjoy their company.
My neighbour and I have a dog sitting circle! Swap dogs if one is out or overnight. Although a new chap wants to join who allows his dog on the furniture. We and our neighbour don't allow this. I agreed to take for a walk, play but leave the dog back at his house.
Your friend needs to get a dog sitter or set up a dog swap/circle.

dancingirl · 26/09/2023 13:47

No, YANBU, but I think people are being really unfair saying things like “it’s a dog not a child”. To some people their dog is like their child, especially if they’re single and/or can’t have children of their own. Obviously there are times like this instance when you don’t want children or dogs there, but you often see times when people have gatherings including children, but get cross when someone wants to bring their dog as “it’s only a dog ffs”. It just makes those people even more hurt and isolated by their supposed friends not understanding what it can feel like to be the only person at a gathering that can’t play happy families.

MrsSkylerWhite · 26/09/2023 13:39

Bedofnail · Today 13:20
**
Loads of “nice” hotels in the countryside are dog friendly, you must have searched hard to find one that wasn’t. Does it really matter if Figo is sitting under the table? Especially if it means your friend is comfortable and relaxed, and spared the expense and faff of finding somewhere for Fido to board.
**
You come across as rather mean spirited”

Nope. Had to take our dog away with us for 13 years, she was too distressed if boarded. Stayed at lots of “naice”, dog friendly hotels in the country. Rooms were always smallest, at the rear looking over the kitchen outflow or similar, smelly with stained carpets. We were charged more for so called extra cleaning too. Same with holiday lets. Many so called dog friendly hotels wouldn’t allow dogs in the dining room (understandably) but neither could they be left in the room alone. So, you risk leaving them in the car or as we usually did missed breakfast, paid extra for room service or ate in relay.

Op is not mean spirited. Our dog certainly negatively impacted the quality of our holidays and we were very fond of her. Wouldn’t have forced her company on a group of friends who weren’t keen.

athrobbingpairoftrousers · 26/09/2023 13:37

‘Does it really matter if Figo is sitting under the table? ‘

Yes it does because it changes the dynamics of the whole weekend and one person’s dog trumps the preference and wants of everyone else.

Bedofnail · 26/09/2023 13:20

Loads of “nice” hotels in the countryside are dog friendly, you must have searched hard to find one that wasn’t. Does it really matter if Figo is sitting under the table? Especially if it means your friend is comfortable and relaxed, and spared the expense and faff of finding somewhere for Fido to board.

You come across as rather mean spirited.